Vytvorte si vlastnú prepracovanú prezentáciu za pár minút. Stačí opísať, čo potrebujete.
Vyskúšajte zadarmo, nie je potrebná kreditná kartaAction Research:
Reading Stamina
Melissa Czyz
American College of Education
Purpose
The purpose of this research is for my student's reading scores to increase on MAP tests with focus on reading stamina inside and outside of the classroom. To make all of this happen, students need to develop stamina when reading in the classroom and at home.
Purpose
Problem Statement
Problem
Statement
Reading stamina is very important. This is something that students should be working on beginning in Kindergarten. Many students have a difficult time reading; whether because they can’t relate to what is being read, or their lack of comprehension. Gulla states, “For many teachers of middle school and high school, the greatest challenge they face in trying to help struggling readers improve their skills can be students’ self-perception” (Gulla, 2012, p. 57). The problem is that students lack reading stamina which then brings a deficit in reading comprehension. I began to realize this was a problem in my classroom, I have decided to conduct my research on the importance of stamina. One way that I know reading stamina and comprehension is a problem, is because my students, when asked to read for 5 minutes, struggle. Reading is used within every subject, every single day. If students can not stay focused while reading a text of their choice, their skills will never grow.
Evidence is tough when it comes to reading stamina and comprehension. I noticed my students struggling with reading for long periods of time. In 5th grade, this should not be occurring. Students need to develop a love for reading, but also need to be taught how that can be. Setting the tone, sharing ideas, and giving students time to develop their skills is important. I want to increase my students reading stamina, and to develop a lifelong love for reading.
Research Questions
Research
Questions
Literature Review :
Takes a look at different methods to get students to gain a love for reading and build their reading stamina
Literature
Review
The Importance of Close Reading
Snow, C. E. (2013)
Purpose- The purpose of this study was to look at the importance of close reading (warm and cold) and how that method could help students who struggle to build their reading stamina.
Problem- Snow identified the problem stating that close readings are important but cold close readings do not benefit students reading performance.
Methodology/Results- Snow used a method of "warm close readings", in which students were able to identify and understand vocabulary and increase their stamina.
Snow concludes, “The focus in the Common Core State Standards on the virtues of “struggling with text” suggests it should. But the reality of reading a text that is too hard without any help is that it often results, not in productive struggle, but indestructive frustration” (2013, p. 19). Snow lets her readers know that students benefit from warm close readings and using those readings will set students up for success.
An ethnographic research study
Gulla, A. N., &
Fink, L. S., R.W.T. (2012)
Purpose - Gulla and Fink (2012) state, “...the greatest challenge they face in trying to help struggling readers improve their skills can be students’ self-perception” (2012, p. 57). The purpose of this study is to develop a way to get students attention and help them develop a love and understanding for reading.
Problem - A ninth grade literacy classroom in New York is followed and studied to see what changes were made in their classrooms to produce a higher level of reading and comprehension skills to pass a state exam. It was said, “...according to the 2008–2009 New York State School Report Card, only 26% of students at Urban passed the Comprehensive English Regents exam with a grade of 55 or above” (2012, p. 57).
Methodology - To develop an independent reading program that gives students choice and freedom.
Results - Students were able to self-manage themselves during their reading time. Their love for reading grew as did their reading stamina.
Gulla states, “The teacher-student interactions that I witnessed were the embodiment of Nel Noddings’s notion of “relational caring” (xvii) in which the caring teacher acknowledges and attends to the needs of students” (2012, p. 61). This care allowed students who came into her class with no want to read, leading to them asking for books for their birthday. The love of reading is a skill that needs to be taught. Knowing your students and creating a community of learners that respect each other will bring success in the classroom.
Literacy Clubs : The Lunch Bunch
Tichenor, M., Piechura, K.,
Diedrichs, R.,
& Heins, E. (2020)
Purpose - This study was to show that students who read for pleasure are able to gain knowledge without being taught skills.
Problem - This study shows different programs to get students reading with a positive attitude, and higher achievements and student engagement.
Methodology - This group gave elementary students the chance to read texts together during lunch with university pre-service teachers. Tichenor states, “While the elementary students eat their lunches, the university students typically read a chapter to the students, which they then talk about. The discussions center on what the elementary students like about the story, what they don’t like about the story, as well as predictions about what might happen next in the story” (2020, p. 12).
Results - . Feedback was given to the students at the end of the semester. The survey read, “Of the 58 students surveyed, 95% reported they would like to return to the lunch bunch the following semester. Of the students who would like to return, 97% said they wanted to return because it was “fun”” (2020, p. 12).
Reserach Methodology/Design
Research
Methodology/
Design
To research the purpose of reading stamina and the effects it has on MAP scores, formative assessment and observation plays an important role in the classroom. Students were shown to lack reading stamina. This lack of motivation and ability to stay focused was clear when the students took their MAP reading test. Observation played a big role when looking at this data. While students took their MAP test, their eyes would wander and their focus would drift. I recognized that on most assessments, my students would stay focused for a few minutes while reading but when it came to long passages, they zoned out. The open-ended research questions will guide my research to finding out what motivated my students to become better readers. With a changed literacy block and a focus on independent reading, students should see an increase in reading stamina which will generate higher scores on assessments.
Data Collection
Data
Collection
To identify students low reading stamina, I collected data from the following:
F & P
F & P/
Observations
F & P is a big deal within our district. This is something we use in the beginning, middle and end of the year to show growth of our students. Attached is the text level gradient that every teacher uses to determine where their students are grade level wise. It is important as teachers to identify their student's position before making any changes within their classroom. Many students as shown below are struggling with reading at grade level. This data gave me the idea that focusing on stamina and comprehension would benefit all students, struggling and non-struggling.
F & P
Students in 5th and 6th grade should have a text level of T-Y. Most students although showed growth from the beginning of the year, still struggled when reading alone.
Scores
Winter MAP Data
Winter MAP
Data
When looking at MAP data, I was able to tell that many students were struggling to make growth from their Fall MAP scores. This was disappointing to see. This data shows both my 5th and 6th grade students Mean RIT were below where they should be. Students in 5th grade in the Winter should show an average of 209.8, the Mean RIT was only 206.5. I noticed a lot of students were struggling with vocabulary. Students who tend to read the wrong level text have a low understanding of words. This was another big reason why stamina and increasing scores was important. The students in 6th grade showed struggles as well. When looking at their individual scores, I was able to adjust my practices to give my students the best learning experience.
Students were below in many areas.
Their scores dropped from Fall MAP.
RIT Scores
MAP Data
Percentiles
Most students were under the 50th percentile. 5th Grade- 8 Students
6th Grade- 5 Students
MAP Data
Plickers & Surveys
Plickers &
Surveys
Plickers is used within my class during specific standards that were being taught. Pre and post assessments are very important to show growth on a certain topic. Using the same questions each time, a teacher is able to see the growth of their knowledge after teaching the specific standard.
Surveys are used to determine the best methods to teach my students. I was able to use this survey to better understand how my students liked to learn and the best ways to get them interested in their projects that went along with their reading workshop.
Plickers
Students use QR codes to answer specific questions that guide understanding of a standard.
Plickers
Multiple Intelligence
Survey
This survey allowed me to group my students accordingly as well as adjust my reading workshop projects to suit my students favored learning styles.
Surveys
Data Analysis
Data
Analysis
While looking at my data, I have realized that most of my students benefited from the reading workshop that was brought into my classroom. The observations made by my conversations with my students, the book talks that we would have, and the whole group open discussions have given me a chance to analyze the success of bringing a reading workshop model into my room. The students enjoyed talking to their classmates about what they were reading. They enjoyed being able to show off their work that they did individually about their text of choice. They were taking ownership of their reading. This was a huge thing that I realized when observing my students. Their lack of care for reading before the workshop model was introduced was evident. The students were able to express themselves within their work and were able to stay focused and increase their stamina while reading at school.
Analysis of F & P/Observations
When this school year started, I noticed that my students lacked the ability to choose texts that were appropriate for their reading level, as well as interesting to them. This was shown by their inability to stay focused during any type of silent reading activity. The students would be asked to read to themselves, and it would last for a few minutes and then noise would begin. I observed that most of my students F & P scores were below grade level. When students read to me, they would have a difficult time recalling what was read. I observed my student’s inability to take proper notes when listening to a text being read aloud. When looking at Fountas and Pinnell, you will see that the many students were below grade level.
F & P/
Observations
Qualitative Data
Qualitative
Data
Qualitative data was collected for this portion of research as well. I was able to observe their lack of commitment when it came to reading. This did allow for some open discussions within the classroom as well as with my PLC coach. All of the observations I witnessed, gave me the idea of changing my literacy block and making it more personal. The students needed to find a way to get into a good book, and stay there until it was finished. This is where my readers workshop came to be and started forming my students into lifelong readers.
Winter MAP Data Analysis
Winter MAP
Data
When my students took their MAP Winter Reading Assessment, they struggled. Most of my students did not show growth. The quantitative data helped drive my research question. The 5th grade students should be scoring 209.8 or higher on their MAP Reading Score in the Winter. 8 out of 14 fifth grade students scored below the 50th percentile. My 6th grade students should be scoring 214.2 or higher on their MAP Reading Score in the Winter. 5 out of 7 sixth grade students scored below the 50th percentile. This was shocking because their scores in the fall were much higher. While observing their test taking skills, I could see they were getting very distracted while reading longer passages. Something needed to be done. I was able to compare their MAP scores from the winter to previous years to see the differences that were occurring.
Plickers Analysis & MI Survey
Plickers &
Surveys
Plickers was used when introducing new topics to my students. The different ways to take pre and post assessments helped my students see the importance of learning. When looking at the Plickers data, although there was not a huge jump, the percentage did increase.
Using surveys helped me understand my students better. This allowed me to develop a much easier way for my students to complete projects that were from all aspects of their learning ability. They were able to create a song about their text, draw a postcard, write a poem, or even create an advertisement using their laptops. All of these played an important role in developing my student’s excitement and stamina for reading. Students wanted to pick books that excited them and gave them information to be successful on their weekly projects. Students in my classroom showed a huge interest in music (Musical-Rhythmic), art (Visual-Spatial) and people (Interpersonal) on the survey. The Multiple Intelligence survey gave me an opportunity to really know my students. I would suggest any teacher use this survey to help group their students.
Future Action Plan
In the future, to gauge my students reading stamina, I will begin all of this in the beginning of the school year. I will give my students surveys to figure out the best way they learn. I will develop their growth mindset to show them that anything is possible. I will use data from MAP assessments in the Fall to guide my pacing. I will make sure that I talk to the previous teachers to see what type of texts the students enjoyed. I will make sure to use formative assessments daily to keep them interested in what they are reading. I will also make sure to talk about reading, constantly. Giving my students the chance to develop an understanding of themselves and reading, will in the long run, teach them that reading is important. The reading workshop model will be in place in the beginning of the year. We will start off slow with the specific time that is used to read, and continue reading longer and longer. They will be able to guide themselves through the reading process with me in the back, holding them accountable. Students need to take ownership, and this process will allow them to do just that.
Future
Action Plan
Conclusion
Conclusion &
References
In conclusion, students learn best when they love what they are doing. I had to find a way to get my students to love reading. Their reading stamina was poor. My students would come into my classroom and have no care to read when asked. I noticed when taking tests, their attention levels were nonexistent. I observed that my students had no care for reading when working one on one with them. Their comprehension struggled because they could not focus, which made it difficult to be successful on state assessments but also in our literacy block. We had to find a way to get them interested in reading again.
To do that, I was able to come up with a reading workshop model that really benefited my students. This model gave my students the opportunity to work on their own time within their literacy block. They had many different tasks that they had to complete throughout the week. This kept them focused and into their books daily. Our chats together, individually, allowed me to observe that their understanding of what was being read was increasing, along with the work they were submitting. The first week the students struggled developing grade level appropriate material, but once we looked at their work, they were able to adjust their effort. Seeing my students have happiness in our reading block, gave me hope that this change was needed and necessary. Most students enjoyed the assignments that went along with their reading, which gave them a reason to read their book. An entire class, reading and working silently on their own stuff, showed me that reading in my classroom will never be the same.
References
References
Ardhian, T., Ummah, I., Anafiah, S., & Rachmadtullah, R. (2020). Reading and Critical Thinking Techniques on Understanding Reading Skills for Early Grade Students in Elementary School. International Journal of Instruction, 13(2), 107–118. https://doi.org/10.29333/iji.2020.1328a
Arman, M. (2019). Student-centered approach to teaching English language: Students’ voices & choices. Ahfad Journal, 36(2), 43–50.
Fountas, Irene C.Pinnell, Gay Su. (Eds.) (2007-2008) Fountas and Pinnell benchmark assessment system 1.Portsmouth, NH : Heinemann
Gulla, A. N., & Fink, L. S., R.W.T. (2012). Putting the "Shop" in Reading Workshop: Building Reading Stamina in a Ninth-Grade Literacy Class in a Bronx Vocational High School. English Journal, 101(5), 57-62. Retrieved from https://go.openathens.net/redirector/ace.edu/login?url=https://search.proquest.com/docview/1015602701?accountid=31683
References
References
Snow, C. E. (2013). Cold versus warm close reading: building student’s stamina for struggling with text. Reading Today, 6, 18.
Tichenor, M., Piechura, K., Diedrichs, R., & Heins, E. (2020). Building a Culture of Independent Reading through Literacy Clubs. Reading Improvement, 57(1), 11–15
.
Trainin, G., Hiebert, E. H., & Wilson, K. M. (2015). A Comparison of Reading Rates, Comprehension, and Stamina in Oral and Silent Reading of Fourth-Grade Students. Reading Psychology, 36(7), 595–626.
Reflection
Reflection
When I first start taking this course, I was extremely confused. I understood the importance of doing research, but did not realize as a teacher how much action research I truly did within the classroom. The ability to acknowledge the work and time we put in as teachers on the formation and understanding of data and processes within school is a lot. This course has opened my eyes to a lot of new things. My action research project gave me the ability to think about my practice and find strengths and weaknesses within it. It also allowed me to take a look at data a little differently. Qualitative data is just as important as quantitative data, and this course has shown me that. Reading stamina has always been important in my classroom but to find peer reviewed articles that support the use of a reading workshop to increase those skills is very profound. The CITI courses gave me a huge understanding of what it really means to include others in your data.
When working on my final presentation, I found it useful to use the information that was in my writing. I was able to adjust and pick the most important parts.
T
Reflection Cont.
Reflection Cont.
Being able to have our presentation edited by others helped me look at my presentation a little differently. My presentation did not have color, and that was a suggestion for creativity. Another suggestion was to fix a section of my presentation that was too long. Being able to have our peers look at our work helps, but also it was great to see their pieces of work. To know what they did their research on and to use some of their information in the future for my classroom. RTI and SEL were two things that popped out as being interesting. I think the ability to peer edit our work gives us a chance to broaden our understanding of different action research topics.
Action research used to be something that I truly did not understand. After this course, I have learned many new tools to use in my classroom and I can't wait to start my action research plan again this upcoming school year for reading stamina!
Vytvorte si vlastnú prepracovanú prezentáciu za pár minút. Stačí opísať, čo potrebujete.
Vyskúšajte zadarmo, nie je potrebná kreditná karta