Send the link below via email or IMCopy
Present to your audienceStart remote presentation
- Invited audience members will follow you as you navigate and present
- People invited to a presentation do not need a Prezi account
- This link expires 10 minutes after you close the presentation
- A maximum of 30 users can follow your presentation
- Learn more about this feature in our knowledge base article
Educator Beliefs and Cultural Knowledge: Implications for Sc
Transcript of Educator Beliefs and Cultural Knowledge: Implications for Sc
A qualitative study that focused on the beliefs of educators. It specifically focused on beliefs related to cultural, linguistics and economic factors of diverse students and families (pg.2)
Why Beliefs Matter
Personal beliefs are powerful filters that shape how a person sees the world, other people and oneself. Beliefs have a stronger influence on behavior than cognitive knowledge and are resistant to change.
Stephanie Onyeador, Bailey Stewart, LaToya Williams
Video: Cultural Competence
Stereotypes lead to discrimination, not just historically, but today
Leads to low expectations and blame on the parents and student
Deficit thinking is a barrier to school reform efforts because educators are less likely to put forth effort if they blame others
Nelson, S. W. and Guerra, P. L. (2013). Educator beliefs and cultural knowledge: Implications for school improvement efforts.
Education Administration Quarterly
, 50 (
Guerra, P. L., & García, S. B. (2004). Deconstructing deficit thinking: Working with educators to create more equitable learning environments.
Education and Urban Society
If a student's cultural norms differ from those taught in school, they have to learn those norms in addition to academic content
Educators might assume that a student with different cultural norms is just not intelligent or well-behaved
Lack of cultural knowledge reinforces deficit thinking!
Break into groups of 4 or 5
Read the scenario
Answer the question (there are no right or wrong answers)
Nine scenarios involving a culture clash and some element of schooling (teacher-student relationship, instruction, curriculum, etc.) were given to the educators for their responses (qualitative approach)
Scenarios were based on real events reported to the researchers by educators
Measured educator beliefs, educator cultural knowledge, and application of that cultural knowledge in practice
Out of 111 educators...
Ineffectiveness of reform efforts may be due in part to educators' deficit beliefs and lack of cultural knowledge
Preparation and professional development programs must better address this issue.
Adds to the small existing body of current literature on beliefs of current educators
Examines the application of cultural knowledge in practice
Participants were 111 educators in Texas and Michigan
The educators responded to scenarios relating to the education of diverse students
Three (3%) - Culturally Aware
Forty-nine (44%) - General Awareness of Culture
Forty-three (39%) - Little Awareness of Culture
Fifteen (14%) - Culturally Unaware
One (>1%) - Culturally Responsive
Used a constructivist grounded theory approach
Coded beliefs as deficit or pluralistic
Coded cultural knowledge on a scale from "no awareness" to "deep understanding" of invisible culture
Coded application as additive or subtractive
Beliefs- deeply personal, individual truths one holds about physical and social reality and about self (pg.6)
Deficit thinking- refers to the notion that particularly low income minority students fail in school because these students and their families experiences deficiencies that obstruct their learning process (lack of intelligence, lack of motivation)
Cultural competence- ability to interact effectively with people of different cultural and socioeconomic backgrounds
Educator preparation- skills and knowledge for creating a safe environment that encourages learning, positive social interaction, and effective communication among students of diverse gender, ability, culture, language, race, ethnicity, and sexual orientation
When personal beliefs and professional knowledge conflict, personal beliefs will override professional knowledge.
Majority of the participants held deficit beliefs about diverse students and their families
Student teachers enter the field with attitudes not conducive to working with children of color in low-socioeconomic communities
Practicing educators tend to hold deficit beliefs about diverse students and families
Educators often have insufficient cultural knowledge to recognize and respond to culture clashes
Sample population: Excluded data from Michigan due to politics