Loading presentation...

Present Remotely

Send the link below via email or IM


Present to your audience

Start remote presentation

  • Invited audience members will follow you as you navigate and present
  • People invited to a presentation do not need a Prezi account
  • This link expires 10 minutes after you close the presentation
  • A maximum of 30 users can follow your presentation
  • Learn more about this feature in our knowledge base article

Do you really want to delete this prezi?

Neither you, nor the coeditors you shared it with will be able to recover it again.


To what extent do reason and emotion affect ethical decision

No description

Omnipotence Acolyte

on 25 May 2014

Comments (0)

Please log in to add your comment.

Report abuse

Transcript of To what extent do reason and emotion affect ethical decision

Emotional Ethics?
Ethics as Care
Real-life Example
Armin Meiwes
Voluntary choice - cool-off period
Cannibalistic element - collaboration
Bleeding --> killing
20kg consumed
Ethics - the study/cognition of moral principles guiding our lives
Would you...
A - Kill and eat the man
B - Walk away
Option A - Emotions
Maximising happiness for greatest number
Intensity, duration, and power
Role of Emotion...
Tells us what NOT to do - linked to intuition
Impulsive decisions made at the head of moment
The "id" driving us - pleasure
Both animalistic and human
To what extent do reason and emotion affect ethical decisions?

Brian Wong 12W

Reason - logic-based cognitive and thinking processes that depend heavily on axioms --> the three truth theories
Emotion - hedonism-based behaviours combined by both subjective perceptions and psychological responses
Logical Ethics?
Kantian Ethics
Competing forces
Complement each other
Affect us: framework/paradigm --> experiences --> positive/negative association
Self-interest Theory
Excitement - "sexual pleasure"
But... Problems
Moral status of actions?
Mill's Harms Principle
Societal displeasure?
Happiness before death...?
Why emotions do not
always apply...
Relativist view - pluralists vs. monists (Incoherent)
Arbitrariness (Constant changes)
"Crossing boundaries"
What are boundaries?
Option A - Reason
Contract and Consent
Rules - free will
Humans as ends, not means
Legitimacy of contract?
Contract vs. contract - binding force?
Special Pleading allowed?
Rights to end life? Property theory
Futility Argument - consent
Suffering and pain - utilitarianism
When Reason fails,
Humanity speaks...
Subjectivity and bias - dogmatism
False Authority
Emotional construct - the human element
Option B - Reason
Cognitive Processes
Past experiences
Social norms
Induction - is the guy crazy?
Golden Rule
Original Position
What makes a society ethical/fair?
Logical Fallacies
Subjective Reasoning
Tolerance of others?
Emotion - Ethics as Care
Boos and Cheers

Role of Reason
Retrospective justification
Cognitive Processes
Self-interest: survival
Afghan soldiers - shepherds
To kill or not to kill?
Price gouging after Katrina
To raise or not to raise?
Importance of ethics
Emotion = role as mediator and instant responses
Reason = long-term paradigm and underlying forces
Ergo: Reason more important
Full transcript