KENTUCKY AND VIRGINIA RESOLUTIONS OF 1798 - 1799
Eleonora Canu
Valentina Di Carlantonio
Compact theory
- the Constitution as a compact among the States
- States voluntarily delegated powers
opposition: federal government is not a compact among the States
it was formed directly by the people
Kentucky resolutions of 1798 and 1799
- Political statements by the Kentucky legislature
- Principle of '98
- Alien and Sedition Acts declared unauthoritative and void
- Called for outright rebellion
The case
Nullification
Background
- the rightful remedy against the federal government
- state level resistance
- founded on the Tenth Amendment
Alien and Sediction Acts of 1798
- four bills signed by John Adams
- extended the powers of the federal government
- Republicans against the Alien and Sedition Acts
- Resolutions drafted by Jefferson and Madison
- Constitution of 1789 Federal
compact
- Federalists vs Republicans
remedies against the strong government
Virginia resolutions of 1798 - 1799
Interposition
States have the right to prevent harm caused by unconstitutional laws.
- Actions taken to interpose
- Madison asserted in his Report that states are "duty bound to interpose"
House of Delegates resolved into a committee sundry resolutions
- Maintain and defend the Constitution against aggression
- General Assembly declares a warm attachment to the union of states
- Federal powers are derived from the Constitution, and it is a compact to which the states are parties
- Maintaining independence against hostilities of foreign countries
- The policy of US forbids a war of aggression
Results
Future quotations
- Kentucky and Virginia resolutions encouraged 14 states in declaring that the Alien and Sedition Acts were unconstitutional
- They expressed outright disapproval