Introducing
Your new presentation assistant.
Refine, enhance, and tailor your content, source relevant images, and edit visuals quicker than ever before.
Trending searches
-agreed that objects could be dismantled and reassembled elsewhere, still remaining their identity....
-contended that the requirement was that object's parts had been reassembled...
-claimed that Z did not contained X's parts at all
-claimed that then the plank been removed from Bombos ship and replaiced with new plank, means now new blank is a part of Bombos ship and old part was no longer part of Bombos ship. Rather it was part of Morion ship...
It's clear that X had changed the identity of its parts and that its parts were identical with the parts of Y.
Judgement: X identical to Y. X is not identical to Z for they had no parts in common
Do you agree with this?
What can possibly be an argument?
-after Morion & Bombos paid the bills, but before they taken possetion..there was a fire in dock B
-fire burned down Morion's new ship (Z) in to the ashes
-under the law company were responsible for Marions ship untill he had taken possetion
-they did not insured Morion ship. Insurance would have had be for a 'new' ship, its mean by the newness ships components parts
-had sent his ship, to the same ship company for complete renewal of all its parts
-require a thousand new planks for renovation
Bombos Lawyer
- claimed that Bombos old then and new now ship is identical X=Y
-argued: under a time objects like human body can undergo a change of identity in all their parts. But overall form retained the same. So Bombos old and new ship its the same and is identical. And Z it was not the same ship as Y
Aging....Immortality ...To understand it we need to consider the nature of identity, because whether you getting older or survive the death depends on whether whatever survives is identical with you-the person...
-Morion persuited to claim ownership of Bombos ship, since he paid for new ship and Y ship was new
-Argued: that Bombos ship was gradually dismantled in dock A and reassembled in dock B. That Bombos ship had been destroyed and Marions ship witch remained...
Judges
-had ordered a new ship from scratch
-ship company had persuaded that what he wanted was a ship with well-seasoned timber and told him that his 'new' ship was under constraction in dock B
-do not need 2nd batch of new planks, instead they will use Bombo's old ones