Mixed-Member Proportional Representation
MMP - Proposed System
MMP: Governments
Ontario Select Committee on Electoral Reform
- usually majority coalition governments
- more parties get seats
- more smaller parties
- greater representation of diverse views
- cooperation among parties
- legitimacy
- fairness of representation
- voter choice
- effective parties
- stable and effective government
- effective parliament
- stronger voter participation
- accountability
SMP: Governments
Current Canadian Electoral System
SMP vs. MMP
- usually single party majority governments
- stable and effective governments able to implement mandates
- less constructive political debate
- elections: not about representation >> competition between governing teams
SMP
Controversial Aspects of the MMP System
MMP
- complexity in calculation
- undemocratic party list creation
- wasted votes in SMP systems
- unstable coalitions
- limited voter choice: one candidate only
- no splitting of votes between candidates and parties
- doesn't produce proportional results
- high barrier of winning seats >> underrepresented groups
- greater voter choice: 2 votes >> one for a party, one for a candidate
- produces good proportionality
- more representation of underrepresented groups