educ 3100 Photovoice

RC
by Ry Colmer1 view·Updated Dec 5, 2020

Audio TranscriptAuto-generated

  1. Hey, I'm Brian.
  2. I'll be walking you through my photo voice that I've
  3. created for E.
  4. U C 3100.
  5. My photo voice will be focusing on the student experience,
  6. particularly elementary school students, access to green and Place, based
  7. based on the elementary school that they attend.
  8. There are three elementary schools in the cliffside area that
  9. will be taking a look at.
  10. We'll be taking a look at John A.
  11. Leslie Cliffside Public School and China Drive Public School.
  12. Before we get started.
  13. Just thio give a visualization.
  14. This is a highlight of the cliffside area and the
  15. three borders of the school, the top most being John
  16. A. Leslie, the lower right hand being China drive in
  17. the lower left hand cliffside public school.
  18. So the first photo I would like to highlight is
  19. a photo from John A.
  20. Leslie. This is a photo of their backfield has taken
  21. in November 2020 shortly after school that I would probably
  22. around 3, 30 and four o'clock.
  23. What I wanted, I wanted to highlight with this photo
  24. was the lack of equipment available to students on dhe.
  25. Really lack of infrastructure.
  26. There's no social outside place.
  27. Gree meeting place.
  28. There's little to no actual equipment.
  29. There's no basketball.
  30. That's it was very little on this playfully plate area.
  31. And it was interesting because this was the only space
  32. there where they were actually students.
  33. That the school, Johnny Leslie, does have the highest attendance
  34. of the three schools in the area.
  35. Uh, but it was interesting to see with the highest
  36. attendance how little outdoor infrastructure was available to the students.
  37. The school also does front on to Midland Avenue, which
  38. is a fairly large and busy street.
  39. On it is the Onley green space that is accessible
  40. for these students in the area without crossing at least
  41. one major intersection.
  42. Yeah, this second photo I wanted to highlight is the
  43. front view from Cliffside Elementary, taken from the front of
  44. the property.
  45. This is the Onley entrance to this.
  46. You have to walk by this to get to the
  47. school. That is the only entrance.
  48. It This is the backside of a set of Kingston
  49. commercial residential units.
  50. Um, and the reason for highlighting this is this is
  51. the student reality.
  52. This is what students have to walk by every day
  53. to access through school.
  54. This is what they look at.
  55. This is the environment that they are exposed to Onda
  56. as you'll see in the coming photos.
  57. This is drastically different, different from the experience of either
  58. of the other schools in the area.
  59. For example, trying Dr School, our third photo is taken
  60. from the front steps of trying.
  61. Dr. Elementary Drive Elementary has the smallest population of the
  62. three schools.
  63. It also has the smallest boundaries of any school in
  64. the TSB Act.
  65. Access by a small, small, quiet road on the area
  66. that it, uh, occupies is generally an above average income
  67. area. There's ample amount of green space is seen in
  68. the photo, and it does.
  69. Back on Lake Ontario, moving to the back of the
  70. school, we take a look now at the back of
  71. Cliffside Elementary.
  72. As we can see, it's predominantly concrete.
  73. There is some play equipment available, which is different than,
  74. uh, you know what we saw at one a.
  75. Leslie. But the infrastructure is aging.
  76. There is a very large slope that may not be
  77. very pronounced in this photo, but would limit access thio,
  78. some students with physical disabilities and unfortunately, this playground.
  79. This this place based in green space isn't terribly accessible
  80. to students, especially in the after hours of school.
  81. Because of the area that is located in backing on
  82. to the commercial residential units at Kingston Road, the area
  83. isn't always the safest after dark and has been, uh,
  84. known to be frequented by drug users and other marginalized
  85. communities such as homeless and nomadic persons.
  86. This is the side view at China Drive Elementary, featuring
  87. a new solid wood social area outwards available to students
  88. one of the Onley outdoor social areas that I saw
  89. the three schools, but one of several acts kind drive.
  90. Yeah, yeah, no one was on site.
  91. This photo was taken shortly after 4 p.m. And it
  92. was the only school that had nobody, nobody at it
  93. both during the time of photographing.
  94. Both Johnny, Leslie and Cliffside did have people present on
  95. the property.
  96. Uh, my drive was the Onley that only property that
  97. have anybody there eso again, possibly because of the low
  98. population, but definitely does seem that the infrastructure is being
  99. under used.
  100. This also was taken a China drive.
  101. It is newly installed playground equipment.
  102. It's currently unavailable due to Cova, but it is on.
  103. Lee is one of only two playgrounds that I saw
  104. while shooting this photo voice.
  105. It is also the largest, the other being at Johnny
  106. Leslie that was a small playground fenced off solely for
  107. the access of a younger grades.
  108. Reason for taking this photo on why I wanted to
  109. highlight it was e find.
  110. This really did bring light to the mis allocation of
  111. resources. This is by far, uh, and I was by
  112. far the smallest population either of the schools in the
  113. area. It occupies normally the one of the largest spaces
  114. geographically, but it clearly has a lot more outdoor infrastructure,
  115. outdoor, green space and natural place space available to its
  116. students than the two sister schools in its area.
  117. To add to this disparity, this is a our last
  118. picture that will be taking a look at is green
  119. space access to the waterfront trail that runs along the
  120. north side of so outside of the city north side
  121. of Lake.
  122. This is step away from China Drive Public School.
  123. It provides access to a very, very large green space,
  124. expensive with tennis courts, conservation area and other facilities as
  125. well. There's year round access to this and it is
  126. by far the largest green space in the area.
  127. It is accessed Onley through the China Dr Community and
  128. really is a is readily available to a small roof.
  129. So first of all, I want to say thank you
  130. for watching.
  131. I also want to highlight the fact that this this
  132. photo voice is the purpose of this photo point is
  133. to bridge communities.
  134. It really is to highlight the fact that although we
  135. all are in the cliffside area, the allocation of resources
  136. for our students, for especially elementary students in regards to
  137. green space in place space available through them appears to
  138. be mismanaged or misplaced.
  139. Um, we would like to see a change in the
  140. community, bring us together as ah one community rather than
  141. three separate communities and encourage equitable access to bring in
  142. place base, especially for for these elementary school students making
  143. it a safe space, making in an accessible place and
  144. really putting the resources where they need to go, creating
  145. a means based allocation of resources rather than a population
  146. or an income based, um, it may even may even
  147. encourage a re division of the school borders, perhaps the
  148. way the current borders air laid out create part of
  149. this inequality.
  150. I also chose to highlight this because as a technological
  151. educator, part of what we cover is sustainability, green technology
  152. and environmental studies.
  153. Um, one of the one of the courses that we
  154. may end up teaching is Forest Street.
  155. So highlighting the access to green space for me was
  156. very important because this is where students begin their journey.
  157. This is what creates the the draw creates the question,
  158. creates that Dr Learn Mawr having access to that green
  159. place as a student so and something, I felt very,
  160. uh, it was very important.
  161. And being elementary students, when they don't realize the effect
  162. that this has on them, and two, they have little
  163. to no ability to speak up for themselves, even if
  164. they do notice the disparity that they're experiencing, don't I?
  165. Projects like this project of the photo voice are refreshing,
  166. and especially as an educator who may be teaching in
  167. the area, it really does help us to develop relationships
  168. with our students, to understand what our students experiences are,
  169. even though they're all part of the same community.
  170. The experiences of student that goes to Johnny Leslie versus
  171. trying versus Cliffside public school could be drastically different.
  172. And the images and the environment that we're exposed to
  173. on a daily basis is drastically different.
  174. So it helps us an educator to understand that I
  175. understand that one school isn't necessarily the other.
  176. Teaching at one other techniques and pedagogy that we used
  177. for teaching at one school may not necessarily translate to
  178. another may not be well received.
  179. Knowing the environment, knowing the access to play in green
  180. space, their students have affect how we shape our curriculum
  181. and the interactions that we have with students.
  182. So thank you for taking the time to watch this
  183. video. And thank you for following me through our photo
  184. voice. Wish you all the best.
  185. Have a great day.