Loading presentation...

Present Remotely

Send the link below via email or IM


Present to your audience

Start remote presentation

  • Invited audience members will follow you as you navigate and present
  • People invited to a presentation do not need a Prezi account
  • This link expires 10 minutes after you close the presentation
  • A maximum of 30 users can follow your presentation
  • Learn more about this feature in our knowledge base article

Do you really want to delete this prezi?

Neither you, nor the coeditors you shared it with will be able to recover it again.


Copy of Anthropology of the Clinic: The Hospital as Fieldsite

No description

Heather J. Murphy

on 12 March 2013

Comments (0)

Please log in to add your comment.

Report abuse

Transcript of Copy of Anthropology of the Clinic: The Hospital as Fieldsite

The Hospital as Field Site Anthropology of the Clinic in"Anthropology and Medicine",
Vol. 15, No. 2, August 2008, 79-89 "Negotiated Interactive Observation:
Doing Fieldwork in Hospital Settings"
- Gitte Wind How to convince staff (and patients) we are not wasting their time? Can we only ever achieve a partial view? - doing participant observation assumes you can become 'one of them'
- anthropologists recognise that the degree of participation will differ according to the fieldsite and activities therein
- Spradley 1980 (58-62): 'nonparticipation' - 'passive participation' - 'moderate participation' - active participation' - 'complete participation' ('going native')
- just as feminist anthropology has taught us to consider the personal background of the fieldworker in the situation, we must also consider it in hospital ethnography
- it seems sufficient to simply write 'participant observation without ever having to actually detail
what exactly that entails in your specific
situation Why are Hospitals tricky Fieldsites? - we must decide whether we are going to view the hospital as an island, or as a hub...

- access can be very stressful to secure...

- our work is often viewed as trivial by medical staff (and patients)...

- there are things we just cannot be privy to; we can only ever achieve a partial view...

- there is no designated 'ethnographer' role in a hospital...

- participant observation is difficult to achieve... Why are there no job adverts for 'hospital ethnographers'? - because there is no convenient role for ethnographers in hospitals - we don't always fit!
- a feeling of not being able to do 'proper' fieldwork because we don't have a neatly defined role in the setting
-successful ethnographers FIND "a credible role" (p.82)
- what roles could we take?
- a patient?
- a staff member?
- a relative/visitor?
(- a volunteer?)
(- a student?)
- 'A RESEARCHER' How To Secure Access to your Hospital Fieldsite? - gaining access usually takes a very long time:
- numerous ethical review boards to get through (University; NHS; the hospital itself... they all have their own requirements and limitations)
- difficult negotiations; you might get access, but on their terms, not yours
- often access comes through personal networks and institutional affiliation
- even when overall access was agreed, "my position was a daily on-going negotiation, which sometimes went well and at other times did not." (p.83)
- access is continually being
played out throughout the
whole research Hospital as Island vs.
Hospital as Hub - Hospital as 'a tight little island' - Coser 1962
- one of the first ethnographies of a 'normal American hospital'
- a place where people are cut off from the 'continent' of 'normal life'
- exists as its own society, with its own rules, roles, structures

- Hospital as 'hub of society' - Zaman 2005
- study of a Bangladeshi hospital ward
- a place invaded and shaped by the values, rules and ideas of the outside world
- a microcosm of the society it exists within
- "a domain where the core values and beliefs of a society come into view" (van der Geest and Finkler
2004) What are the barriers
to conducting participant observation in a hospital setting? Is it worth all that bother to do ethnography in hospitals? - Staff (and patients) are often suspicious of our fieldwork
- "The work of an ethnographer often appears trivial..."
- "...or as if the ethnographer is watching, monitoring or policing staff inappropriately." (p.83)
- "hanging around... drinking coffee, taking notes, chatting. These activities do not look like work and they definitely do not look like academic research." (ibid)
- "seen... as time wasting or even interfering with the real work of the health workers." (ibid)
- is it a quantitative/qualitative issue? --> There is a need to be
taken seriously... - some things we have to figure out:
- what is our 'role'?
- what is our occupation and place within the infrastructure?
- what activities will we perform?
- what do we tell people when they ask us 'what we are doing'?
- how to we negotiate access to be there?
- how to we participate on a day-to-day basis?
- how do others in the hospital view us?

- the answers to these questions
will be different for all field
sites and all projects Yes! "Negotiated
Interactive Observation"? - the question of degree of participation is not just relevant for hospital fieldwork - is has everything to do with today's ethnography as a whole method
- we know that "most people do not form neatly demarcated and closed social groups that can be entered and studied as cultural islands" (p. 84)
- as participant observation currently stands, it "accentuates the ethnographer's authority over the field and its people" (ibid)
- ethnographers will also be scrutinised by their informants
- participation means you get involved, and that brings INTERACTION (however, not all parties in the interaction are bound by the same strings)
- thus, "interactive observation goes both ways"! (p.85)
- "There will be a constant negotiation of when and
how the observation and interaction will and will
not take place." (ibid) - in hospitals, we can see all manner of things being played out:
- "Hospitals are places of intensity, of life-and-death drama, creating moments of truth, self-discovery and rites of passage. In being removed from 'normal' life, a patient is frequently given the opportunity - or confronted with the necessity - of taking stock of kinship, friendship, meaning, finitude, mortality and other core issues of life."
(Long, Hunter and van der Geest 2008:72) References:
- Long, D., Hunter, C. and S. van der Geest. 2008. 'Introduction: When the field is a ward or a clinic: Hospital Ethnography' in Anthropology & Medicine. Vol. 15, No. 2, Aug 2008, 71-78

- van der Geest, S. and K. Finkler. 2004. 'Hospital Ethnography: Introduction' in Social Science and Medicine. Vol. 59, No. 10. 1995-2001

- Wind, G. 2008. 'Negotiated Interactive Observation: Doing Fieldwork in Hospital Settings' in Anthropology & Medicine. Vol. 15, No. 2, Aug 2008, 79-89

- Zaman, S. 2005. Broken limbs, broken lives: Ethnography of a hospital ward in Bangladesh. Amsterdam: Aksant. Heather J. Murphy
Full transcript