The Carr Brothers

3rd-7th Victims

Jason Befort

Bradley Heyka

2nd Victim

• 26 years old
• Science teacher
• Coach at Augusta High School

• 27 years old
• Financial anaylist

Ann Walenta

All the evidence that was shown in the courtroom.

• 55 years old
• Librarian
• Cellist

Aaron Sander

Heather Muller

The house the Carr brothers broke into.

• 29 years old
• Studying priesthood

• 25 years old
• Church preschool teacher

What happened?

What happened?

Holly Schreiber

• Happened on December 11, 2000
• The brothers attempted to carjack Ann Walenta
• Ann tried to escape from the Carr brothers, but they shot her multiple times
• She died a few days later in the hospital

• 25 years old
• School teacher

Stryker Soccer Complex: The place the Carr brothers took the victims to kill them.

• Happened on December 14, 2000
• Carr brothers broke into the men's house around 11 pm
• Carr brothers tortured and sexually abused the victims
• Forced at gunpoint to perform sexual acts with eachother for the entertainment of the brothers
• Both of the women were raped and all five of the victims were beaten
• Each victim had to go to an ATM naked and take out all of their money in their bank accounts
• Carr brothers took the naked victims to a soccer field around 2 am
• There was snow on the ground and it was 17 degrees
• The brothers made the victims kneel on the ground and shot each one of them in the back of the head
• They then got in one of the victims truck and ran over each victim
• Carr brothers returned to the house and stole anything of value and beat and shot Holly's dog

Investigation

Convictions

• By the next morning, police already had calls of the two men on the outskirts of town
• The police went to Reginald Carr's girlfriend's house where they found him trying to sneak out of a window
• That afternoon the police had Jonathan Carr in custody.
• The police found a .380 Caliber dumped along the highway near the soccer fields
• Police confirmed it was the gun that shot all of the victims and the tires of Andrew's car.
• The men were identified by Schreiber and dying Walenta.

Works Cited

• The brothers had their trial together
• Reginald Carr: Guilty of all 50 crimes charged against him
• Jonathan Carr: Guilty of 43 crimes
• These crimes include capital murder, first degree murder, robbery, sexual assault, rape, etc.
• The two brothers both received the death penalty
• The brothers have been appealing their case so a specific date has not been set to execute the brothers
• The trial took 8 weeks long
• It was reported that Reginald Carr winked and smiled at all of the victims families as he walked out of the courtroom

Who are the Carr Brothers?

Reginald Carr

The Survivor

Jonathan Carr

• Born in 1978
• Grew up in Dodge City
• Would put up fights at school and experienced with the knowledge of drugs starting at six years old
• As an adult had a series of failed marriages

• Holly Schreiber was the only survivor
• When the Carr brothers shot her in the back of the head the bullet deflected off of her barrette and grazed her skull.
• As the Carr brothers drove over the victims she was small enough that she sunk in the snow bank so the car didn't crush her
• After she laid on the snow for 30 minutes she saw Christmas lights so she ran over a mile to try and get help
• She pounded on a couples door at 3 am and told them everything that happened before she saw any medical attention

• Born in 1980
• Grew up in Dodge City
• Suicidal throughout high school

• Davidson, Sam. "Wichita Massacre." Occidental Dissent. N.p., 9 Dec. 2011. Web. 15 Apr. 2015.
• "Reginald and Jonathan Carr." Criminal Minds Wiki. N.p., n.d. Web. 14 Apr. 2015.
• Webster, Stephen. "The Wichita Massacre." The Wichita Massacre. Racial Nationalist Library, Aug. 2002. Web. 15 Apr. 2015.
• "The Wichita Horror by Denise Noe." New Nation News. New Nation, n.d. Web. 15 Apr. 2015.

• During the robbery, the Carr brothers found an engagement ring in a popcorn can.
• Jason Befort told Holly that he was planning to propose to her in a couple of days.
• Currently, Holly is married to the first victim, Andrew Schreiber, and they live in Kansas City with kids.

1st Victim:

Andrew Schreiber

Home Life for the Carr Brothers

• 23 years old
• Assistant baseball coach at Newman University

What happened?

• Their parents fought a ton and were extremely violent with one another
• The brothers witnessed their father and later their mother's boyfriends sexually abuse their older sister
• After their parents divorced, their father abandoned them
• Their mother married again where herself and her kids were abused
• The boys would occasionally live with their grandma
• She was very abusive to the boys

• Happened on December 8, 2000
• Andrew was at a convenient store when the Carr brothers approached him
• At gun point, the brothers made Andrew drive to various ATM's withdrawing his own money
• The brothers left him in a field, unharmed, and shot the tires of his car

The Carr Brothers: Spree Killers

By:Ellie Keating