Solutions
Works with
Pricing
Log in
Teams
Get started
Log in
Get started
E. "Weapons of the Weak"
TT
by
T.A. Tran
·
106 views
·
Updated Mar 6, 2021
Share
Embed
Re-use content
Create your own
Chapters
00:00
Weapons of the Weak
00:13
protest tactics: marches, demonstrations, sit-ins, occupations, civil disobedience, strikes
02:58
everyday resistance: subtle, indirect, non-confrontational acts against dominant power
05:29
guerrilla warfare: hit & run combat tactics
06:38
highly mobile, no clear frontline
07:47
adapts to local conditions & limited resources
09:48
Winning hearts & minds via... -social services -political program -propaganda
10:30
Chapter 8
11:01
Chapter 9
11:22
Chapter 10
12:13
Chapter 11
12:15
Chapter 12
Audio Transcript
Auto-generated
00:00 - 00:03
Finally, let's talk about strategies and tactics that we might
00:04 - 00:07
find in the course of a revolution or insurgency or
00:08 - 00:11
tactics strategies that inform the breakout of revolt.
00:12 - 00:16
So let's look at some pretty, uh, you know, intuitive
00:16 - 00:21
things like protest tactics, marches, demonstrations, sit ins, occupation, civil
00:21 - 00:24
disobedience. These are things that are relatively unsurprising that you
00:24 - 00:24
would find.
00:25 - 00:25
And, of course, of a revolution.
00:26 - 00:29
Right? Um, but I want to say a little bit
00:29 - 00:30
about strikes.
00:31 - 00:35
Strikes like the 2012 Marikana miners strike in South Africa.
00:35 - 00:40
Pictured Here are the best tools that workers have not
00:40 - 00:43
only to improve working conditions, but also to change the
00:43 - 00:46
entire economy if they can get a general strike going.
00:46 - 00:50
So general strike is a strike that happens in an
00:50 - 00:53
entire sector or throughout an entire economy is not just
00:53 - 00:54
located in one workplace.
00:55 - 01:01
So through the strike, right workers are basically withholding their
01:01 - 01:05
labor, and this stops the regular functioning of the economy
01:05 - 01:08
and stops the flow of profits to their employers or
01:09 - 01:11
to the government or to the top, whoever they're working
01:12 - 01:16
for. And so as long as workers continue to work
01:16 - 01:18
and play the role that is expected of them.
01:18 - 01:21
There is no incentive for bosses or governments to respond
01:22 - 01:24
to their demands, whether they speak for a better wage
01:24 - 01:27
or better working conditions or a more egalitarian society.
01:28 - 01:30
In fact, lots of workers don't just strike for better
01:31 - 01:31
conditions for themselves.
01:32 - 01:35
They are striking for some broader social change for everyone.
01:35 - 01:40
So basically, workers have to stop work to be heard
01:40 - 01:43
because all their leverage lies in their labor power.
01:44 - 01:45
They are the ones that are producing the goods and
01:45 - 01:48
services that make society function and that make profit for
01:49 - 01:49
their bosses.
01:49 - 01:53
And if they stop work, they create a disruption in
01:53 - 01:55
everyday life that forces people to listen and forces society
01:56 - 01:56
to change.
01:57 - 02:00
But striking can also be extremely dangerous, as when the
02:00 - 02:04
police, um, come to the defense of the private mine
02:04 - 02:08
owners, as in the Marikana South Africa case, rather than
02:09 - 02:11
defending the lives of the striking workers.
02:11 - 02:14
And so, in this case, um, the police shot and
02:14 - 02:18
killed 34 um, mine workers that went on strike, um,
02:19 - 02:24
in 2012, and and instead of being deployed to protect
02:25 - 02:30
the mineworkers from retaliation from their bosses and in the
02:30 - 02:32
U. S, we see this very same sort of violence.
02:32 - 02:32
The U.
02:32 - 02:37
S. Is actually has the bloodiest labor history out of
02:37 - 02:39
all Western industrialized countries.
02:39 - 02:41
And that is because of the ways in which the
02:41 - 02:44
police has been deployed to protect private property interests and
02:45 - 02:48
the interests of the business owners, employers over the workers
02:48 - 02:53
and, um, and this history of employers hiring private mercenaries
02:54 - 02:57
in order to violently repress striking workers.
02:59 - 03:04
We also find everyday resistance as a weapon of the
03:04 - 03:04
weak. Right.
03:05 - 03:10
These are any subtle, indirect or non confrontational acts that
03:10 - 03:13
challenge power holders to make daily life more bearable for
03:14 - 03:17
people. And so think about a situation in which power
03:18 - 03:21
relations are highly unequal between a boss and a worker
03:21 - 03:24
between the landlord and tenant between the Lord and the
03:24 - 03:29
surf master slave Brahman untouchable, as in, um, the caste
03:29 - 03:29
system in India.
03:30 - 03:33
Any dominant race versus a subjugated race, right?
03:34 - 03:37
Power relations in these contexts are very unequal.
03:38 - 03:41
And so if the subjugated person were to openly resist
03:42 - 03:45
rise up against the dominant, they would surely die.
03:46 - 03:48
They would surely be putting their life at risk, putting
03:49 - 03:51
their livelihood at risk, and so they have to find
03:52 - 03:58
some other way right to resist power to, um, silently
03:59 - 04:01
assert their dignity, right?
04:01 - 04:05
To make it so that the material appropriation of their
04:05 - 04:09
labor that they're feeling, um is lessened, right?
04:09 - 04:11
Just to make daily life more bearable, more livable.
04:12 - 04:18
And so then the subjugated people will engage in X
04:19 - 04:23
that will kind of undermine how power normally works.
04:24 - 04:27
It undermines the authority of the dominant in a way
04:28 - 04:30
that the dominant doesn't realize this and hidden ways, right?
04:30 - 04:34
So this can take place via theft or arson or
04:34 - 04:35
tax evasion.
04:35 - 04:37
Or if you're at work, right and you feel like
04:37 - 04:40
you're not being paid fairly, you might do less work
04:40 - 04:42
when the bosses are looking or you might slow down
04:43 - 04:45
work. You might do less quality of work, right?
04:46 - 04:50
Um, just to even the playing field or lots of
04:50 - 04:53
times we've seen in history that workers will kind of
04:53 - 04:56
mess with machinery on the workplace and pretend that it
04:56 - 04:57
broke down by itself.
04:58 - 05:02
Um, sometimes everyday resistance just takes place in your mind,
05:02 - 05:06
as when you dream about salvation from, you know, slavery
05:07 - 05:12
or from, um, your very exploitative work situation or you
05:12 - 05:15
dream of revenge against the dominant right that is exploiting
05:16 - 05:20
you. And in fact, each of these acts, while they're
05:20 - 05:23
subtle and interact and they don't actually directly confront power,
05:24 - 05:27
they still become fuel and practice for open resistance.
05:28 - 05:33
Later, lastly, I'm going to go over a particular form
05:33 - 05:36
of insurgency that is guerilla warfare.
05:37 - 05:39
Guerilla warfare consists of hit and run combat tactics.
05:40 - 05:43
This is usually conducted by a small group of combatants,
05:44 - 05:46
right, and you can think about it as then popping
05:47 - 05:51
up, attacking and then retreating again before their opponent even
05:51 - 05:53
knows what's going on and has the opportunity to retaliate.
05:54 - 05:58
And so guerilla warfare is making your strategies of fighting
05:59 - 05:59
extremely mobile.
06:00 - 06:04
There is no clear front line here everywhere, and everything
06:04 - 06:09
becomes a potential terrain of battle, and so contrast this
06:09 - 06:11
to traditional warfare.
06:11 - 06:15
Conventional warfare, in which two armies come together in a
06:15 - 06:17
given territory and fight to the death and whatever armies
06:18 - 06:21
left standing, is the one that claims that territory, whereas
06:21 - 06:25
guerilla warfare doesn't have like a meeting place.
06:25 - 06:29
The meeting places anywhere the guerrillas pop up in order
06:29 - 06:33
to attack and retreat again, and then pop up in
06:33 - 06:35
another location where you least expect it to attack and
06:35 - 06:36
retreat again.
06:37 - 06:40
So let's take a look at a quote from Mao,
06:41 - 06:45
who is one of the very influential strategists of guerilla
06:45 - 06:49
warfare, He said, Select the tactic of seeming to come
06:49 - 06:52
from the east and attacking from the west Avoid the
06:52 - 06:54
solid attack the hollow.
06:55 - 06:57
When guerrillas engage a stronger enemy, they withdraw.
06:58 - 07:00
When he advances, harass him.
07:01 - 07:04
Then when he stops, strike him when he is weary,
07:04 - 07:06
pursue him when he withdraws.
07:07 - 07:11
And so the idea is to find your enemies weakest
07:11 - 07:16
points and to attack their, for instance, attacking their communications
07:17 - 07:21
line attacking person now that are less armored, right, hiding
07:22 - 07:25
among rough terrain in caves among civilians.
07:26 - 07:29
So that entails winning over the support of the population
07:30 - 07:30
so that you can hide among them.
07:31 - 07:35
Right? All of these ways protect you from an upon
07:36 - 07:41
your opponent while you're sort of re, uh, regrouping and
07:41 - 07:44
re strategizing getting your forces together for the next attack.
07:45 - 07:49
And so guerilla warfare is extremely adaptable.
07:50 - 07:53
It adapts to the changing local conditions of particular local
07:54 - 07:57
conditions that you face and the limited resources that you
07:58 - 08:01
have. So basically, you try to maximize what little you
08:01 - 08:03
have and compensate for your own weaknesses.
08:04 - 08:05
And so one of the ways that this is done,
08:06 - 08:10
um, is through, For instance, if we look at the
08:10 - 08:16
Vietnam War, right, the Vietnam gorilla rebel fighters They have
08:16 - 08:19
dug this very elaborate series of tunnels and got civilians
08:20 - 08:23
to help them do this to, um where these tunnels
08:23 - 08:26
they might dig underneath a US military base.
08:26 - 08:28
And then they would crawl through the tunnels and an
08:28 - 08:30
attack within the base and the retreat in the tunnel
08:30 - 08:31
before anyone was the wiser.
08:32 - 08:35
Um, so then they would seemingly come out of nowhere,
08:36 - 08:39
right? And that they would also have, you know, spaces
08:40 - 08:43
for eating and cooking and sleeping and showering in these
08:43 - 08:50
tunnels. Um, that then allowed them to be safe and
08:51 - 08:54
to hide out from, you know, their opponents from the
08:54 - 08:54
U. S.
08:55 - 09:00
Military from the South Vietnamese government army and from the
09:00 - 09:00
bombing campaign.
09:01 - 09:03
So as soon as the bombs started to come, they
09:03 - 09:04
would jump into one of these tunnels.
09:05 - 09:10
So, overall right, guerilla warfare is best used against a
09:10 - 09:16
traditional army that's technologically superior, because technological, superior armies you
09:16 - 09:20
cannot win against unless you play smart because you don't
09:21 - 09:22
have the force behind you, Right?
09:22 - 09:25
So if you have an invading army that has all
09:25 - 09:27
these big tanks and helicopters and bombers and you don't
09:28 - 09:29
have any of those things, how do you win against
09:30 - 09:30
an army like that?
09:31 - 09:32
You have to win through guerilla warfare.
09:33 - 09:37
Um, because that army is going to be less mobile
09:37 - 09:40
venue, right, even though it's technologically superior is gonna be
09:40 - 09:40
less mobile.
09:41 - 09:44
So you have to use your mobility, um, as a
09:45 - 09:46
in your advantage.
09:47 - 09:52
And finally, the guerilla warfare tactics is not just about
09:53 - 09:56
military strategy, but there is also a political program involved,
09:56 - 09:59
a political project involved in this and that.
10:00 - 10:02
It's about winning the hearts and minds of the people
10:03 - 10:08
via good governance by providing them social services or by
10:08 - 10:13
forwarding a political program of unification and emancipation of all
10:13 - 10:14
the people.
10:14 - 10:19
And so your goals have to seem to accord with
10:19 - 10:21
the aspirations and the interests of the people to win
10:21 - 10:23
their hearts and minds over to you.
10:23 - 10:26
Um, because that will increase your likelihood of success.
10:26 - 10:28
And so usually this entails using propaganda.
10:30 - 10:32
So let me show you an example of some propaganda
10:33 - 10:36
posters that were used by the Viet Cong during the
10:36 - 10:39
Revolutionary War during the Civil War in Vietnam.
10:40 - 10:42
Um so due to limited resources like posters like this
10:43 - 10:46
one were often drawn on scrap paper and then distributed
10:46 - 10:47
that way.
10:47 - 10:51
And this particular poster called on civilians to pave the
10:51 - 10:53
path to victory by participating in the war, and in
10:54 - 10:56
particular, it seems to be calling civilians, too.
10:57 - 11:01
Construct and operate the Ho Chi Minh Trail, which is
11:02 - 11:07
a series of roads, paved roads that were built largely
11:07 - 11:11
by civilian supporters of the insurgency and sometimes the insurgents.
11:11 - 11:14
With four civilians that build these roads for them and
11:14 - 11:18
on these roads, they would transport supplies to different, you
11:18 - 11:20
know, rebel stations.
11:21 - 11:24
And so they often relied on civilians to do this
11:24 - 11:27
type of work and mobilize civilians to support the war
11:27 - 11:30
effort. In this way now also noted, note the gender
11:30 - 11:33
dimension here that this woman right is sort of like
11:34 - 11:38
leading the way here and guiding the transport vehicles through
11:38 - 11:39
the whole human trail.
11:39 - 11:44
And, um, this is very common in particularly left wing
11:45 - 11:49
insurgency's, where you see much higher participation rates by women
11:50 - 11:54
not only a support staff for the war, but also
11:54 - 11:56
as active fighters as guerilla fighters.
11:57 - 12:00
I mean, that's because women are more drawn to left
12:00 - 12:03
wing insurgencies because they often have a promise of gender
12:04 - 12:07
egalitarianism. They're more committed to the ideals of gender equality
12:08 - 12:09
than other types of insurgencies.
12:10 - 12:15
Would be, um, so let's take a look at one
12:15 - 12:17
more propaganda poster example from this era.
12:19 - 12:24
And so this says, um, this poster points out Nixon
12:26 - 12:28
as a murderer, right?
12:29 - 12:31
This is sort of what this says, and you can
12:31 - 12:35
see how in Vietnamese Nick Song, uh, that's just the
12:35 - 12:36
Vietnamese way of saying Nixon.
12:37 - 12:39
And there's a caricature of him here.
12:39 - 12:43
And this propaganda poster refers to how three times more
12:43 - 12:46
bombs were dropped during the Vietnam War than all of
12:46 - 12:47
World War Two combined.
12:48 - 12:49
And that was a world war, right?
12:50 - 12:53
So then that's seven bombs for every man, woman and
12:53 - 12:57
child in all of the areas that were, uh, became
12:58 - 12:59
the battlefield in the Vietnam War.
13:00 - 13:03
So posters like this were used to really highlight that
13:03 - 13:07
the vast majority of deaths suffered during the war were
13:07 - 13:09
from US actions and not the actions of the guerilla
13:10 - 13:12
fighters. And this was another way of winning over the
13:12 - 13:16
hearts and minds of the people to the revolutionary insurgency
See full transcript