Creating Engaging Discussions
Jen Obando - Sr. Instructional Designer - Stevens WebCampus
First Order of Business
First Order of Business
TODAY'S SCHEDULE
1
Pros and Cons
Examples and Use Cases
2
Today's schedule
3
Setting them Up
4
Managing and Grading
Essential Understandings
One size will never fit all
A Word About Ed Tech
Any ed tech tool is simply a means to an end – to help students achieve a specific learning goal
- Class size
- Course level
- Content type (theoretical, applications, collaborative, etc.)
- Student demographic
- Comfort level with technology
- Resulting work load for instructor
- ……
Pros, Cons, and Use Cases
Pros, Cons, and Use Cases
Discussion Board Formats
Formats
1 + 2
Post one original thought, respond to two peers
3CQ
1 Compliment,
1 Comment,
1 Connection,
1 Question
3CQ
MANIC
- Most important thing
- Agree with the reading
- Not agree with the reading
- Interesting
- Confusing
TQE
(good for readings):
- Thoughts,
- lingering Questions,
- Epiphanies
Recall, Summarize, Question, Connect, and Comment
Recall, Summarize, Question, Connect, and Comment
- Works well for starting or ending the week
- recall it, summarize it, phrase a remaining question, connect it to the class as a whole, and comment on that class session (or reading)
Lecture/Reading Reaction
Divide discussion into 4 groups
- Questioners
- Example Givers
- Divergent Thinkers
- Agreers
How to Set Up Great Discussions
The "How To"
Goals to Keep in Mind
The Set-Up
The Quest
Insert a 3x3 table
Create a Discussion Prompt with a Hyperlink
or any other size you want
Your Turn
Insert an Image
Insert a Video
Managing the Workload
Asking students to participate means added work for us!
Let's Discuss
Let's Discuss
Post-discussion summaries
Assign student facilitators
Instructor posts initial prompt
Avoid close-ended prompts
Instructor summarizes main points
Ideas for Managing
Allow them to guide discussion
Create fewer throughout semester
Acknowledge some students by name (shout outs)
Keep track of your shout-outs
They provide the feedback to further the discussion
You provide the guidelines
Rethink # of responses expected
Give at least one to each student in semester
Grading Strategies
Ideas for Grading
Rubric examples
University of Central Florida
Rubrics
1
2
3
Assign points only to comments that advance the conversation
Conversation Advancers
Tell student up front how many you will grade
IRS Audit
- 3 out of 5
- 5 out of 7
- 5 out of 10
Allow peer review/feedback to inform your grading
Peer feedback
Need to be thoughtfully designed.
Wrap-Up
In Conclusion, Discussions...
Students need guidelines.