Solutions
Pricing
Log in
Teams
Get started
Log in
Get started
Basil
AB
by
Anthony Baker
·
40 views
·
Updated Feb 16, 2022
Share
Embed
Re-use content
Create your own
Chapters
00:00
Basil of Caesarea (d. 379)
01:14
Cappadocian Fathers -first family -Origen to Gregory Thaumaturgus -Philokalia
05:43
-Monastic order -charitable work -doctrinal fights leading up to Constantinople (381) -homoousias
07:22
Against Eunomius -unbegotten is not an essential name of God -Properties=otherness within unity
09:36
On the Holy Spirit -liturgical question
11:40
“Everything that partakes of [the Spirit’s] grace is filled with joy according to its capacity."
12:54
Logos/Spirit Natural Kinds/Grace Literal/Anagogical
14:37
Encomium
Audio Transcript
Auto-generated
00:01 - 00:06
basil of caesarea called accessory and because that's where he's from,
00:06 - 00:14
but because that's where he became bishop somewhat reluctantly uh in in late,
00:14 - 00:15
late in life.
00:15 - 00:18
Now, what's significant about that date of his death, 3 79
00:19 - 00:21
is that the first
00:21 - 00:25
The Council of Constantinople happens two years later,
00:25 - 00:30
381 and that's the one that that writes the version
00:30 - 00:33
of the creative Neisseria that would continue to use.
00:34 - 00:34
Um
00:35 - 00:37
So we've talked about the fourth century as
00:37 - 00:40
this time of turmoil within doctrinal term turmoil
00:41 - 00:46
along with jurisdictional turmoil among bishops and priests
00:46 - 00:47
um
00:47 - 00:50
throughout the mediterranean throughout the the world,
00:50 - 00:52
the greek world of the church,
00:53 - 00:56
basil of caesarea takes a leading role
00:57 - 01:02
uh in um the debates now
01:03 - 01:09
he is the the eldest actually, no, he's the elder brother, but he's not the oldest of,
01:09 - 01:11
but he is one of three
01:12 - 01:16
uh theologians that we call the Cappadocia in Father's.
01:16 - 01:20
That refers to base to basil himself himself,
01:20 - 01:22
his little brother Gregory of Nisa
01:23 - 01:27
and close friend Gregory of naciones is to Gregory's
01:27 - 01:29
is about to be three Gregory's. I'll tell you about that in a second.
01:30 - 01:35
The outcome from Cappadocia, which is in what is in present day Turkey.
01:37 - 01:42
And these three are really the the
01:43 - 01:45
uh after Athan ASIS,
01:45 - 01:50
they are the most significant voices of the century and as this
01:50 - 01:52
is the century in which the nicene creed is being authored,
01:52 - 01:52
they are
01:53 - 01:57
really the three giants of greek theology
01:57 - 01:58
for with a tenacious,
02:00 - 02:03
because of the timing as much as anything.
02:04 - 02:04
Um
02:06 - 02:11
Athanasius is sort of the grand old statesman of the Nicene party at this point. Um
02:11 - 02:17
he is, has more or less cloistered himself away in in Egypt
02:17 - 02:20
um Baselitz said, wrote letters to him, tried to sort of get his patronage,
02:20 - 02:21
tried to sort of
02:22 - 02:24
Fanboy him a little bit,
02:24 - 02:29
but Athanasios wasn't interested um and then Athanasios ultimately
02:29 - 02:33
dies and basil emerges as the most important um
02:33 - 02:37
um as part of a team of the most important theological voices,
02:37 - 02:41
he's from what I call the first family of Nicene orthodoxy,
02:41 - 02:43
I told you had a little brother named Gregory Vanessa,
02:43 - 02:44
we're going to talk about Gregory
02:45 - 02:49
um Their oldest sister was Macarena.
02:51 - 02:55
Uh we're going to read a bit about Macarena
02:55 - 02:56
ah
02:57 - 02:59
the the the theological teacher,
03:00 - 03:07
Gregory says, she's the one that go to um for discussions about um
03:08 - 03:12
the soul discussions about the nature of christ, it may be that Macarena had some
03:13 - 03:14
some sort of
03:14 - 03:20
broadly construed Aryan tendencies that seem to be uh something interesting
03:20 - 03:22
sort of in the family dynamics as they sit around the,
03:23 - 03:24
the dinner table from time to time.
03:25 - 03:31
McQueen is one of the very first um inhabitants of um female monastic,
03:31 - 03:33
of female monastic communities.
03:33 - 03:35
She has a lot to do with the formation of those communities.
03:35 - 03:39
The writing is a rule for those communities and this is big within the family.
03:39 - 03:42
Um this sort of sense of this is the highest calling
03:42 - 03:44
and theologian is to form a community
03:44 - 03:47
of theologians and contemplate ear's and prayer
03:47 - 03:48
prayers.
03:49 - 03:53
Um and there is a community did form,
03:54 - 03:57
I've forgotten where because basil went and explored
03:57 - 03:59
one in Egypt but I believe came back
04:00 - 04:04
uh and found that a double community um well read about this in our
04:04 - 04:09
readings for the for for this week a double community of men and women
04:10 - 04:11
which is
04:12 - 04:16
sister was involved, his mother was involved a grandmother was a holy woman.
04:16 - 04:18
I'm also named Macarena
04:19 - 04:21
and the heritage of the capital.
04:21 - 04:27
Ocean theologians really comes from the the founder,
04:27 - 04:29
the founding preacher and theologian of
04:30 - 04:32
Christianity in that part of the world.
04:32 - 04:36
So now we're back into the two hundreds with someone named Gregory Thermometer gis.
04:36 - 04:41
Uh he was supposed supposed to have been thought to have been
04:42 - 04:43
a disciple of origin.
04:43 - 04:49
So he leaves alexandria or Palestine where he studied under
04:49 - 04:53
origin and then comes to Cappadocia and founds the churches there
04:53 - 04:56
and the theological communities there and this really is the,
04:56 - 04:59
is the source of their theology.
05:01 - 05:06
Gregory and Gregory and uh Nancy Lanza so the friend
05:06 - 05:09
and they still collaborate on a collection
05:09 - 05:11
of origins works called the Phil O'Cealleagh.
05:11 - 05:13
This is the ancient,
05:13 - 05:15
physically not to be confused with the one
05:15 - 05:19
written in Russia in the early modern years
05:19 - 05:22
that the little book the way of the pilgrims about there actually to fill Scalia's.
05:22 - 05:27
That was just a big collection of church fathers but also spiritual masters
05:28 - 05:31
of the eastern church through the through the centuries.
05:31 - 05:35
The original philo colleague of the O. G. Of phyllo Kollias. That was a collection of
05:36 - 05:39
origins work written collected by
05:39 - 05:42
basil and his friend Gregory.
05:44 - 05:47
So they're known for the monastic orders as I said,
05:47 - 05:50
based especially is known for um the research he did on
05:50 - 05:53
how to found a monastic order on founding monastic orders,
05:53 - 05:57
pulled away into the entry work of theological argumentation
05:57 - 05:58
um
05:59 - 06:02
and um ultimately to be bishop of caesarea,
06:03 - 06:05
also known for their charitable work. Um
06:05 - 06:08
And that's a very famous sermon
06:08 - 06:11
um on giving it one more than one but
06:11 - 06:14
one especially favorite serpent on giving to the poor.
06:14 - 06:16
Um They're writing and doing their
06:16 - 06:20
ecclesiastical work and their theological doctrinal work
06:20 - 06:24
during the time of a great famine it hits in the fourth century.
06:24 - 06:25
So
06:26 - 06:30
calling us to speak well of christ and the spirit is of a piece for them
06:31 - 06:34
with calling us to be generous with our wealth.
06:35 - 06:38
Um So much as we might happen to have.
06:39 - 06:44
Uh Doctor as I mentioned, the Council of Constantinople 3 81.
06:44 - 06:49
They are so the the importance of these folks is that they're coming in between 3 25.
06:49 - 06:50
1st Council of Nicaea
06:50 - 06:57
3 81 at First Council of Constantinople and Gregory especially is championing that
06:57 - 07:02
term of from Athanasius and from the original nice scene statement creed,
07:02 - 07:03
homo
07:03 - 07:04
ideas
07:05 - 07:07
and there are particular
07:08 - 07:08
um
07:09 - 07:13
Aryan Ish voices. There's there's lots of varieties I've mentioned Ovarian ism
07:14 - 07:19
particular one that he's dealing with comes from as bear tells us 80 s and you know,
07:19 - 07:20
Meus.
07:21 - 07:26
So he writes his first great doctrinal text is against, you know,
07:26 - 07:28
mia several volumes of work.
07:29 - 07:32
Uh and you get a long history of that long sort of
07:32 - 07:33
uh
07:33 - 07:39
synopsis of that, of that text in bear a couple of things in notes about it. Um
07:40 - 07:45
the the the the sort of the key to the fight here is what the term un begotten means
07:45 - 07:46
um
07:46 - 07:52
un begotten according to, you know, meus is in the essential name of God, its name.
07:52 - 07:54
It's it's it's what it means to be God.
07:54 - 07:58
And of course, once you say that anything that God, if God begets
07:59 - 08:01
if God, the father begets the son,
08:01 - 08:04
well then the sun is not essentially God because the son is begotten.
08:05 - 08:08
So what is that word on the UN begotten doing
08:09 - 08:11
in our in our trinity, Terrien
08:12 - 08:14
crystal logical vocabulary,
08:14 - 08:18
that's really where the where the where the center of this argument is,
08:18 - 08:24
and basil is going to push hard to say one begotten is what he calls a property
08:26 - 08:31
uh that within the divine, within the divine oneness.
08:31 - 08:35
That can be distinct from other properties within the witness.
08:35 - 08:37
Is that it's a funny way that he's got here
08:37 - 08:39
and it's not the part that's not the way that sticks
08:41 - 08:42
by the time we get the gregor of nancy.
08:42 - 08:45
Lanza's and especially leading up into the fifth century,
08:45 - 08:48
this property is not going to be the common way of,
08:48 - 08:50
of distinguishing the persons of the trinity
08:50 - 08:52
and going persons we're gonna call the hypotheses
08:53 - 08:55
term, that he tends to migrate to his properties.
08:55 - 08:58
And he says properties are what allows us to
08:58 - 08:59
um
08:59 - 09:02
maintain, maintain distinctions or otherness within unity.
09:03 - 09:08
So it is a property of God to be begotten and a property of God to be un begotten.
09:08 - 09:09
But neither one of those
09:10 - 09:12
disrupt the union of essence.
09:13 - 09:15
That's what he wants to say back to to, you know, Mia's.
09:15 - 09:18
So it's again it's a sort of
09:18 - 09:20
it's a funny way of talking about it.
09:20 - 09:22
It's not a part that especially in the way that it comes to our ears,
09:22 - 09:25
it's not a part that sounds particularly persuasive with, you know,
09:25 - 09:29
the father is a property, he was, his fatherhood is a property,
09:29 - 09:32
He allows that to be distinct properties.
09:32 - 09:32
Um
09:33 - 09:35
But the language is gonna need some work,
09:36 - 09:41
the thing that he is along with the anti, you know, meus uh
09:42 - 09:43
treat us,
09:44 - 09:47
um which is really the last um
09:47 - 09:50
Well, that's that's not quite true because Greg Lisa Rights one by the same name,
09:50 - 09:55
but it's we're beginning to sort of come to an end of the arian controversies,
09:55 - 09:58
other controversies are going to take over in the next century.
09:58 - 10:03
So we're coming to the end of the great texts that are written to ensure that um
10:04 - 10:07
to ensure that uh
10:08 - 10:13
Christianity maintains a unity of essence between father and son.
10:13 - 10:15
That's what all of this is about.
10:16 - 10:19
He then moves into the, at the end of anti you know, Meus.
10:19 - 10:23
And then in a separate work, he writes a treatise that continues to be very popular.
10:23 - 10:26
This second one, especially the final one on the Holy Spirit.
10:26 - 10:28
So he writes on the Holy Spirit twice, once at the end of that Anti, you know,
10:28 - 10:32
Mia's and then once in a in a separate book just called on the Holy Spirit,
10:32 - 10:35
which you can find in a little green edition like mine.
10:36 - 10:37
Um,
10:38 - 10:42
and this begins with a liturgical question. Let me read it to you here.
10:42 - 10:44
So, remember, this is a bishop
10:44 - 10:48
who serves in in in a diocese and goes from church to church.
10:48 - 10:51
So writing liturgies,
10:51 - 10:53
composing liturgical prayers as part of what he does and
10:53 - 10:55
he's showing us that this is where some of the
10:55 - 10:56
um
10:56 - 10:58
some of the controversy comes from lately.
10:58 - 11:01
While I pray with the people, we sometimes finish the docks ology to God,
11:01 - 11:04
the Father with the form Glory to the Father with the Son,
11:04 - 11:06
together with the Holy Spirit.
11:06 - 11:10
And in other times we use glory to the Father through the Son and in the Holy Spirit.
11:10 - 11:14
So, he writes a big portion of this text is like what's up with those prepositions,
11:14 - 11:18
what's the right preposition to use when we talk about the Holy Spirit and what
11:18 - 11:22
he ultimately gets that he sort of wanders around in this for a bit,
11:22 - 11:25
but what he's trying to get at is the spirit is is God with us.
11:25 - 11:26
The spirit is
11:26 - 11:28
is divine,
11:28 - 11:30
the divine presence among us.
11:30 - 11:31
And so all the prepositions, he said,
11:31 - 11:35
bringing its God sending the work that has done in christ
11:35 - 11:39
out into the church through the prayers and to us.
11:40 - 11:43
One of the lines from here I think is particularly interesting and I
11:43 - 11:46
want to take the last couple of minutes and talk about this.
11:46 - 11:49
Um everything that partakes of the spirit's grace
11:49 - 11:53
is filled with joy according to its capacity.
11:54 - 11:57
Everything that partakes of the spirit's grace is
11:57 - 11:59
filled with joy according to its capacity.
11:59 - 12:01
What's interesting about this to me
12:01 - 12:07
is, first of all, um the way that the he has a sense of the spirit as meeting us,
12:07 - 12:11
where we are meeting us as who we are as the creatures that we are
12:11 - 12:12
the capacity.
12:12 - 12:18
So you can even say sort of what defines a thing is the capacity it has for Joy
12:19 - 12:22
Joy here as a kind of deifying term.
12:22 - 12:24
The capacity has to enjoy God.
12:25 - 12:27
And the spirit then, is the presence that
12:27 - 12:30
fills that, that ignites that joy,
12:30 - 12:33
not ignites it more a rock doesn't have the
12:33 - 12:35
same capacity for joy and God's presence as a
12:35 - 12:41
cat and the cat maybe doesn't as much as I do or differently than I do for sure.
12:42 - 12:44
But the spirit knows the nature of the
12:44 - 12:47
spirit knows those capacities and can ignite them.
12:47 - 12:49
And I think this is really exciting. I actually think there's also a link here
12:50 - 12:52
to the way that he
12:52 - 12:53
talks about scripture.
12:53 - 12:57
So, one of the things that that that bear points out is that in uh
12:58 - 13:01
and you know me as his reading of scripture, he says,
13:01 - 13:05
what the scripture gives us our names of God's essence,
13:06 - 13:09
it gives us information about who God is.
13:09 - 13:12
And we find again this question of knowledge and what's knowledge supposed to do.
13:12 - 13:15
And basil is not going to say scripture doesn't give us knowledge,
13:15 - 13:16
He doesn't think that, but he says,
13:16 - 13:19
nature doesn't give a scripture doesn't give us knowledge
13:19 - 13:21
like facts about God,
13:21 - 13:23
scripture lets us know God.
13:24 - 13:26
And so for that reason,
13:28 - 13:32
scripture really tells us the truth. In a funny way, it tells us the truth.
13:32 - 13:34
I'm using the word, it's not baseless word.
13:34 - 13:38
Um, but he tells us it's scripture tells us the truth and ago jik lee,
13:38 - 13:43
it tells us the truth by changing us by lifting us up into truth itself.
13:43 - 13:47
Um, scripture is not, he says, giving us literal facts.
13:47 - 13:51
It's it's allowing us to be participants in the truth.
13:51 - 13:53
And so I think that there's something here about the Holy Spirit
13:53 - 13:58
to this is sort of the sense of his the spirit inhabits
13:58 - 14:00
the text of scripture.
14:00 - 14:03
Think about the way paul talks about the spirit and the letter here,
14:03 - 14:03
the letter and the spirit,
14:05 - 14:07
there's a kind of analogy to be made that I'm trying to draw
14:07 - 14:10
if you can see what I'm saying in the same way that the cats
14:11 - 14:14
has. It is what it is because of a capacity for joy.
14:14 - 14:19
And then the spirit fills it with joy and it it becomes the fullness of itself.
14:19 - 14:21
Scripture is that to scripture is like
14:21 - 14:24
word's literal words that are capacities
14:25 - 14:32
uh that that capacities for desertification and when the spirit fills them,
14:32 - 14:35
either reader sort of ride that wave into the presence of God.
14:35 - 14:36
I think it's something beautiful here.
14:37 - 14:37
Um,
14:37 - 14:42
final thing I want to say then is his little brother Gregory at
14:42 - 14:45
his death in 379 writes an encomium that's still used as one of the
14:46 - 14:50
great examples of classical rhetoric and the thing that
14:50 - 14:52
he says in there is just like in scripture,
14:52 - 14:56
just like with the apostle paul, just like with the profits when we needed basil,
14:56 - 14:58
the most God sent him to us.
14:58 - 14:58
It's really quite beautiful
See full transcript