Send the link below via email or IMCopy
Present to your audienceStart remote presentation
- Invited audience members will follow you as you navigate and present
- People invited to a presentation do not need a Prezi account
- This link expires 10 minutes after you close the presentation
- A maximum of 30 users can follow your presentation
- Learn more about this feature in our knowledge base article
Evidence Based Practice
Transcript of Evidence Based Practice
Behavioral Problems & Substance Abuse
American Psychological Association Task Force on Evidence-Based Practice for Children and Adolescents (2008). Disseminating evidence-based practice for children and adolescents: A systems approach to enhancing care. Washington , DC: American Psychological Association.
Evidence Based Practice
What is it?
Evidence Based Practice
Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology
, 37(1), 2008.
Naomi Leong, MS LMHC, MFT
of the best available
Institute of Medicine
2 major elements of EBP:
1. Sound assessment
2. Evidence-based interventions
Accurate identification of disorders
Ongoing monitoring during care (even weekly)
Outcome evaluation at end of treatment
Longitudinal data for short
long term outcomes
Procedures shown to improve symptoms
Makes it possible to match the child's condition to the appropriate treatment
ACA Code of Ethics
Counselors have a responsibility to the public to engage in counseling practices that are based on rigorous
NASW Code of Ethics
American Counseling Association www.counseling.org
Social workers should base practice on recognized knowledge, including
based knowledge, relevant to social work and social work ethics.
Best practices mean adhering to ethical standards
National Association of Social Workers
For Children and Adolescents
Challenges to an Evidence-Based Practice
Children present with multiple
social and family problems and situations,
Most evidence-based treatments (EBTs) are designed for
A scientifically minded approach
Evidence-based Practice (EBP)
Evidence-based Treatment (EBT)
Refers to either
programs for which there is a strong
A framework for discussing the broader movement
Criticism of EBP
Medical model origins
Neglects person variables
Types of evidence
Traditional psychometric and quantitative approaches rooted in Western European and North American cultures
Disease oriented approach
Prevention not emphasized
Scientific advances have been organized by
due to prominence of the DSM and major funding organizations such as NIMH.
Efforts being made to use more diverse forms of research including qualitative methods.
Rather than focusing on particular theories, models, or treatments, EBP focuses on the
of assessment, treatment and ongoing monitoring in efforts to promote quality care.
Family centered care
EBP is about integrating
in initial assessment and diagnosis, case formulation, intervention procedures, clinical decision making, and monitoring of client progress.
"Psychological services are most likely beneficial when they are responsive to a
specific problems, strengths, personality, sociocultural context, and preferences"
(Presidential Task Force on Evidence-Based Practice, 2006)
Criticism of EBP
Could lead to restriction of services
Recommendations may lead to the development of lists of
treatments that could:
limit reimbursements by managed care companies
be applied to populations where there is no evidence of efficacy
Continuing research will lead to the development of
treatments that are
Lillienfeld, S. (2014).
Evidence-Based Practice: The Misunderstandings Continue
. Retrieved 9-4-14 from www.psychologytoday.com
Why is EBP important?
Many practicioners are not using scientifically supported therapies for
Surveys show only 20% of people with Major Depressive DO receive effective treatment.
EBP reduces clinical error:
Decreases chances that clients will be exposed to interventions that:
Criticism of EBP
Mandates Cookie-Cutter Approach
Prevents clinicians from using unvalidated interventions
Does not take enough theoretical plausibility into account
EBP needs to be expanded to incorporate
along with rigorous research evidence so
programs are not left out.
EBP relies too heavily on random controlled trials.
Only implies getting informed consent if using experimental interventions.
Treatments can be modified for individual clients.
Eliminates clinical judgment
Criticism of EBP
Client preferences and values
Clinical judgment and expertise
Research evidence on efficacy and effectiveness
Coping Cat: Ages 7-13
C.A.T. Project: Adolescent
Evidence Based Treatments (EBT's)
Presented by diagnosis
Cognitive- Behavioral Treatment
Therapist manual and client workbook
Computer version: called Camp Cope-A-Lot
Coping Cat Workbook $27, C.A.T. Project Workbook $27, Therapist Manual $24
Computer version $200 for individual use, $2000 for an institution
Social Effectiveness Training for Children (SET-C)
For children and adolescents ages 7-17
Multi-component treatment program
Decrease social anxiety
Increase interpersonal skills
Expand range of enjoyable activities
Combines group social skills training, structured peer generalization sessions, and individualized behavioral exposure treatment.
One educational session with parents, 12 group sessions, and 12 in-vivo exposure sessions over a 12 week period.
Therapist's Guide, Parent's Guide, activity cards for group sessions and weekly contracts for setting behavioral goals.
Adolescents Coping with Depression (CWD-A)
Sixteen 2-hour sessions over an 8 week period in small groups.
Increasing pleasant activities
Challenging unrealistic thinking that fosters depression
Social skills, improving communication, conflict resolution
Includes parallel parent course that addresses solutions to conflict with their teens.
Cost: FREE downloads at
Brief, individual treatment program (5-9 sessions) for youth who are also receiving SSRI's.
InterPersonal Therapy for Depressed Adolescents (IPT-A)
Brief 12-16 session psychosocial intervention
Goal: Decrease a client's depressive sx and improve social functioning within the context of his or her significant relationships.
Identify interpersonal competencies
Developmental: Addresses separation from parents, exploration of authority in relation to parents, development of sexual relationships, peer pressures. etc.
Cost: $25 from Guilford Press
Parental involvement: An individual tx but some degree of parent/guardian involvement helps with tx success.
Gately, G, (August 13, 2014). Evidence-based 'Gold Standard': Coveted Yet Controversial www.jjie.org
The Incredible Years
Small Group Dinosaur
Parent and Teacher training programs
Ages 4-8 with disruptive bx
2-hour weekly small group sessions for 20 weeks
How to be successful in school
How to be friendly
Functional Family Therapy (FFT)
Multisystemic Therapy (MST)
Self-administered Treatment, plus Signal Seat
Time out chair that sounds an alarm whenever the child leaves the chair without permission.
Signal seat increases parental consistency, minimizes inconvenience.
Penn Prevention Program (PPP)
Manuals not available to the public yet!
Structured therapist's manual and workbook.
20 group and 2 individual sessions
Problem solving skills
Sense of self
Cost: Workbook $24 $Therapist Manual $21
The California Evidence-Based Clearinghouse for Child Welfare www.cebc4cw.org
Mentalization-Based Treatment (MBTA)
Training available at the Anne Freud Centre
Self harm, trauma
Extensive training and funding
Primary and Secondary Control Enhancement Training (PASCET)
Family Focused Treatment for Adolescents (FFT-A)
For adolescents with Bipolar Disorder and their families
21 session, 9 month intervention: 12 weekly, 6 biweekly, 3 monthly
Communication Enhancement Training
Problem-Solving Skills Training
Cost: $28 for paperback
Individual-Family PsychoEducational Psychotherapy (IF-PEP)
Biopsychosocial approach based on cognitive-behavioral and family systems principles.
Cost: Therapist Manual $25, Parent Workbook
$25, Child Workbook $25
Learn about symptoms of mood disorders
Effectively manage the symptoms
Improve problem solving
Improve emotional regulation
Decrease family tension
Applicable to an outpatient mental health setting
Accessible (doesn't require grants, funding, extensive certification process, treatment manuals available, etc.)
The California Evidence-Based Clearinghouse for Child Welfare
APA Journal Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology, Special Issue: Evidence-based psychosocial treatments for children and adolescents: a ten year update, Vol 37, Issue 1 (2008)
Blueprints for Healthy Youth Development
No treatments have been identified that supported
psychotherapeutic or cognitive-behavioral treatments such as:
Individual therapy, Play therapy, Cognitive Therapy
Behavioral Parent Training (BPT)
No significant difference between those who were taking concurrent Rx and those who were not
Behavioral Classroom Management
Treatment manual not available but...
LifeSkills Training (LST)
School or institution based
Rational-Emotive Mental Health Program (REMH)
Helping the Noncompliant Child (HNC)
Free ten-hour basic web-based training www.musc.edu/tfcbt
Treatment Manual: Treating Trauma and
Traumatic Grief in Children and Adolescents $31 Available at www.guilford.com or www.amazon.com
Psychoeducation and parenting skills
Affective expression and regulation
Trauma narrative and processing
In vivo exposure
Conjoint parent/child sessions
Enhancing personal safety and future growth
Prolonged Exposure Therapy for Adolescents (PET-A)
Therapist guide available as ebook $20 books.google.com
For treatment of PTSD
Ages 12-18 but has been used with children 6-12
8-15 sessions or 2-4 months
Clients are encouraged to repeatedly approach situations or activities they are avoiding because they remind them of their trauma (
in vivo exposure
as well as revisit the traumatic memory several times through retelling it (
GAD, Social Phobia, or SAD
Full package including manuals, books and 1 CEU available for $335 from www.socio.com
12-16 weekly sessions
Lots of parental involvement needed- home based exposure challenges.
Bridges gap between home, clinic and school goals.
Uses humor and rewards.
Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR)
$210 for DVD course www.emdr.com
Information processing therapy
Involves simultaneously thinking of a negative belief, a positive belief and body sensations while moving their eyes back and forth for 20-30 seconds.
"Possibly efficacious" by APA
Adolescents with PTSD
(1) the past events that have laid the groundwork for dysfunction are processed, forging new associative links with adaptive information;
(2) the current circumstances that elicit distress are targeted, and internal and external triggers are desensitized;
(3) imaginal templates of future events are incorporated, to assist the client in acquiring the skills needed for adaptive functioning.
Treatment manual available for $30 from www.guilford.com
Ages 3-8 with disruptive bx
Addesses faulty parent-child interactions.
8-10 sessions are held in a playroom setting.
Phase I: Parents give increased attention to the child while ignoring minor inappropriate bx.
Phase II: Parents learn to provide direct, concise instructions to the child, allow the child sufficient time to comply, and provide appropriate consequences for compliance or noncompliance.
Triple P Positive Parenting Program
Multidimensional Family Therapy
Brief Strategic Family Therapy (BSFT)
Sexualy risky bx
Improve family functioning
Free manual available at:
12-16 family sessions
Cash's Body Image Therapy, plus Virtual Reality
Free tx manual available at:
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy
Dialectic Behavioral Therapy
A person is having emotional problems because of unresolved unconscious conflicts.
Focuses on the behaviors and interactions a client has with family and friends.
Helps people to identify and change inaccurate perceptions about themselves and the world.
Focuses on changing destructive behaviors, replacing bad habits with good ones.
Promotes acceptance and change simultaneously. Targets emotional dysregulation, suicidal bx, interpersonal deficits, and tx resistance.
Expressive or Art Therapy
EBT's are based on one or more types of therapies.
Based on the idea that people can heal themselves through art, music, dance, writing, etc.
Involve using toys and games to help a child identify and talk about their feelings.
Virtual reality simulations are used as repeated exposures to represent the client's body in various significant contexts:
in the kitchen
in front of a mirror
Safety behavior prevention
Body self-esteem building
(for the most part)
Cost $17 for paperback
Modified for adolescents by incorporating illness-specific elements for this population.
Weekly Family Skills Training
Weekly Individual Therapy
Essential element of traditional DBT. Clients are encouraged to call when they have the urge to engage in problem behaviors.
Free treatment manual available at:
DBT and CBT complement and supplement each other well. DBT effective with
parasuicidal bx , emotional dysregulation,
, CBT more appropriate for
. DBT concepts expands the range of self-talk options available to the teen. Use of imagery and other DBT techniques are
CBT to life
Services and Teens at Risk www.starcenter.pitt.edu
Based on the viewpoint that eating disorders areise from teen's inability to rely on other human beings for satisfy their emotional needs.
No treatment manual
Eating disorders lack a gold standard treatment but this one looks really hopeful and evidence is building:
The Maudsley Method
Puts parents at the center of making sure their kids eat, rather than blaming them.
Treatment manual available: www.textbookrush.com $29
Standardized Program Evaluation Protocol (SPEP)
Looks at "generic" programs to see how close they come to evidence-based treatments.
Can be a bridge between EBT's and programs already in use.
Being used in the at-risk-youth field.
to make sure your intervention is effective.
Be a wise consumer of research:
keep up to date on research
be open to other types of evidence than RCT's but proceed with caution
don't just read headlines
be aware that other treatments may be effective but lack studies.
Actually a combo of DBT and CBT
Antecedent Assessment & Intervention Strategies
Language and autism: Applied behavior analysis, evidence and practice
A treasure chest of behavioral strategies for individuals with autism
Joint Attention Intervention
Lesson ideas and activities for young children with autism and related special needs
Seeing is believing: Video self-modeling for people with autism and other developmental disabilities
Story-Based Intervention Package
The new social story
Activity schedules for children with autism
Treatment package with Therapist Manual, Parent Workbook and Child Workbook available at www.centreforemotionalhealth.com.au
$60 per age group
Preschool 3-6 years
Cognitive-Behavioral treatment for Anxiety
12 weeks, 8 weekly individual sessions followed by 2 biweekly sessions.
Available in individual or group format
Improved coping strategies
Extremely important to adhere to evidence-based practice with this dx due to controversy surrounding harmful and sometimes fatal treatments.
"The most important intervention for young children dx with RAD and who lack attachment to a discriminated caregiver is for the clinician to advocate for providing the child with an emotionally available attachment figure" (AACAP, 2014).
Few studies have been done on psychotherapies with youth, but current evidence shows including these
leads to benefits:
Psychoeducation about illness and tx options
Social skills training
Basic life skills training
Problem solving strategies
Psychoeducation for family
1. Address child's needs for safe, dependable, predictable, responsive caregiving
The goal is for the child to gain new learning about relationships that can be generalized to other significant relationships- that relationships are not dangerous.
2. Address the child's traumatic history using EBT models such as TFCBT.
If the child does not have memory of their pathogenic care and/or does not have PTS sx then revisiting trauma directly is not indicated.
It is important for the clinician not to provide info about past trauma that the child is not already aware of.
Focusing on past trauma is important so that it is not confirmed for the child that certain things cannot be spoken.
3.Address unsafe or high risk bx immediately using EBT models.
Problem Solving Skills Training
Sexually inappropriate bx:
Ongoing risk assessment and safety planning
4. There have been no psychopharmacologic trials for RAD.
Rx may be called for to treat co-morbid conditions or for symptom specific tx of emotional dysregulation.
(Potter, et al, 2009)
Center for Child & Family Health, Clinical Guildenlies Series, 2009: Reactive Attachment Disorder, Potter, et al.
There is not a specific EBT for RAD, but there are clinical guidelines for an EBP approach.
Problem Solving Skills Training (PSST)
Ages 7-13 with Disruptive Bx
20-25 sessions with the child
+ Practice version adds homework
+ Practice and Parent Managment version adds parent sessions
Unable to locate complete manual
but an overview of the knowledge and skils needed for a clinician is available for free at :
Manual: Problem-solving Skills Training for Children and Adolescents with Oppositional, Aggressive, and Antisocial Behavior: Overview, (Kazdin, 2009)
Positive reinforcement of appropriate bx
Teaching alternate bx's
Managing thoughts and feelings
American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry
American Counseling Association
University of Pittsburg Medical Center, Western Psychiatric Institute and Clinic
University of Pittsburg Medical Center, Western Psychiatric Institute and Clinic
American Association of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry
For Substance Abuse & Behavioral Problems:
Children and adolescents with sexually inappropriate bx
hx of sexual abuse
Treatment Protocol based on research on EBT's, rather than single EBT
(Hof, et al, 2009)
Building rapport, safe environment
Sharing stories of offending bx and personal victimization
Ownership of bxs, understanding development of unhealthy patterns
Exploration of client's fantasies
Understanding bx cycle, thoughts, feelings, triggers, impact of victimization.
Teaching model of healthy sexuality
Reexamine current relationships
Focusing on client's taking responsibility for their actions
Education on sex offender assault & lapse cycle, identifying realistic replacement bxs
Building client's support system
Development of relapse prevention plan
Treatment Protocol, not EBT
Treatment protocol outlined earlier in presentation
Hof, D. D., Dinsmore, J. A., Hock, C. M., Bishop, M. A., & Scofield, T. R. (2009). Deviant sexuality in children and adolescents: A protocol for the concurrent treatment of sexual victimization and sex offending behaviors. In G. R. Walz, J. C. Bleuer, & R. KI. Yep (Eds.), Compelling counseling interventions: VISTAS 2009 (pp. 235-245). Alexandria, VA: American Counseling Association.
VALID and RELIABLE!
At the beginning, during, and at the end of tx
Children's Depression Inventory (CDI)
$349 for online kit with 25 tests, 2.75 per additional test
Clinical Outcomes in Routine Evaluation (CORE)
34 item full outcome measure
Valid and reliable across dx
Behavior and Assessment System for Children (BASC)
Assesses behavior in ages 2-21
$637 for starter set with computer entry and 25 tests
Designed for EBP
Quick to administer
Self-report takes 30 min
Free downloads of manuals and forms available at: http://www.coreims.co.uk/download-pdfs
Over the last week…
1. I’ve felt edgy or nervous
2. I haven’t felt like talking to anyone
3. I’ve felt able to cope when things go wrong
4. I’ve thought of hurting myself
5. There’s been someone I felt able to ask for help
6. My thoughts and feelings distressed me
7. My problems have felt too much for me
8. It’s been hard to go to sleep or stay asleep
9. I’ve felt unhappy
10. I’ve done all the things I wanted to
0- Not at all
1- Only occasionally
5- All the time
Short version of self reports takes 10 min
Screen for Child Anxiety Related Disorders (SCARED)Youth Version
10 min to administer
Child PTSD Symptom Scale (CPSS)
Further research needed on whether SCARED Brief Assessment is empirically supported
5-10 min to administer
Trauma Symptom Checklist for Children (TSCC)
$172 for intro kit
Mood and Feeling Questionnaire (MFQ)
5-10 minutes to administer
Short version for both caregiver and child with only 13 items available
Eyeberg Child Behavior Inventory (ECBI)
Parent reports takes 5-10 min
$208 for kit including manual and 50 tests
General outcome assessment
15 min to administer
Parent, child and provider versions
General outcome assessment
Looking to the future...
Research will need to focus on increasing developmental, cultural, systemic, preventative, and humanistic considerations
Areas for growth
Types of Evidence
Random Controlled Trials (RCT's)
People are randomly assigned to treatment conditions, one of which is a control group.
2. Quasi-Experimental Design
People are not randomly assigned to groups.
i.e. Case Study
An in depth look at a particular situation
On the other hand...
Many of the EBT's recommended may be due to the fact that they have the most research behind them.
Research Designs 101
4. Observational Research
3. Correlational Research
1. True Experimental Design
Looks at the covariation of two variables
and keeping in mind...
Something can be considered credible based on appearances
Using EBT's but also...
Successful treatments typically involve intensive 40 hr/week interventions.
One of the biggest...