Online Course Critique EDU 630

JP
by Jody Pecena1 view·Updated Apr 30, 2021

Chapters

Audio TranscriptAuto-generated

  1. Hello and welcome to my presentation Um for education 6
  2. 30 we will be doing a course critique on the
  3. introduction to morality combining everything that we have learned about
  4. online learning theories, best practices and online learning theorists.
  5. Yeah. I'm going to start with a brief course overview
  6. of the course that I have critiqued.
  7. Um evaluating online learning can be problematic as each program
  8. of online is unique in design and demographic of students.
  9. It's advertising too often.
  10. The U.
  11. S. Department of Education has reviewed several programs and the
  12. evaluation system used in each many online and in person
  13. programs require an accreditation to be considered reputable or worthy.
  14. However some programs are not geared towards people who are
  15. seeking a higher education.
  16. So when you advertise to those who are seeking a
  17. degree or higher education that would accelerate the program to
  18. meet those specific indicators set forth by the U.
  19. S. Department of Education.
  20. However like I said not all online programs are seeking
  21. the same type of audience or set of students, therefore
  22. all of them don't need to meet the same rigorous
  23. criteria, which makes it kind of hard to critique them.
  24. Um Later on in my critique, I have used the
  25. quality scorecards set forth by the online learning consortium.
  26. So morality is of everyday life is a massive open
  27. online course or a mook That was free.
  28. There was also an option to earn a certificate for
  29. a nominal fee of $49.
  30. Um When this course is open, It can have anywhere
  31. from 1000 to 10,000 students enrolled.
  32. It all depends on the interest.
  33. At the time, the selling point of the course was
  34. offered via coursera dot org and the selling point is
  35. that it was taught by a well known Yale University
  36. psychology professor and his graduate assistant.
  37. So it's not geared towards anyone who is seeking higher
  38. education but rather those who are wishing just to enlighten
  39. themselves and expand upon their knowledge in the world of
  40. psychology specifically morality.
  41. So I personally chose this course because it relates to
  42. my undergrad degree in psychology and I felt like it
  43. was a nice break from learning about a topic that
  44. didn't revolve around the world of special education and educational
  45. jargon. It was like a breath of fresh air to
  46. me. So this six week course um includes a variety
  47. of different modes.
  48. There's ted talks, there's online videos, there's readings, there's discussion
  49. boards, um there's recorded office hours, so to speak or
  50. conversations with the instructor, the graduate assistant, Sometimes there's guest
  51. speakers, there's assessments, there's all sorts of material to review
  52. and read.
  53. Um the courses accessible on a variety of devices.
  54. You can access it on a desktop computer, you can
  55. access it on a laptop tablet, a smartphone.
  56. Ultimately, the only technology needed in order to be successful
  57. throughout this course is a device that has internet, so
  58. any kind of device that has internet, you can most
  59. likely access the course.
  60. Yeah, so when I was doing the critique, um, and
  61. I was assessing the course, like I stated, the course
  62. era doesn't necessarily provide massive open enrollment online courses.
  63. Two have people obtain a higher degree.
  64. So one of the criteria that we needed to address
  65. and determine if this course is good.
  66. Um, I found from the online learning consortium, like I
  67. stated quality scorecards.
  68. So these scorecards provide institutions and accreditation agencies, whoever is
  69. seeking to use them the necessary benchmarking tools to ensure
  70. that the course and the material that they are providing
  71. that the institution is providing is reliable.
  72. It's valuable in an online learning environment for all stakeholders,
  73. for faculty, for the university's putting them on for the
  74. students who are enrolled for all powers that be, that
  75. are going to be involved, all stakeholders.
  76. So for me personally, when I completed these scorecards and
  77. I went through, I only reviewed Them as a student,
  78. so I wouldn't say that my score is 100 accurate.
  79. But from a student standpoint, what I could score, I
  80. feel gives and overall perspective of how engaging the courses,
  81. how much effort goes into the course and what you're
  82. really going to get out of the course.
  83. So the first one is institutional support.
  84. This score was a possible 27 points.
  85. I gave it a 10 out of 27.
  86. You can go through and look at all of the
  87. different indicators to see why I gave it.
  88. Um, and the justification for why I gave that score.
  89. So, Mhm, The next one is technology support as a
  90. student. Um For me, it was hard to determine Um
  91. many of the technology system specifics needed for designing and
  92. supporting the course because I was a student, not necessarily
  93. the instructor designing the course.
  94. Um so this quality scorecard only scored two out of
  95. a possible 21 points.
  96. Yeah, the next one is course development and instructional design.
  97. Again, I was not the person designing the course, um
  98. but from my perspective, this scorecard received a um 18
  99. out of 36, so about 50%, many of the things
  100. I gave a zero because I couldn't answer yes or
  101. no to them.
  102. Okay, Course structure scored a 15 out of 24.
  103. Um the structure is very solid, I would say, um
  104. for me personally, the course objectives, I am very used
  105. to, from a teacher's perspective, stating the student will be
  106. able to, this is the outcome of the course.
  107. These were kind of discussed in the introduction video and
  108. throughout the syllabus and more of a paragraph format instead
  109. of explicitly stated as a bullet pointed statement, so to
  110. speak. So they scored a 15 out of 24 student
  111. support, I felt Reasonably supported.
  112. Should I need something again?
  113. This is a massive open enrollment course.
  114. So there could be anywhere from 1000 to 10,000 students
  115. in this class at the same time.
  116. Um as I wasn't a student who went through the
  117. entire six week course, I couldn't tell you if I
  118. needed support, if I would receive, you're not from what
  119. I could see, there were some options for tutoring for
  120. resources for students with disabilities and I think that that
  121. is pretty good.
  122. Yeah, talking about teaching and learning, They scored an 11
  123. out of 15.
  124. So I would say despite the extremely large possible enrollment,
  125. I think interaction feedback and differentiation were all implemented pretty
  126. well. social and student engagement.
  127. They were thoroughly the professor and the graduate assistant through
  128. all the videos that were posted.
  129. They always recommended and encouraged social engagement with your peers
  130. who are enrolled in the course.
  131. Finally, faculty support.
  132. Again, it was a difficult area for me to evaluate
  133. as I was a student enrolled in the course and
  134. finally evaluation and assessment.
  135. Um Again, I was a student so it was hard
  136. to evaluate the behind the scenes information.
  137. Um I took my best educated guess based on the
  138. information I was able to access.
  139. Uh huh.
  140. Okay. As far as theory and best practices um this
  141. massive open enrollment course definitely had its benefits.
  142. While there are starting inundates the course was for sure,
  143. self paced and allowed students to work at their own
  144. speed truly reflecting an online environment.
  145. Online learning is very self directed and this course definitely
  146. fit in in this format.
  147. Students were able to be active in their learning or
  148. not active.
  149. They were given that choice.
  150. Um The teacher and instructor in the professor from Yale
  151. and his graduate assistant, they acted more as facilitators presenting
  152. the material kind of guiding us on how we could
  153. manipulate and use the material, but they for sure we're
  154. facilitators instead of standing there teaching in front of us.
  155. Um The course also provided numerous opportunities to interact with
  156. the peers and instructors through those discussion boards and email
  157. um which also touches on connective is um um it
  158. shows a few characteristics of blended learning theory um using
  159. different discussion boards, live chats, things like that.
  160. Um and it provided students with some autonomy of what
  161. they learn and the pace they learn at.
  162. So all of these theories allow students the opportunity to
  163. work with the instructor as well as independently dewey's experience.
  164. Experiential learning theory is also seen throughout this course.
  165. Um, discussion with peers and professor is encouraged to experiment
  166. and to apply the morality values and things that we
  167. were taught that was also encouraged as far as drawbacks
  168. as with anything, there's always drawbacks.
  169. So again, it's a massive open enrollment course.
  170. Um, There was anywhere from hundreds to thousands of people,
  171. so you were guaranteed feedback on your assessment.
  172. But if you weren't taking and assess if you weren't
  173. taking the course with the nominal fee of $49 to
  174. receive a certificate, you didn't necessarily have to take the
  175. assessment. So there wasn't a guarantee that you would receive
  176. feedback. Um A lot of the office hours and discussions
  177. were pre recorded.
  178. Um you could email in questions or right on the
  179. discussion board and then the professor or guest speaker or
  180. graduate assistant would discuss that.
  181. But if it wasn't, there weren't always live discussions, so
  182. that is definitely a drawback.
  183. But again, if you are just a person who is
  184. looking to see um enlighten yourself, then this is a
  185. great course.
  186. Finally, in conclusion, I would definitely recommend enrolling in a
  187. course or one of a similar, similar format if you're
  188. looking just to enlighten yourself or gain a deeper knowledge
  189. on a specific topic that has piqued your interest.
  190. Or if you're a high school student or an early
  191. college student who is not really sure of the track
  192. that they want to go and you want to gain
  193. some more information.
  194. If you think that that might be a career path
  195. or something that would interest you.
  196. Courses like this would definitely benefit you.
  197. It is a course with low risk and high reward.
  198. If you place the time and effort into it, it
  199. should be noted um That again, the score card that
  200. I used is generally used by people who have access
  201. to every part of the course, not just me.
  202. Um so overall, I would recommend this course or one
  203. similar. There is a plethora of these courses available online.
  204. Until I completed this project, I had no idea how
  205. much knowledge is out there at the fingertips.
  206. If you are willing to put in the work.
  207. These are the references for my proof presentation.
  208. And does anyone have any questions?
  209. I hope you enjoyed watching, feel free to email me
  210. if you have any questions or concerns