Send the link below via email or IMCopy
Present to your audienceStart remote presentation
- Invited audience members will follow you as you navigate and present
- People invited to a presentation do not need a Prezi account
- This link expires 10 minutes after you close the presentation
- A maximum of 30 users can follow your presentation
- Learn more about this feature in our knowledge base article
Gothic Architecture: Aretha Vinson & Mary Ann van Bodegraven
Transcript of Gothic Architecture: Aretha Vinson & Mary Ann van Bodegraven
That the decorative elements of Christian Gothic churches (statues, stained glass windows, etc.) enhanced the architecture of their buildings.
AFFIRMATIVE: Aretha Vinson
NEGATIVE: Mary Ann van Bodegraven
BAS 220 Assessment 1 Debate ~
The Decoration of Gothic Churches:
Enhanced or Detracted?
That decorations actually
from both the architectural and religious impact of these structures
Three ways to demonstrate this:
1. Referencing the exterior form and key elements of Gothic architecture
2. Considering the stripped Gothic churches of Calvinist Holland in the 16th & 17th Centuries
3. Examining the aesthetic and spiritual qualities of ruined Gothic churches
The Iconic Exterior View and Key Features of Gothic Churches
The Aesthetic and Spiritual Qualities of Stripped Calvinistic Gothic Churches
Contemplating the Form and Function of Ruined Gothic Churches
Reims Cathedral Flying Buttresses (Honnecourt 1230; Unknown n.d.)
Images of the
('statue storm') destruction.
Left: Frans Hogenberg,
Right: Dirck van Delen,
The Beeldenstorm in a Church
Paintings of interior of St Laurent’s Church, Rotterdam, by Anthonie de Lorme and Cornelis de Man (upper right).
I called to the Lord from my narrow prison and he answered me in the freedom of space
Ruined church images
(Clockwise from top left: Nithin 2015a; GozARTE 2016; Art UK n.d.; Exploring Castles 2015; The History Blog n.d.)
(Frankl 1946; Image Nithin 2015b)
FOR THE AFFIRMATIVE:
Accademia.org. 2016. Explore Museum: Artworks: Michelangelo’s David. The photograph of Michelangelo’s David. Accessed 6th October. http://www.accademia.org/explore-museum/artworks/michelangelos-david/ (SLIDE 22)
Ask Ideas.com. 2016. Travel: 15 Most Beautiful Notre Dame De Paris Rose Window Pictures. The photograph captioned “Awesome Rose Window of Notre Dame de Paris”. Posted February 16. Accessed 6th October 2016. https://www.askideas.com/15-most-beautiful-notre-dame-de-paris-rose-window-pictures/ (SLIDE 9)
A View On Cities. 2016. Paris: Paris Pictures: Gargoyles at the Notre-Dame Cathedral. A photograph of the gargoyle rain spouts on the Notre Dame Paris. Accessed 7th October. http://www.aviewoncities.com/gallery/showpicture.htm?key=kvefr0215 (SLIDE 8)
Bing Image Search. 2016. Creative Commons License. The image of question marks. Accessed 7th October. (SLIDE 20)
Blue Edge Crafts. 2016. The image of an Embossing Folder Cross with Words. Accessed 2nd October. https://www.blueedgecrafts.com.au/shop/ (SLIDE 8)
Dave and Deb. 2012. the planet D website. The photograph of Notre Dame Cathedral from the River Seine captioned “A different angle of Notre Dame in Paris, France”. Accessed 1st October 2016. http://theplanetd.com/notre-dame-cathedral-from-the-river-seine/ (SLIDE 5)
Davies Clay, Thomas. 2010. Cathedral Quest. Gothic Architecture. The image of a Romanesque and Gothic Arch. Accessed 1st October 2016. http://www.cathedralquest.com/gothic_architecture.htm (SLIDE 7)
Emotional Response Modelling. 2016. Why Are Emotions Important? The image of Emotional/Rational. Accessed 7th October. http://www.adsam.com/emotions.php (SLIDE 19)
European Trips. 2016. Places to Visit In Paris: Notre Dame de Paris – Notre Dame Cathedral. Posted 3rd May by Tina. The photograph of inside Notre Dame Cathedral captioned Notre Dame Cathedral. Accessed 7th October 2016. http://europeantrips.org/notre-dame-de-paris.html (SLIDE 10)
Godfrey, Mark. 2013. The image of a cartoon 'I'm sorry Adam, but there comes a time when a girl needs a little more than a 'fig leaf'...!'. http://www.jantoo.com/cartoon/59930375 (SLIDE 22)
Great Big Canvas. 2016. The photograph of markets at Notre Dame, Paris. Accessed 7th October. http://www.greatbigcanvas.com/view/tourists-at-the-market-stall-with-cathedral-in-the-background-notre-dame-de-paris-paris-ile-de-france-france,127786/ (SLIDE 18)
Mapping Gothic France. 2016. The image of a Line Drawing of the North Transept of the Cathedral Basilica of St. Denis. Accessed 2nd October. http://mappinggothic.org/ (SLIDE 4)
Musique Sacrée à Notre-Dame de Paris. 2016. Concert Saison 2016 – 2017. The image of a concert in Notre Dame De Paris. Accessed 7th October. http://www.musique-sacree-notredamedeparis.fr/concerts-i-saison-2016-2017 (SLIDE 17)
Notre Dame De Paris. 2016. Cathedral for Art and History: Paintings. The photograph of the painting Les Grans Meys. Accessed 7th October. http://www.notredamedeparis.fr/spip.php?rubrique89 (SLIDE 9)
Paris 17. 2009. Wikipedia Commons. Uploaded 1st July, 13:52. The photograph of the West rose window of Notre-Dame de Paris 2009. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:West_rose_window_of_Notre-Dame_de_Paris_2009.jpg (SLIDE 8)
Paris Convention & Visitors Bureau. 2015. Notre-Dame and Ile de la Cité on the big screen. The photograph of light streaming in through a rose window. Accessed 7th October 2016. http://en.parisinfo.com/discovering-paris/themed-guides/walks-on-the-trail-of-film-locations-in-paris/notre-dame-and-ile-de-la-cite-on-the-big-screen/notre-dame-and-ile-de-la-cite-on-the-big-screen (SLIDE 21)
Shakko. 2008. Wikipedia Commons. Posted 13:04, 17th May. The image of a Buttress and Flying Buttress. Accessed 1st October 2016. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/8/83/Romanesque_and_Gothic_loads.jpg (SLIDE 7)
Sherman, Carl. 2016. The Senses – A Primer: The Five (?) Senses. The image of Sight, hearing, taste, smell and touch. Accessed 7th October. http://udel.edu/~spfefer/art307/project3/ (SLIDE 19)
Truth in Charity. 2012. La joie de vivre. Posted on 7th November. The photograph captioned “Detail of a door pillar from Notre Dame’s facade with scenes from creation”. Accessed 6th October 2016. http://www.truthincharity.com/tag/france/ (SLIDE 8)
We Share Pics. 2016. Roman Catholic Churches in The Middle Age. The image of a painting of Religion of the Medieval Ages. Accessed 2nd October. http://wesharepics.info/imagergkl-roman-catholic-church-in-the-middle-ages.asp (SLIDE 8)
Wikipedia. 2016. The image of a painting titled “Destruction of religious images in Zurich, 1524”. Last modified on 4th October, 21:41. Accessed 7th October 2016. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iconoclasm (SLIDE 17)
Design for the Smoking Room at Cardiff Castle, by William Burges (Bergersen 2009)
FOR THE NEGATIVE:
Art UK. n.d. Moonlit Lake with a Ruined Gothic Church and Boatmen by Sebastian Pether, accessed September 18, 2016. http://artuk.org/discover/artworks/moonlit-lake-with-a-ruined-gothic-church-a-church-and-boatmen-169797.
Bergersen, Cindy. 2009. Bad Decorating #3: See what you are looking at, 23 September, accessed October 8, 2016. http://decodingdecor.com/major-decorating-disasters-part-iii-see-what-you-are-looking-at/.
Exploring Castles. 2015. The Seven Key Characteristics of Gothic Architecture, accessed September 15, 2016. http://www.exploring-castles.com/characteristics_of_gothic_architecture.html.
Frankl, Victor. 1946. Man's Search for Meaning : The Classic Tribute to Hope from the Holocaust. London: Edbury.
GozARTE. 2016. Nos Vamos de Excursion Lisboa Coisa Boa, 20 February, accessed September 18, 2016. http://gozarte.net/nos-vamos-de-excursion-lisboa-coisa-boa-11-al-18-de-junio/.
Honnecourt, Villard de. 1230. Drawing of a Buttress at Reims. Bibliotheque National, Paris.
Hopkins, John Henry. 1836. “Gothic Architecture, with Various Plans and Drawings for Churches”, Anglican History. accessed September 12, 2016. http://anglicanhistory.org/usa/jhhopkins/gothic1836/.
Megamoth. 2013. Fluttering: Idle Musings of the Megamoth, 18 January, accessed September 18, 2016. http://mega-moth.tumblr.com/post/40887355051.
Nithin, CV. 2015. 14fbQ-shettihalli-church-settihalli-india, accessed September 15, 2016. http://www.trover.com/d/14fbQ-shettihalli-church-settihalli-india.
—. 2015. 14fcF-shettihalli-church-settihalli-india, accessed September 17, 2016. http://www.trover.com/d/14fcF-shettihalli-church-settihalli-india.
Risebero, Bill. 2011. The Story of Western Architecture. London: Herbert Press.
The History Blog. n.d. Original floor of Coventry Cathedral revealed, accessed September 10, 2016. http://www.thehistoryblog.com/archives/37497.
Unknown. n.d. Photo of Reims Cathedral Flying Buttresses. Ithaca: Cornell University. https://www.flickr.com/photos/cornelluniversitylibrary/3485982355/sizes/l/in/photostream/.
Vanhaelen, Angela. 2012. The Wake of Iconoclasm: Painting the Church in the Dutch Republic. University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press.
Voges, Ramon. 2016. “Power, Faith, and Pictures: Frans Hogenberg’s Account of the Beeldenstorm.” BMGN - Low Countries Historical Review 131 (1): 121–140.