Loading presentation...

Present Remotely

Send the link below via email or IM

Copy

Present to your audience

Start remote presentation

  • Invited audience members will follow you as you navigate and present
  • People invited to a presentation do not need a Prezi account
  • This link expires 10 minutes after you close the presentation
  • A maximum of 30 users can follow your presentation
  • Learn more about this feature in our knowledge base article

Do you really want to delete this prezi?

Neither you, nor the coeditors you shared it with will be able to recover it again.

DeleteCancel

Feminism 101: gender, power and violence

Introductory lecture for undergraduates - please feel free to download, use and share
by

Alison Phipps

on 15 February 2016

Comments (0)

Please log in to add your comment.

Report abuse

Transcript of Feminism 101: gender, power and violence

Feminism 101:
Gender, Power and Violence

Carol Jenkins reads Ida B. Wells
One for the lads
Rape in colonisation and conflict
The Oxford 'colonial cocktail' trivialised (or even celebrated) the brutality of this period in our history: a brutality which was often embodied in acts and allegations of gendered and sexual violence (and which is ongoing in a variety of contemporary dynamics and oppressions)

Violence against women has been reported in every episode of colonisation and every international and domestic conflict zone, and functions as an act of humiliation and domination, usually perpetrated by occupying/conquering groups and forces (and often by agents of the state)

For Yuval Davis ('Gender and Nation', 1997), women are targeted because they are seen as the biological/ideological/cultural reproducers of the nation: however, men and boys are also often victimised (and because these assaults tend to remain hidden, they are underestimated), and can be forced to become perpetrators

Cultural/ethnic/racial power relations are enacted and produced through these deeds of gendered and sexual violence
Carceral feminism and state violence
Rape and racial oppression
Ida B. Wells was a leader of the early Civil Rights movement in the US - this is an excerpt from one of her speeches, read by news anchor Carol Jenkins

Wells' activism focused on the practice of lynching - as part of this, she exposed how rape functioned as a means of social control

'Interracial rape was not only used to uphold white patriarchal power but was also deployed as a justification for lynching black men who challenged the Southern status quo' (McGuire, 'At the Dark End of the Street', 2010, pxviii).

This case study encapsulates why we need to take an intersectional analysis to the topic of gender, power and violence
Key questions:
Colonisation
as
sexual violence
Dangerous Brown Men
In her essay 'Can the Subaltern Speak?', Spivak (1988) uses the phrase 'white men saving
brown women
from brown men' (emphasis mine)

This dynamic has also been key to processes of colonisation, and characterises neocolonial projects such as the War on Terror

Bhattacharyya (2008) argues that rhetorical framings of the War on Terror were based on a conception of the West as uniquely progressive, set against the idea of Muslim-majority communities (and particularly the men in them) as inherently misogynistic and homophobic

This gave additional fuel to the 'civilising mission' of the War on Terror and its strategic use of the figure of the 'victimised Muslim woman' in Afghanistan and elsewhere (simultaneously concealing the prevalence of violence and abuse in the West)

It also framed the abuse of prisoners in facilities such as Abu Ghraib, which made deliberate/strategic use of sexualised forms of torture
Turning an intersectional lens on issues of gender, power and violence means 'asking the other question' and expanding our appreciation of these terms:

We need to see violence as not only wielded by men over women, but also as central to other intersecting relations of domination and oppression

We need to broaden our focus on physical/sexual violence, to include state, community and symbolic forms

We need to understand how power resides in the act or threat of violence, and also in claims to state protection made by some individuals/groups which produce the (often violent) governance of others

We need to look at these dynamics globally, as well as nationally and locally
An intersectional analysis
http://socialdifference.columbia.edu/files/socialdiff/projects/Article__Mapping_the_Margins_by_Kimblere_Crenshaw.pdf

http://uk.sagepub.com/sites/default/files/upm-binaries/13299_Chapter_16_Web_Byte_Patricia_Hill_Collins.pdf

http://jan.ucc.nau.edu/~sj6/carby%20white%20woman%20listen.pdf

http://www.theguardian.com/education/2015/oct/19/lgbt-students-on-lad-culture-will-i-be-safe-on-campus-today

http://crj.sagepub.com/content/14/5/593

http://indiancountrytodaymedianetwork.com/2016/02/03/bring-me-girl-why-revenant-was-hard-my-friends-and-me-163227

https://muse.jhu.edu/journals/hypatia/v018/18.2smith.pdf

http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/history/2015/06/the_deadly_history_of_they_re_raping_our_women_racists_have_long_defended.html

http://www.incite-national.org/page/incite-critical-resistance-statement

https://zulfahmed.files.wordpress.com/2013/12/disciplineandpunish.pdf

http://titsandsass.com/getting-away-with-hating-it-consent-in-the-context-of-sex-work/

http://www.juliaserano.com/excluded.html#excerpts

http://www.dailylife.com.au/news-and-views/dl-opinion/why-some-peoples-outrage-over-the-cologne-attacks-is-racist-20160107-gm1ayd.html

https://www.opendemocracy.net/5050/amrit-wilson/indias-anti-rape-movement-redefining-solidarity-outside-colonial-frame#.Uwk2sq9zoWo.twitter
The case of campus sexual harassment and rape can be used to illustrate key feminist points about how violence, or the threat of violence, is central to dominant forms of masculinity and gendered power relations

Susan Brownmiller ('Against Our Will', 1975) described rape as a 'process of intimidation by which all men keep all women in a state of fear'. For Brownmiller, violence (and more importantly the threat of violence) caused women to restrict their freedom of movement and look to men for protection (this analysis inspires initiatives such as Reclaim the Night)

Liz Kelly ('Surviving Sexual Violence', 1988) developed the concept of a continuum of violence ranging from sexual harassment to sexualised murder, through which men control women and preserve their power and space
Every day, I am afraid to leave my room. Even seeing people who look remotely like my rapist scares me. Last semester I was working in the dark room in the photography department. Though my rapist wasn’t in my class, he asked permission from his teacher to come and work in the dark room during my class time. I started crying and hyperventilating. As long as he’s on campus with me, he can continue to harass me.

Emma Sulkowicz, Columbia University Student
People have...been physically threatening towards me. Groups of guys have said I’m not a man, and crowded around and pushed me. I’ve been punched for being transgender. It can make me not want to go into uni. I avoid certain guys in my class and, for some classes, I just sneak in at the back. Sometimes I might not bother going out at all.

Homophobia and transphobia at university are often seen as a separate thing to lad culture, but lad culture is basically privileged people not considering anyone else. It’s sexist, and enrolled in the sexism is also homophobia, transphobia, and biphobia, which are all intrinsic to lad culture.

Mat Wilkie, British Student
CONTENT NOTE
This presentation contains descriptions of violent and sexually violent experiences
'Lad culture' and sexual harassment/violence in higher education function to maintain male privilege by making women feel unsafe. However, this is only part of the story:

In 'lad cultures' (and 'frat' cultures), white socially privileged men enact or threaten forms of symbolic, physical and sexual violence to maintain their position over and protect territory from
a number of Others
: including women but also people of colour, working class people, LGBT people, disabled people

Sociologically, this can be seen as part of the backlash against increasing gender equality, but it may also reflect broader widening participation agendas in higher education and the increased visibility of LGBTQ and gender nonconforming people amongst student and youth cultures (Phipps, '(Re)theorising laddish masculinities in higher education', 2016)
Meanwhile, at the Oxford Union:
Kimberlé Crenshaw on intersectionality
For Smith (2003), sexual violence does not just occur within the process of colonisation, but colonialism itself is structured by the logic of sexual violence

Subjugation of women of native nations, often through brutal acts of sexual violence, is key to settler colonial projects

This is also used to humiliate (and thus subdue) men, and to prevent the reproduction of the indigenous population or 'dilute' it through the creation of mixed-race offspring

In the context of settler colonialism (and chattel slavery and after), accusations of sexual violence have also been used to keep dominated men in line through state and community retribution (often fatal)

These political/cultural/racist violences have been justified by the rhetoric of protection, a dynamic which continues to inform race relations in the UK, US, Australia and other countries - white men saving white women from brown and black men
The War on Terror actively used feminist rhetoric as part of its justificatory strategy, sometimes co-opting it and sometimes with the active co-operation of feminist groups - an example of what Ahmed ('Women and Gender in Islam', 1992) terms 'Colonial Feminism'

There are other examples of women's victimisation (either real or rhetorical) being used as a pretext for state and political violence:

Bumiller ('In an Abusive State' 2008) argues that feminist anti-rape campaigning has been appropriated by (or sometimes complicit with) neoliberal agendas concerned with criminalising particular groups of men (in the case of the US this is largely African-American men, but this could be other groups in other countries)

Bernstein ('Militarized Humanism meets Carceral Feminism', 2010) uses the phrase 'carceral feminism' to describe this relationship: this also operates in relation to the sex industry, in which agendas around 'law and order' and immigration control are pursued through a feminist framework which foregrounds exploitation and abuse (and trafficking in particular)
The prison is one of a variety of forms of state violence these carceral projects invoke and reproduce; they also generate risk for some groups in the process of protecting others

For example, Crenshaw (1991) highlights how black women in the US are less likely to report domestic violence because they do not want to invite oppressive police interventions into their communities or feed racist stereotypes

Levy and Jakobsson's (2014) study of the criminalisation of sex workers' clients in Sweden shows how this project to eradicate the industry through 'ending demand' actually puts sex workers at risk
They can become more dependent on potentially exploitative third parties in order to protect clients from arrest
They are more likely to take risks such as meeting in secluded locations or allowing clients to conceal their identities, and (in the absence of alternative sources of income) may provide services they would not previously have agreed to, in order to survive
They are also unable to rely on the police for protection from violence, because the focus shifts to protecting clients (income) from police intervention
Politicising victimisation
Both carceral and colonial feminisms make use of women's victimisation to justify particular social and political agendas, which often result in oppression and state violence towards marginalised people (both women and people of other genders)

These people are often sacrificed for the sake of an 'ideal victim':

In relation to the sex industry, the safety of sex workers is secondary to eradicating the industry in order to protect 'good' women from being objectified

In the contexts of settler colonialism and chattel slavery, protecting the 'honour' of the white female victim was a pretext for the violent subjugation of indigenous or enslaved men, while indigenous or enslaved women who were victimised were usually blamed for their assaults (this dynamic is preserved in attitudes towards women of colour who experience sexual and domestic violence)
Dynamics around 'deserving' and 'undeserving' victims are intersectionally structured, and feed forms of state and community violence against victims and both real and imagined perpetrators

Although women in the sex industry experience high rates of violence, it is extremely difficult to convict anyone of raping a sex worker (Phipps, 'Rape and Respectability', 2009)

In the US, black men arrested for raping white women are more likely to be charged with a felony than black men arrested for raping black women or white men arrested for raping white women

Before Dylann Roof opened fire at Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church in Charleston, South Carolina - killing nine people - he reportedly told churchgoers, 'You rape our women, and you’re taking over our country, and you have to go.'
Although feminism has been critical of the notion of the 'ideal victim', contemporary anti-violence activism often continues to look to the state for protection for some women to the detriment of others

This is particularly pronounced in relation to sex workers, who can be positioned explicitly as the enemy who are collaborating with patriarchy and putting other women at risk (LeMoncheck, 'Loose Women, Lecherous Men', 1997)

'When the sex war is won prostitutes should be shot as collaborators for their terrible betrayal of all women.' - Julie Burchill

Conversely, when sex workers are not being defined as 'fallen women' who endanger others they are seen as always already victimised: this invalidates their consent and means that it is very difficult to talk about specific abuses against them
The concept of the 'ideal victim' is also at play in debates around trans women's access to women-only spaces and support services

In this context, trans women are not only positioned as 'imperfect' victims, but also often conceptualised as aggressors or potential aggressors who might trigger the trauma responses of cisgender women who are survivors and need to be protected

This is based in a refusal to acknowledge and respect the trans woman's identity as a woman: an act of symbolic violence which also conceals the fact that trans women are particularly at risk of victimisation by men

'The claim to ‘ownership’ of rape victimisation by cisgender women, through the projection of violence on to trans women...commodifies it and invisibilises the experiences of trans women who have been subjected to violence and abuse' (Phipps, 'Whose personal is more political?', 2016)
How do acts, threats and allegations of violence reflect and reproduce existing power relations?

What do our definitions of violence include and exclude, and how is this shaped by the meanings attached to gender and other interdependent social categories ?

Who can claim state protection, and who is more often the focus of violent state governance or community retribution?

How does this interact with definitions, understandings and experiences of victimhood for different types of people?

How do these dynamics around power and violence enter and function within the political and geopolitical spheres?
Intersectionality is a concept developed by black feminists and codified by Crenshaw in her famous article 'Mapping the Margins' (see also Hill Collins, Carby and others)

'Rather than examining gender, race, class and nation as distinctive social hierarchies, intersectionality examines how they mutually construct one another.' (Hill Collins, 'It's All in the Family', 1998)

First applied to black women's intersecting experiences of gender, race, and class, this is now a foundational feminist principle which has been used to analyse the interlocking/co-production of a variety of categories, structures and oppressions
Friends Frangipani
(Papua New Guinea) on violence against sex workers
Useful links
There are numerous other examples which could be explored in response to these questions:


For example, the 'corrective rape' of lesbians in South Africa is produced by the policing of norms around gender, sexuality, nation and race (women of colour being disproportionately at risk)

The backlash against refugees in reaction to the sexual assaults in Cologne on New Year's Eve 2015/16 highlights how women's victimisation often becomes a conduit for the enactment of concerns and oppressions to do with race, ethnicity and nation

Similarly, Western reactions to recent high-profile rape cases in India reflect how sexual violence becomes part of racist narratives which both construct notions of 'culture' and conceal sexual violence and abuse in the West

We must try to keep an intersectional focus by 'asking the other question', if we are to fully explore and understand issues around gender, power and violence
Serano's comments about the inadequacy of second-wave feminisms to conceptualise particular types of violence apply to many of the other examples which have been presented here. With all these (and more) in mind, we can now make more sense of our key intersectional quetions:
Full transcript