Southwestern University Racial History Project

KV
by Kristine Velez423 views·Updated Sep 10, 2026
Powered by AI

Need to present on this topic?

Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.

Free to try, no credit card required

Transcript

Southwestern University

Racial History

Project

A collaborative project by

  • Saul Zuniga, SU '22 History
  • Kristine Velez, SU '22 Anthropology
  • Melissa Johnson, Professor of Anthropology and Race & Ethnicity Studies, SU

Funded by SCOPE

Assistance from Southwestern U Library Special Collections (Megan Firestone and Haley Bryce)

1

Introduction

Introduction

Our current historical moment: unpacking how racism has shaped us

Why Now?

With the rise of Black Lives Matter and its re-invigoration this summer (2020), there is a clarion call for every institution to undertake a reckoning of its past, in order to try to move toward a more racially just future.

There is a nationwide effort on this front in higher education, with many universities examining their past to understand how wealth generated from enslaved labor funded many institutions (Universities studying slavery).

These efforts have also broadened to focus on better understanding who universities were designed to teach, and the ways that universities have been tied to the racial exclusion and oppression of American Indians, Asian Americans, Mexican Americans and others, from the processes by which these institutions were built, to the curricula they taught, and the students, teachers and administrators they sought out.

Universities Studying Slavery

Universities Studying Slavery and More

Institutions of Higher Education in the US were initially founded by and for slavers.

There is likely no institution founded before the Civil War that was not directly tied to chattel slavery (plantation and otherwise), through funding, and through administrators, faculty members and students owning enslaved people of African descent.

These institutions have thus been fundamental to processes of racialization put into place by people in power (wealthy and educated men of European descent) . These processes generated racial categories that continuously elevated “whiteness” and limited the possibilities (oppressed) of black, indigenous and other people of color. (Wilder 2013, Harris, Campbell and Brophy 2019)

The details vary, and are important, and, if any university wants to truly create an institution that is fully accessible and welcoming to all people, to which any one can feel like they truly belong, that university must understand the specific ways in which its history worked to elevate and center whiteness.

Simply imagine “traditional student” in your head….what picture do you get? (Bahrainwala 2020)

Students in front of Mood-Bridwell Hall on the campus of Southwestern University in 1912. Southwestern University Special Collections

This project makes liberal use of two prior books on Southwestern’s history, which while thorough accounts in many ways, leave out any serious consideration of race (Jones, W 1973; Jones, R 2006). Indeed, the more recent of these includes this comment:

“One of the great voids in the records of Southwestern’s history is a lack of material regarding its institutional policy on race and the racial views of its Curators, Trustees, faculty and students. It is touched on so lightly that one might conclude there was no racial problem. And, indeed, in a sense there was none, African-Americans were not knowingly admitted to Southwestern until the 1960s, and that was that.” Jones 2006, p. 114.

We are not content with the ‘that was that.’ We also understand "race" to include groups beyond African-American, including White, Native American and Mexican American. We understand SU’s connection to processes of racialization to include a whole lot more than the question of which students were allowed to be admitted.

SU histories and race

Positioning the Project in Critical Race Theory

Race and Racialization

Race emerged as an idea, in Europe, from the unfolding of racial capitalism, plantation slavery, Euro-settler colonialism, and indigenous genocide and dispossession. Europeans forcibly removed/ kidnapped African peoples from their home to the shores of the Americas to become chattel slave laborers. Europeans could engage in this violence more easily by casting African peoples to all be the same based on some features of contrast in appearance between Africans and Europeans. In addition as Europeans stole land from indigenous populations of the Americas through the process of settler colonialism, using violence that led to indigenous genocide, it was easier for Europeans to justify this process by seeing indigenous peoples in these lands as fundamentally different and lesser than Europeans. Chattel slavery and indigenous genocide generated race in European thought, and, through global imperial processes, ideas of race spread across the globe.

The Idea of Race

Analyses of human genetics show us that ‘racial’ categories do not describe human genetic variation. Humans do not clump out genetically into a few groups. Who gets placed into what category is a social (political, economic, cultural) process, one that has been called racial formation or racialization. These processes are never fixed or static. Instead racial categories are ever changing and always contested by people who do not benefit from belonging to the category they fall into.

A helpful example of this is that the category ‘white’ was limited to people from northern and western Europe in early 20th C US history. People from Eastern Europe were not understood to be white when they first migrated to the US, As they assimilated, worked to claim whiteness for themselves (by aligning against Black and indigenous people), they ‘became’ white (Painter 2010).

Racial Categories

Racialization and Assemblages

These kinds of shifts—changes in who the dominant order places in what categories-- are common. In addition, what else is associated with these racial categories—the ideas about what kind of person, the legal rights and institutional possibilities for any of these categories--are also always shifting. Michelle Alexander’s analysis of the shifting meaning and legal possibilities for being black in the US—from slave, to secondary citizen to criminal today are a good example of this (Alexander 2020).

This is the kind of approach to race and racialization we are taking with this project—in what ways did Southwestern University’s root colleges contribute to the racial projects that were taking place in Texas in the 1840s-60s. Racial projects at this time were defining what ‘Black’ ‘Indian’ ‘Mexican’ and ‘White’ meant (and the legal and cultural practices these categories entailed), and defining who belonged in which of those categories. These categorizations and definitions were always created by, and served, those in power--the economic, political and intellectual elite.

We use insights from the classic Omi and Winant (2014) racial formation concept, as well as more recent critical race theory. Deleuze and Guattari’s concept of assemblages reminds us of the materiality of race, both in terms of peoples’ bodies and the material items--things, places-- that become associated with different racial categories-in-formation (Saldanha 2006, Weheliye 2014).

2

Historical Context

Historical Context

Politics, Demographics and Religion

Methodism

The history of higher education in Texas is tightly bound with the history of Methodism in Texas

Methodism

The Great Awakenings and Higher Education

National and International Context

The first Universities in the U.S.

Colleges and Universities in the US

Universities established before 1850 in (what would become) the United States were almost always founded as religious institutions. Different protestant denominations (eg Methodist, Presbyterian, Baptist) were behind some of the most well known of these. For example, Princeton University was founded by the Presbyterian Synod as the College of New Jersey in 1746.

Nassau Hall completed; College of New Jersey moves from Newark to Princeton. 1756. https://www.princeton.edu/meet-princeton/history#c1700s

The Great Awakenings

There were successive waves of religious fervor emanating out of Europe in the 18th and 19th centuries. Protestant preachers were inspired to proselytize throughout the British colonial world, and in the new country of the United States, preachers from New England felt compelled to minister to enslaved people in the plantation south, Indians in the Indian territory, and the unsaved on the frontier. John Wesley, the founder of Methodism, was a key figure in the first Great Awakening.

The Great Awakenings

George Whitefield preaching to a crowd, mid 1700s. Photos.com/Thinkstock

The Methodist Church in Texas

Texas

"Itinerant" Preachers of Methodism came to Texas in the early 1800s, excited to bring the word of God to the frontier. When Texas belonged to Spain and then to Mexico, the state support of Catholicism made this challenging. The formation of the Texas Republic ushered in a wave of itinerant preachers, and enabled the establishment of a formal Methodist church in Texas.

The North/South Split

The "Slavery Question"

Importantly, during the era of the Republic, and only 3 years after Rutersville College was founded, the Methodist Episcopal Church in the United States split into Northern and Southern churches over "the slavery question." The Texas delegation to the gathering where this split occurred was itself divided, and the individual who enthusiastically voted for Texas to support slavery and join the Southern church was Littleton Fowler, who is closely tied to Southwestern's root colleges.

Pen sketch and autograph of Littleton Fowler, undated.

A Tennessee native, Littleton Fowler worked as a Methodist minister and college financial agent before volunteering to go to Texas in 1837. Over the next eight years he labored to advance Methodism in the region. He served as a missionary, superintendent of the Texas Mission, presiding elder, and college agent and trustee. Fowler established churches, raised subscriptions for their construction, and designed their buildings. He attended the General Conference in 1844 and the convention that formed the Methodist Episcopal Church, South. Rev. Fowler also farmed and speculated in land.

https://www.smu.edu/Bridwell/SpecialCollectionsandArchives/Exhibitions/EarlyTexas/Fowler

Circuit Riders

The figure of the "itinerant preacher" or "circuit rider" is worth considering. These individuals loom large in the histories of Southwestern's root colleges. Both the memoirs and letters of these preachers, and how they are written about by their contemporaries and early chroniclers of church history, are revealing. Circuit riders are a study in racialization.

These are swashbuckling figures, enduring wind, rain, snow; they ford swollen rivers, risking everything to spread the word of god. They are romantic personages---imagined as, and imagining themselves as, noble and brave and selfless in the service of God. Just the man of god and his horse, galloping across hill and vale to reach the next congregation. A heroic figure, the circuit rider was the epitome of white excellence in the imaginations of European descended middle class people in the US, working at all costs to share enlightenment with those in the dark/those who are darker.

Itinerant Preachers

Illustration from The Circuit Rider: A Tale of the Heroic Age by Edward Eggleston depicting a Methodist circuit rider on horseback.

The church as a race-maker

Norman Spellman, himself a former faculty member at SU, writes "strengthened by able recruits, the Texas Mission grew so rapidly that it was organized as an annual conference in 1840, with 1,878 members (1,648 white and 230 "colored") gathered in three districts, and fourteen circuits served by seventeen preachers" (Spellmann, accessed 2020).

The practice of Methodism in Texas ensured that white /Euro descended people and black/colored/Afro-descended people were kept separate, and unequal. The black congregants always were ministered to second, and only if the circuit rider had time.

Church Membership in 1840

The namesake preachers

SU's Roots

Martin Ruter (Rutersville College) and John W. P. Mckenzie (McKenzie College), both European descended eastern US raised and educated men, were ‘itinerant preachers’ of Methodism in the 1830s, set on doing the "good work" of bringing God's word to the rough and rugged foreign land of Texas that was in so much need of God’s word.

Ruter and Alexander

https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/88241157/robert-alexander

By reprinted in Texas Methodist Historical Quarterly; Cody, C.C., Ed., Georgetown, Texas, 1909, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=83862312

Martin Ruter and his colleagues

Histories of SU always begin with Martin Ruter. Ruter was an illustrious Methodist circuit rider, who had a dream of bringing the word of god, and higher education to the frontier.

Born in 1785 in Massachusetts, Ruter studied in the Northeast (he was connected to the founder of Wesleyan University in Connecticut) and headed westward.

In Texas, Ruter traveled with Robert Alexander, another "itinerant" Methodist preacher. Alexander was much younger and would become one of the most important links connecting Rutersville, Wesleyan College, Soule University, and McKenzie Institute to Southwestern U.. Often traveling with Ruter and Alexander was the aforementioned slavery-supporting Littleton Fowler.

Martin Ruter was excited about the idea of creating an institution of higher learning, connected to the Methodist church, in Texas. He died within a year of arriving in Texas. But in that short time he had convinced and excited enough people that his dream came into fruition shortly after he died.

Robert Alexander, Eliza Ayers Alexander and child

https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/88241150/eliza-perkins-alexander

https://www.smu.edu/Bridwell/SpecialCollectionsandArchives/Exhibitions/EarlyTexas/Fowler

This place and others: A reminder

The Larger Context

  • Globally, the age of revolutions was just a few years ago: France, the US, Haiti
  • The plantation economy fueled by enslaved labor is in full throttle in the US south
  • Andrew Jackson’s Indian Removal Act was just passed, the Trail of Tears was underway.
  • Migration into Texas from Germany
  • There were escalating tensions between the US and Spain----after the Louisiana Purchase; and concerning the fate of “Texas”

1800-1850

Texas until 1850

During this time period three of SU's root colleges were founded (Rutersville, Wesleyan and McKenzie).

This time period also saw four successive government's controlling this land:

  • Spain
  • Mexico
  • Texas Republic
  • United States

Spanish Colonial Texas

Spanish Colonial Texas

Texas belonged to Spain; it was at the northern edge of Spain's colonial holdings. Spain had limited control of the area. The area was home to multiple groups of American Indians and some very northern living Mexicans (who were most commonly of both indigenous American and Spanish ancestry, and sometimes African ancestry, too).

In the late 1700s, this part of the world was an out-of-the way part of Spain’s New World empire. But when the U.S. purchased Louisiana and expanded westward. Spain worked harder to claim this place, encouraging colonization (mostly by mestizos, but including a not insubstantial population of Afro-Mestizos).

The Mission Espada Chapel, in San Antonio, is a well-preserved example of Spanish colonial architecture.

https://study.com/academy/lesson/the-spanish-colonial-era-in-texas-1776-1821.html

Mexican Texas

Mexican Texas

In the meantime, Mexico (including Texas) was working to gain its independence from Spain, and was successful in 1821. Mexico immediately instituted a more liberal and progressive scheme for citizenship and rights for all people (black, indigenous, mestizo) and outlawed slavery (Menchaca 2001; Torget 2015).

Struggling to maintain control of this outpost that was Texas, because of general US expansion, Mexico invited colonization from people in the US. The Mexican government granted land to these Anglo colonists and and looked aside as they brought enslaved people with them, and expanded their ownership of humans over time. Stephen F Austin’s work as an empresario, bringing in the “Original 300” was one group of these colonists. Rutersville College is deeply interconnected with these individuals.

Map of the conjoined state of Coahuila and Texas with major land grants shown in color. Image available on the Internet and included in accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107.

Republic to Annexation to US

Tension over this issue of slavery (among other issues)---and fundamentally over the desire of Anglo/Euro colonists to become wealthy from growing cotton (see Torget 2015) led to Stephen F Austin leading the Texas Revolution against Mexican forces.

The Anglo colonists ended up rising up against the very people who had granted them land only a couple of years earlier and with whom they had multiple economic and political ties. The fighting spread over years. And even though these colonists “won,” and Texas became an independent republic in 1836, Mexico did not give up trying to reclaim this place for the next decade.

Both Texas’ independence as a Republic and these continuing altercations are also tightly tied to Rutersville College.

In 1845, the Republic ended, Texas was annexed to

the US and Rutersville, Wesleyan and Mckenzie Colleges all existed.

The Texas Republic and Annexation to the US

Shifting Demographics

Native Americans, Blacks, Mexicans and Whites

Shifting Demographics

Native Americans

http://www.native-languages.org/texas.htm

Throughout this entire time, the indigenous peoples who lived in Texas, using its lands and waters, but not relating to land as property that could be owned, suffered the increasing presence of Euro (and to a lesser extent Afro-) descended people.

By 1835, with Jackson’s Indian removal act, indigenous peoples from more eastern portions of the US were migrating westward, and some ended up in Texas. For example, there is reference to Lenni Lenape/Delaware people in Smithwick’s memoir (Smithwick 1900) and numerous texts from the time refer to Cherokee, Catto and others.

Groups that appear to have been in Texas since Cabeza de Vaca include the Karankawa, Tonkawa, Waco, Caddo and others. Comanche extended themselves southward during this time, and Lipan Apache used lands in the more western parts of Texas. These groups had long histories of complicated relationships with one another

Spain created a binary between “settled good mission Indians” v. “savage Indians” that carried through to when Texas became part of the U.S., albeit in slightly different form.

Native Americans

Two rough estimations of areas inhabited by different American Indian groups in Texas before the significant spread of white settler colonialism

http://hmsteamtx.weebly.com/uploads/3/8/0/9/38091121/native_texans_map.pdf

Mestizos/Mexicans, Afro-Mestizos, Blacks and Whites

Under the Spanish and Mexican regimes, Texas was populated by mestizos and afro-mestizos. The casta system of racialization was in operation, and in the eastern Texas municipality of Nacogdoches, the racial group that constituted the highest percentage of heads of household in the 1793 census were identified as Afro-mestizo (Menchaca 2001: 117).

Free people of African descent, and runaway enslaved people of African descent also headed to Texas when it belonged to Spain and Mexico; and would travel through Texas to reach Mexico after 1836 (eg Carrigan 1999, Schoen 1937).

Demographically, Anglo people were initially in the small minority, and primarily Euro descended people (Spaniards) were not that much more populous before 1821. With Mexico’s invitation to Anglo settlers from the US, the demographic profile of this place began to change, and the change would become dramatic. The Mexican mestizo population became relatively much smaller, the Anglo population began to explode, and the population of enslaved people of African descent also grew, while the indigenous population dropped as a result of the violence of settler colonialism.

Mestizos, Afro Mestizos, Blacks and Whites

Anacleto Escutia (Mexican, active 1850s), Portrait of Vicente Guerrero; oil on panel. Wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Vicente_Ram%C3%B3n_Guerrero_Salda.

September 15, 1829, Afro-Mestizo Mexican President Vicente Ramon Guerrero issued the Guerrero Decree, prohibiting slavery in most of Mexico

Shifts and Interactions

Demographic Characterization

In the early days of the Republic of Texas, Texas Ranger Noah Smithwick’s (1900) framing is probably on point. He points to a massive influx of white people in the 1830s and 40s, but a still strong presence of Comanches, along with other Native groups identified by name, a not insubstantial population of Mexicans, the presence of both enslaved and free blacks, and routine but not common intermarriages between all of these groups.

Anglos aimed to settle, while indigenous people tried to maintain their ability to survive in their territories (and to maintain access to their sacred lands). But as Anglo populations began to be demographically overwhelming, many Indians moved further westward. While there was no large coordinated uprising of people of African descent, a steady number escaped slavery to Mexico, as the possibilities for citizenship and equality for free black people were cut off by the Texas Republic and its laws, and then by US law after annexation. By the 1840s, Anglos were not the only Euro-descended populations moving into Texas, a growing stream of German immigrants began to move in.

Racialization before 1830

The combination of these demographic shifts and the political, legal and economic shifts between 1810 and 1840 contributed to a solidification of racial categories.

Racialization before 1850

Categories

Processes of racialization filled out the categories in construction: White, Black, Indian and Mexican. By the late 1840s these categories had spatial aspects (some places more associated with one group than another), phenotypical and linguistic aspects (how people looked physically and the language they spoke slotted them into one category or another). For example, people who might have been categorized by tax collectors and census takers as afro-mestizo in 1810 might be Mexican in 1840; the one drop rule that guarded boundaries of whiteness in the United States became increasingly instituted.

Euro descended peoples increasingly used the following terms interchangeably: “negro,” “slave,” “servant” and “black,” (whereas in the 1820s, some free black people were slave owners, for example).

And the European settlers who had at one point recognized the different indigenous peoples as different from one another…Karankawa, Tonkawa (referred to as tonks and kronks by early Anglo settlers (Smithwick 1900)), Waco, Caddo, Comanche, Apache etc.---began to classify all of these different kinds of people as “savage Indians" in their written descriptions.

The Categories

Whose categories?

What is being described here are what can be found in texts that have been written almost exclusively by the Anglo settlers---the racialization processes that are identifiable in these texts are from the Euro/Anglo point of view, the point of view that became codified in the institutions (political, economic, religious, and educational) that these Anglo colonists created, and that came to dominate life in this part of the world.

The African descended people and the different Indian groups certainly had their own takes on these racial categories---but these traces are more difficult to find—and will be for a later project. The Mexican leaders and government also certainly had different understandings of what the Anglo colonist was and the efforts of the Spanish and then Mexican governments to control how Anglo settlers established themselves in Texas was certainly informed by these takes. But the Anglo, or white, racial frame prevailed in the development of institutions here (Feagin 2020).

The Eurocentric Standpoint

Two 1850 Profiles

Texas Population at 1850

US Census Data

According to the U.S. Census in 1850, the total population of Texas was 212,592. The population comprised 154,034 whites, 397 free Negroes, and 58,161 slaves. (US Census, Texas 1850).

The second United States census in 1860 gave Texas a population of 604,215. This included 182,566 slaves and less than 400 free Negroes, and 421, 249 whites (U.S. Census, Texas, 1860).

Indians were not counted, and the national level census data did not ask if whites were Mexican or Anglo. Censuses also likely undercounted generally, and especially undercounted vulnerable populations who wanted to stay out of the view of the state, like free blacks.

US Census Data

Texas Population 1850

study of surnames and urban v. rural

A demographic study

The Civil War and SU's Root Colleges

Two of the root colleges persisted through the US Civil War—McKenzie College folded shortly after the war, and Soule University lasted nearly ten years after the end of the war. Both Rutersville and Wesleyan folded before the war. Nonetheless all of the root colleges have connections to the Civil War. Since the Methodist Church in Texas sided fully with the cause of slavery, the students who attended all of this schools were likely to support the confederacy and sign up to be soldiers. They were also leaders in the confederate army. Texas seceded from the Union a little bit later than other southern states because its Governor, Sam Houston was a Unionist, the legislative conference deposed Houston, and proceeded to secede from the Union in early 1861.

Over 70,000 Texans served in the confederate army, most of them traveling eastward in various regiments to fight in the larger and more significant battles of the war. Some of the most decorated and illustrious regiments had numerous soldiers connected to Southwestern’s root colleges, most were or had been students at Rutersville, Wesleyan, McKenzie and Soule, but trustees, teachers and administrators could also be found in the ranks of the soldiers. Texas did not have many battles, but Soule University served as a confederate hospital for soldiers who needed care. Abraham Lincoln proclaimed emancipation for enslaved peoples in 1863, but Texas did not concede to this until Union troops arrived in 1865. The collapse of plantation slavery and the loss of revenue that slavers experienced arguably led to the demise of Mckenzie College, and exacerbated troubles at Soule University.

The Civil War

3

Four Institutions

Before Southwestern, the four root colleges were spread throughout the eastern half of Texas for different spans of time

These institutions were united through charters with the Texas Methodist Church, and Texas Methodist Church leaders like Robert Alexander

We focus on three of them

The Root Colleges

Robert Alexander

Rutersville College

Rutersville, Fayette County, Texas

1841-1856

Included both a preparatory school and a college

Awarded a total of 32 degrees

Enrolled 100s/year.

Eg 1844-45 had 194 students enrolled.

Rutersville College

McKenzie College

McKenzie College

Clarksville, Red River County, Texas

Begun and run by John W. P. Mckenzie, Methodist preacher

1841-1868

Enrolled a large number of students; for example, in 1854 it had 300 boarding students.

Included both a preparatory school and a college

The college was a plantation.

Dormitories at Mckenzie College

By Southwestern University Special Collections - http://www.southwestern.edu/library/how-we-remember/root-institutions/McKenzierevised.htm, PD-US, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?curid=24943100

Wesleyan College

San Augustine, San Augustine County , Texas

1844-1847

Maintained relatively small enrollments

Least significant in SU's history

Wesleyan College

Sketch of Wesleyan College. Courtesy of Southwestern University. Image available on the Internet and included in accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107.

Soule University

Chappell Hill, Washington County, Texas

1855-1875 (when charter moved to Southwestern)/1887 (when Soule closed)

Enrolled about 170 students per year at its hey day

But only 8 college graduates before 1862

Soule University

Main Building of Soule University, Southwestern University Special Collections

4

Rutersville College:

The Deepest Root

Rutersville

College

The main building of Rutersville College, circa 1841.

Southwestern University Library Special Collections

Creating the Town

By 1839, a group of Anglo men inspired by Ruter and his dreams of Methodism and higher education in Texas, created the Rutersville company. Their aim was twofold---1. to create a ‘godly’ town---and 2. to put an institution of higher education/secondary education in this town, to be the first such institution in Texas (Jones 1973: 39-40).

To make this happen would require land. Here we are in the newly minted Texas Republic---where the “Original 300” and others owned leagues of land given to them by Mexico, when the Mexican government encouraged this colonization.

Once the town was created and land set aside for the college, the men of the Rutersville Company identified a president, teachers, funders and students to bring the institution of Rutersville College into being.

Rutersville: The Town

John Rabb

John Rabb

John Rabb, land donor

It was indeed one of these "original 300" that provided a large lease of land that brought Rutersville into being: John Rabb (Jones 1973)

Rabb was a successful planter, who also had one of the earliest gins in the republic (Anonymous 2020). Like most colonists he had come with family, likely all of them aspiring slave-owners. And, indeed by 1845, John Rabb himself owned slaves (Tax Rolls for Fayette County, 1845). He planted a large area of lowlands along the Colorado River near the newly minted town of Rutersville.

http://thetexasunderground.blogspot.com/2014/06/john-rabb-1798-1861.html

Rabb's Prairie on the Colorado River, July 2020

Ideas of Morality

Doctors, preachers and others constituted the other members of Rutersville Company. Most would be on record as owning enslaved people of African descent by 1850. Once they had secured the land from Rabb, they founded the town of Rutersville and invited white settlers to join them. But anyone who wanted a lot in Rutersville had to pledge to not have any intoxicants on their property in the town, and to forfeit their ownership should they do so. It was meant to be a ‘temperate’ place for only people of ‘fine character' (Jones 1973: 39-40). Fine character seems to have been enhanced by owning enslaved people, hunting and killing Indians, and fighting Mexicans, from what is revealed by their biographies and how they are praised by contemporaries.

Codes of Morality

Rutersville's Connection to Slavery

Slavery and the People of Rutersville College

Almost all of what I have shared above, except perhaps the specific information that the Rabb family was a family of slavers, is widely available; and the history of Rutersville College has been described many times (in addition to Jones 1973 and Jones 2006, see Sinks 1898)

What the remainder of this discussion of SU's first college will show are more details about the people closely connected to Rutersville, as well as some anecdotes about the place of Rutersville, and the life of circuit riders in Central Texas from the primary literature that point to how racial categories began to consolidate at this point in time in this place, and how Rutersville College contributed to that process.

Members of the Rutersville Company

Rutersville Company

The Rutersville Company members consisted of ten members (gleaned from Sinks 1898 and Jones 1973).

Of the 4 for whom there are records, 3 own slaves at some point between 1837 and 1850

Trustees and Administrators

Of the 18 for whom there are records, 9 were slave owners sometime between 1837 and 1850

Trustees and Administrators

Donors of land, of cash (and pledged ‘subscriptions’)

Donors

Of the 36 for whom there are records in the Texas County Tax Rolls (from 1837-1860), 1850 Slave Census, and information on individuals from Texas State Historical Association articles, 23 were slaveholders.

These individuals also were are disproportionately large-scale slave owners compared to the other categories of people. Note that among the funders are some of the largest owners of enslaved people in Texas’ history, for example the son of Jared Groce (Curlee 1922)

Depiction, Jared E. Groce, an early American colonist of Texas and owner of Bernardo Plantation. Image available on the Internet and included in accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107.

Teachers

Teachers

Teacher Ann Catherine Goodwin Haynie was married to James Asbury Haynie (son of Rutersville agent the Reverend John Haynie). Ann and James together owed about 7 enslaved people, most teachers typically owned 1 or 2. Ann typically owned between 1 and 2 over that time period; her husband James owned 6 in most years.

James son John was a decorated confederate soldier.

Of the 9 instructors for whom we have found records, 6 were slave-owners (sometime between 1837 and 1850)

Students as owners of enslaved people

Students

Of the 38 male students for whom I (MJ) have found records, 17 were slave-owners, or lived in slave-owning families (slave-owning between 1837 and 1850). (students and their parental support are lListed in Rutersville College Catalogue).

Of the 16 female students for whom I have found records, 13 were slave-owners or lived in slave-owning families. These numbers suggest that women who attended Rutersville, on average were wealthier than the men.

What this tells us: Euro-descended people who administered, taught at, studied at and funded this first institution of higher learning in Texas often owned people of African descent. And the trajectories of ownership suggest that most Euro-descended people wanted to own people, and aimed to become wealthy enough to do so. To be a "gentleman" (or "gentlewoman") meant owning an enslaved person of African descent.

Rutersville College and chattel slavery were closely intertwined. Indeed, Rutersville College could not have come into being without the money that enslaved Africans generated for the donors and trustees of this college.

What all of this Means

Consolidation of Racial Categories

Processes of Racialization

Racial Formations: The Consolidation of Racial Categories

Blackness: From the viewpoint of Rutersville College

Blackness

Invisibilization

The most notable aspect of blackness in the records, memoirs, letters and historical accounts that feature or are connected to Rutersville College is the absence of mention. Although there were always people of African descent in and around Rutersville, and in the groups that the circuit riders and others encountered as they moved through Texas; they are not often mentioned—they are invisibilized.

African descended people were present in Texas, and indeed as noted above, there were free blacks in Texas. In addition, enslaved African descended people escaped bondage by moving through Texas to get to Mexico (Carrigan 1999). And these people lived and traveled through despite the efforts of the Texas Republic to make blackness and freedom an impossible connection.

Rutersville and African-descended peoples

Rutersville & Blackness

Rutersville

Spellmann’s account of the history of Methodism notes numbers of members of the Methodist church in 1840, under Ruter’s efforts: “the Texas Mission grew so rapidly that it was organized as an annual conference in 1840, with 1,878 members (1,648 white and 230 “colored”) gathered in three districts, and fourteen circuits served by seventeen preachers” (Spellmann accessed 2020).

In 1847, the Methodist church claimed 138 white members living in Rutersville and 29 colored members (Phelan 1924: 294). Over 20% of church members were Black, but there is very little mention of them in any documentation, other than this reporting of numbers. This is because, even if any free Blacks were among these, it was UNIMAGINABLE to the men of Rutersville Company, to Martin Ruter, to the other founders of the College, that an African-descended person could be a student at Rutersville or could become an educated leader on par with the Rutersville students.

Founding the College and Erasing Freedom

The Honorable Francis Moore was an interesting figure in the history of Rutersville College. He was a leading legislator in the Texas Republic (Benham, accessed 2020), and served as an early trustee of Rutersville College. He introduced the legislation that certified Rutersville College as an institution of higher education in Texas, and it was his pre-eminence and his excitement about the College that ensured a smooth approval by the Texas legislature.

But, Moore also is known for his work introducing legislation that made it impossible for free blacks to submit petitions to the Texas Republic’s government (Schoen 1937, p. 84). Free blacks in the US (a foreign country to Texas) routinely used petitioning to try to claim citizenship rights, and white slave-owning state legislatures often tried to block these, while some advocates worked to create legislation to make such petitions possible (see Jones 2018). Moore than can be understood as making it impossible for a free black person to have any legal rights in Texas, stripping away “freedom.”

The "Honorable" Francis Moore

Drawing, Portrait of Francis Moore, Jr. Image available on the Internet and included in accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107. https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/moore-francis-jr

A story shared in Phelan's comprehensive history of early Methodism in Texas.

"The Copper-Colored Negro"

Important to note that Robert Alexander, the man who ties all of SU's root colleges together was one of the team of preachers traveling and working together when this incident occurred. Robert Alexander closed out this day's sermon.

The story teller was the Baptist minister was Z. Morell and the incident took place in 1838 in Washington, Texas.

1838. Washington, Texas. There was a ‘grocery’ (in the middle of town about halfway between Morrell’s residence and a house of worship on the other side of town.

On typical Sundays the preachers would preach in the church, and others would gather in the grocery and hold a mockery of the preaching. Prayer meetings were usually held at the house of worship, but at this particular time a group of preachers from different denominations planned to hold a multi-day meeting, and chose a billiard house with a “long gallery in front” in the middle of town to hold their meeting.

On the second night of the meeting, there were “loafers and gamblers” as well as citizens according to Morrell, and the usual crowd that disturbed the peace during Sunday worship were there.

Setting the Scene

The Story

Morrell recounts:

“A man was stationed outside of the house, just behind where the preacher stood with a hen in his arms. While the preacher was lining out his hymn he would hold the chicken by the neck. When the congregation would sing he would make it squall.

A large copper-colored negro man was stationed on the gallery in front with some twenty or more these lewd fellows around him, partly intoxicated. When the congregation sang and the hen squalled, the negro, acting under orders, would put his hand in at the window and shout at the top of his voice “Glory to God!” The response from outside was given “Amen and Amen”

I was sitting nearby by the window from whence the disturbance came. My wife and daughter were nearby me. I arose and stood by the window with the walking cane in my hand that I had brought back from Tennessee, made of hickory, with a buck-horn head. My bosom heaved with holy indignation, and as the negro put his head into the window the second time, and as the congregation sang and the hen squalled,

I struck him just above the left eye, making a scar that he carried to his grave…….After the stroke with the cane they were peremptorily ordered away with the statement that there were more dangerous weapons behind. …The sermon was preached by Mr. Roark; Mr. Alexander closed" (Phelan 1924 pp. 99-100).

What this story tell us

Take Aways

Phelan relates this story approvingly. It is included as one of a number of ‘colorful’ small stories—interludes in his recounting of the efforts of earnest circuit riders to expand Methodism in Texas. The “bosom heaving with holy indignation” phrase is telling. The preacher’s ire is not directed towards the engineers of this amusing mockery of the sermon—very likely whites directing this from the outside, but it is the combination of mockery happening and, critically, the imposition of blackness into the white space of the church. The preacher felt fully justified, dignified in the eyes of God, even, in permanently maiming this “copper colored negro's" face.

The dehumanization of blackness that Morrell’s celebration of this event entails is remarkable. As is Phelan’s inclusion of it. It is worth taking a moment to imagine if it had been of the young white male students at Rutersville College engaging in this kind of joking and poking fun---would Morrell have felt so justified in beating such a person with his cane, and creating a scar for life?

Enslaver Hayden

The story of Gerard Hayden, who was a student in 1842 (but according to a newspaper article originally from Maryland), is revealing of the relationship between Rutersville College student whiteness and blackness. Hayden was murdered in 1850 by two of the enslaved African descended people he owned, according to newspaper reports. The story was so interesting that it appeared in a number of different newspapers across the Untied States shorty after it happened.

The “negros” (and the communicating of this story reveals the interchangeability of the words “negro” “slave” and “black”) knocked him on the head with a maul, and dragged him to burn him on a fire, when he did not die, they dragged him to a camp made of plank and burned him up. The two men confessed to the crime. The newspaper article quotes them as saying he was kind and never whipped them; but the articles also note that Hayden “dragged four negroes” to “that county” (Fayette) about a year before the murder and that the negroes “had been grumbling ever since” (Monmouth Democrat 9 May 1850; Daily Nashville Union 4 May 1850).

When Hayden was listed as a student in the second year of Rutersville College’s existence, he was also listed in the Fayette County Tax Rolls as owning one slave. This story makes clear that the Rutersville students were not benign slave owners. That Hayden was beaten with a maul, burned alive some and then carried to be burned to death, suggests that he was cruel. His murderers took this great chance, knowing that they were likely to be hanged for this crime. This story ruptures the popular story that White Texans like to tell of “benign” slaver/enslaved relationships.

The Demise of Gerard Hayden

The original inhabitants

Indianness

Heterogeneity

In the earliest accounts that Euro-descended people wrote about this part of the world, the differences between the indigenous groups of Texas was recognized and described. There was indeed interaction of all different types between the different kinds of people who lived in this place.

Contrasting early Texas Ranger Noah Smithwick’s account of his life in Texas among less religious and educated peoples with the memoirs and letters of those connected to Rutersville demonstrates a tendency that develops over time in Euro accounts of Texas. Euro/Anglo understandings of indigenous peoples flatten all American Indians into one group, seen as savage, dangerous and not fully human.

Smithwick includes detailed ethnographic description of different tribal and linguistic groups, and even notes differences within tribal/linguistic groups depending on where people lived. He also refers to a variety of families who are made of people marrying across racial/ethnic lines; and he himself lived among the Comanche for a while (Smithwich 1900). The men and boys of Ruterville will describe a different set of experiences and understandings.

The early Frontier

A group of Tonkawa Indians in 1898.

Photo: the Tonkawa Tribe of Oklahoma

White Settler Colonialism: From Paper to Practice

For example, John Rabb, the early donor for the town and college recollects his life in a memoir. He states that in 1824, after he had claimed and attempted to settle on those rich fertile lands along the Colorado River that are today known in Euro Texas as “Rabb’s Prairie), he was “driven by the Indians from the Colorado River to the Brazos, and compelled to remain there one year before I returned” (Phelan 1924: 35).

Martin Ruter writes in 1839, “In coming to this place we passed through a part of the country not inhabited, but occasionally infested by Indian robbers who come on horseback from the north (travelling either by night or in the forest), for the purpose of stealing horses and murdering and plundering the travellers whom they find unarmed” (as shared in Phelan 1924 on p 84). The idea that “Indians” were “robbing” the land-thieving white settlers is remarkable.

John Haynie, agent for the college, and whose children are tied to Rutersville and Soule, writes of his experiences in 1840. He was in his 50s, living in Austin, and within a year or two his son and daughter in law would be settled in at Rutersville. “The Indians were quite troublesome this year on my circuit. They were frequently before me and behind, within a few hours, killing the people, stealing their horses. I frequently saw their tracks in my path….In the Spring when I was home, the Indians went down and stole all my horses and lefts us with only the horse I ride” (Phelan 1924: 125). Again, Indians are lumped in as one people, and the theft of land and livelihood that Anglo settlement was causing was invisible to these pious Methodists.

White Settler Colonialism

The establishment of Rutersville College depended upon land grants. These are initially Spanish and Mexican white settler incursions into indigenous lands. But because Texas was on the margins, these initial grants often existed more on paper than in practice. But by the 1830s, and as the town of Rutersville was created, the land under Rutersville and lands elsewhere that contributed to Rutersville development were no longer only paper claims.

They were now occupied by Anglo settlers and planted with cotton and other crops, white settlers fully colonized these lands, thieving them from the different Indian groups who had used them in the past. The Indians who were displaced were unsurprisingly not pleased, and the many memoirs, letters and accounts of the circuit rider and early settlers connected to Rutersville, are peppered with stories of the reprisals of Indian groups, with the name of the group often left out.

Indian Hunting as Rutersville Practice

The Texas Rangers fighting Iron Jacket, a Comanche chief. Image available on the Internet and included in accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107.

The genesis of this project –looking into SU’s racial history---was in part motivated by a brief comment in Clara Scarborough’s award winning public history of Williamson County, Land of Good Water. In it she notes: “It was said that the boys who enrolled at Rutersville did little but hunt Indians prior to 1842” (Scarborough 1973: 135).

This comment comes from reports of what followed when two Rutersville students, Henry and Fields Earthman who were out “hunting horses” (Jones 1973: 33) were attacked by “Indians” shortly after the school opened in 1840, one of them died, the other escaped back to the school. The Rutersville boys spent the better part of the next three weeks in pursuit of the “Indians,” and one of these students claimed later as an adult that “they did little but hunt Indians while at school at Rutersville prior to 1842” (Jones 1973: 33; Looscan 1898: 656).

Rutersville and Indian Hunting

Trustees, Donors, Parents

https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/8742232/george-washington-barnett#view-photo=105483968

It was not only students who were interested in killing “Indians.” Both Trustees and donors have leading raids against Indians as important, and positive, elements of their biographies.

For example, Trustee G. W. Barnett served as a captain of “one of four volunteer companies under Colonel John Henry Moore, organized to attack the Tawakoni Indians in 1835 (Kemp accessed 2020).

John Murchison a donor and parent of a student participated in the battle of Kickapoo, in which a group of Anglo colonist/Texas Republicans fought a group of about 900 Indians and Mexicans who were part of the Cordova Rebellion (Largent accessed 2020).

And, donor Bartlett Sims was captain of a company sent on an expedition against the Waco and Tawakoni in 1826 (Hazlewood accessed 2020).

The take away here is that repelling and killing “Indians”—and seeing all Native Americans as singular Indians, as savage, as enemies was a central piece of the identity of many Rutersville connected men.

Donors and Leading Attacks on "Indians"

This place was Mexico, it became Texas just before Rutersville was established, and Mexico tried to win it back

Mexicanness

In general, students and teachers of Rutersville were very committed to the Texas’ republic’s cause and understood themselves as Texas Republicans opposed to Mexico. The Rutersville students and the men in their families heeded every call to arms against the not infrequent Mexican incursions. Although the Republic had claimed it won the Texas Revolution, and that it was an independent republic, Mexico continued to try to retake the Republic.

Not much more than a year after Rutersville was founded, in 1842, the Mexican Army captured San Antonio, and all the Rutersville students, white young men over the age of 15 took arms and “hurried to the standard of the Lone Star.” No men remained ”and even ten females left” (Jones 2006: 17). But this identification with the Texas Republic and against Mexico, and Mexicans, was not uncomplicated, as the story of the Hill family reveals.

Asa Hill, his family and Jose Mendes

Asa Hill and Joseph Mendez

Asa Hill was one of the first settlers in Rutersville, and he enrolled himself and two of his sons John Christopher Columbus Hill and James Monroe Hill in Rutersville College when it began.

In the years prior Monroe Hill had served the Texas Republic in the battle of San Jacinto, and from that battle is the story of a young man who was also enrolled in Rutersville College in its first year of operation: Jose Maria Mendes, listed as Joseph Mendes in the school’s first catalog (Sinks 1898).

According to Sinks, who spoke personally with Monroe Hill towards the end of his life, Mendes was a “Mexican fifer boy” that Monroe had captured at San Jacinto. Sinks continues, “Mendez was offered permission to return to Mexico he chose, but he preferred to remain in Texas rather than be forced into the Mexican army again, which he feared would be the result if he went home. He lived with the family of Mr. Asa Hill, Monroe Hill's father.” He is only listed as a student at Rutersville in that first year, and Monroe Hill told Sinks that after living with Monroe’s father’s family, Mendes became a silversmith in Houston, where he died of yellow fever sometime in the late 40s.”

https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/29995597/james-monroe-hill#view-photo=85973765

John Christopher Columbus Hill/

Juan Cristobal Gil

The story of John Hill shows that boundaries between Anglo Texan and Mexican were fluid in practice than the rhetoric of the written record reveals

The Unlikely Story of John Christopher Columbus Hill

John Christopher Columbus Hill

Juan Cristobal Gil

https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/169944905/john-christopher_columbus-hill

When Mexico captured San Antonio in 1842, Asa, John Christopher Columbus and his brother Jeffrey Barksdale Hill all went to fight for Texas (Asa and John were among the Rutersville men who “took up arms”).

Earlier that year, Monroe had joined a volunteer company in response to the Adrian Woll invasion. According to a biography of Monroe Hill posted on the find-a-grave site, before John Christopher Columbus Hill left for the Rio Grande, Monroe gave him a “a new rifle telling him ‘never to surrender it to a Mexican.’

John, Jeffery and their father Asa joined the Somervell expedition to the Rio Grande and joined the forces who chose not to follow Somervell’s commands to disband and return home because they were so far outnumbered. The privateer-led soldiers who continued on to Ciudad Mier fought the Mexican forces, but lost and were captured and then marched to Mexico City as prisoners of war. The commander Domingo Huerta moved them to El Rancho Salado and there famously had the prisoners choose from a container of beans. If the prisoner chose a black bean, he would be executed, a white bean he would be spared.

Asa Hill drew a white bean, and he and his sons, who were not adults yet remained as prisoners. Jeffrey had been injured in the fighting, and John Christopher Columbus made repeated, and ultimately successful, appeals to get his father and brother released in 1843.

The Capture of San Antonio and the Mier Expedition

Mier Expedition Descending the Rio Grande. After separating from Somervell's command near Guererro, Captain William S. Fisher and a force of slightly more than three hundred men followed the course of the river en route to Ciudad Mier.

https://www.shsu.edu/~his_rtc/MierText.htm

Juan C. Gil, a leading Mexican

El Colegio de Mineria

This is where the story becomes interesting. John Christopher Columbus Hill, who was only fourteen at the time, had so impressed the Mexican general Pedro Ampudia, that Ampudia sent Hill “under special escort to President Antonio Lopez de Sana Anna.”

The Mexican leadership were so impressed with Hill that “they encouraged him to remain in Mexico,” and he agreed to do so if they released his father and brother. Hill remained in Mexico, attended the Colegio de Mineria, graduating with distinction in 1851.

He changed his name to Juan Cristobal Gil, married a Mexican woman, Augustina Segrado, had four children and had a successful career serving as a both a technical expert under Porfirio Diaz, and as a practicing physician. He maintained close contact with his relatives and friends in Texas, visiting there regularly, and sent his son Carlos to Swarthmore College in Pennsylvania. After more than 35 years in Mexico, and after his wife died in 1891, he returned to Texas and “married the sweetheart of his youth.” He died in Monterrey in 1904 (Blanton accessed 2020 and Jones 2006: 17-18).

John to Juan

https://www.ingenieria.unam.mx/EN/history.php

Anglo Texans on Mexicans

The Typical Rhetoric of Anglo Texans about Mexicans

Monroe Hill’s comment to his brother, never surrender his gun to a Mexican reveals the general attitude that Anglo settlers in the Texas Republic had toward Mexicans. Gone were the friendly relations that characterized Stephen F. Austin’s first entreaties to Mexico when he sought land in this country. As the revolution began to take shape and throughout the days of the Republic, Anglo attitudes to Mexicans soured, and this souring began to be encoded in laws and policies of the Republic that dis-enfranchised Mexican people from lands they had long been given (Menchaca 1999).

An orientation that sees Mexicans as “other” and lesser can be found throughout accounts of circuit riders and others tied to Methodism in Texas. For example, David Ayres, circuit rider, Rutersville supporter and parent, who moved to Texas in 1834 from New York, writes about his travels through Texas in that year. Ayres described the settlement at San Patricio: “the settlement was composed of Mexicans and Irish Roman Catholics—all, or nearly all, were very ignorant” (Phelan 1924: 55). Eight years later in 1842, President Lamar, a strong supporter of Rutersville, and methodism more generally, describes a stockade near Austin “would keep out pigs, but it would not turn Mexicans or Indians” (Phelan 1924: 259). Mexicans and Indians are often cast together, the two enemy forces that the Anglo settlers face; and while Indians are seen as savage, Mexicans are cast as cruel—with the depradations of Santa Ana standing in for Mexicans as a whole. For the Methodists of Rutersville, the religious difference, and Mexicans’ commitment to Catholicism only makes that difference less bridge-able.

This is a drawing of the Alamo Mission in San Antonio. It was first printed in 1854 in Gleason's Pictorial Drawing Room Companion and was reprinted in Frank Thompson's 2005 "The Alamo", p 106

By Unknown author - Frank Thompson, The Alamo (2005), p. 106, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=4934888

The unmarked category

https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/jones-john-b

https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/47590319/_

Whiteness

Some of the white educated Methodist men connected to Rutersville.

Martin Ruter, Robert Alexander, David Ayers, Francis Moore Jr, Capgt GW Barnett, John Haynie, Monroe Hill, John CC Hil,, John B. Jones, Alexander Thomson. John Rabb [Other photo credits elsewhere in presentation)

All of the accounts so far shared are written from an imagined “neutral” point of view (Mignolo 2009); from the standpoint of the white, and most often Methodist, educated men who are writing the letters, memoirs, and accounts that show up in both primary and secondary documents and on the highway marker signs.

From the point of view of these white middle class educated Methodist men, whiteness is everything that the other racial categories are not. For example in the simplest terms, for these men, black as slave and insignificant and brutish means white is free, significant and civilized; Indian as savage and wild and not fully human means white is controlled and refined and fully human, Mexican as cruel and ignorant and worshiping incorrectly means that white (and Methodist) is kind and wise and most godly.

Viscous whiteness

Sticky Social Circles & Dispositions

For example, John Rabb (one of the members of the Rutersville Company) married a Crownover. Both Rabbs and Crownovers are enrolled students.

David Ayres daughter married Robert Alexander, the Methodist preacher who ties all of these colleges to Southwestern.

Rabb joined three of David Ayres children (who would be students enrolled at Rutersville) in being converted at a camp meeting at Caney Creek in 1837 (Phelan 1924: 73).

And, at a Caney Creek event in 1834, Lydia McHenry, John Rabb, John Crownover and Thomas Bell, all either instructors, trustees or students at Rutersville were all converted (Phelan 1924 p: 40).

Students married one another, for example Monroe Hill married Jane Kerr. Children of Rutersville students attended Mckenzie Institute and Soule University. These tight social circles helped to consolidate whiteness.

Furthermore, whiteness consolidates, or in Saldanha’s words, echoing Deleuze and Guatarri, becomes viscous (Saldanha 2006, 2007). White people stick together, and their whiteness gets stickier as they do so. These early Methodists tied to Rutersville did just that. The families of students (and to some extent administrators and instructors) were interconnected; and intermarriage between them was not uncommon. They constituted a social circle and encountered one another at Methodist camp meetings throughout the area.

It was literally unimaginable to have a black or native American attend Rutersville College, even though black and native people lived throughout the area. And the one instance of a Mexican student enrolling is for at the most for a year.

Additionally, whiteness assembled with a set of dispositions and values in these early days of Rutersville. The aspirations for a particular type of morality---refrain from drink, from crude language, sexual chasteness and attending church meetings—also associated itself with this group of people. The founders and first sets of students at Rutersville valued a particular genteel respectability grounded in European modes of being. The very act of emphasizing the importance of higher education, of aiming to strengthen white settler presence in Texas through these kinds of religiously affiliated and morally specific institutions and cultural developments attaches these dispositions to Whiteness.

Rutersville as a Racial Assemblage

Concluding Thoughts: Rutersville as Racial Assemblage

Fundamentally, Rutersville College was built by white wealthy or middle class educated Methodist men for middle class educated men. The desired white Methodist students enrolled, and these men worked together to establish this college.

Meanwhile, this part of Texas was home to plantation slavery and the presence of significant numbers of enslaved people of African descent who shared dark skin and some other phenotypic features, and who were forced to speak English (but who also created a shared language across the different linguistic groups that had come from West Africa, a language that would change through time but come to be called African American English Vernacular).

This part of Texas was also inhabited by “Indians,” most of whom did not take kindly to white settler colonialism, and who themselves did not have the pale skin, thin hair, face shapes and blue eyes of the Anglo settlers, but instead had brown skin, and thick dark hair, and who varied by language, culture dress and facial physiognomy.

And this place, which had just been Mexico a few years before was also home to brown skinned, brown eyed Spanish speaking Catholic Mexicans.

The establishment of Rutersville College, through its funding from slavery, its slave-owning participants, the “Indian attacking” of its leading figures, and the readiness of its students and faculty to take up arms against Mexico, contributed to the consolidation of whiteness in Texas, and to the racializing assemblages that link property and political power to pale skin.

The people connected to Rutersville

Copy this link and paste in your browser!

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1oDmuX3zVG0CA7i4PENy7zDdnoIlRyv3Pbm90laQKrCU/edit?usp=sharing

Database of People

Future Research

There are a host more questions that could be asked about Rutersville College, and our team was limited to some extent by what we could do by the pandemic: we had no access to the materials held in other archives (like UT, SMU and other institutions). Fortunately there was enough digitization of historical materials for us to produce what we have. It would have been interesting to look at the curricular materials, and documentation of student debating societies and other student activities at the time (especially when the split over slavery occurred in the Methodist Church). We did not have time to take a detailed look at the full set of letters and memoirs of individuals like John Rabb, or Chauncey Richardson, or Robert Alexander, for example, where commentary about different kinds of people might have been located.

Additionally, piecing together a more detailed social history of the town of Rutersville itself would be interesting. There were Black people in Rutersville Methodist congregations, were there Native American or Mexican people in the area as well, beyond Jose Mendes? What were the experiences of these people? Because the vast majority of historical materials were written by white men, and occasionally white women, it is difficult to find the traces of Black and Brown people in these materials; but those traces likely exist, and an important next step in this project would be to find those and document what Rutersville College was from their perspective.

Future Research

5

McKenzie College

McKenzie College

Overview:

  • McKenzie Institute/College was one of S.U.’s Root Colleges
  • Located in Red River County (1841-1868)
  • Its history illustrates aspects of racialization and its role in the 20 year success of this independent institution

Red River County

Red River County (RRC)

Time Period: 1839-1868

  • During Texas’ transition into Statehood.
  • Clarksville; aka- “The Gateway to Texas” ¹
  • The Antebellum South ²

Land Acknowledgment: Caddo, Cherokee, Chickasaw, Comanche, and Shawnee.³

"Gateway to Texas"

1

Clarksville was given this name to indicate American Settlers crossing the Red River as a primary route entering into Texas.

*Many influential historical figures to American and Texan History passed through the region. This includes Sam Houston and David Crockett.

Texas Trivia

General Sam Houston signed the Charter for Clarksville to be integrated into Red River County.

Texas Trivia

The Antebellum South

2

  • A 15 year period (1846-1861) where the “economy, [was] dependent on agriculture, [which] was concentrated first on subsistence farming and herding and then on production of cotton as a cash crop” (Campbell, TSHAOnline, Para.2)
  • The primary source of physical labor was through Chattel Slavery
  • Black/Mulatto/Indigenous populations were used (and viewed) as property for this system of oppression

Tensions with Indigenous Populations

3

Tensions continued to rise between Indigenous Populations and American (Euro-descended) Settlers; the causation was the ownership over land. (... like always...)

Settlers would describe the battles as “Indian Raids” on “American Soil”

**This is problematic seeing as to how Native Peoples of the region were being grouped into one large label as "Indian" while simultaneously having their land stripped from them.**

Reverend John Witherspoon Pettigrew McKenzie

Rev. John W.P. McKenzie

  • Former teacher/Principal¹
  • Admitted into the Tennessee Conference of the Methodist Episcopal Church in 1836 as an Itinerant preacher²
  • He and his wife, Matilda, were then transferred to the Arkansas Conference to become missionaries to the Choctaw people near the Texas Frontier.³
  • In 1839, he and his wife were assigned to the Clarksville Circuit

History in Education

1

  • Served as Principal of Georgia’s Gainesville Academy for a year.
  • Became the head of his own school for 5 years in Tennessee before going into the ministry.

What Is An Itinerant Preacher?

Traveling Christian Evangelists who preached the gospel of Christianity.

Methodism was known to begin using Circuit Riders in the early 1800s.

2

Interactions with the Choctaw Nation

3

McKenzie and his wife were missionaries for the Choctaw; utilizing Methodist teachings.

The Choctaw, just recently experiencing the Tear of Tears, continued to be harassed and abused by American settlers.

McKenzie sympathized for the Choctaw and became an advocate against the demoralizing treatment. (Though he did not viewed them as equals in society.)

**This caused turmoil within the local community and McKenzie was faced with threats. His outward appearance (whiteness and stature/build) is what kept him from being harmed.**

Matilda McKenzie

Matilda McKenzie

Matilda McKenzie, Rev. McKenzie’s wife, is rarely mentioned throughout history or any archival documents that we were able to obtain.

Note that she held a great influence with her own interactions with the Choctaw Nation.

This includes being the head teacher of the first school opened exclusively to women in the Choctaw Nation in “Indian” Territory - now known as Oklahoma.

Insights

Insights

This is a prime example of gender biases throughout history (this specific time period) and shows who was deemed “worthy” of having their histories documented.

Matilda’s race, as a white woman, DID contribute to her being acknowledged for her work - even if only in a handful of accounts.

American History is written in a way that highlights the voices of White Christian Men with an Elite Social Status, while ignoring those with lesser social standings.

**Something I would like to have been able to find more of was the experiences/stories of individuals who were silenced at the time - that being Black, Indigenous, and Mexican Populations in the region.

Having a written record of their experiences would aid in gaining a deeper understanding of what life was like during Southern Antebellum Society and the Civil War.**

Development of the Institution

Development of the Institution

  • After being assigned to the Clarksville Circuit, McKenzie purchased ~421 acres of land in RRC in 1839; naming it Itinerant Retreat. ¹
  • 2 years later, with declining health, due to living conditions during travel, McKenzie chose to retire from the circuit. He also had a growing desire to return to teaching.
  • In 1841, McKenzie Institute was created. ²
  • Utilization of land:
  • John W.P. McKenzie’s personal residence
  • Institutional operations (campus/ student residence) ³
  • A plantation to supplement the needs of the Institution
  • cotton was never grown on the plantation and majority of the crops/livestock were designated towards student body/ faculty sustenance. The profits from anything sold at market went right back into funding the daily operations of the Institution.

Itinerant Retreat

1

Located 3 miles outside of Clarksville, TX

'Itinerant Retreat' is translated by the Methodists as 'The Haven of the Traveling Preacher'.

Starting the institution was McKenzie’s way of continuing his commitment to Methodism and to God after leaving the circuit. Therefore, naming the property to be affiliated with the Church seemed fitting. This commitment to his faith can be further seen in his teachings to students.

Student Enrollment

2

  • McKenzie began teaching anyone who was willing to learn from him.
  • He started with 16 students (1841) , which eventually grew to average ~200 students per year (1854-61).

Institution Operations

3

The Male/Female Dormitories

  • The Preparatory School began in 1841
  • Began in a single log cabin and later grew into 4 academic buildings and residence halls (one male and one female)
  • The Female and Collegiate (College) Departments were not implemented until 1845
  • Women were able to learn the same material as the Collegiate department, while being educated in a physically separate setting from the men. Yet, upon graduation, the men were awarded diplomas while the women received certificates of completion...

How were students able to pay for tuition??

Tuition Payments

  • Students and their families were able to trade slave labor, Confederate Bonds, and “notes with security” * as valid forms of payment. As well as regular monetary payments.
  • Licentiates for the ministry ( [Christian] Religion Majors) & the children of fellow Itinerant preachers attended for FREE

*This is essentially a type of loan/bond that is backed by stating the borrower’s assets as collateral if not repaid.

Contributions To Structures Of Racialization

How does this contribute to racialization?

For starters, noting that these acceptable forms of payment are established in an economic structure that is based on racial hierarchies is of utmost importance.

1) Confederate bonds were paid out to white men who fought for the social, political and economic ideologies of white supremacy. Allowing these bonds as form of payment demonstrates the compliance to structures set in place within the given era.

2) The trading of slave labor communicates that black slaves were not viewed as people but rather property and financial assets.

3) Allowing a select few to attend the Institution at no cost contributes to the construction of WHO the "ideal" / "traditional" student was and continues to be - configured from the identities one holds.

**The structure of the Racial Hierarchy throughout History**

Teachings

Teachings

List of a few Required Textbooks:

  • The Bible
  • Mental philosophy; Embracing the Three Departments of The Intellect, Sensibilities, and Will

by Thomas Cogswell Upham, 1869

  • A Textbook On Natural Philosophy

by John William Draper, 1847

Relevance

Why is this relevant?

Students were being taught that racial structures/hierarchies within society were to be upheld.

Having the Bible as a required text, along with mandatory daily 4 a.m. chapel attendance, solidifies the notion that McKenzie intended to have the school be a continuance of his Itinerant work.

  • Methodism teachings promoted the practice of slavery (to an extent) - look at 'Methodism and Slavery'.

The other two required textbooks mentioned provide academic reassurance that white individuals were " naturally superior" to BIPOC.

These teachings promoted the continuance of the racial inequality and mistreatment that occurred.

A "Brief" Overview of Methodism's Stance On Slavery

It wasn't until the early 1840s when preachers like William Capers and William A. Smith began utilizing scripture as justification for slavery.

Methodism teaches that Christians are to “submit to their governing law”, therefore, if slavery is legal, then it was morally okay.

There were also preachers like George Whitefield, another founder of Methodism, who believed that 1) race did not play a role in intelligence and 2) black slaves and free white men were equals when it came to education and religion; though he still argued that they did not deserve equal treatment or legal rights.

Debates over slavery eventually created a divide amongst members of the church causing Divisions within the Church itself.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Black/African-American Methodist Church's

The African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church (1821)

The African Methodist Episcopal Church (1816)

All-African American Colored Methodist Episcopal Church (1870)

-These were created due to racial prejudice experienced by black members of the Church

The Methodist Church Splits into 2 bodies

Methodist Episcopal Church -- this is the body JWP McKenzie operated under--

-supported legal slavery

Methodist Episcopal Church, South (1845)

-supported all forms of slavery

Methodism and Slavery

John Wesley, a founder of Methodism in the U.S., believed slavery and the slave trade were immoral. He would incorporate these teachings into his sermons. In 1774, he wrote Thoughts on Slavery; in this essay, Wesley discussed societal reasons for the support of slavery while opposing them and disproving the notion that black slaves were beings from places that were populated with "violent" and "uncivilized brutes" (Painter, 2001). He even aimed to make his arguments without any form of Biblical references - this was done in efforts of reaching a wider audience; non-religious readers.

He attempted to make it against the religion to be a slave owner. This only lasted for a couple of years.

Over time, the number of members in the church, who were also slave holders, continued to grow. In order to have membership retention, Wesley decided to compromise and allow slave-holding- as long as it was legal in practicing states and owners were not inflicting "cruel" treatment to their slaves.

Members of The Board of Trustees Known to Have Owned Slaves

Board of Trustees

**Probable that there were more; these names were found through The 1850/1860 U.S. Federal Census Slave Schedules**

Impacts of the Civil War on the Institution

Impact of the Civil War on the Institution

Abraham Lincoln and Union Soldiers at the Battle of Antietam

https://www.history.com/topics/american-civil-war/american-civil-war-history

1) Student Enrollment drastically declined as students chose to join the efforts of the Confederate Army

2) Come the end of the Civil War - and implementation of the Emancipation Proclamation and Juneteenth - JWP McKenzie freed the slaves from working the plantation.

  • Losing the free labor of the previously enslaved black population would create additional expenses to the institution's financial plans

Ultimately, the financial strain would lead to the Institution's closure in 1868.

Future Research Interests

***Restrictions in Archival accessibility this summer, due to COVID-19 closures, prevented us from further researching these topics***

*** Archival Documents for McKenzie College are located at the SMU library archives***

Future Research Interests

  • Student Life

-Any documented racialized activities?

  • Debate Societies and School Newspapers

-The Dialectic Society and the Philologian Society

-The Bee (Female Department) and The Owl (Collegiate Department) Newspapers

  • How did students discuss topics like slavery and statehood among their peers?
  • How does this contribute to the construction of whiteness and racialization within Southwestern’s History??
  • Aunt Dicey

“... an old colored woman that seemed to have universal oversight of the cooking department," - Andrew Davis (Jones 2006, 33)

  • Who was she? How/When did she wind up at McKenzie College? How did she contribute to the continuance of the Institution and to what extent?
6

Soule University

Soule University

Soule University building. Accessed from an archived web page of SU special collections

https://web.archive.org/web/20070927194021/http://www.southwestern.edu/library/how-we-remember/root-institutions/Soulerevised.htm

- 1855 -1887

- 4th and final of the SU root colleges

- A very large building...

Chappell Hill, TX

Chappell Hill, TX

"Chappell Hill Texas TX Map professionally designed by GreatCitees.com."

Accessed from http://townmapsusa.com/d/map-of-chappell-hill-texas-tx/chappell_hill_tx

- Chappell Hill is located 57 miles northwest of Houston in Washington County (Christian, 2010). In 1845, Washington County had 1,374 slaves (Torget, 2007). By the 1850s, Chappell Hill grew “as the center of large cotton plantations” and had strong connections to the Methodist Church (Christian, 2010).

- In order to transport the growing cotton economy, Chappell Hill residents worked towards the establishment of a railroad. The Washington County Rail Road was organized by two “Chappell Hill planters” and one of them, W. W. Browning, was actually appointed to the Board of Trustees of Soule University and was a member for many years. He had 62 humans enslaved as of 1860.

- These developments made Chappell Hill an important trading hub in the region which made it a favorable location for the Confederacy during the Civil War.

Summary

Founding and end

- In the early 1850s, Dr. R. J. Swearingen and William Chappell, two Trustees of the Chappell Hill Male and Female Institute, offered the Texas Methodist Conference $50,000 ($1,473,529 today) “secured by notes and obligations” towards a new institution. In 1855, a Board of Trustees was appointed and the new institution was named Soule University (B. Jones, 49).

- Soule was one of the root colleges of Southwestern University and was the last one still operating. One of it's presidents, Francis Asbury Mood, resigned in 1873 to finalize the arrangement of Southwestern University. Soule continued as a separate entity but would cease operations a few years later (Cody, 230-2).

- In it's history, Soule provided diplomas to 27 young men (Cody, 234). The main reason for this, as we will see, was the hardship that came with war and the enthusiasm the community had to answer such a calling.

Swearingen and Chappell

Intrinsic connection to slavery

- The $50,000 offered by Swearingen and Chappell just about automatically secured Chappell Hill as the location for Soule University (W. Jones, 49). Both men were prominent slave owners. As of 1860, Dr. R. J. Swearingen had 85 slaves and William Chappell had 30. Dr. Swearingen also donated the land used for Soule’s new building (Ibid, 51).

- Both became members of the Board of Trustees though Chappell showed up much more than Swearingen at the meetings (R. Jones, 88). Though Swearingen was elected as a teacher in Soule’s new Medical Department in Galveston (R. Jones, 92).

Felder and Kirby

Endowments and slavery

- A few years into operation, large sums of money were offered to Soule by Gabriel Felder and Jared Kirby both of $12,000 [$353,647 today] ( R. Jones, 92). This was evidently important seeing that a local newspaper at the time talking about the success of the institution mentions that it has been endowed by “two wealthy planters.”

- Kirby owned 139 slaves while Felder owned 50. However neither endowment would be paid in full with Felder’s being the only one to be partially used for the construction of a new building (Ibid, 92). Felder also pledged an additional $10,000 [$294,706 today] which was paid. He became President of the Board of Trustees and served from 1858 till his death in 1868 (Cody, 233).

Trustees and slavery

Trustees and slavery

- Of the 16 initial trustees, 5 showed up on the 1860 slave schedule. Among them was the first President of Soule, T. B. White, who owned 14 slaves. The succeeding President, William Halsey, owned 10 slaves. The additional three trustees are...

- J. H. Davidson: 10 slaves

- J. D. Giddings: 12 slaves

- R. J. Swearingen: 85 slaves

Soule and the Confederacy

Soule and The Confederacy

- The community of Soule University was largely in support of the Confederacy. Many of the trustees saw family members enlist themselves in the Confederacy. There were also many students who went to war such as Rufus King Felder, son of Gabriel Felder, who is pictured here [left] sitting next to his cousin (Ural, 2017).

- The property of Gabriel Felder became a Confederate camp called Camp Felder. The Board of Trustees, under his presidency, also resolved to buy Confederate bonds and notes which may have played a role in the institution’s lasting poor finances (Chicoine, 100).

- The President of Soule at the time, George W. Carter, was enthusiastic about the War and actually discharged himself of his duties in order to go fight. He urged students and graduates to enlist and follow him (Cody, 227-8). There was an ad on a local newspaper stating that “Dr. Carter, of Soule University has been commissioned as a Colonel” and was taking in anyone “desiring to join the service under one of the most gallant officers of the Confederacy…”

- Confederate authorities turned Soule University into a Confederate hospital. Soule remained closed until 1865 however not too long after, yellow fever would cause it to close again until 1868 (Cody, 228-9).

Rufus King [Felder] next to Miers [Felder]. From (Ural, 2017).

https://www.historynet.com/fighting-fast-texas-brigade-sharpsburg.htm

Future Research Interests

Future Research interests

This experience has grounded me to understand Soule University, its historical actors, and the socio-historical context that they lived in (and actively profited from). I have learned of many potential research opportunities that could tell us more about the racial history of SU. These include:

- Research on the financial assets of the University. There was a brief mention of collectively owned crops that failed one season (from Minutes of the Board of Trustees). Crops require bodies to harvest them... ?

- Selection of textbooks and their sentiment on abolition?

Larger research opportunities include...

Francis Asbury Mood

Francis A. Mood

A key figure in the history of SU as president of Soule and founder of SU. Though I already have much information on Mood, further research is needed to understand the interactions between himself, the Methodist church, and the Confederacy. Mood lived a busy and complicated life and in many instances, actively sided with and worked for the Southern cause.

- This need for additional research largely comes from the fact that Mood “ was somewhat disingenuous" about his connections to slavery and the confederacy (W. Jones, 45). The long reluctance to address this part of our history has not helped either.

Medical Department of Soule University in Galveston, TX

Medical Department

A little known fact about SU history is that Soule University founded what became the first medical department in Texas. Though it operated under Soule University for only a few years, it was still an influential part of its history. There were moments after the Civil War when it was the only aspect of Soule that operated successfully.

- Historians, such as Daina Ramey Berry, have pointed out that much of the medical education and practice in 20th century America was connected to or relied upon the institution of slavery. Future research could include reaching out to the modern descendent of this medical branch (University of Texas Medical Branch) with the goal of finding evidence that may reveal the active use and exploitation of Black bodies.

"Cover of the Galveston Medical Journal, 1868." from UTMB Health SHARED.

http://hdl.handle.net/2152.3/477

7

Concluding Thoughts

Southwestern has a story that it likes to tell itself about itself. Our history is of valor and triumph in the face of adversity. We were a utopian vision of the first institution of higher education on the Texas frontier, following just after the brave soldiers of the Texas Republic in claiming land for "Texians." The root institutions struggled, but they survived and excelled---bringing enlightenment to the darkness of the rugged frontier. The successive institutions strengthened us. Francis Asbury Mood’s clarity of vision and persistence brought Southwestern University into being. The general force of good and justice that was Southwestern is exemplified by the good work (good trouble?) of Jessie Daniel Ames, who worked against sexism and for racial justice; and our arc has continued to bend towards justice. The general outlines of this frame organize the historical work done on Southwestern to date.

Conclusions

The other side to the story

Through our detailed analysis of the broader context in which the root colleges existed, including the roles that Texas Methodism, white settler colonialism’s violence against indigenous people, chattel slavery of African-descended people in the Texas Republic cotton plantation economy, the ongoing tensions between Mexico and Texas/the U.S. here and the rise of the southern Confederacy all played in the establishment and functioning of Rutersville, Mckenzie and Soule. These institutions would not have existed without the lands stolen from indigenous peoples and the labor of enslaved African-descended people. And each institution centered whiteness and excluded others in slightly different ways as we have shown. These institutions functioned to help consolidate racializing assemblages that link property, wealth and power with education and pale skin, and that generate racial categories for others on Euro-centric terms of engagement. It is imperative that Southwestern recognize this history, and think clearly about how it may be repeating itself today, and to find steps forward to move towards a more truly racially just institution.

The Root Colleges as Racializing Assemblages

While there is much that is true in this story, it handily leaves out a less laudatory current in the history of the institution, that of centering a particular version of whiteness with class, gender, and religious elements at the very real expense of Blackness, Indian-ness and Mexican-ness. The institution came into being only by Anglo/Euro theft from Black, Indian and Mexican peoples—theft of freedom, labor, land and the possibilities of being seen as, being allowed to be, fully human in the eyes of the laws, economic systems, political, religious, etc. institutions that were developing in Central Texas, aided and abetted by Southwestern’s root colleges. Furthermore, through this theft and these exclusions, Southwestern’s root colleges contributed to the consolidation, or territorialization of racializing assemblages of whiteness, blackness, indianness and mexicanness. Those racial categories became more fixed through the creation and functioning of Southwestern’s root colleges.

Next Steps

Next Steps

As indicated, there are questions left unanswered about each institution we researched, and we never even looked closely at Wesleyan College. We particularly point to trying to identify Black, Indian and Mexican accounts and perspectives on these institutions and the people who made them function. But equally important is focusing on the early history of Southwestern University itself, from its founding through until today. The money bolstering the founding of SU is very likely still based in slave-holding, and a not insignificant number of trustees, administrators, students etc in those early years may well have been slavers, or have come from slave-holding families. Blacks were now free, and were living throughout Williamson County. Indians were still very present and expressing their discontent with white settler colonialism in very visible ways in Texas until 1900. And there continued to be a small presence of Mexican-Americans; their number set to grow in the 1900s. What was the relationship between these groups of people and Southwestern? In what ways did Southwestern contribute to shifts in what it meant to be White? Black? Indian? Mexican?

We hope what we have shared piques people’s interest and we invite anyone to join us on this journey!

8

Sources

Sources

Secondary Sources

Primary Sources

McKenzie College

Phelan, Macum. 1924. A History of Early Methodism in Texas, 1817-1866. Nashville: Cokesbury Press.

Jones, Ralph Wood. 1973. Southwestern University, 1840-1961. Austin, Tex.: Jenkins Pub.

Jordan, Milton. 2010. “Mckenzie College, Red River County, Texas, (1841-1868).” East Texas Historical Journal 49 (1).

Osburn, John D. 1960. “Mckenzie College.” The Southwestern Historical Quarterly 63 (4): 533–53.

Karppi, Daniel G. "Render Unto Caesar, Render Unto God: Texas Denominational Colleges and Universities and the Politics of the Civil War Era." PhD diss., Baylor University, 2008.

Jones, William B. 2006. To Survive and Excel: The Story of Southwestern University, 1840-2000. Georgetown, Tex.: Southwestern University.

TSHAONLINE

Ancestry.com. 1850 U.S. Federal Census - Slave Schedules [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations Inc, 2010.

Ancestry.com. 1860 U.S. Federal Census - Slave Schedules [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations Inc, 2010.

McKenzie College material [Southwestern University: Root Institutions and Affiliated Colleges, McKenzie College 136U 1.1]

An Act to Incorporate the McKenzie Male and Female College [Southwestern University: Root Institutions and Affiliated Colleges 136U 1.4]

Constitution and Bylaws of the Dialectic Society of McKenzie College; Together with a Catalogue of the Honorary and Regular Members for 1859-1860 [Southwestern University: Root Institutions and Affiliated Colleges, McKenzie College 136U 1.1]

Revision of the Constitution, Bylaws, and Regulations of the Philologian Society of McKenzie College; Also a Catalogue of the Regular Members for 1859-60, and Additional Honorary Members [Southwestern University: Root Institutions and Affiliated Colleges, McKenzie College 136U 1.1]

Primary sources

Soule University

- Ancestry.com. 1860 U.S. Federal Census - Slave Schedules [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations Inc, 2010.

- J.D. Baker & Bros. The Colorado Citizen (Columbus, Tex.), Vol. 2, No. 32, Ed. 1 Saturday, April 9, 1859, newspaper, April 9, 1859; Columbus, Texas. (https://texashistory.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metapth177564/: accessed July 1, 2020), University of North Texas Libraries, The Portal to Texas History, https://texashistory.unt.edu; crediting The Dolph Briscoe Center for American History.

- The Weekly Telegraph (Houston, Tex.), Vol. 27, No. 21, Ed. 1 Wednesday, August 7, 1861, newspaper, August 7, 1861; Houston, Texas. (https://texashistory.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metapth236155/: accessed July 1, 2020), University of North Texas Libraries, The Portal to Texas History, https://texashistory.unt.edu; crediting The Dolph Briscoe Center for American History.

- Soule University Board of Trustees. [Minutes for the Soule University Board of Trustees: 1875-1876], book, 1857-01/1876-09; (https://texashistory.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metapth981990/: accessed July 1, 2020), University of North Texas Libraries, The Portal to Texas History, https://texashistory.unt.edu; crediting Chappell Hill Historical Society Museum.

Secondary sources 1

Secondary Sources #1

- Carole E. Christian, “Camp Felder,” Texas State Historical Association: Handbook of Texas, https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/camp-felder

- Carole E. Christian, “Chappell Hill, TX,” Texas State Historical Association: Handbook of Texas, https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/chappell-hill-tx

- Cody, C. C. “Soule University.” Texas Methodist Historical Quarterly 2, No. 3 (January 1911): 221-234. https://texashistory.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metapth90887/: accessed July 1, 2020), University of North Texas Libraries, The Portal to Texas History, https://texashistory.unt.edu; crediting Denton Public Library.

- Chicoine, Stephen. The Confederates of Chappell Hill, Texas : Prosperity, Civil War and Decline. Jefferson, North Carolina: Mcfarland & Company, Inc, 2011.

- Warren W. Hassler and Jennifer L. Weber, “American Civil War,” Encyclopædia Britannica, June 17, 2020. https://www.britannica.com/event/American-Civil-War

Secondary sources #2

Secondary sources #2

- Jones, William B. To Survive and Excel : The Story of Southwestern University, 1840-2000. Georgetown, Tex.: Southwestern University, 2006.

- Jones, Ralph Wood. Southwestern University, 1840-1961. Austin, Tex.: Jenkins Pub, 1973.

- Torget, Andrew J.. Texas Slavery Project. “The Database.” Accessed June 19, 2020. http://www.texasslaveryproject.org/database/about.html

- Ural, Susannah J. “Fighting ‘Too Fast’: The Texas Brigade paid a high price at Sharpsburg for its fighting prowess,” Historynet, December, 2017. https://www.historynet.com/fighting-fast-texas-brigade-sharpsburg.htm

- For Measuring the worth of US Dollars in 19th century: https://www.officialdata.org/us/inflation/1800

Introductory and Contextual Material and Rutersville College

References A - F

Alexander, Michelle. 2020. The new Jim Crow: Mass incarceration in the age of colorblindness. The New Press

Anonymous, “Rabb, John,” Handbook of Texas Online, accessed September 22, 2020, https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/rabb-john.

Bahrainwala, Lamiyah. 2020. "Precarity, citizenship, and the “traditional” student." Communication Education 69(2): 250-260.

Benham, Priscilla Myers, “Moore, Francis, Jr.,” Handbook of Texas Online,

accessed September 22, 2020, https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/moore-francis-jr.

Blanton, Joseph E. “Hill, John Christopher Columbus,” Handbook of Texas Online, accessed September 23, 2020, https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/hill-john-christopher-columbus.

Carrigan, William Dean. 1999. Slavery on the frontier: The peculiar institution in Central Texas, Slavery and Abolition 20(2): 63-96.

Curlee, Abigail. 1922. The History of a Texas Slave Plantation 1831-63. The Southwestern Historical Quarterly 26(2): pp. 79-127

Daily Nashville Union (Nashville, Tennessee) · 4 May 1850, Sat “From Texas”

Feagin, Joe R. 2020. The white racial frame: Centuries of racial framing and counter-framing. Routledge.

Find-a-Grave sites for multiple persons. Used especially for photographs.

References A- F

References H-L

Harris, Leslie M, James T. Campbell and Alfred L Brophy. 2019. Slavery and the University: Histories and Legacies. Athens: University of Georgia Press

Hazlewood, Claudia “Sims, Bartlett Samuel,” Handbook of Texas Online, accessed September 23, 2020, https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/sims-bartlett-samuel.

Jones, Martha S. 2018. Birthright citizens: A history of race and rights in Antebellum America. Cambridge University Press, 2018.

Jones, Ralph. 1973. Southwestern University 1840-1961. Austin: Jenkins Publishing Company/San Felipe Press.

Jones, William B. 2006. To Survive and Excel: The Story of Southwestern University, 1840-2000. Georgetown, Texas: Southwestern University

Jordan, Terry G. 1969. Population Origins in Texas, 1850. Geographical Review (59)1: 83-103

Kemp, L. W. “Barnett, George Washington,” Handbook of Texas Online, accessed September 23, 2020, https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/barnett-george-washington

Largent, F. B., Jr., “Murchison, John,” Handbook of Texas Online, accessed September 23, 2020, https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/murchison-john.

Looscan, Mrs.M. 1898. Chapter XII: The Women of Pioneer Days in Texas—Domestic and Social Life During the Periods of the Colonies, The Revolution, and the Republic, in Wooten, Dudley G (ed). A Comprehensive History of Texas 1685-1897. Dallas, Texas: William Scarf. Pp. 649-668.

References H- L

References S - Z

Saldanha, Arun. 2006. "Reontologising race: the machinic geography of phenotype." Environment and planning D: society and space 24(1): 9-24.

Saldanha, Arun. 2007. Psychedelic White: Goa Trance and the Viscosity of Whiteness. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

Schoen, Harold. 1937. The Free Negro in the Republic of Texas. The Southwestern Historical Quarterly 41(1): 83-108.

Sinks, Julia Lee. 1898. Rutersville College. The Quarterly of the Texas State Historical Association 2(2): 124-133

Smithwick, Noah. 1900. The Evolution of a State: Or, Recollections of Old Texas Days. Gammel Book Company.

Southwestern University Special Collections, for access to photographs and other documents.

Spellmann, Norman W. 2020. “Methodist Church,” Handbook of Texas Online, accessed September 22, 2020, https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/methodist-church.

Texas County Tax Rolls, 1837-1860 for various counties, especially Fayette, Washington. Accessed in multiple ways, often through Family Search.

Torget, Andrew J. 2015. Seeds of Empire: Cotton, Slavery, and the Transformation of the Texas Borderlands, 1800-1850. University of North Carolina Press Books.

US Census Records 1850 and 1860, and 1850 Slave Schedules for Texas.

Weheliye, Alexander. 2014. Habeas Viscus: Racializing Assemblages, Biopolitics, and Black Feminist Theories of the Human. Duke University Press

Wilder, Craig Steven.2013. Ebony and Ivy: Race, Slavery and the Troubled History of America’s Universities. New York: Bloomsbury.

References S - Z

References M -R

Menchaca, Martha. 2001. Recovering history, constructing race: The Indian, black, and white roots of Mexican Americans. University of Texas Press.

Mills, Charles W.. “Global White Supremacy.” In White privilege : essential readings on the other side of racism, edited by Paula S. Rothenberg, 95-102. New York, NY: Worth, 2012

Mignolo, Walter D. 2009. Epistemic disobedience, independent thought and decolonial freedom. Theory, culture & society. 26(7-8): 159-181.

Monmouth Democrat (Freehold, New Jersey) · 9 May 1850, Thu “Horrible Murder by Negroes”

Omi, Michael, and Howard Winant. 2014. Racial formation in the United States. Routledge.

Painter, Nell Irvin. 2010. The history of white people. WW Norton & Company

Phelan, Macum. 1924. A History of Early Methodism In Texas, 1817-1866. Nashville: Cokesbury Press, 1924.

Rutersville College Catalog 1841 and 1842. Southwestern University Special Collections.

References M- R