Introducing 

Prezi AI.

Your new presentation assistant.

Refine, enhance, and tailor your content, source relevant images, and edit visuals quicker than ever before.

Loading…
Transcript

-agreed that objects could be dismantled and reassembled elsewhere, still remaining their identity....

-contended that the requirement was that object's parts had been reassembled...

-claimed that Z did not contained X's parts at all

-claimed that then the plank been removed from Bombos ship and replaiced with new plank, means now new blank is a part of Bombos ship and old part was no longer part of Bombos ship. Rather it was part of Morion ship...

It's clear that X had changed the identity of its parts and that its parts were identical with the parts of Y.

Judgement: X identical to Y. X is not identical to Z for they had no parts in common

Do you agree with this?

What can possibly be an argument?

...imagine hour by hour old ships but perfectly seaworthy, planks are replaced by new planks one by one.

The problem is:

Will it be the same old ship OR a complete new one?...

By: Ausra Surd

Ship company

-after Morion & Bombos paid the bills, but before they taken possetion..there was a fire in dock B

-fire burned down Morion's new ship (Z) in to the ashes

-under the law company were responsible for Marions ship untill he had taken possetion

-they did not insured Morion ship. Insurance would have had be for a 'new' ship, its mean by the newness ships components parts

Bombos - with

Ship X=Y ?

(dock A)

-had sent his ship, to the same ship company for complete renewal of all its parts

-require a thousand new planks for renovation

The Case of Identity

Brian Smart (341-343)

Bombos Lawyer

Marions Lawyer

- claimed that Bombos old then and new now ship is identical X=Y

-argued: under a time objects like human body can undergo a change of identity in all their parts. But overall form retained the same. So Bombos old and new ship its the same and is identical. And Z it was not the same ship as Y

Aging....Immortality ...To understand it we need to consider the nature of identity, because whether you getting older or survive the death depends on whether whatever survives is identical with you-the person...

-Morion persuited to claim ownership of Bombos ship, since he paid for new ship and Y ship was new

-Argued: that Bombos ship was gradually dismantled in dock A and reassembled in dock B. That Bombos ship had been destroyed and Marions ship witch remained...

Morion-with ship-

is Z=Y?! (dock B)

Judges

-had ordered a new ship from scratch

-ship company had persuaded that what he wanted was a ship with well-seasoned timber and told him that his 'new' ship was under constraction in dock B

-do not need 2nd batch of new planks, instead they will use Bombo's old ones

Learn more about creating dynamic, engaging presentations with Prezi