Implementation of Radioactivity Workshop in Science Center and its Improvements During the First Year in Action Research Design
Karel Kolář, karel@fykos.cz, Faculty of Mathematics and Physics, Charles University, CZ
HSCI 2017, Portugal - Braga, 10th - 14th July 2017
Outline of this presentation
- Motivation
- What are these workshops and where
- Workshop with radioactivity
- What has been improved
- What are we struggling with now
- Summary and vision for future
https://www.seoclerk.com/pics/want31088-1zcV2Q1441993263.png
About me
http://wiki.rvp.cz/@api/deki/files/10483/=800px-Kraj_Hlavni_mesto_Praha.svg.png
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c3/Europe_location_CZ.png
- Ph.D. student
- Physics Education and General Problems of Physics
- Prague (Praha/Prag), The Czech Republic
- Faculty of Mathematics and Physics, Charles University
https://hrdlicka.cz/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/Praha_Hrad_mala.jpg
http://www.pragueinsider.eu/media/uploads/praha/praha_7.jpg
Motivation
- My Ph.D. study - efficiency of informal/out-of-school education
- Growing number of "Science Centers"
- New workshop at iQLANDIA
- Some useful research -> action research
Motivation
http://cdn2.hubspot.net/hubfs/197491/why.jpg
Radioactivity in Czech schools
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/b/b5/Radioactive.svg/512px-Radioactive.svg.png
Radioactivity in Czech schools
Framework Educational Programmes - very concise but contain radioactivity
- Lower secondary (6 - 9)
- Forms of energy - ... , nuclear energy, fission reaction, nuclear reactor, nuclear power plant; protecting people from radioactive radiation
- Upper secondary (10 - 13) - prep for a university = "gymnázium"
- The pupil - uses the knowledge of quantizing radiation energy and microparticles to solve physical problems; assesses the nuclear transformation in terms of input and output particles as well as the energy balance; uses the law of radioactive transformation to predict the behavior of radioactive substances, suggests possible ways of protecting humans from hazardous radiation
- Atoms - the quantization of electron energy in the atom; spontaneous and stimulated emission, laser; nuclear energy; synthesis and atomization of nuclei; chain reaction, nuclear reactor
- But it is usually in the last year of physics at the level
- Some schools do not have experimental equipment
https://www.centrumbabylon.cz/User_Files/iqlandia.jpg
Workshops at iQLANDIA
iQLANDIA - Science Center in Liberec with rich educational program
- Exhibitions
- Planetarium
- Thematic Science Shows
- "Labs" = Workshops
https://www.centrumbabylon.cz/User_Files/photos/537f446247556hvezdna.brana2.jpg
http://g.denik.cz/25/25/laborky-v-iqlandii-nove-i-nemecky_denik-630.jpg
Workshops
http://1gr.cz/fotky/idnes/16/073/cl6/SUC64bd63_WorkshopyviQLANDII1.jpg
- Program for schools/classes/groups
- Actively engaging the students
- Different sciences
- Many different topics
- Primary (1 - 5)
- e.g. "Magnetomania", "Unrestful water"
- Lower secondary (6 - 9)
- e.g. "Science toy", "Hearing and listening"
- Upper secondary (10 - 13)
- e.g. "Energy", "Science in kitchen"
Radioactivity workshop
official name: Nuclear energy
- 8 workplaces/tables
- max 1 class (~ 30 pupils), usually 15 ~ 25
- working in groups of ~ 3
- worksheet for every workplace
- 5 ~ 10 min of introductory talk, ~ 75 min work in teams
- for 8 - 13th grade
Radioactivity workshop
Workplaces
https://web.pslib.cz/getFile/id:13100/IMG_20161018_124221.jpg
- Workplaces with a measurement
- Distance of radioactive source from detector
- Thickness of shielding material
- Different materials (5 metals + air)
- Alpha radiation and shielding of that
- Other activities
- A protective suit
- Nuclear power plant (scheme)
- Model of tokamak
- Dates of important events connected with radiation
https://web.pslib.cz/getFile/id:13103/IMG_20161018_133753.jpg
https://web.pslib.cz/getFile/id:13098/IMG_20161018_122037.jpg
Some pictures
nuclear power plant
protection suit
distance dependence
https://web.pslib.cz/getFile/id:13099/IMG_20161018_122110.jpg
What is action research?
In short -> see picture
Useful design
- provides concrete feedback
- researcher in closer contact with researched activities, more active
- -> description of interventions
http://cei.ust.hk/files/public/arcycle.jpg
Our action research
- Observation
- Preparation of workshop
- Pupils working; during some workshops
- Analysis of worksheets
- Tests for participants
- Feedback
https://web.pslib.cz/getFile/id:13102/IMG_20161018_130750.jpg
In spite of 1 year cooperation -> just preliminary results
Dealing with operational problems
- Sometimes 6th grade without any prior knowledge
- Workshops are according the demands of schools
Workplaces
https://i.ytimg.com/vi/9EZodcmpPzE/maxresdefault.jpg
- Some thoughts about natural radioactivity
- Takes too much time to measure properly
- Radioactivity of natural sources
- Not so much radioactive (except for pitchblende (uranium ore))
- Possible new workplace?
- Radioactivity in medical care - just thoughts, it should be interactive
Worksheets
- New workshop -> provisional worksheets this year (black and white) - possible to change texts
- All worksheets start with "flavor text"
- Improvements of textation, placement of texts, highlighting
- e.g. chosing of metal for measurement of the shielding
- Added and removed some questions
- Added - question about the number of nuclear reactor in the Czech Republic (9 - NPP Dukovany (4), NPP Temelín (2), Řež (2) and FNSPE in Prague (1))
- Just now printing colourful version (see higher)
Tests
- Pretest/Posttest -> gain
- 5 simple open-ended questions
- Anonymous, evaluated as group
- The research tool is not optimal
- Motivation of participants
- Writing takes time
- Retention?
- Results
- Depends on the group
- Often seemingly almost no improvement
- Can be influenced by - lack of motivation, they want to go to the exposition, lack of self confidence, maybe complicated questions...
- This is not conclusive - small sample, improvements on-go
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/19/Castle_Romeo.jpg
Future plans
- We'd like to continue
- Test
- Make it electronic
- Problem with tablets
- Try to quantitatively measure gain/effectsize and on greater sample
- Maybe cooperation on some new workshop
Acknowledgments
The presentation was supported by the Charles University, project GA UK No 188515.
The research and this presentation would not be possible without cooperation of iQLANDIA and its employees.
Acknowledgments