Send the link below via email or IMCopy
Present to your audienceStart remote presentation
- Invited audience members will follow you as you navigate and present
- People invited to a presentation do not need a Prezi account
- This link expires 10 minutes after you close the presentation
- A maximum of 30 users can follow your presentation
- Learn more about this feature in our knowledge base article
Transcript of Murat Inan
University of Sheffield
The Great Dichotomy
Low level of education
Low level of income
High level of education
High level of income
Interested in politics
What do these all mean in practice?
Spending formative years under an authoritarian regime/laws makes an individual less likely to participate in politics. Besides this direct effect, it also stabilizes the role of modernization effect on political participation.
For the other side of the relationship, traditional members of the society are less likely to participate in politics. What is more, they are also less likely to be influenced by the period they spent their formative years in.
Logistic regression is a probabilistic model used to predict binary (dummy) outcome variables. Binary variable is a special categorical variable with two possible outcomes. The variable takes on the value “1” if event happens (success) and “0” if event does not happen (failure).
Data and Methods
What is the interplay between modernization and socialization effects regarding to their impacts on political participation?
Given the assumptions of the political socialization approach, I argue that due to relatively liberal laws and regulations and conflict-ridden political environment,
members of the Cold War generation in Turkey are more likely to develop an activity-prone characteristics
than their counterparts from the Pre-Cold War and the Post-Cold War generations. Besides this direct effect, socialization period plays
an indirect role
on political participation either by
stabilizing or promoting the modernization effect
As the classical modernization theory implies;
well-educated, well-off and manual/non-manual job occupants are more likely to participate in politics
than others. Additionally, indicating to a
modernization effect also plays an indirect role on political participation by
facilitating the socialization effect
a more marked impact on higher categories
of socioeconomic development.
The Classical Modernization Theory: Classical modernization theorists pointed out a positive relationship operating from modernization to higher political participation (Lipset 1959; Lerner 1958: 43-75; Black 1966: 9-26; Eisenstadt 1966:1-19; Inkeles 1974:325).
The Socialization Theory: Individuals who come of age in the same period are influenced by the same politico-historical context. Recognizing political events starts at the age of 14-15 (Jennings and Niemi 1981; Mishler and Rose 2007).
The Classical Modernization Theory
The Socialization Theory
Data and Methods
Original Coding, Recoding and Questionnaire Wording of Variables
Turkish generations and their formative periods
(1928-1959): Suppressed political and civil rights.
(1960-1980): Enhanced political and civil rights & Conflict-ridden political environment
(1980-1989): Suppressed political and civil rights.
Some generations are more likely to participate in politics. Besides this direct effect, this generational effect is more marked for higher levels of socioeconomic development.
Higher socioeconomic development is positively associated with political participation. What is more, this modernization effect is stronger for some particular generations.
Limitations of the Study
Lack of longitudinal data.
No perfect isolation of Age, Cohort and Period (ACP) effects.
Inability to compare modernization and socialization effects regarding to their power
Measurement of modernization
Age Cohort and Period (ACP) Effects
1. Age (aging) Effect:
A curvilinear relationship between age and political participation.
2. Cohort (generational) Effect:
Rather long term changes that occur during formative years and leave a "lasting" mark on individual attitudes and behaviors.
Silent generation, Baby boomers, Millennials
3. Period Effect:
Short term changes that influence members of the society from all age groups.
Economic crises, natural disasters etc.
Classical modernization theory presents
a process of transition from traditional to modern society
. Analogous to the
two poles of an axis
, traditional and modern societies are clearly portrayed. The contrast between these poles is called
"the great dichotomy”
Signing a petition
Joining in a boycott
Attending a lawful demonstration
A repeated cross-sectional data from four rounds of Turkish Values Survey conducted between the years 1990 and 2007.
“No answer” and “don’t know” answers were set to missing.
The final sample consists of 6012 respondents aged over 18.
World Values Survey (WVS)
Cross sectional & cross cultural
Changes in values and attitudes across 97 countries
Random sampling method
Representing 88% of the World`s population
Launched in 1981
Six waves so far
Modernization & Socialization Effects Political Participation
Modernization theory lacks explaining generational effects and socialization theory lacks explaining differences between socioeconomic categories.
The main premise of this paper is to provide
a generational insight into the classical modernization approach
a modernization vision into the socialization approach
within the scope of their interpretation of political participation. It implies
a reciprocal conditionality
between modernization and socialization effects.
Decentralization of power
Political and Civil Rights
The Vietnam War
The Cuban Missile Crisis
The U2 Incident
NATO`s Containment Policy
The Cold War Period
Developing countries political context.
Harvard IJAS, 2014