Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.
Free to try, no credit card requiredWillful Virgin or Do You Have to Be
a Lesbian to Be a Feminist?
QUESTION
Do you think that Marilyn Frye is right to say that close relationships with men are cause for less radical reform? Do you think that her theory discourages heterosexual women, or those othered by her theory, from becoming more active in the feminist community?
Bibliography
"Department of Philosophy." Department of Philosophy. Michigan State University, n.d. Web. 08 Aug. 2016. <http://
www.philosophy.msu.edu/people/faculty/marilynfrye/>
"Quote of the Day: Marilyn Frye - The Progressive Pub." The Progressive Pub. N.p., 16 July 2015. Web. 09 Aug. 2016. <http://the-
orbit.net/progpub/2015/07/16/quote-of-the-day-marilyn-frye/>
"CSWIP: The Canadian Society for Women in Philosophy." CSWIP. N.p., 2011. Web. 07 Aug. 2016. <http://cswip.ca/index.php/
events/295/>
Frye, Marilyn. "Marilyn Frye Quote." A-Z Quotes. N.p., n.d. Web. 09 Aug. 2016. <http://www.azquotes.com/quote/962441>
Frye, Marilyn. “Willful Virgin or Do You Have to Be a Lesbian to Be a Feminist?” Theorizing Feminisms. Hackett, Elizabeth;
Haslanger, Sally. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2006. 325-332. Print.
"The Best Songs About Being Single and Happy." About.com Dating & Relationships. N.p., 1 Mar. 2016. Web. 09 Aug. 2016. <http://
dating.about.com/od/datingprep/qt/readerbeingsinglesongs.htm>
Twitter. N.p., n.d. Web. 07 Aug. 2016. <https://twitter.com/marriagegoais>
Mae, Lucien. "Hawaii Considers Same-sex Marriage Bill in Special Legislative Session." Dot429. N.p., 28 Oct. 2013. Web. 09 Aug.
2016. <http://dot429.com/articles/3341-hawaii-considers-same-sex-marriage-bill-in-special-legislative-session>
How Can the Theory be Improved?
The theory can be improved by considering ways that groups who are not women can advocate feminism without patriarchal influence (LGBTQ individuals, those experiencing racial discrimination, etc.).
The theory can address ways in which marriage does not subordinate women to the point that women cannot protest their beliefs. The inclusion of non-traditional couples such as those who do not identify as any gender, as well as same-sex marriages where patriarchal ideals do not govern the couple will better the theory.
Strength of the Arguments Continued
In her essay, Marilyn questions if "you can fuck without losing your virginity?" (Frye, 331), later stating: "I think everything is against it, but it's not my call" (Frye, 331).
Marilyn's second statement, acknowledging it is an opinion, alleviates the ability to fight over her statement. She understands that her opinion is not necessarily correct for everyone and that there may be other ways to allow men in one's life without losing the relentlessness that comes with less personal associations with the patriarchy. The way she states "'but it's not my call'" (Frye, 331), can alleviate the humbleness that comes from acknowledging she might be wrong, but how this comment is meant to be understood is up to interpretation.
From Theory to Social Praxis
Marilyn Frye gives examples of how women can live Virgin lives as a way to oppose the stereotypical woman's roles.
These Virgins refuse to enter the institution of marriage, do not support or witness the weddings of others" (Frye, 331).
"They do not pressure their daughters or their mothers, sisters, friends or students to relate to men in the ways they do" (Frye, 331).
"They create value and they create meaning, so when the pressures to conform to patriarchal female heterosexuality are great, they have a context and community of resistance to sustain them" (Frye, 331).
Strength of the Arguments
Presentation by: Taylor Rieger
Class: Sociology 312
Professor: Lori Walker
"Their imagination and their politics are shaped more fundamentally by a desire to empower women and create friendship and solidarity among women than by a commitment to appease, comfort or change men" (Frye, 331).
Regardless, if a person completely embodies her ideas, Marilyn Frye's arguments can challenge people to defy expectations and to not worry about social obligations. They allow for question of the roles women are forced to fill. She continually mentions that what she is writing is her opinion, built from her own experiences.
Coincidentally, the challenge she poses, to defy expectations, can cause people to not identify as feminist or act upon their beliefs due to Frye's doubt of them achieving any substantial change.
Problems Addressed
The main problem addressed by the essay is the control of women by patriarchal ideals of heterosexual women. This includes women's duty to serve and agree with men, particularly their husbands. By redefining the terms lesbian and Virgin, Marilyn Frye attempts to free women from the confines of their roles and expectations. The goal is to free women, allowing them to achieve individual desires.
Opposition Continued
It is posed that in order to be a feminist who is unafraid of aggravating men, one must be a lesbian- someone who is unattached to males on a level that forces conformity or loyalty. As it cannot be said that an entire group can or cannot do something, it is incorrect to say that heterosexual women cannot be ruthless feminists. The essay also does not address that men and people who do not identify as male or female can be active participants in the feminist community. The essay is written by a radical feminist who does not consider the fact that people who are passionate about feminism might not fit into the mold which radical feminism has adopted, a lesbian (homosexual) woman.
Naturalizing Female Sexuality
Social institutions have begun naturalizing female sexuality as complacent and loyal to men. These guidelines are thought to maintain women's natural sexuality, which is to give birth and provide for children. Those who oppose their "natural sexuality" are not giving way to "the power relations which are expressed and maintained by the institutions of female heterosexuality in patriarchal cultures" (Frye, 329). Opposing this constructed sexuality can allow for freedom from relationships and obligations.
Virgin
Society considers a Virgin a person who has not had sexual contact. According to Frye, a Virgin is not actually what modern society considers a Virgin, but instead it is a woman living her life on her own with no direct influence by a man.
Lesbian
The essay proposes that heterosexuality is dictated by patriarchal ideals about women's actions and desires. A lesbian is a woman who outright rejects these historic ideals, substituting her own.
Traditionally, Virgin is defined as "not betrothed, not married, not bound to, not possessed by any man" (Frye, 330). This is the definition Marilyn Frye uses throughout her essay to explain women's independence from men.
The definition of ourselves is not static and one is not always considered a lesbian by rejecting patriarchal ideals. It is the labeling of ourselves that causes and maintains that women who promote feminism are lesbians.
Picture: http://dating.about.com/od/datingprep/qt/readerbeingsinglesongs.htm
"So long as we do not actively, perversely and obstinately create ourselves, lesbians are impossible" (Frye, 330).
Opposing Arguments
The essay, as a whole, seems to oppose the institution of marriage. Historically marriages has been male dominated, but with women and men in less traditional roles, I do not think it is correct to expel marriage in all cases as there are instances where women are not bound by the ideals of their partners, even instances where marriage does not involve a man. In this case a man cannot use his position in the marriage to overpower and force his wife to conform to his ideals and practices.
Picture Top: https://twitter.com/marriagegoais
Picture Bottom: http://dot429.com/articles/3341-hawaii-considers-same-sex-marriage-bill-in-special-legislative-session
Summary
Feminist or Lesbian?
The essay, Willful Virgin or Do You Have to Be a Lesbian to Be a Feminist? by Marilyn Frye, discusses the stereotypes of the modern feminist. It deals with non-traditional definitions of the words lesbian and Virgin and how women can embody these definitions. One of its main topics is how to embody these definitions in ways that promote individual thought and autonomy rather than succumbing to the patriarchal expectation of heterosexual women.
Traditionally it is thought that women who promote women's rights are automatically considered lesbians. Betraying heterosexual female ideals causes this stereotype because women are no longer fulfilling traditional expectations of how women are meant to act. This can be summarized by a quote from Willful Virgin or do you Have to Be a Lesbian to Be a Feminist?: "a woman who is feminist or does anything or betrays any attitude or desire which expresses her autonomy and deviance from conventional femininity is a lesbian" (Frye, 326).
Marilyn Frye
Marilyn Frye Continued
Picture: http://www.azquotes.com/quote/962441
Strengths of the Argument
Frye uses the fact that all people have individual thought to promote women to rely on themselves without fear of male opinion or approval. She advocates personal approval over anything else that can influence action.
The use of the traditional definition of the word "Virgin" works in favour of Frye's argument. The definition is reputable and her theology builds off of it in a way that not only supports, but advocates non-traditional female roles such as independent thinkers and single women and non-mothers.
http://www.philosophy.msu.edu/people/faculty/marilynfrye/
http://www.philosophy.msu.edu/people/faculty/marilynfrye/
http://cswip.ca/index.php/events/295/
Picture: http://the-orbit.net/progpub/2015/07/16/quote-of-the-day-marilyn-frye/
By: Marilyn Frye
Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.
Free to try, no credit card required