The Internet belongs to everyone. Let’s keep it that way.

Protect Net Neutrality
Loading presentation...

Present Remotely

Send the link below via email or IM

Copy

Present to your audience

Start remote presentation

  • Invited audience members will follow you as you navigate and present
  • People invited to a presentation do not need a Prezi account
  • This link expires 10 minutes after you close the presentation
  • A maximum of 30 users can follow your presentation
  • Learn more about this feature in our knowledge base article

Do you really want to delete this prezi?

Neither you, nor the coeditors you shared it with will be able to recover it again.

DeleteCancel

Anti-Trafficking Philanthropy: A Cautionary Tale

No description
by

SWAN Vancouver Society

on 14 November 2017

Comments (0)

Please log in to add your comment.

Report abuse

Transcript of Anti-Trafficking Philanthropy: A Cautionary Tale


Anti-Trafficking Philanthropy Red Flags
To continue this discussion or learn more about
critical perspectives of the anti-trafficking rescue industry, contact

SWAN Vancouver Society







info@swanvancouver.ca
604 719 6343
www.swanvancouver.ca
Facebook: Swan_Vancouver
Twitter: SwanVancouver
Anti-Trafficking
Philanthrophy
is BIG business.
Anti-Trafficking Philanthropy: A Cautionary Tale

SWAN Vancouver Society
November 2017

Anti-trafficking is BIG business.

"The provincial government did not break down how the
$72-million will be spent. " Globe and Mail June 30, 2016
Sensational stories that generate sympathy combine with ignorance so pervasive that so long as you put trafficking in the title of your wild claims, you can get away with anything. People throw money at this issue.
governments
anti-sex work organizations
faith-based organizations
NGOs
police
others
Who profits?
March 2015 Hycroft Manner/University Women's Club
Anti-sex work/Anti-trafficking donations ask: $10 000
Tonight's Take Away

"Circumspection. The exploitation of the girls at COSA occurred because its director learned early on that sensationalizing the stories of those he sheltered increased donations. The media abetted his success by failing to do due diligence in their investigative reporting. And unsuspecting donors unwittingly supported a man engaging in very questionable practices that hurt young girls. We are all complicit and need to avoid falling into such traps."
Anti-trafficking philanthropy is largely aimed at milking the privileged classes' feelings of guilt and pity.
What do we hope people take away
from this film?
The Wrong Light Producer Susan Maclaury,
sex trafficking - sex workers & sex worker rights orgs
labour trafficking- migrant workers & migrant rights orgs
Can the organization give a detailed breakdown of what the
money supports?
Does the money go to domestic or international raids and 'rescues'?
Is the money sent overseas?
How much time has been spent considering unintended consequences or collateral damage?
Thank you
Does the anti-trafficking initiative address all types of
human trafficking or just 'sex trafficking'?
Does the anti-trafficking initiative collaborate with those working on the ground in those fields?
Does the anti-trafficking initiative have an evidence base or does it rely on a base of graphic, violent, or 'sexy' images and stories?
But what are we saying?
Does human trafficking exist?
YES
Should police, governments, NGOs, faith-based groups & others fundraise and/or work to address it?
YES
However, when it comes to anti-trafficking initiatives, we ask for


informed, responsible & ethical advocacy
healthy skepticism
prudent & circumspect charitable giving
But...how will you know?
Operation Northern Spotlight
October 2017: $$$$$/53 police agencies/14 arrests/unclear how many cases will actually go to trial
While these factors are not always necessarily a bad thing ,
in some cases they can be cause for concern.
Anti-Trafficking
Philanthropy
Red Flags
We are accustomed to seeing human trafficking indicators/red flags in 'training toolkits', which have come to include everything from having a STI, difficulty establishing or maintaining healthy relationships, texting to substance misuse. 'Training toolkits' neglect to point out these red flags could indicate many issues that are not human trafficking. Furthermore, it is unclear the extent to which these red flags are based on empirical evidence of human trafficking.
The following list turns the idea of 'red flags' on its head in order to raise awareness about the well-meaning but sometimes inadvertent harms of anti-trafficking philanthropy. We hope this list encourages people to be thoughtful about the anti-trafficking causes and organizations they support by inspiring healthy skepticism that encourages extra research and that extra question.
*Red flag
Full transcript