Solutions
Features
Pricing
Log in
Teams
Get started
Log in
Get started
Online Course Critique EDU 630
JP
by
Jody Pecena
·
1 view
·
Updated Apr 30, 2021
Share
Embed
Create your own
Chapters
00:00
Chapter 1
00:23
Chapter 2
00:27
Chapter 3
03:38
Chapter 4
03:40
Chapter 5
05:12
Chapter 6
05:33
Chapter 7
05:35
Chapter 8
05:59
Chapter 9
06:00
Chapter 10
06:24
Chapter 11
06:25
Chapter 12
07:01
Chapter 13
07:03
Chapter 14
07:42
Chapter 15
07:44
Chapter 16
08:00
Chapter 17
08:01
Chapter 18
08:14
Chapter 19
08:17
Chapter 20
08:26
Chapter 21
08:28
Chapter 22
08:45
Chapter 23
08:47
Chapter 24
08:49
Chapter 25
10:43
Chapter 26
10:48
Chapter 27
11:44
Chapter 28
11:45
Chapter 29
12:55
Chapter 30
12:57
Chapter 31
Audio Transcript
Auto-generated
00:02 - 00:07
Hello and welcome to my presentation Um for education 6
00:08 - 00:12
30 we will be doing a course critique on the
00:12 - 00:17
introduction to morality combining everything that we have learned about
00:17 - 00:21
online learning theories, best practices and online learning theorists.
00:24 - 00:27
Yeah. I'm going to start with a brief course overview
00:28 - 00:31
of the course that I have critiqued.
00:32 - 00:36
Um evaluating online learning can be problematic as each program
00:37 - 00:40
of online is unique in design and demographic of students.
00:41 - 00:43
It's advertising too often.
00:43 - 00:43
The U.
00:44 - 00:47
S. Department of Education has reviewed several programs and the
00:47 - 00:50
evaluation system used in each many online and in person
00:51 - 00:56
programs require an accreditation to be considered reputable or worthy.
00:57 - 01:02
However some programs are not geared towards people who are
01:02 - 01:03
seeking a higher education.
01:05 - 01:08
So when you advertise to those who are seeking a
01:08 - 01:11
degree or higher education that would accelerate the program to
01:11 - 01:13
meet those specific indicators set forth by the U.
01:13 - 01:14
S. Department of Education.
01:15 - 01:18
However like I said not all online programs are seeking
01:18 - 01:21
the same type of audience or set of students, therefore
01:22 - 01:24
all of them don't need to meet the same rigorous
01:24 - 01:28
criteria, which makes it kind of hard to critique them.
01:29 - 01:32
Um Later on in my critique, I have used the
01:32 - 01:35
quality scorecards set forth by the online learning consortium.
01:37 - 01:41
So morality is of everyday life is a massive open
01:42 - 01:45
online course or a mook That was free.
01:45 - 01:48
There was also an option to earn a certificate for
01:48 - 01:49
a nominal fee of $49.
01:51 - 01:54
Um When this course is open, It can have anywhere
01:55 - 01:58
from 1000 to 10,000 students enrolled.
02:00 - 02:01
It all depends on the interest.
02:02 - 02:05
At the time, the selling point of the course was
02:05 - 02:09
offered via coursera dot org and the selling point is
02:09 - 02:11
that it was taught by a well known Yale University
02:12 - 02:14
psychology professor and his graduate assistant.
02:16 - 02:19
So it's not geared towards anyone who is seeking higher
02:19 - 02:22
education but rather those who are wishing just to enlighten
02:23 - 02:25
themselves and expand upon their knowledge in the world of
02:25 - 02:27
psychology specifically morality.
02:28 - 02:32
So I personally chose this course because it relates to
02:32 - 02:35
my undergrad degree in psychology and I felt like it
02:35 - 02:38
was a nice break from learning about a topic that
02:38 - 02:42
didn't revolve around the world of special education and educational
02:43 - 02:46
jargon. It was like a breath of fresh air to
02:46 - 02:52
me. So this six week course um includes a variety
02:53 - 02:54
of different modes.
02:55 - 02:58
There's ted talks, there's online videos, there's readings, there's discussion
02:59 - 03:03
boards, um there's recorded office hours, so to speak or
03:03 - 03:07
conversations with the instructor, the graduate assistant, Sometimes there's guest
03:07 - 03:14
speakers, there's assessments, there's all sorts of material to review
03:15 - 03:15
and read.
03:16 - 03:19
Um the courses accessible on a variety of devices.
03:20 - 03:23
You can access it on a desktop computer, you can
03:23 - 03:25
access it on a laptop tablet, a smartphone.
03:26 - 03:29
Ultimately, the only technology needed in order to be successful
03:29 - 03:32
throughout this course is a device that has internet, so
03:33 - 03:35
any kind of device that has internet, you can most
03:35 - 03:36
likely access the course.
03:38 - 03:45
Yeah, so when I was doing the critique, um, and
03:45 - 03:48
I was assessing the course, like I stated, the course
03:49 - 03:53
era doesn't necessarily provide massive open enrollment online courses.
03:55 - 03:58
Two have people obtain a higher degree.
03:58 - 04:05
So one of the criteria that we needed to address
04:06 - 04:07
and determine if this course is good.
04:08 - 04:11
Um, I found from the online learning consortium, like I
04:11 - 04:12
stated quality scorecards.
04:13 - 04:18
So these scorecards provide institutions and accreditation agencies, whoever is
04:18 - 04:21
seeking to use them the necessary benchmarking tools to ensure
04:22 - 04:25
that the course and the material that they are providing
04:27 - 04:28
that the institution is providing is reliable.
04:29 - 04:32
It's valuable in an online learning environment for all stakeholders,
04:33 - 04:36
for faculty, for the university's putting them on for the
04:36 - 04:40
students who are enrolled for all powers that be, that
04:40 - 04:41
are going to be involved, all stakeholders.
04:43 - 04:47
So for me personally, when I completed these scorecards and
04:47 - 04:51
I went through, I only reviewed Them as a student,
04:52 - 04:56
so I wouldn't say that my score is 100 accurate.
04:58 - 05:00
But from a student standpoint, what I could score, I
05:00 - 05:07
feel gives and overall perspective of how engaging the courses,
05:08 - 05:10
how much effort goes into the course and what you're
05:10 - 05:12
really going to get out of the course.
05:13 - 05:16
So the first one is institutional support.
05:17 - 05:20
This score was a possible 27 points.
05:21 - 05:23
I gave it a 10 out of 27.
05:23 - 05:25
You can go through and look at all of the
05:25 - 05:28
different indicators to see why I gave it.
05:29 - 05:32
Um, and the justification for why I gave that score.
05:32 - 05:38
So, Mhm, The next one is technology support as a
05:38 - 05:43
student. Um For me, it was hard to determine Um
05:44 - 05:48
many of the technology system specifics needed for designing and
05:49 - 05:51
supporting the course because I was a student, not necessarily
05:52 - 05:53
the instructor designing the course.
05:54 - 05:58
Um so this quality scorecard only scored two out of
05:58 - 05:59
a possible 21 points.
06:00 - 06:05
Yeah, the next one is course development and instructional design.
06:05 - 06:10
Again, I was not the person designing the course, um
06:11 - 06:18
but from my perspective, this scorecard received a um 18
06:19 - 06:21
out of 36, so about 50%, many of the things
06:21 - 06:23
I gave a zero because I couldn't answer yes or
06:23 - 06:24
no to them.
06:25 - 06:29
Okay, Course structure scored a 15 out of 24.
06:31 - 06:35
Um the structure is very solid, I would say, um
06:37 - 06:41
for me personally, the course objectives, I am very used
06:41 - 06:45
to, from a teacher's perspective, stating the student will be
06:45 - 06:47
able to, this is the outcome of the course.
06:48 - 06:51
These were kind of discussed in the introduction video and
06:51 - 06:54
throughout the syllabus and more of a paragraph format instead
06:55 - 06:59
of explicitly stated as a bullet pointed statement, so to
06:59 - 07:05
speak. So they scored a 15 out of 24 student
07:05 - 07:08
support, I felt Reasonably supported.
07:08 - 07:09
Should I need something again?
07:10 - 07:13
This is a massive open enrollment course.
07:13 - 07:19
So there could be anywhere from 1000 to 10,000 students
07:20 - 07:21
in this class at the same time.
07:22 - 07:27
Um as I wasn't a student who went through the
07:27 - 07:31
entire six week course, I couldn't tell you if I
07:31 - 07:33
needed support, if I would receive, you're not from what
07:33 - 07:38
I could see, there were some options for tutoring for
07:38 - 07:41
resources for students with disabilities and I think that that
07:41 - 07:42
is pretty good.
07:44 - 07:49
Yeah, talking about teaching and learning, They scored an 11
07:49 - 07:49
out of 15.
07:50 - 07:56
So I would say despite the extremely large possible enrollment,
07:56 - 08:00
I think interaction feedback and differentiation were all implemented pretty
08:00 - 08:04
well. social and student engagement.
08:05 - 08:08
They were thoroughly the professor and the graduate assistant through
08:09 - 08:10
all the videos that were posted.
08:10 - 08:14
They always recommended and encouraged social engagement with your peers
08:15 - 08:17
who are enrolled in the course.
08:19 - 08:20
Finally, faculty support.
08:21 - 08:23
Again, it was a difficult area for me to evaluate
08:23 - 08:30
as I was a student enrolled in the course and
08:30 - 08:32
finally evaluation and assessment.
08:33 - 08:37
Um Again, I was a student so it was hard
08:37 - 08:39
to evaluate the behind the scenes information.
08:41 - 08:44
Um I took my best educated guess based on the
08:45 - 08:46
information I was able to access.
08:47 - 08:47
Uh huh.
08:49 - 08:53
Okay. As far as theory and best practices um this
08:54 - 08:57
massive open enrollment course definitely had its benefits.
08:57 - 09:01
While there are starting inundates the course was for sure,
09:02 - 09:04
self paced and allowed students to work at their own
09:04 - 09:06
speed truly reflecting an online environment.
09:08 - 09:11
Online learning is very self directed and this course definitely
09:12 - 09:13
fit in in this format.
09:14 - 09:17
Students were able to be active in their learning or
09:17 - 09:18
not active.
09:18 - 09:19
They were given that choice.
09:20 - 09:24
Um The teacher and instructor in the professor from Yale
09:24 - 09:28
and his graduate assistant, they acted more as facilitators presenting
09:29 - 09:32
the material kind of guiding us on how we could
09:32 - 09:35
manipulate and use the material, but they for sure we're
09:36 - 09:41
facilitators instead of standing there teaching in front of us.
09:42 - 09:48
Um The course also provided numerous opportunities to interact with
09:48 - 09:52
the peers and instructors through those discussion boards and email
09:53 - 09:57
um which also touches on connective is um um it
09:58 - 10:02
shows a few characteristics of blended learning theory um using
10:03 - 10:07
different discussion boards, live chats, things like that.
10:08 - 10:11
Um and it provided students with some autonomy of what
10:11 - 10:13
they learn and the pace they learn at.
10:14 - 10:21
So all of these theories allow students the opportunity to
10:21 - 10:25
work with the instructor as well as independently dewey's experience.
10:26 - 10:30
Experiential learning theory is also seen throughout this course.
10:31 - 10:35
Um, discussion with peers and professor is encouraged to experiment
10:36 - 10:42
and to apply the morality values and things that we
10:42 - 10:49
were taught that was also encouraged as far as drawbacks
10:50 - 10:52
as with anything, there's always drawbacks.
10:52 - 10:56
So again, it's a massive open enrollment course.
10:57 - 11:01
Um, There was anywhere from hundreds to thousands of people,
11:01 - 11:03
so you were guaranteed feedback on your assessment.
11:04 - 11:07
But if you weren't taking and assess if you weren't
11:07 - 11:10
taking the course with the nominal fee of $49 to
11:10 - 11:12
receive a certificate, you didn't necessarily have to take the
11:13 - 11:15
assessment. So there wasn't a guarantee that you would receive
11:15 - 11:19
feedback. Um A lot of the office hours and discussions
11:20 - 11:20
were pre recorded.
11:22 - 11:24
Um you could email in questions or right on the
11:24 - 11:27
discussion board and then the professor or guest speaker or
11:27 - 11:29
graduate assistant would discuss that.
11:30 - 11:34
But if it wasn't, there weren't always live discussions, so
11:35 - 11:36
that is definitely a drawback.
11:37 - 11:39
But again, if you are just a person who is
11:39 - 11:44
looking to see um enlighten yourself, then this is a
11:44 - 11:44
great course.
11:47 - 11:51
Finally, in conclusion, I would definitely recommend enrolling in a
11:51 - 11:54
course or one of a similar, similar format if you're
11:54 - 11:57
looking just to enlighten yourself or gain a deeper knowledge
11:57 - 11:59
on a specific topic that has piqued your interest.
12:00 - 12:03
Or if you're a high school student or an early
12:03 - 12:05
college student who is not really sure of the track
12:06 - 12:07
that they want to go and you want to gain
12:07 - 12:08
some more information.
12:08 - 12:10
If you think that that might be a career path
12:10 - 12:11
or something that would interest you.
12:12 - 12:15
Courses like this would definitely benefit you.
12:15 - 12:18
It is a course with low risk and high reward.
12:18 - 12:22
If you place the time and effort into it, it
12:22 - 12:28
should be noted um That again, the score card that
12:28 - 12:31
I used is generally used by people who have access
12:31 - 12:34
to every part of the course, not just me.
12:35 - 12:39
Um so overall, I would recommend this course or one
12:40 - 12:43
similar. There is a plethora of these courses available online.
12:44 - 12:48
Until I completed this project, I had no idea how
12:48 - 12:51
much knowledge is out there at the fingertips.
12:52 - 12:54
If you are willing to put in the work.
12:57 - 13:04
These are the references for my proof presentation.
13:05 - 13:07
And does anyone have any questions?
13:07 - 13:10
I hope you enjoyed watching, feel free to email me
13:10 - 13:11
if you have any questions or concerns
See full transcript