Journalism Prezi

CR
by Chris Rostrom4 views·Updated Mar 14, 2011
Powered by AI

Need to present on this topic?

Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.

Free to try, no credit card required

Transcript

Technology Creates New Public Forum

-Faster

-Less control over information

-Audience feedback

-Faster

Daily Kos posting on February 11, 2006 “WaPo’s Jim Brady is still a wanker.” referring to Jim Brady, the executive director of WashingtonPost.com, who decided to shut down comments on a Post blog in response to reader reactions Brady deemed obscene.

 

“Brady’s a GOP gasbag and stooge who’s merely clone of Bill Keller of the NY Times, who’s also well-known for his hostility toward bloggers.” How should journalists react to this kind of vocabulary and innuendo?

O’Reilly, Limbaugh, Keith Olbermann,

or Air America are not offering debate.

They’re promising answers.

Journalist Roles

  • Opinion helps people make sense of information.
  • Do you believe that?

-Report with details of scheduled events

-Disclose wrongdoing

-Outline developing trends

-Analyze issues and events

-Provide context

-Editorial comment (columnists)

-"It is crucial that the news media play the role of honest broker and referee as it carries the common discussion...[and] decipher the spin and lies of commercialized argument, lobbying and political propaganda" p.167

*Help community to find resolutions, through reporting on compromise

Michael Crichton's Argument Culture

Michael Crichton's "Crossfire Syndrome"

"We are all assumed these days to reside at one extreme of the opinion spectrum or another... but in the real world, few of us hold these extreme views. There is instead a spectrum of opinion."

"We are all assumed these days to reside at one extreme of the opinion spectrum or another.... but in the real world, few of us hold these extreme views. There is instead a spectrum of opinion."

  • Pro-abortion or anti-abortion
  • Free traders or protectionist
  • Pro-private sector or pro-big government
  • Feminists or chauvinists
  • Pro-abortion or anti-abortion
  • Free traders or protectionist
  • Pro-private sector or pro-big government
  • Feminists or chauvinists

More Public Discussion?

  • New media forum doesn't necessarily expand the scope of public discussion
  • Media outlets focus on a "narrow range of blockbuster stories"
  • This means many important concerns facing the nation are left out of public discussion, leaving disasterous social consequences
  • As journalists what can you do to include more in the public discussion?

Journalism as a Public Forum

Ancient Public Forums

  • A good example of this is Greece

Handout and Candy Drawing

  • Fill out the handout
  • Discuss with your neighbor
  • On the index card list one idea you have on how to portray a story in a non-polarizing yet effective manner
  • Put your name on the index card
  • Turn it in to win big candy

John Stewart v. Crossfire

In Reality...

Potential Problems

In Theory... 

  • Just a refresher
  • End of "winner and loser" shows in the Argument Culture
  • Spin replaces verification..."Right becomes a matter of who has the greatest might, wattage, or rhetorical skill" (pg 168).
  • Responsibility of verification forfeit..."The live interview format, as any newsmaker will happily acknowledge, cedes power to the interviewee. The guest controls what they say, with broad power to filibuster, mislead, or even lie" (pg 168).
  • Are you more likely to believe a qualified journalist or an eye witness?
  • "The technological argument is the digital equivalent of tyranny, not freedom. Rather than liberated, we become captive to the technology. The job of the journalist becomes simply to make sure the technology is functioning" (pg 169).

Authentic rather than posed debate..."Now we can let the journalist mediator get out of the way, and let the debate occur in the genuine public square, not the artificial one defined by NBC or CBS news" (pg 168).

A shift in verification..."technology will free those who produce the news from having to exercise judgment and responsibility...we can rely on the marketplace of facts and ideas, not on journalists, to sort out the truth" (pg 168).

Forum Open to All

-Radio Call-in Shows

-TV Talk Shows

-Editorial Pages

-Blogs

-Chat rooms

-Public Polling

Example: Hardball Chris Matthews accuses Chris Shearer of stalking a lady.  Death threats.

Michael Scott's opinion on YouTube

Wikipedia

Alex, Chris, Jessica, and Shayla

  • Allows articles to be created and modified by multiple people
  • Philosophy: "factual errors inserted by one user will be caught and changed by another" (pg. 169)
  • John L. Seigenthaler example
  • Have you ever heard of an inaccurate account from wikipedia? 
  • Do you agree that it shouldn't be allowed as a source for school papers?

Potential Problems

-False information

-Inappropriate information

-Defamation

Conclusion 

Discussion question 

"The worry is not the wondrous addition of citizen media, but the decline of full-time, professional monitoring of powerful institutions." (Kovach & Rosenstiel, 184-5)

 

So what's a journalist to do? 

"A newspaper that fails to reflect it's community deeply will not succeed. But a newspaper that does not challenge its community’s values and preconceptions will lose respect for failing to provide the honesty and leadership that newspapers are expected to offer" (Kovach & Rosenstiel, 180).

 

Where’s the happy medium? What can we as journalists do to satisfy both elements?

1. Make sure that the forum adheres to other journalistic standards.

2. Recognize the role of compromise in democratic society.

3. Engage the audience.

"As rich and empty as the new forums may be, depending on the posting, they cannot supplant the search for fact and context that the traditional journalism of verfication supplies. If those who gather and then deliver the news no longer spend the time and money to report and verify and synthesize--if they fear that applying judgment is an act of elitism, or that the technology now frees them of these old burdens--then cyberspace chatter is all we are left with" (Kovach & Rosenstiel, 184).

 

Michelle Peralta story http://universe.byu.edu/node/13756  

 

Jade McDowell’s response http://universe.byu.edu/node/13833 

Technology Creates New Public Forum

THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.