TRANSITIONAL BILINGUAL EDUCATION

SM
by Sarah Morgan597 views·Updated Oct 27, 2015
Powered by AI

Need to present on this topic?

Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.

Free to try, no credit card required

Transcript

Introduction

All of the formal methods of teaching bilingualism in US schools stem from The Bilingual Education Act of 1968, also called Title VII of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act. This act was put into place because as many as 50% of children in Spanish-speaking communities were dropping out of public schools. This amendment was a solution made to address this problem and prevent discrimination in public education. This act also made it to where bilingual education programs were federally funded.

The roots of transitional bilingual education were planted by professor Jim Cummins. In 1999, Jim Cummins presented a public discourse debating the benefits of teaching bilingualism in schools. He and many of educators believed there were better methods for teaching a second language in schools.

Effectiveness

Description

Implementation

Transitional Bilingual Education is effective because it is easier for children to be able to learn a second language when they already know their native language fully through transfer. However, this instructional practice is considered “subtractive.” This means that when children go through this program they might lose a lot of their native language because they are not continuously learning it and using it in school. So, while this practice is effective in helping children learn a new language, it is not effective in the maintenance of their native language. There is also a social issue that could arise from having children in a different classroom, separated from the other students being taught in English.

The transitional method in Bilingual Education helps students transition from their native language to English. Initially, subjects are taught in their native language and as time goes on instruction is gradually taught more and more in English. Eventually, the classroom will only be taught in English. Within this model there are early exit and late exit methods of instruction.

What would a transitional bilingual classroom look like?

First, a student is enrolled in school that either speaks no English or their English is very limited. The student is then assigned to a bilingual teacher and is taught in a classroom with other ESL students. The teacher will speak to the students in both English and Spanish. The bilingual teacher becomes the promoter of transition from one language to another. The aim of transitional bilingual education is assimilation into general education.

“The students are taught briefly through their home language until they are proficient enough in the majority language to cope in mainstream education.” (Baker 2011 p.215) This will decide when the student will exit the program.

The aim of this program is to increase the use of the majority language in the classroom while decreasing the use of the student’s home language in order to promote English fluency.

Early Exit

Goals

The goal of the transitional model is to help ELLs (English Language Learners) successfully acquire the English language so that they can be placed in the mainstream education. The goal of Transitional Bilingual Education is not to replace a student's native language with English. This program encourages that English is acquired gradually so that the student can become fluent. This program allows second language learners to obtain a quality education in the United States.

  • Maximum of 2 years of instruction using the native language
  • Utilizes a student's native language to teach literacy and content areas
  • Typically will not occur earlier than the end of first grade
  • Once students are thought to be proficient enough in English they can move into mainstream education
  • Works to balance students' content understanding with their English language proficiency
  • Asks the question: if a student does not understand a learning concept in their first language, how will they learn it in their second?
  • Ovando & Collier believe that Early Exit is not as effective because it does not give enough time to initially learn English

Late Exit

  • 40% of classroom teaching is done in the student's native language until Grade 6
  • Students are eligible to leave the Late Exit program between 6 & 7 years after their initial school enrollment
  • Includes cognitively challenging work in a student's native language along with meaningful content taught in English
  • Promotes full academic proficiency in the student's native language and English
  • Instruction in Kindergarten begins at around 10% English and gradually increases with each grade level, representing a slower but more effective transition
  • Textbook states that "late exit transitional bilingual education students were performing higher at mathematics, English language and English reading than students in other programs" by grade 6 (Baker, 258).

Drawbacks of Transitional Bilingual Education

Legislation is incredibly important when it comes to bilingual eduction which is why people who think like this are a part of the problem

There are some drawbacks in teaching a student with this method.

It can take up to six years for a student to acquire academic competence in a second language, a fact this program does not account for. This type of instruction does not promote social integration. The students are isolated in a classroom with other students of the same immigrant background. Studies have shown that kids learn from other kids. So who will these students be learning English from? They are learning from only one instructor and other students who are still trying to master the English language. This can cause some delays in the learning process.

This program also sends a message to the student that maintaining their native language is not as important as learning English.

References

Baker, C. (2001). Foundations of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism (5th ed.) Multilingual Matters.

Texas Education Agency. Title III Language Program Definitions. 2009, May 29). Retrieved Oct 22, 2015.

University of Michigan. ELL in Elementary Schools. (2005, Novmber 27) Retrieved Oct 22, 2015

Different Languages, Same Goal: Transitional Bilingual Education. (n.d.). Retrieved October 22, 2015

Fuller, J. (2011, January 15). Bilingual Education:What It Is, and Why and How It Works (or Doesn’t). Retreived October 24, 2015.

Why it is Important to Educators

It is important for us to know all the options of Bilingual Education and each programs' pros and cons. With that knowledge we can make the best educational decision on which instructional practice should be implemented in schools. We must then become advocates for our students through both administrative and legislative means.

TRANSITIONAL BILINGUAL EDUCATION

Sarah, Amy, Keely, Stacey, & Ashley