Stakeholder management:

JW
by Joe Walker21 views·Updated Jun 3, 2014
Powered by AI

Need to present on this topic?

Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.

Free to try, no credit card required

Transcript

Where we are today

Prioritise

Identify

Understand

Manage

What we propose -

Fairness

The Borussia

Dortmund Model

Are we Dodge or are we Ford?

  • After an embarrassing early exit from the European Championships in 2000, German football had reached a crisis point
  • Clubs throughout the country were forced to rethink strategy and a nationwide overhaul of the current system ensued
  • German clubs went through a transition period, none more so than Dortmund
  • In 2010, Germany came third in the FIFA World Cup after defeating England 4-1 and Argentina 4-0
  • But, what does this mean for Newcastle United and it's loyal stakeholders?

Are we Ryanair or are we Southwest?

Stakeholder management:

Conclusion and recommendations

1980s &1990s

Early 21st Century

Newcastle United F.C

Current decade

Current decade

Stakeholder influence and organisational change

Premier League forms

Prioritise

Identify

Understand

Manage

Understand

Prioritise

Understand

Identify

Manage

Prioritise

Identify

Manage

Prioritise

Understand

Identify

Manage

1920s & 1930s

For Sale

For Sale

For Sale

Early 20th Century

1950s

1940s

Inter-City Fairs Cup winners

1960s & 1970s

Promotion #3

Promotion #4

Kevin Keegan

WWI

WWII

  • Premier League Runners-Up
  • £15m world record signing

The John Hall years

The Ashley years

Promotion #5

Promotion #1

  • Joe Kinnear is appointed Director of Football
  • Derek Llambias resigns
  • Mike Ashley takes over as Chairman

Promotion #2

Understand

Prioritise

Identify

Manage

Hughie Gallacher joins NUFC

Newcastle United F.C established

Theory suggests that while a fairness approach is more effective in attracting, retaining and motivating reciprocal stakeholders to create value, an arms-length approach is more effective in motivating self-regarding stakeholders with high bargaining power

Promotion #6

Aims and objectives

Farewell Kevin Keegan

  • Relegation from Premier League
  • Alan Shearer leaves and is replaced temporarily by Chris Hughton
  • Dennis Wise appointed Director of Football
  • Llambias replaces Chris Mort as chairman

Advocacy

Bobby Robson becomes manager

The Joe Harvey

years

Andy Carroll leaves NUFC for Liverpool - £35m

Advocacy

Club is no longer for sale after failing to find a buyer

November 2013

Return of the glory years

New manager: Kevin Keegan

  • Discuss the historical development of Newcastle, focusing on crucial events, crises and successes
  • Identify key stakeholder groups and critically analyse their ability to facilitate and block initiatives for change
  • Suggest courses of action for successfully managing Newcastle's stakeholders and a strategy for improving the club on and off the pitch

December

2010

October

2009

February

2009

September

2008

January

2008

October 2012

1948

1910

Fairness

Arms-length

1961

1934

1989

1984

1978

1998

Where we are

1899

1982

1951

1955

1965

1969

1914

2007

1999

1996

1997

1993

1992

1892

1939

Advocacy

Stakeholders

1925

Season End

2009

December

2008

June 2013

January

2011

1903

June

2008

Power/Interest

Matrix

Understand

Manage

Prioritise

Identify

Where we're going

External

Sponsors

Keegan leaves

Fans

Other employees

WONGA.COM deal

Board members

Backroom staff

Internal

National

media

Players

Local

press

Mike Ashley

Season End

2010

Manager

NUFC banned the Chronicle newspaper from its grounds

The start of the

glory years

Governing Bodies

Kinnear gets sick and is replaced by Alan Shearer

  • Club is no longer for sale
  • Attempt to sell naming right of stadium

Relegation #3

Borussia Dortmund

Relegation #4

Although strong season start Chris Hughton is sacked and replaced with Alan Pardew

Relegation #2

  • Keegan resigns
  • Joe Kinnear appointed as manager

Relegation #1

Relegation #5

  • Organizational practices such as an open and honest exchange of relevant information and an inclination to resolve problems through collaboration;
  • Formal contracts not detailed because stakeholders tend to rely to large extent on trust and self-enforcement;
  • Relationships with stakeholders are long-lasting

NUFC return to

top-flight football

A shift from the 'short-termism'

  • Organizational practices such as use of secrecy and information asymmetries in the firm’s favor, playing stakeholders off against each other to weaken their bargaining position;
  • Reliance on economic and legal sanctions to enforce obligations ;
  • Short-term relationships

Youth development and coaching: a overhaul

Fans are not a commodity

FA Cup victory

over Barnsley

  • Poor financial management led to a heavy debt-load
  • Westfalenstadion sold and renamed after a local insurance firm
  • €2m loaned from Munich to make payroll payments
  • Share price plummeted by 80%
  • A series of short-term managers throughout the proceeding seasons, culminating in a 13th place finish in the Bundesliga in 2007/8

Fans are not a

commodity

King Kev returns

  • A complete overhaul of the German coaching philosophy
  • Former legends assumed coaching positions
  • Academy strategically placed next to Westfalenstadion
  • Home-grown talent and integrated scouting network cuts wages
  • 17 of 26 man squad are German - homegrown core
  • Jurgen Klopp appointed in 2008: implemented a progressive, sustainable approach
  • Instilled the philosophy of growing (U23s) and buying young, cheap and hungry players
  • Given freedom to manage without pressures of a hyper-critical, patriarchal board despite mediocre start
  • 50+1 structure - 51% of shares owned by club members
  • Board members are selected by shareholders, giving fans a voice in club decisions
  • Match tickets for all members of the community - €8.95
  • Keeps club deeply rooted in the local community

Antagonism

The Borussia way

Newcastle United

Youth development

& coaching:

a overhaul

Antagonism

Antagonism

  • Ashley must segregate himself from footballing decisions
  • Given Pardew can adapt and lead effectively, he should be given the opportunity to see out his remaining 7 years
  • Clear communication to the fans is essential. They must be patient and acknowledge their club is in transition
  • A return to the romanticised, football club ideology
  • Fan appointed board members with fan interests at heart
  • Season ticket price freeze a move in the right direction
  • A move away from the 'give with one hand, take with the other' philosophy
  • Re-establish NUFC as a means for community good: freedom of Tyne press, local sponsors, local investment

A shift from the

'short-termism'

of football

  • Ashley's reign littered with embarrassing financial management
  • St. James' Park renamed the Sports Direct Arena in a controversial move, later to be reversed
  • 13th - average league finish during Ashley's 6 year reign
  • Relegated to Championship in 2009
  • Short-term manager culture a component of the Ashley years
  • A complete overhaul of the football philosophy
  • Grassroots investment in local schools, academy facilities, coaching staff, youth scout network
  • Introduction of NUFC legends such as Alan Shearer, Peter Beardsley and Paul Gascoigne to coaching staff
  • A move away from expensive transfers to homegrown talent

'What is a club in any case? Not the buildings or the directors or the people who are paid to represent it. It’s not the television contracts, get-out clauses, marketing departments or executive boxes.

It’s the noise, the passion, the feeling of belonging, the pride in your city.

It’s a small boy clambering up the stadium steps for the very first time, gripping his father’s hand, gawping at that hallowed stretch of turf beneath him, and without being able to do a thing about it, falling in love.'

- Sir Bobby Robson