Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.
Free to try, no credit card requiredOnline Learning: An Evaluative Review
Jody Pecena
Post University
EDU637
Introduction to Morality
Introduction to
Morality
Course Overview
Course Overview
Evaluating online learning and courses can be problematic as each program is unique in design and demographic of students its advertising to. The US Department of Education has reviewed several programs and the evaluation system used in each. Many online and in person programs require an accreditation to be considered “reputable” and “worthy”. Advertising to those who are seeking a degree or higher education would accelerate the program to meet specific indicators and criteria. However, not all online programs are seeking the same type of audience or set of students, therefore they don’t all need to meet the same rigorous criteria.
Moralities of Everyday Life is a Massive Open Online Course (MOOC) that was free or an option to earn a certificate for a nominal fee ($49). When this course is open there could be anywhere from 1,000 to 10,000 students enrolled. The selling point to the course, offered via Coursera.org, was that it was taught by a well-known Yale University psychology professor and his graduate assistant. It was not geared towards anyone seeking a higher education degree, but rather those who were wishing to enlighten and expand upon their knowledge of the world of psychology—specifically morality. This is a 6-week long course that includes a variety of TedTalks, online videos, readings, discussion boards and recorded conversations with the instructor, graduate assistant and guest speakers.
Quality Scorecards
Scorecards
0=Deficient 1=Developing 2=Accomplished 3= Exemplary
Total Possible Points= 225
Score=
Institutional Support
(27 Total Possible Points)
In the area of institutional support, according to the Quality Scoreard, Coursera.org and the Morality course scored a 10/27. This is not to say that they don't qualify in the last 4 indicators, but not having an insider perspective, we are unable to score these indicators fairly without knowledge.
Institutional
Support
Technology Support
(21 Total Possible Points)
As a student enrolled in this online course, it is hard to determine many of the technology system specifics needed for designing and supporting a massive online program. Therefore, many of the indicators scored a "0". This does not mean they are not there, just that I have not witnessed or been made aware of them. I can say, that in the introduction of the course, I was directed to the IT department who would be able to help me should I experience any technical difficulties while enrolled in the course. The category scored a 2/21 possible points.
Technology Support
Course Development & Instructional Design
(36 Total Possible Points)
This course scored an 18/36 possible points in the area of course development & instructional design. Again, without being a member of faculty or staff, it is hard to definitvely state the program follows through with the indicators scoring a "0".
Course Development/Instructional Design
Course Structure
(24 Total Possible Points)
In the area of course structure, this course scored a 15/24 possible points. All in all this course's structure is very solid with the exception of specific course objectives being stated in the syllabus and throughout weekly modules.
Course Structure
Student Support
(48 Total Possible Points)
The student support category scored a 28/48 possible points. The two indicators this course was lacking in was an option for tutoring as well as process and resources for students with disabilities. The lack of both can be understood as this is a MOOC, and is not connected to any type of degree. This course is designed for those individuals who are wanting to further their knowledge on the science of morality and how it affects our everyday lives, not necessarily obtain a higher education degree.
Student Support
Teaching & Learning
(15 Total Possible Points)
The category of teaching & learning is a definite strength in this particular course scoring a 11/15 possible points. Despite the extremely large enrollment, interaction, feedback and differentiation are implemented.
Teaching & Learning
Social & Student Engagement
(3 Total Possible Points)
Social & Student
Engagement
Throughout this course, students are enouraged to discuss topics with colleagues and peers via discussion boards as well as via email. This area scored a 2/3 possible points.
Faculty Support
(18 Total Possible Points)
Faculty Support
Again, this is a very difficult area to evaluate as I was a student in the course, not an instructor. I am unable to definitively say that faculty are provided these supports and explained clear expectations and standards. Because of this, this area only scored a 0/18 possible points. I am confident that Coursera.org does indeed provide its' faculty with support and a clear set of expectations and guidelines as they are a well known online learning platform.
Evaluation & Assessment
(33 Total Possible Points)
Again, as a student enrolled in this course, it is hard to score the behind the scenes components of evaluation and assessment of the course. Due to the role I am playing, and my lack of behind the scenes information, this category scored a 5/33 possible points. In his introduction, the professor explained the importance of completing the pre-course and post course survey as he and his graduate assistant utilize that information and feedback to make adjustments and improvements to the course for future sessions.
Evaluation
& Assessment
Benefits
Benefits
This massive online open enrollment course has its benefits. While there are start and end dates, this course is self-paced and allows students to work at their own speed. This course also provides numerous opportunities to interact with peers and instructors via discussion boards and through email. There is an option to email questions or thoughts to be discussed during the recorded office hours. These office hours feature the professor, his graduate assistant and most weeks, a special guest speaker. This course not only allowed for social interaction and thoughtful discussion, it also provided a variety of resources to further explore the topic of morality.
Drawbacks
Drawbacks
Just like most things in life, this course has some drawbacks. As it is open to between hundreds to thousands of people, you may not experience that 1-1 interaction with your instructor. While there are guest speakers included in this course, again, you may not get to interact with them in a live setting. Their conversations and discussions, while based upon questions from students in the course, are prerecorded and uploaded for students to watch. Specific feedback is limited to assessments (which often have opinion based required responses) and discussion boards- in which case the actual instructor may not be responding to you due to the large enrollment.
Conclusion
Despite this course only scoring a 91/225 quality scorecard points (according to my evaluation), I would highly recommend enrolling in this course or one of a similar format if you are looking to enlighten yourself on a topic that has peaked your interest. This course was very low risk with a high reward if the time and effort is placed into it. It should be noted that instutition and course evaluation tools such as the OLC Quality Scorecard are generally used by individuals who have access to all parts of a program, not just the perspective of a student. It is always important when evaluating a course or program to utilize multiple perpectives and not just that of the students to obtain a valid and reliable assessment.
References
References
Evaluating Courses Online. (2020). Retrieved November 26, 2020, from https://www.utoledo.edu/dl/faculty/teach_online/online-evaluation.html
Moralities of Everyday Life. https://www.coursera.org/learn/moralities/home/welcome
Olcsloanc. (2011, November 4). Quality Scorecard [Video file]. Retrieved December 4, 2020, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ic2YXM3lUoU
U.S. Dept of Education(2008). Evaluating Online Learning Challenges and Strategies for Success [PDF]. WestEd With Edvance Research, Inc for U.S. Department of Education. Retrieved November 26, 2020 from https://www2.ed.gov/admins/lead/academic/evalonline/evalonline.pdf
Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.
Free to try, no credit card required