SEL Program Review Positive Action

FF
by Fern Fagan3 views·Updated Mar 11, 2021

Chapters

Audio TranscriptAuto-generated

  1. Hi, everyone.
  2. I am going over the SCL program Review of Positive
  3. Action. I look at the theory of the program.
  4. I also look at what the program itself entails.
  5. I provide a sample lesson for eighth grade and I
  6. look at the implications of research but also draw my
  7. own conclusions.
  8. Based on this review, I draw a lot from the
  9. Positive Action Website, which you can find connected under my
  10. references list at the end of this presentation.
  11. They claim Positive Action is the leading SCL program for
  12. pre K through 12.
  13. Positive action is based on the intuitive philosophy that we
  14. feel good about ourselves when we do positive actions.
  15. This program is organized into a total number of seven
  16. units. These units are also organized by grade level, thereby
  17. making them easily malleable for specific needs.
  18. Based on age combined, these units tend to all five
  19. competencies of CEO self awareness, self management, social awareness, relationship
  20. skills and responsible decision making Unit one is self concept
  21. again. I draw directly from the website on the website.
  22. It provides images, um, for each unit unit number one.
  23. This program starts with helping students identify themselves and understand
  24. their self concept.
  25. Students learn that self concept means the way they think
  26. and feel about themselves, and their families and friends influence
  27. their self concepts for a unit to the positive actions
  28. for your body and mind, students become aware of their
  29. responsibility for the care of their bodies and learn the
  30. physical and intellectual aspects of self concept.
  31. They learn that positive people take care of their bodies
  32. and minds.
  33. They feel healthy and strong and are excited by new
  34. ideas. Lessons focus on specific positive actions for physical health,
  35. nutrition, hygiene, avoiding harmful substances, exercise, sleep of winning illness
  36. and positive actions for intellectual health, learning, problem solving, creative
  37. thinking, memory and curiosity.
  38. Right Unit number three is managing yourself responsibly.
  39. Students discover that managing their resources is an important positive
  40. action and improves their self concept.
  41. Lessons will also focus on nine specific feelings.
  42. Love, anger, worry, jealousy, pride, fear, loneliness, thankfulness and discouragement.
  43. Students learn ways to manage their feelings so their feelings
  44. do not control them.
  45. The next unit we have treating others the way you
  46. like to be treated treat people the way you would
  47. like to be treated.
  48. That's the key for getting along with others.
  49. Students also learn in practice respect, empathy, friendliness, kindness, cooperation
  50. and positiveness as positive ways of dealing with others, telling
  51. yourself the truth.
  52. Self honesty is difficult.
  53. It takes perception and practice.
  54. In this unit, students practice telling themselves the truth, knowing
  55. themselves, not blaming others, admitting mistakes, not making excuses and
  56. keeping their word.
  57. Uh huh.
  58. Improving yourself continually.
  59. Self improvement means developing and integrating the physical, intellectual and
  60. social emotional domains to grow toward one's personal ideal.
  61. In this unit, students learn how to set short term
  62. and long term goals and they and how to make
  63. goal setting work.
  64. They are taught to believe in their potential, to have
  65. courage, to try to turn problems into opportunities and to
  66. work steadily towards improvement.
  67. And the seventh and final unit is a review.
  68. It's a chance to recall the positive actions, learn to
  69. practice many of them again and to check on the
  70. progress of the goals and to establish new goals.
  71. It is also an excellent time to see all the
  72. concepts of positive action.
  73. Working together, students see that the self they started with
  74. at the beginning of the year has clearly improved, giving
  75. them reason to trust in themselves and their continued growth.
  76. So we go back to the main page, and we
  77. look at the program the implementation of the program.
  78. There are a couple ways that this program can be
  79. implemented, which I will discuss in the pricing bubble.
  80. While Positive Action is a program that focuses on SCL
  81. aspect of the classroom, it is also a program that
  82. aligns with academic standards, such as the common core state
  83. standards. The program also claims that provided lessons satisfy about
  84. quote seven academic objectives per lesson.
  85. Um, something that I didn't provide in this presentation visually,
  86. is that the lessons are supposed to take about 15
  87. minutes each.
  88. So, um, this program also provides a good time frame
  89. for integration into your everyday curriculum.
  90. Something that I thought it was important to note to
  91. note is that positive Action offers a Spanish version of
  92. their curriculum.
  93. However, it is only K through eight.
  94. Unlike the English curriculum, which is pre K through 12.
  95. When we look at the pricing, when it comes to
  96. training, we have our online webinar.
  97. We have our on site orientation.
  98. We have our on site training of trainers doing a
  99. little bit of continuing of costs and pricing.
  100. Um, the website offers reinforcement products and curriculum products, so
  101. some of these products include grade based learning kits ranges
  102. from hundreds of hundreds of dollars to thousands of dollars.
  103. Um, the kits that are up in the thousands of
  104. dollars range are kits that would in company, for example,
  105. um, an entire middle school.
  106. So sixth through eighth or you could get one just
  107. for 6/7 or eighth.
  108. They also sell merchandise such as T shirts, stickers, responds,
  109. buttons, notes, etcetera.
  110. Everything is under $100 and it starts around a couple
  111. dollars. For example, there is a positive note note pad
  112. that's offered for about $4 moving on to the sample
  113. lesson. This is a sample lesson I picked up for
  114. eighth grade.
  115. I believe the website provides to it is titled Outside
  116. Pressure makes me a little crazy.
  117. Um, and I will comment on this title in my
  118. conclusion slide.
  119. So the goal of this lesson again, these lessons are
  120. meant to be 15 minutes.
  121. This goal is to introduce the positive action of recognizing
  122. how various outside pressures affect telling yourself the truth and
  123. your identity objectives to discuss negative peer pressure and to
  124. provide positive waste of dealing with it to discuss positive
  125. and negative peer pressure materials provided are a script, books
  126. and positive action journals.
  127. Here is a visual of what the end of this
  128. lesson would look like.
  129. Um, it's totally scripted.
  130. And there's supposed to be some sort of, uh, radio
  131. going on as part of this.
  132. Um, yeah, I guess you could call it a uh
  133. Oh, my God.
  134. I'm blanking on the word, Um, but basically, it's just
  135. like a pretend session.
  136. And it's to give students an example of situations.
  137. So it ends with, um Well, what did you learn
  138. about peer pressure?
  139. The teacher is supposed to wait for responses.
  140. Um, and then some might say peer pressure can be
  141. either positive or negative, although unfortunately, negative peer pressure is
  142. much more common.
  143. The best thing you can do is to think for
  144. yourself to measure the negative peer pressure against your thoughts,
  145. actions, feeling circle.
  146. The great question to ask yourself is If I do
  147. this, am I going to feel great about myself or
  148. not? So great.
  149. Pause. Just long enough to think through that and you'll
  150. have your very own answer.
  151. I believe the lessons go from pre K until 12.
  152. I just wanted to pull from eight because I am
  153. currently placed in an eighth grade classroom.
  154. So in conclusion, um, this this review of this program,
  155. it's very clear that positive action works.
  156. I will.
  157. I pulled a couple quotes, um, from research that will
  158. relate to this.
  159. There are multiple studies and articles praising the program for
  160. being applicable to a range of grades, as well as
  161. praising general success from the program.
  162. This program also addresses all five competencies of S E.
  163. L. However, while it is important to give praise to
  164. this program, it is also essential to note that this
  165. program reflects levels of fabulous language.
  166. Um, looking back at the lesson for grade eight that
  167. I just went over, um, the word crazy using that
  168. is a is A B list.
  169. Another point is that there is inconsistency with keeping resources
  170. up to date.
  171. When I was doing my research and looking at the
  172. articles that were linked on this Web site, um, at
  173. least a couple of them were expired links and some
  174. studies that I used, um, in reference to reviewing this
  175. program, reinforce problematic concepts such as B m i B
  176. m. I has been proven to, um, not be an
  177. efficient way to measure the health of someone.
  178. Um, it has even been claimed as unethical, racist and
  179. sexist. So from my research, these are some points, um,
  180. one from each of the four articles that I went
  181. over, Even with positive results being seen in studies, some
  182. studies still only show quote a modest magnitude of affects
  183. over an extended period of programme implementation.
  184. Quite a few of the articles that I went over
  185. discuss um, the issue or problem of quote modest magnitude.
  186. Um however, there for the second point, there was a
  187. favorable change over time and social, emotional and character development
  188. For students and positive action schools.
  189. The favorable change specifically relates to anxiety and depression.
  190. Um, the articles I looked at also meant to connect
  191. to multiple competencies.
  192. So some of them looked at the physical benefits of
  193. this program as well as the social and emotional benefits.
  194. Students and positive action schools were 20 to 39% less
  195. likely to have ever used tobacco, alcohol and marijuana than
  196. students in control schools.
  197. There is demonstrated potential of positive impact from CL programs
  198. like positive action when it comes to physical health.
  199. So I'm not sure why My reference list, um, didn't
  200. save. I apologize for that.
  201. I will be providing it.
  202. And when I share this and the discussion forum, uh,
  203. thank you, everybody for listening to my presentation.