Introducing 

Prezi AI.

Your new presentation assistant.

Refine, enhance, and tailor your content, source relevant images, and edit visuals quicker than ever before.

Loading…
Transcript

New Empiricisms for 21st Century Social Inquiry: Problematic Realisms After the Ontological Turn

Elizabeth DeFreitas

Manchester Metropolitan University

Liz DeFreitas

Posthuman Realisms in the Anthropocene: Techniques for an Empirical Encounter

Elizabeth St. Pierre

University of Georgia

Elizabeth St. Pierre

Deleuze’s Transcendental Empiricism and Post Qualitative Inquiry

Jerry Rosiek

University of Oregon

Jerry Rosiek

Agential Realism’s Challenge to the Logic of Inference

in Social Inquiry

REPRESENTATION

Posthumanism and Agent Ontologies

Inference

IMPLICATIONS

INFERENCE

Our Book

Forthcoming

January 2021

4 Logics

4 Types of Logic

• Logic is the study of the mathematical properties of formal language systems. Divorces logic from ontology.

• Logic is the study of the semantic features of inference –for example the use of words like “some”, “all,” “and”, “or”.

• Logic is the study of special truths—logical truths—the most general features of all true statements.

• Logic is the study of the most general features of judgment and valuation.

Beyond Reductio ad Absurdum Reasoning

Reductio ad Absurdum

Sorry Sherlock!

The ontological indeterminacy of posthumanism and agential realism violates the two premises on which Reductio arguments depend:

  • Principle of Non-Contradiction

  • Law of the Excluded Middle

Relational Possibility

Josiah Royce's

System Sigma

Relational Possibility

O-Relations

A More Capacious and Open Ended Logic of Judgment That Begins in Ontological Indeterminacy

Relational Possibility

O-Relation

Relational Possibility

Multiple relations are possible, but not all can be enacted.

Relational Possibility

F-Relations

Relational Possibility

Once a relation is acted upon among multiple possible relational possibilities, then the associated indeterminacy is resolved into particularity, and more familiar rules of inference apply.

O-Relation inferences are the unacknowledged sea upon which most forms of empirical reasoning float.

Ethics

THE BIG QUESTION FOR POSTHUMANIST EMPIRICISM

Aesthetics

A Third Term

How do the selections or cuts in the ontologically indeterminate spaces of inquiry get made?

Politics

Royce's logic system highlights that there must be a "third" term, other than the agents and available possibilities, in terms of which cuts get made--for humans or non-humans.

Metaphysics

Metaphysical Questions

I think this leads to an ontology of future possibilities and their influence on the present.

Futurity

Final Causes

Marek Tesar

University of Auckland

Marek Tesar

New Empiricism

and Pre-Socratic

Western Thought

Aislinn O'Donnell

Maynooth University

Aislin O'Donnell

Archipelagic Thought

Learn more about creating dynamic, engaging presentations with Prezi