Copy of Twin Studies

BZ
作者:Brittany Zeo0 次观看·更新于 2014年11月30日
由 AI 提供支持

需要就此主题进行演示?

在几分钟内创建您自己的精美演示文稿。只需描述您的需求。

免费试用,无需信用卡

文本

Doing an experiment for this would be difficult because of the nature of the experiment.

If I had to do research it would be qualitative correlational experiment with the largest sample possible to make it as accurate as one can.

The problem would be the ethical issues that go along with doing an experiment of this nature.

Amy

My hypothesis

Beth

Jewish home

lower class

brother was athletic, successful etc.

family values:

academic success

simplicity

tradition

emotional restraint

I hypothesize that reared apart MZ twins have a higher correlation than originally thought.

I think that things like health and personality have influence from genes and not completely reliable on the environment.

Jewish home

higher class

brother had a learning disability

family values:

materialistic

not academic

Ethical issues

Amy was treated like a rejected child

Beth was treated like a princess in her family

Separating twins at birth

Psychological harm to people

You alter people's lives forever

Someone could have lived a completely different life

The case of the Jims

Jim s

Jim L

characteristics:

nail biter

bed wetter

hypochondriac

school trouble

life events:

dog named Toy

married twice

first to Linda

second to Betty

sons name is James Allen

work:

gas station

sheriff

personality/quirks:

chain-smoked Salems

life events:

dog named Toy

married twice

first to Linda

second to Betty

sons name is Allen

work:

gas station

sheriff

personality/quirks:

chain-smoked Salems

characteristics:

nail biter

bed wetter

hypochondriac

school trouble

Every summer, they both drove their family down to Florida in light blue Chevy's from Ohio to Pas-grille Beach for vacation

(Wright, L. (1997))

(Kaplan & Sadock (1999))

(Wright, L. (1997))

Correlation Inheritance

France

into fine arts

112 on IQ test

Wealthier

slim

tall

U.S.

Conclusion

Nature or nurture?

into fine arts

129 on IQ test

only did worse in 2 out of 15 categories of IQ test

on verbal comprehension, reasoning, memory processing speed and IQ, consitantly 10 points higher

slim

tall

Which of these do you think are hereditary?

  • Mental illness
  • Personality
  • Appearance (hair color, eye color etc.)
  • IQ
  • Physical condition
  • Health
  • Language

Showing how closely related two things are

Twins are good for studying this because MZ twins share the same genes with each other

So in theory MZ twins should have a higher correlation than DZ twins

When you rear apart people though, their environments are different so there are different things affecting their socialization

(Segel, N. (2014))

(Segel, N. (2014))

77 Years spent apart

almost identical personalities

average of twins reared apart for an IQ test is 7 - 14 points.

Two twins, one raised by the biological mother were separated close to birth.

One dropped out of school to work

They were of similar body type

IQs were in the range but not as close as usual

IQs are not controlled by the environment

In the personality tests, they were almost identical in everything

Personalities are not supposed to be genetic

(Segel, N. (2015))

The Nature Vs. Nurture Debate

2 for nature (Jims and Beth and Amy)

2 for nurture (U.S. and France and 2 women who spent

77 years separated)

There is no right answer

There is supporting evidence for both sides of the debate

Reared apart MZ twins are going to have a lower

correlation than reared together MZ twins.

The study would not be able to be

reproduced today so we cannot

get new evidence

The debate of Nature vs Nurture is defined according to Simplypsychology as "a debate within psychology [that] is concerned with the extent to which particular aspects of behavior are a product either inherited or acquired characteristics."

I am studying the debate by using twin studies to determine what aspects of someone's life is either predetermined by genetics or influenced by the environment.

Twins are good subjects for this debate because when they are reared apart, they have the same genes but are influenced by different factors of the environment. This allows us to see just what aspects are inherited or influenced.

This also allows us to take a side of nature or nurture or stay neutral.

Controlled by environment

physical condition

health

language

personality

(Englbrecht, C.)

Controlled by genes

hair color

eye color

IQ

blood type

height

(Englbrecht, C.)

Twin Studies

by Brittany Zeo