Introduction
"Being a student-athlete is challenging because you have to juggle practice schedules and traveling for games with classes….Most of us have scholarship responsibilities, so we can’t afford to fall behind in our school work."
KRISTY CARLIN - Women’s Basketball Player at Southeast Louisiana University
Cont. Introduction
- SLU is a Sub Bowl Division I institution, but the student-athletes there face the same stressors as those who compete in revenue generating sports at major D1 institutions.
- Endless hours dedicated to athletics and academics, hardly leaves time for personal life let alone acquire a job. Meanwhile institutions are making millions of dollars off the efforts these student-athletes give on the field.
Cont. Introduction
- We argue SAs deserve a stipend from the NCAA due to the money made off of their likeliness, jersey sells, etc.
- Draw comparisons between individuals at the nation’s military academies and provide a model on how NCAA could provide stipends for student-athltes.
Why the Need?
- Athletes deserve the financial benefits of their labor;
- Under the current system they do not see any financial return;
- The National Collegiate Athletic Association is not giving back revenue to the people who created in the first place;
- For example, last weekend’s NCAA Men’s and Woman’s basketball tournaments generated and what came back for athletes ?
Why the Need ? Cont.
- Many of the players on college basketball and football teams come from low income, disadvantaged backgrounds, etc;
- The player is putting the fans in their seats, selling the jerseys and doing all the work, not the college or university. Yet the college or the university is making all the money;
- Revenue that is generated by college athletes needs to be shared with them.
Why the Need ? Cont.
- In reality, lots of behind the scenes dealings are taking place that the NCAA has no concept of;
- Moreover, what does the NCAA often do when they find a violation of its policies? They punish innocent athletes who have nothing to do with the violation;
- The NCAA and its member institution need to abandon their archaic system of servitude.
Why the Need ? Cont.
- What should happen with the jersey and video game sales. In addition, college athletes also can’t do things like sign endorsement deals or make paid appearances.
Questions for discussions
- What right can the NCAA tell a person how they can make a living?
- Why is the NCAA so intent on limiting the earning potential and free exercise of speech of student-athletes?
- Why is it that only the NCAA that can profit from others hard work and success?
Possible Solutions
- All of the major sports leagues have player unions, it negotiated everything !
- Each school will need to pool the revenue generated from apparel and merchandise sales from each of its teams;
- This step towards equality is only half the battle. The issue of athletes being free to make money outside of the University setting still remains;
- The long hand of the NCAA should not restrict what an athlete does on his or her own time and with their own image.
Service Academy Stipends and Pay for Play
United States Military Academy (USMA)
- Recruited athletes made up 22% (279/1246) of the student body of the class of 2002.
- Admissions is based on a “whole person” score.
USMA Cost of Enrollment
- The cost per graduate was $349,327 for the graduating class of 2002. For 2012, inflation alone brings the number to over $400,000.
CADET PAY
- Stipend For FY 2011: 12 months
- Unsecured Loan: before Spring break of Jr year
- $25,000 at 1% interest through a financial institution
- Cadet student body treasurer lobbies financial institution for best rate and terms.
Summer Training
- Cadet Basic Training: Mid June-Mid August for incoming freshmen;
- Cadet Field Training: Mid June-First Week Aug;
- Army Schools: Airborne, Air assault;
- Cadet Leadership Training: 30 days during the summer entering Jr or Sr year;
- Athletes also help with camps;
- Cadets rarely get more than 2 or 3 weeks for summer vacation and only 2-3 weeks for Christmas.
Mandatory Athletics
- All cadets must partake in at least:
- 1 competitive club and 1 intramural sport
- Non-athletic student = Scholarships + work related income
- Military student = Schooling paid + scholarships + stipend
Time Constraints of the Student-Athlete
- SA: Substantial amount of time representing the institution Scholarships + No pay
- Compromised break periods
- 30+ hours/week in sport-related activities
Student-Athlete Financial Aid Limitation
- Bylaws 15.1, 15.1.1: Cost of attendance + Pell Grant
- Bylaw 15.02.2: Cost of attendance
- Other institution-related expenses
- Bylaw 15.02.4.2 - Exceptions
- Money from parents/guardian
- Established outside programs (15.2.6.3)
Student-Athlete Financial Aid Limitation Cont.
- Military students - Stipend
- Non-athletic students - Work-related income
- Student-athlete - Only what the institution allows
- Modify Bylaw 15.1: Allow SA to accumulate funds from external sources above and beyond cost of attendance and/or the Implementation of other aid option
Additional Scholarships
Options:
- Corporate: - Best Buy $1,000 - Dell $20,000;
- Group: Rotary Club, Masons, Kiwanis, etc;
- Non-athletic student: apply for any and all;
- Modify Bylaws 15.02.4.2, 15.1;
- SA: apply for any and all
Military Model
- per ACADEMIC YEAR month for every athlete.
- Treated as part of grant in aid so it is non-taxable.
Sample Data: 2009-10 Athletic Department Revenue-Cost Number Crunch
Low-Interest Loan Option
- $25,000, the average undergrad student loan debt for the US, which is available midway through the student athletes’ Jr year.
- Loan and terms are lobbied each year by Student Athlete Body representatives.
- Loan not through the institution, but a credible financial institution.
Benefits of Option
- ↓ Fund-seeking from potentially illegal sources by SA
- ↓ Possibility of infractions regarding aid/benefits
- ↓ Attrition: ↑ Upper class experience
- ↑ Relocation expenses upon graduation
- Potential ↑ High school interest in athletics
- A more = Continuum: Military - Non-Athlete – SA
What it takes:
Modification of Bylaws 15.1, 15.1.1, 15.02.2, 15.04.2.2
Title IX Benefit
- If all athletes were paid, then it may increase participation of the “underrepresented sex” and lead to less programs being dropped due to Prong 1 compliance.
"Being a student-athlete is challenging because you have to juggle practice schedules and
traveling for games with classes….Most of us have scholarship responsibilities, so we can’t
afford to fall behind in our school work."
Kristy Carlin; Women’s Basketball Player at Southeast Louisiana University
SLU is a Sub Bowl Division I institution, but the student-athletes there face the same stressors as those who compete in revenue generating sports at major D1 institutions.
Endless hours dedicated to athletics and academics, hardly leaves time for personal life let alone acquire a job Meanwhile institutions are making millions of dollars off the efforts these student-athletes give on the field.
We argue SAs need to reserve a stipend from the NCAA due to the money made off of their
likeliness, jersey sells, etc.
Drawing comparisons individuals at the nation’s military academies and provide a model on how NCAA could provide stipends for student-athltes.
Improving the Athletic Scholarship: A Military Model
Alexander M. Bruce INDIANA UNIVERSITY
Daniel J. Ciccarelli K 611
Paulo V. B. Negri NCAA Compliance
Riley D. Buchanan Chad Witkemper
Ryan P. Vooris
Cost of Attendance (Current IU Costs)
United States Military Academy (USMA)
USMA Cost of Enrollment
- The cost per graduate was $349,327 for the graduating class of 2002. For 2012, inflation alone brings the number to over $400,000.
Cost of Attendance (Current IU Costs)
- Recruited athletes made up 22% (279/1246) of the student body of the class of 2002.
- Admissions is based on a “whole person” score.
Service Academy Stipends and Pay for Play
- Stipend For FY 2011: 12 months
- Unsecured Loan: before Spring break of Jr year
- $25,000 at 1% interest through a financial institution
- Cadet student body treasurer lobbies financial institution for best rate and terms.
How do we generates the $$$?
1. Sport camps/clinics
2. Distribution of tournament and conference bowl game revenues
3. Third Party Contributors (Boosters)
4. Broadcast, Television, Radio, and Internet Rights
When an athlete is given cash illegally it may prompt this reaction.
Make it legal and it doesn’t look so bad.
Time Constraints of the Student-Athlete
Student-Athlete Financial Aid Limitation
Student-Athlete Financial Aid Limitation
- All cadets must partake in at least:
- 1 competitive club and 1 intramural sport
- Cadet Basic Training: Mid June-Mid August for incoming freshmen
- Cadet Field Training: Mid June-First Week Aug
- Army Schools: Airborne, Air assault
- Cadet Leadership Training: 30 days during the summer entering Jr or Sr year
- Athletes also help with camps
- Cadets rarely get more than 2 or 3 weeks for summer vacation and only 2-3 weeks for Christmas.
- Military students Stipend
- Non-athletic students Work-related income
- Student-athlete Only what the institution allows
- Modify Bylaw 15.1: Allow SA to accumulate funds from external sources above and beyond cost of attendance
- Implementation of other aid option
- Military student Schooling paid + scholarships + stipend
- Non-athletic student Scholarships + work related income
- SA: Substantial amount of time representing the institution Scholarships + No pay
- Compromised break periods
- 30+ hours/week in sport-related activities
- Bylaws 15.1, 15.1.1: Cost of attendance + Pell Grant
- Bylaw 15.02.2: Cost of attendance
- Other institution-related expenses
- Bylaw 15.02.4.2 - Exceptions
- Money from parents/guardian
- Established outside programs (15.2.6.3)
Sample Data: 2009-10 Athletic Department Revenue-Cost Number Crunch
- per ACADEMIC YEAR month for every athlete.
- Treated as part of grant in aid so it is non-taxable.
Options:
- Corporate: Best Buy $1,000 Dell $20,000
- Group: Rotary Club, Masons, Kiwanis, etc.
- Non-athletic student: apply for any and all
- Modify Bylaws 15.02.4.2, 15.1
- SA: apply for any and all
- $25,000, the average undergrad student loan debt for the US, which is available midway through the student athletes’ Jr year.
- Loan and terms are lobbied each year by Student Athlete Body representatives.
- Loan not through the institution, but a credible financial institution.
How do we generates the $$$?
1. Sport camps/clinics
2. Distribution of tournament revenues
3. Third Party Contributors (Boosters)
4. Broadcast, Television, Radio, and Internet Rights
All of the major sports leagues have player unions, it negotiated everything !
- If all athletes were paid, then it may increase participation of the “underrepresented sex” and lead to less programs being dropped due to Prong 1 compliance.
Make it legal and it doesn’t look so bad.
↓ Fund-seeking from potentially illegal sources by SA
↓ Possibility of infractions regarding aid/benefits
↓ Attrition: ↑ Upper class experience
↑ Funds for debt pay-off
↑ Relocation expenses upon graduation
Potential ↑ High school interest in athletics
A more = Continuum: Military - Non-Athlete – SA
What it takes:
Modification of Bylaws 15.1, 15.1.1, 15.02.2, 15.04.2.2
When an athlete is given cash illegally it may prompt this reaction.
Athletes deserve the financial benefits of their labor.
Under the current system
and see not one penny in return
The National Collegiate Athletic Association
without giving back to the people who created the revenue in the first place.
For example, last weekend’s NCAA Men’s and Woman’s basketball tournaments generatied and what came back ?
many of the players on college basketball and football teams come from low income, disadvantaged backgrounds and the theft of their rightful earnings becomes even worse
The player is putting the fans in their seats, selling the jerseys and doing all the work, not the college or university. Yet the college or the university is making all the money. This is unfair and immoral.
Revenue that is generated by college athletes needs to be shared with them.
In reality, lots of behind the scenes dealings are taking place that the NCAA has no concept of.
Moreover, what does the NCAA often do when they find a violation of its policies?
they punish innocent athletes who have nothing to do with the violation.
The NCAA and its member institution need to abandon their archaic system of servitude
JERSEY`s sales, video games, College athletes also can’t do things like sign endorsement deals or make paid appearances
what right can the NCAA tell a person how they can make a living? Why is the NCAA so intent on limiting the earning potential and free exercise of speech of student-athletes? Why is it that only the NCAA that can profit from others hard work and success?