Revision in Creative Writing

JC
by John Chrisman0 views·Updated Dec 10, 2013
Powered by AI

Need to present on this topic?

Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.

Free to try, no credit card required

Transcript

I don’t think workshops, in school, is a great place for idea generating sort of stuff, but… most of my idea movement comes from people that we talk outside of school. Mostly that’s because I feel like the idea generation is a very vulnerable stage and so you have to share with people that you trust.”

“Some people really get you, and really get your stuff and so you know that they would be a really good reader for you.”

Quotes

“Some people [in workshop] I trust their opinion, um, mostly I trust people’s opinion that I’ve worked with more and that I’ve read their stuff…. If I respect your writing I’ll respect your comments better because then I’m like, wait, you might know what you’re talking about.”

Data

  • Revision relies heavily on feedback from others
  • Only certain groups/individuals are "qualified" to give feedback
  • Workshop feedback is least trusted
  • Writers' Groups are most trusted

My Study

  • Took place over 2 months
  • Conducted several interviews with 1 writer
  • Followed 1 text through a workshop session and subsequent out-of-school feedback

Why study Creative Writing?

Revision and Creative Writing

Conclusions/Implications

  • CW is basically unstudied
  • There's a lot to learn
  • CW is a significant % of English Students
  • CW students are specifically in school to learn how to write
  • Composition can learn from CW
  • Workshops and Peer Review

Peer Review

John Chrisman

1) Don't Promote PR as the only place for useful feedback

2) Keep PR groups stable

3) Nurture interaction between peers beyond just PR

4) Develop investment in peers work over the course of the project

Creative Writing

1) Workshop provides a nice place for somewhat like-minded writers to meet

2) May not be sufficient as the only form of instruction

3) Should focus more on trust building early on

4) Conclusions about a CW course's effectiveness cannot be drawn solely from what happens in the workshop