Solutions
Pricing
Log in
Teams
Get started
Log in
Get started
Silver Linings Playbook Analysis
MG
by
Megan Gerdeman
·
4 views
·
Updated May 2, 2021
Share
Embed
Re-use content
Create your own
Chapters
00:00
Silver Linings Playbook Analysis
00:10
Mass Media Myths? What are those?
01:15
Underlying myths/ stereotypes
02:24
Meaning and possible interpretations
03:23
Potential Harmful Effects
03:57
Judgement/ Evaluation
04:20
Personal Harm from Myths
04:58
Advocacy Action plan
Audio Transcript
Auto-generated
00:00 - 00:04
They also welcomed by silver linings, playbook analysis presentation where
00:04 - 00:07
I'm gonna be addressing all the mass media missed that
00:07 - 00:08
are present in this and breaking them down for you.
00:09 - 00:12
So enjoy what are those?
00:12 - 00:13
So mass media missed.
00:14 - 00:17
They are just all these miss present inside of movies
00:17 - 00:20
that are unrealistic, not going to happen in real life.
00:20 - 00:24
And they give the wrong impression on a lot of
00:24 - 00:28
people. So there's about four mass medium is present in
00:28 - 00:31
this movie and when they break them down for you
00:31 - 00:31
real quick.
00:32 - 00:32
So there's myth.
00:32 - 00:34
Number two, there's such a thing as love at first
00:34 - 00:35
sight myth.
00:35 - 00:38
Number six, the role of gender and masculinity myth number
00:38 - 00:40
seven, the love of a good and faithful true woman
00:40 - 00:42
can change a man from a beast into a prince
00:42 - 00:42
and myth.
00:43 - 00:45
Number eight, bickering and fighting me in a couple of
00:45 - 00:45
truly in love.
00:46 - 00:47
So let's take a look and see how I use
00:47 - 00:49
the present in the film and the film.
00:50 - 00:53
Patrick Celentano Junior, an irritable and desperate man, attempts to
00:53 - 00:57
find the silver lining in his otherwise miserable life through
00:57 - 01:00
the love of a Truman Tiffany Maxwell, Pat becomes happy
01:00 - 01:01
and finds meaning in life again.
01:01 - 01:02
That's myth number seven.
01:04 - 01:06
Throughout their initial encounters, Pat and Tiffany bigger but is
01:06 - 01:09
often portrayed in a comical, almost endearing way that's myth
01:09 - 01:09
number eight.
01:10 - 01:12
Finally, Pat reveals a Tiffany that he fell in love
01:12 - 01:13
with her the moment he saw her.
01:14 - 01:19
This myth number two, So the primary myth, demonstrated in
01:19 - 01:22
silver linings playbook is myth number seven, which is the
01:22 - 01:24
love of a woman, can change a man from obese
01:24 - 01:24
to a price.
01:25 - 01:28
Pat was extremely depressed and rageful after leaving the mental
01:28 - 01:32
hospital as in scene, but he freaks out throughout the
01:32 - 01:32
entire movie.
01:34 - 01:36
Um right from the beginning of the movie, you can
01:36 - 01:39
see Pat's delusions regarding his marriage, which are highlighted by
01:39 - 01:42
his devotion to mid number seven, which is changing yourself
01:43 - 01:44
in the name of True love.
01:44 - 01:47
He tells us to his father towards the beginning of
01:47 - 01:49
the movie and he says, what am I going to
01:49 - 01:52
do? I'm getting in shape, I'm getting trim, I'm getting
01:52 - 01:53
really fit for Nikki.
01:53 - 01:55
I'm going to read Nikki's teaching syllabus and get my
01:55 - 01:56
old job back.
01:57 - 02:01
So you can see here Path attempting to change in
02:01 - 02:04
the name of his love for his estranged wife here.
02:04 - 02:07
Mid# six, the role of gender is also briefly
02:07 - 02:09
mentioned. Pat believes in order to win Nikki back.
02:10 - 02:13
He needs to get stronger and more, you know, built
02:13 - 02:15
and have a solid career that's been going a masculine
02:16 - 02:16
role in their relationship.
02:17 - 02:20
He later repeats this transpiration goal to tip on it
02:20 - 02:21
when he acknowledges her beauty.
02:22 - 02:24
So he doesn't quite a few times in the movie.
02:25 - 02:28
Okay, so the preferred reading of this movie would be
02:28 - 02:30
that two people can come together despite mental health issues
02:31 - 02:33
and other personal problems and create a happy silver linings
02:34 - 02:34
filled life together.
02:36 - 02:37
The movie also shows that the love of the right
02:38 - 02:40
person is more effective in changing someone's outlook on life
02:40 - 02:44
than inside a presence, therapy and mental hospitals are.
02:45 - 02:47
The movie also shows that we can fix others and
02:47 - 02:50
more prominently ourselves if we're given the most motivation of
02:50 - 02:51
true love.
02:52 - 02:55
The oppositional reading however, dismisses these miss because some of
02:55 - 02:58
the messages conveyed in silver linings playbook are unrealistic.
02:59 - 03:02
It is unlikely that Pat's personality change can be attributed
03:02 - 03:03
solely to Tiffany's presence.
03:04 - 03:05
An educated viewer understands this.
03:06 - 03:09
An educated audience member will also realize that the figuring,
03:10 - 03:13
fighting and naming that patent Tiffany engaged in early or
03:13 - 03:15
not, not healthy tools to use in a real relationship.
03:17 - 03:20
You would never get the girl after you called Tiffany.
03:20 - 03:25
Some of the names that pact holder never believing what
03:25 - 03:27
is portrayed in silver linings playbook could have some negative
03:27 - 03:32
consequences. For example, after viewing this film, someone might be
03:32 - 03:34
willing to believe that like Tiffany, they could ultimately change
03:35 - 03:38
the person personality of someone like that who has bipolar
03:38 - 03:40
disorder and other issues in real life.
03:41 - 03:43
People like Pat, who are violent and bipolar get aggressive
03:43 - 03:44
very easily.
03:45 - 03:47
It might not take kindly to people calling them crazy
03:47 - 03:48
and suddenly trying to change them.
03:49 - 03:50
On the flip side.
03:50 - 03:53
It's also not entirely healthy to behave like Tiffany who
03:53 - 03:56
deals with grief by being promiscuous and is sometimes downright
03:56 - 03:57
rude as well.
03:58 - 04:01
While those movies kind of unrealistic, it doesn't mean it's
04:02 - 04:04
um an enjoyable film.
04:05 - 04:08
In fact, people often watch movies, especially romantic comedies like
04:08 - 04:11
silver linings playbook because they wish to escape their less
04:12 - 04:12
exciting realities.
04:13 - 04:16
It's an unhealthy for movies to present these types of
04:16 - 04:18
relationships to the public, but it's like bad junk cute
04:19 - 04:22
we did Anyway, so the problem with these films is
04:23 - 04:25
many of not all people do believe that they can
04:25 - 04:29
change their romantic partner, but by portraying characters such as
04:29 - 04:33
patent Tiffany as being easily curable, It reinforces some of
04:33 - 04:38
these romantic misconceptions, let's say hypothetically someone watch silver linings
04:38 - 04:41
playbook and then shortly after began a romantic relationship with
04:41 - 04:43
a man or woman that was suffering from bipolar disorder.
04:44 - 04:46
They might mistakenly think that they will be able to
04:46 - 04:48
change their lives for the better.
04:49 - 04:50
But that's not the case.
04:50 - 04:52
People typically only change on their own accord or in
04:53 - 04:57
this case certain mental health illnesses because of medication and
04:57 - 05:02
therapy. Romantic comedies definitely have effects on people but they
05:02 - 05:03
pretty much all negative.
05:04 - 05:07
The entire premise of romantic comedies was these different people
05:08 - 05:11
can truly find love, makes the audience asked, Why can't
05:12 - 05:14
I? And the obvious answer is because no one can
05:15 - 05:18
as well as almost everyone else to have friends who
05:18 - 05:19
have their therapist or have disorders, etcetera.
05:20 - 05:23
And none of them are dating each other or head
05:23 - 05:24
over heels in love.
05:24 - 05:26
In fact, I'm pretty sure none of my friends have
05:27 - 05:28
unbreakable bonds with each other.
05:28 - 05:31
Perhaps some sort of predestined connection.
05:31 - 05:33
The only couples that I have seen with that kind
05:33 - 05:35
of connection or Jack and Rose and Jim and pam.
05:37 - 05:40
But those are all fake couples of course, which supports
05:41 - 05:41
the idea that romances.
05:42 - 05:45
The media is completely skewed movies like silver lining playbook
05:46 - 05:50
and movies that are categories as romantic comedies have a
05:50 - 05:53
place in pop culture, a source of entertainment for they
05:53 - 05:55
portray romance and correct and cheaply.
05:57 - 06:00
So I hope you enjoyed my presentation and if you
06:00 - 06:01
have any questions asking now
See full transcript