Tourist Oriented Prostitution in Barbados

AC
by Alanna Cawston67 views·Updated Oct 28, 2014
Powered by AI

Need to present on this topic?

Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.

Free to try, no credit card required

Transcript

Tourist Oriented Prostitution in Barbados

How do male tourist-orientated prostitutes in Barbados deal with issues of gender identification and negotiation between the white female tourist and the black “beach boy”? This will help us understand how these actors conceptualize their situation.

Summary of arguments:

  • Male tourist-orientated prostitution is based on a quest for the sexual other
  • This quest is structured along racial and gendered lines, where white emancipated Western female goes in search of these quintessential hypersexual black male
  • White women play dual roles, breadwinner provide economic/financial support and care/emotional support
  • Black men are denied economic/social/cultural success because of colonial pasts
  • White women provide opportunities denied to these men based on their race such as cultural definitions of masculinity affirmed, status, material goods and independence
  • Men use traditional roles of hypersexualized black man, drawing upon their African Ancestry, untamed primitive nature and extoic appeal, to attract white women tourists

Strengths

1. Phillips does a great job using first hand testimonials of the beach hustlers and the white women. This gives us an inside perspective of the black prostitution phenomena in Barbados.

2. Phillips provides us a concrete understanding of the relationship between the hustlers and the white women, this helps us fully conceptualize the relationship between the two.

Weaknesses

1. She lacks testimonials from the white women, this can lead her research to become very biased and one sided.

2. Philips lacked in giving any suggestions on improving the situation for young black men in Barbados.

New Directions of Research:

1. How white women and hustler marriages affect the women back in their countries of origin, in particular family relations.

2. Looking at Barbados’ social structure and understanding the dynamics between the classes and genders.

Questions for the Class....

1. What do you think causes Barbados to have larger numbers of male prostitute then other countries of similar socioeconomic status?

2.What are some of the aspects that Phillips discusses that make beach hustlers so appealing to white women?How does beach hustling help promote marginalized mens statuses in Barbados’ society?

3. White women are usually seen as innocent and pure, why do you think the Barbados men refer to them as much more “adventurous” than the native women of Barbados? How does this affect stereotypes we usually come across?

Sexual Regulation and Sex Work

Research Question:

Why prostitution in our time is considered to be a problem and for whom (police, media, feminists, residence)? This will allow us to understand how prostitution becomes a visible and regulatory social problem.

Summary....

  • State, citizens, and media play important role in defining/ identifying prostitution
  • Subjected to special regulation, distinct from other indoor businesses, subjected to moral regulation
  • Prostitutes prevented from entering into discourses that determine their work and construct their identities ( simply a social problem).
  • Decriminalization will allow prostitutes to have more control over their work and not be controlled by pimps or the police.
  • There are widely held perceptions, ie. sinner, sexual deviant, lead prostitution to become a social problem
  • Prostitutes have practical consciousness about how organize lives, refuse to be poor, maintain control over working conditions.

Strengths

  • Brock includes many dialogues within the article which helps to give an in depth and well rounded understanding of the social and economic issues present in the sex trade industry.
  • Brock does a great job highlighting the different areas that contribute to the stigmatization of prostitution (state, citizens and media).

Weaknesses

- Brock does not include perspective for other workers in the sex trade (i.e pimps).

-Does not look at men in prostitution or minority (more specifically aboriginal) woman.

New Directions for Research

  • Further analyze how Aboriginal women are affected by the sex trade industry and how being a minority individual makes a woman more prone to filling the stereotype of being more likely to fall into this line of work?
  • Researching further information, and comparing and contrasting the differences between men and women in the sex trade industry.

Questions for the Class.....

1. What can be done to address why prostitution becomes an occupational choice for individuals today? Would changing these factors have a smaller or larger impact than making prostitution legal on decreasing the number of those involved?

2. How would giving the woman the ability to leave the ‘business’ freely and without a criminal record change the industry?

3. If prostitution was decriminalized how would this benefit prostitutes? How would this affect safety and morale? Also, if decriminalized how would this benefit society as whole, especially economically?

Research Question...