Solutions
Pricing
Log in
Teams
Get started
Log in
Get started
Solipsism
AL
by
Andreia Lewis
·
1 view
·
Updated Nov 10, 2020
Share
Embed
Create your own
number two
Audio Transcript
Auto-generated
00:00 - 00:02
okay. Today, I'll be giving a crash course on epistemological
00:03 - 00:04
and metaphysical solipsism.
00:06 - 00:08
To begin, we must first give a simple definition to
00:08 - 00:10
solve schism, the view or a theory that the self
00:11 - 00:12
is all that could be known to exist.
00:15 - 00:18
We will be delving deeper into the following theory with
00:18 - 00:19
these topics covered.
00:21 - 00:24
An introduction to the two branches assaults is, um, the
00:24 - 00:27
problem of other minds calling reality into doubt.
00:28 - 00:28
Rene Day Card.
00:29 - 00:29
One's existence.
00:31 - 00:36
The difference between epistemological metaphysical solipsism, arguments for metaphysical solipsism
00:37 - 00:40
and arguments against metaphysical solipsism, and then a brief summary
00:43 - 00:44
to begin.
00:44 - 00:47
There are two main branches of salt is, um, epistemological
00:48 - 00:52
solipsism and metaphysical solipsism toe.
00:52 - 00:53
Understand the two.
00:53 - 00:56
We must first define epistemology and metaphysics as our own
00:57 - 00:57
branch of philosophy.
01:00 - 01:04
Epistemology is a branch of philosophy that investigates what distinguishes
01:05 - 01:06
justify believe from opinion.
01:06 - 01:09
A Metaphysics is a branch of philosophy that deals with
01:09 - 01:12
the first principles of things, including abstract concepts such as
01:13 - 01:16
being knowing substance caused identity, time and space.
01:19 - 01:22
Epistemological solipsism is a claim that one can only be
01:22 - 01:24
sure of the existence of one's mind.
01:25 - 01:28
The existence of other minds in the external world is
01:28 - 01:30
not necessarily rejected, but one cannot be sure of its
01:31 - 01:36
existence. Metaphysical solipsism is a variety of idealism, which asserts
01:36 - 01:37
that nothing exists.
01:37 - 01:40
It's externally to this one mind, and since this mine
01:40 - 01:43
is the whole reality thing, the external world was never
01:43 - 01:44
anything more than an idea.
01:45 - 01:49
An example of an epistemological paradox is if a tree
01:49 - 01:51
falls in the woods and known is there to tweet
01:51 - 01:53
about it or C.
01:54 - 01:58
It doesn't make a sound, since the existence of other
01:58 - 02:01
minds in the external world is not necessarily rejected, but
02:02 - 02:03
one cannot be sure of its existence.
02:03 - 02:06
We cannot prove that a tree falling down in the
02:06 - 02:13
woods exists beyond our own mind Now for the problem
02:13 - 02:14
of other minds.
02:16 - 02:20
Okay, try to prove your real to someone you can't,
02:21 - 02:22
and it's scary.
02:22 - 02:24
I'm guessing the only good argument you could come up
02:24 - 02:25
with is, But I'm riel.
02:26 - 02:27
I'm sure you know you are.
02:28 - 02:31
After all, you are a conscious being with thoughts, behaviors
02:31 - 02:35
and emotions, but your consciousness is entirely private to you.
02:35 - 02:37
Put simply, no one can read your mind.
02:38 - 02:40
So in terms of proving that there are gears turning
02:40 - 02:42
up there, you're out of luck and So, um, I
02:44 - 02:46
this is salt is a merely explained as a concept.
02:47 - 02:48
Therefore epistemological solipsism.
02:51 - 02:58
Okay, now, about culling reality into doubt, our own consciousness
02:59 - 03:01
is the only thing we can prove to exist toe
03:01 - 03:04
ourself only our own consciousness is the only thing you
03:04 - 03:05
can know exists.
03:06 - 03:08
How do you know that anything you are experiencing in
03:08 - 03:11
the material world isn't a figment of your imagination?
03:12 - 03:13
You can't prove that either.
03:13 - 03:14
This is metaphysical solipsism.
03:15 - 03:17
This goes beyond salt system as a concept and calls
03:18 - 03:20
everything we know about our existence and reality into doubt.
03:24 - 03:27
Now on Renee Dick Heart and his View on solipsism
03:31 - 03:33
Cart, pictured on the right, better known as the Father
03:33 - 03:36
of Modern philosophy, was the philosopher in the 16th century,
03:36 - 03:39
respected for his work in geometry and algebra, as well
03:39 - 03:43
as numerous books on philosophy and one book Meditations on
03:43 - 03:43
first philosophy.
03:44 - 03:47
He shares his thought process when suspending any ideas that
03:47 - 03:48
could even be slightly doubtful.
03:49 - 03:51
He argued that since he can't distinguish streaming from being
03:51 - 03:54
awake and vice versa, he has reason to doubt the
03:54 - 03:56
external world around him and as he states.
03:56 - 03:59
But I cannot forget that at other times I have
03:59 - 04:01
been deceived in sleep by similar illusions and attentively.
04:02 - 04:06
Considering those cases, I perceived so clearly that there exists
04:06 - 04:08
no certain marks by which the state of waking can
04:08 - 04:12
ever be distinguished sleep that I feel greatly astonished and
04:12 - 04:12
in amazement.
04:12 - 04:16
I almost persuade myself that I am now dreaming following
04:17 - 04:20
this theory and with deductive reasoning, he soon came to
04:20 - 04:22
the conclusion that the self is all that can be
04:22 - 04:25
known to exist as per his infamous quote cognito ergo
04:26 - 04:28
sum. Or I think, therefore I am.
04:30 - 04:33
This quote is a basis for modern epistemology today.
04:33 - 04:35
If ourself is the one thing we know for certain,
04:36 - 04:37
we can use that as our base of all knowledge
04:38 - 04:38
and philosophical reasoning.
04:39 - 04:42
As a father father of modern philosophy, he was the
04:43 - 04:45
first philosopher recorded to talk about his very own method
04:45 - 04:47
of Cartesian doubt name for his method of doubt.
04:48 - 04:51
Cartesian Doubt is an epistemological method of deductive reasoning that
04:51 - 04:57
distinguishes justified belief from opinion now on to the problem
04:58 - 04:58
of ones existence.
05:02 - 05:07
Yeah, Dakar argued, regardless of solipsism, we have to be
05:07 - 05:11
riel. Okay, in this excerpt from meditations on first philosophy,
05:12 - 05:12
he states.
05:13 - 05:16
But doubtless I did exist if I persuaded myself with
05:16 - 05:18
something. But there is some deceiver or other who was
05:19 - 05:21
supremely powerful in supremely sly and who is always deliberately
05:21 - 05:22
deceiving me.
05:22 - 05:24
Then, too, there is no doubt that I exist.
05:24 - 05:26
If he is deceiving me and let him do his
05:27 - 05:28
best, a deception, he will never bring it about that
05:29 - 05:30
I am nothing so long as I shall think that
05:31 - 05:31
I am something.
05:32 - 05:35
Thus, after everything has been most carefully weighed, it must
05:35 - 05:35
finally be established.
05:36 - 05:39
This pronouncement, I am I exist, is necessarily true every
05:39 - 05:40
time I uttering or conceive it.
05:41 - 05:44
In my mind, the car argued that to think that
05:44 - 05:45
we exist is knowing we exist.
05:47 - 05:49
He posed this idea of a higher power, controlling our
05:49 - 05:50
senses, feeding a solutions.
05:52 - 05:54
But even if that were true, you would have to
05:54 - 05:57
exist in order to be deceived and being conscious.
05:57 - 05:59
Whatever consciousness is, it exists.
06:01 - 06:03
This is what the car argues throughout meditations on first
06:03 - 06:07
philosophy. And as he concludes, I think therefore I am
06:10 - 06:14
now we will investigate the difference differences between epistemological solipsism
06:14 - 06:15
and metaphysical solipsism.
06:18 - 06:21
Epistemology is a branch of philosophy that investigates what distinguishes
06:22 - 06:25
justify belief from opinion And with that being said, epistemological
06:26 - 06:30
solipsism is nothing but an abstract concept crafted from Cartesian
06:30 - 06:31
doubt and method, a logical skepticism.
06:32 - 06:34
It cannot be argued or disproven.
06:34 - 06:40
Unlike most philosophical theories, epistemological solipsism is a concept that
06:40 - 06:41
just kind of sits there.
06:41 - 06:43
I think therefore I am is the basis of modern
06:44 - 06:46
philosophy, and it's the one thing we know for certain.
06:48 - 06:51
Rene did car neither promoted or denied salt ism, but
06:51 - 06:53
rather use Cartesian doubt to craft an irrefutable statement.
06:54 - 06:57
So metaphysical sobs is where we start unpacking the likelihood
06:58 - 06:58
of sobs in itself.
06:59 - 07:02
As we start questioning our very own being, are you
07:02 - 07:03
really the only conscious being in existence?
07:04 - 07:10
Does reality exists beyond your senses Now for an argument
07:11 - 07:11
for metaphysical solipsism?
07:14 - 07:17
Just because you can perceive an object to your five
07:17 - 07:18
senses does not mean it exists.
07:19 - 07:20
You could be dreaming or hallucinating.
07:22 - 07:23
There is what you believe to be in the material
07:24 - 07:26
world. But if you're perceiving the material world in your
07:26 - 07:28
mind and your thoughts or private, there is no basis
07:29 - 07:31
in which you can prove the objects, existence and reality.
07:31 - 07:34
For that matter, for example, you cannot prove that this
07:35 - 07:36
presentation is really, just because you can perceive it.
07:37 - 07:40
Reality is only treat yourselves and ourselves only which supports
07:41 - 07:42
solves ism as a plausible idea.
07:45 - 07:52
Now for an argument against metaphysical solipsism further long and
07:52 - 07:55
meditations on first philosophy as a car argues that to
07:55 - 07:56
be conscious is to exist.
07:56 - 08:00
He refutes solipsism, He states, if you can have an
08:00 - 08:03
idea that is not present in his own reality, the
08:03 - 08:05
cause of that idea lies outside of him and his
08:05 - 08:09
reality. Ah, concept like time travel, for example, is impossible.
08:10 - 08:12
But to merely imagine, it means that there is something
08:12 - 08:13
outside of your own reality.
08:15 - 08:17
This supports the idea that one's reality is not the
08:17 - 08:18
only thing to exist.
08:23 - 08:23
You too.
08:27 - 08:32
Sorry. Okay, in summary, to think is to exist, but
08:33 - 08:34
you cannot prove you exist to others.
08:35 - 08:36
This is epistemological sauces.
08:37 - 08:41
Um, while you're able to privately perceive reality, you're not
08:42 - 08:44
able to prove whether or not reality exists outside of
08:44 - 08:47
your own conscious calling doubt on existence of reality and
08:48 - 08:48
other beings.
08:49 - 08:50
This is metaphysical solipsism.
08:51 - 08:51
Thank you.
See full transcript