Evalutation - Lucy Sayers

LS
by Lucy Sayers0 views·Updated Mar 27, 2012
Powered by AI

Need to present on this topic?

Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.

Free to try, no credit card required

Transcript

Evaluation - Lucy Sayers

4.HOW DID YOU USE THE MEDIA TECHNOLOGIES IN THE CONSTRUCTION, RESEARCH, PLANNING AND EVALUATION STAGES?

Research

During the research stage of my coursework I used a number of technologies to help improve my previous knowledge on music video conventions, this would have been impossible if the technology wasn’t available.

At this current time social networking websites such as Facebook and Twitter are hugely popular amongst young people and adolescents, therefore using these websites enabled my group to gain audience feedback for our music video. We decided on this because Facebook allows you to upload music videos directly from the web, it also enables your online friends to leave positive and negative feedback on the product. The audience feedback we received was crucial in the final editing of our video as we took it all into account before making minor changes.

YouTube was also significantly important in our research stage as it enabled us to have immediate access to any artist in the world in seconds. We took full advantage of this material and spent numerous hours browsing all kinds of musician’s music videos looking for inspiration for our own. We even looked at other students previous videos which are still accessible on the web.

Similarly I predominantly used Google for my research; this allowed me to access thousands of archives such as (http://www.esfmedia.com/page/Key+Concepts+in+Media+Studies) without this I would have struggled to understand some of the key concepts behind the theorists involved in decoding the meaning in music videos. It also aided me to find the conventions of our music video genre. I used Google images to research into other front covers and digipak ideas; we wanted our digipak to be emotive, and therefore looking at other digipaks for artists in the same genre category helped us to pitch an idea together.

‘Wikipedia’ also had a major part in my researching element; it permitted me to explore facts and information from the greatest encyclopaedia in the world. I got to explore terms and definitions of key theorists, such as ‘Goodwin’ in great detail. I did doubt the source due to its unreliability as it is an interactive website open to members of the online public. This resulted in me cross referencing the information I found on Wikipedia with the information I found on Google, so that I could be 100% sure is was reliable.

I posted the first ideas for our music video on a website called ‘vimeo.com’ as it is an unbiased forum which enabled me to ask people about our idea who weren’t friends and family, this then helped me to pitch ideas to the group on ways we could have improved our idea in a much fairer way than if we asked the people in our class.

During the planning process we used various new technologies to help prepare ourselves for the filming process. I used Google maps to browse the satellite images so I could find suitable locations to use, this was very helpful as we changed music videos half way through the construction stage, therefore we were time pressured to plan a new video, which included new filming locations. This modern advancement let me explore into my surroundings from a three dimensional perspective.

I also used YouTube to view other music videos to gain inspiration; this was a vital source for my group, due to the change of video. YouTube enabled us to browse other videos in the same genre as the song we used. Similarly Wikipedia helped my group with the background on the artists we studied. We weren’t that familiar with ‘Christina Perri’ at the beginning after only hearing one song, but after some background research we began to listen to her songs more and more until we found one that fitted our desired narrative structure.

Additionally, we used prezi.com to create zooming presentations that enabled us to layout our research and planning material, for example our storyboards and shot lists. The website overall was a success for our planning as we could present our information in a modern format. Also using blogger.com enabled us to electronically lay out our work and show the step by step plan of our video planning and production. These websites are vital in the current technological advanced world.

Construction

During the construction stage of our video we used various modern technologies, without these it would be near impossible to create a music video. We used a Canon video camera to film all of the moving images. We then used a USB cable to link the camera to a Mac. Despite the camera being relatively old, we managed to film our video with only a few minor problems. One being the battery life, due to the age of the camera the battery life was relatively short and therefore proved filming in distances far away from an electric socket to be difficult. Also, some of the tripods were uneven or damaged and therefore resulted in us having a badly framed shot, we then had to go back out and shoot it again. The modern advancement of video cameras enabled us to have much more well defined images than years before.

Similarly, we used a cannon still camera to take the photographs for our stop motion aspect, this was very time consuming as we had to take hundreds of photographs without moving the tripod, yet moving the note paper tiny little steps so that it looked as professional as possible. The video camera had a number of modern capabilities, for instance zooming distance of 35X optical zoom, this shows major advancement in the equipment used to film music videos today compared to years ago when the zoom was 5X.

We used the editing software ‘Final Cut Express’ to help us make our music video, its designed for the advanced editing of digital video. It’s becoming more and more popular with wider audiences, such as with amateur video producers. The programme itself enabled us to edit and cut the footage we filmed so that it integrated together. We also added a number of effects to our video, for example the echo when the boy screws up the letter, this makes the impact much more emphasised to the audience. We also used fade in, fade out and slow-motion to help us create the desired image we could imagine. We chose to use ‘Final Cut’ because it’s much more advanced than ‘I-Movie’ which is what we used at AS level. This programme enabled us to edit at a higher ability, therefore letting us engage deeper with our audience. It allowed us to explore further into the technological aspects used to create moving images.

During the construction of our ancillary products we used ‘Fireworks Pro’ which enabled us to edit our digipak and advert to make it look as professional as possible. We already had previous experience and knowledge with fireworks, therefore it didn’t take us long to grasp the editing features. Without this programme our digipak would have been extremely difficult to produce as the programme gave us the correct layout and measurements that we needed to produce a six piece product.

Also, we used ‘Garage Band’ to download a piano version of ‘Jar of Hearts,’ we then edited and cropped down the music so that it fitted over our narrative introduction.

Overall all three areas were successful, we only had a few minor issues along the way, one being the website ‘Prezi’ wouldn’t open or let us edit, therefore using it to present our information proved difficult, eventually after the website was updated it worked again.

Evaluating

Finally, the use of media technologies was used in the evaluation stage helped us to gain audience feedback, as we were able to distribute our production piece all over the web.

Websites were once again vital in this stage as we uploaded our music video onto ‘Tumblr’ which is a blog account, this let a whole different audience watch our video. Overall this proved successful as a number of the viewers from Tumblr left comments. After uploading our video to YouTube it took 24 hours for our group to get 91 online views, we found this impressive as that’s 91 different people from all over the globe that have watched our product. I learnt from this that mainstream sites generate lots of popularity which can be broadcasted worldwide; this meant that the internet was a vital source for us as our video was able to travel the globe.

Similarly, I used ‘Microsoft Excel 2007’ to collect the data from my questionnaires; this software enabled me to create a number of graphs which helped me to sort my data into manageable figures.

During the production of our music video we received a lot of audience feedback which we took into account. W e listened to the advice and the criticisms that we received both personally, from questionnaires and anonymously on YouTube. We gained audience feedback at three vital parts of the production, the presentation of our initial ideas, after we had produced the video and the initial ideas for our ancillary products.

We talked to two A-level Media Studies classes to gather a selection of different people and opinions on our music video ideas. Overall the responses we received were very positive and people could see potential in our idea. Our audience seemed to enjoy the stop motion aspect of the narrative as they felt the letter was very “personified.” Our audience were much more positive towards our stop motion, letter narrative than the previous one to ‘Kids’ by MGMT which consisted of two paths of life, the right one and the wrong. They described the narrative as very “cliché” and “stereotypical,” we took these opinions into account when we were coming up with the idea for ‘Jar of Hearts.’

When we spoke to our class group they offered a number of different advice techniques, they suggested that we added the journey of the girl character alongside the journey of the letter, to show a connection between the two. We thought that this was a good idea as it enabled us to show relationships.

Secondly, we showed our music video to both the A2 classes, a sociology class and various subject teachers, this helped us to get specialist and non specialist opinions. We then distributed questionnaires out to our audience so that they could each have an open opinion on our video. Overall they seemed to feel a lot of empathy for our female protagonist; they enjoyed the narrative and the stop motion. The only negative we received was that the voice over needed to be redone, due to sound problems.

Our audience asked us if we could add any more varied technical aspects into our video, we went away and thought about it and decided to have the letter crawl up the fridge, and into a photograph of the girl which then becomes a moving image as the letter crawls into it and follows her.

Overall we were very pleased with the responses to our video as we were looking to create something abstract and dynamic, something that we think we were successful doing. Our biggest critique said that he “didn’t understand how the letter changed locations.” We thought about this and decided to add a serious of photographs of two people talking by a car, totally distracted and therefore oblivious to the letter crawling into the backseat, we then added point of view shots from the letter inside the car as it travels towards the cliffs. The next shot we see is of the letter on the cliff edge, we all agreed that adding this in helped the continuity of the narrative. Similarly he also said that we needed to do the voice over again because the last utterance was unclear, due to time pressures we didn’t edit this, but we have identified this as our weak aspect and overall we think that we have produced a high grade music video.

Finally, after we showed our class our ancillary products the majority of our feedback we received was positive, although we did have some critiques that were confused by our digipak idea. This was because unlike the other groups in our class we hand drew all our ideas rather than digitally drawing them for the first draft. We also took these opinions into account and decided to make a few changes to our outside pages so that an audience who doesn’t know our music video could still relate to it.

The group suggested we did something abstract with the digipak and they advised us to go against “typical” digipak conventions. After processing this we decided to put our track list on the inside, in-between the two discs. This is unusual for a digipak idea. Our media teacher also contributed to the feedback of our ancillary products by suggesting we “change our font so it fits with the rest of the digipak.” Font was difficult during our production stages as we had to download a number of them from the internet as the already existent ones didn’t fit with our work. Similarly a student also said that our advert was “too clumped together and busy,” we improved upon this by removing the quote and making the font smaller, this reduced the word load on the advert.

Similarly, we uploaded our video onto YouTube, so that we could gain feedback from viewers online and therefore people who didn’t know us personally.

From our YouTube results we found aspects of our video appealed to our audience; our most popular would be the use of stop motion. We wanted our audience to enjoy this aspect as its unusual and therefore not expected in a love video. Someone also said “I love the way the letter has a strong representation of love” this is exactly what we hoped the audience would decode; the letter is a representation of the ties between the two people.

HOW EFFECTIVE IS THE COMBINATION OF YOUR MAIN PRODUCTAND THE 2 ANCILLARY TEXTS?

The combination of our main product and ancillary texts linked very closely together which will help establish recognition of the band due to the use of similar imagery.

As a group we have created a strong lace between our main product and our ancillary texts; we did this because we wanted a powerful and hard hitting emotion to be felt from not only our music video but our other products too. I decided it would be a good idea to combine visual aspects from our music video onto our printed productions, for instance we developed our ideas from the flashback scene at the start of our music video where the couple are show to be close and very at ease with each other. We then decided to create a visual opposition to this happy moment and use polaroid photographs hanging on a piece of string in order to show the cracks and separation in the couple’s relationship.

When considering the design for our magazine advert I decided that the best way to fully understand how to create the link was to put myself in the shoes of the audience, that way I was able to suggest that we relate the visual image of our digipak to the image on our magazine advert. We decided to create a collage of pictures of the couple where there body language represented different aspects of their relationship, for instance when they are angry at each other the girl is show with her back turned towards the boy whilst he rests his head on this hands. We then cut these all out and stuck them onto a cardboard heart which we later put on grass and took a photograph, after much playing with different colours we decided the best background suitable would black as it's emotionless just like their relationship in the final stage.

We decided against using any typical fonts like ‘Arial’ as its not as moving for our audience if its traditional and boring, therefore we used a font called ‘Lemon Chicken’ which we downloaded of the internet. This made our album name and advert stand out much more than if we used Arial. At first we only used the font on the advert, but after showing our media teacher she suggested we try it on the digipak as well to create another link between them. We did this and it looked much better.

We originally planned to have a jigsaw piece cut out from the cardboard heart to signify the stolen piece but after much debating we all decided that the heart looked much better completely full just like it used to be. Our aim was to create a message that people will come and go throughout your life, heartbreak is natural and nobody is worth hurting yourself over. S.Halls theory suggests that the message behind a text is not the same for everyone, he believes that everyone decodes texts differently, you either accept all and therefore are dominant, you accept some but not all and are then negotiated and you accept none of it and are oppositional. We took this theory into account when producing our texts as we wanted there to be a preferred meaning which is stated above but we also wanted the audience to choose how they read our text.

The photographs used on our advert act as a signifier for the artist, simply because we also used them on our digipak. This enabled us to create a continuous link across each text so that the audience understand they are all part of the same promotional package.

During the production stage of our ancillary products we only had a few minor problems. We started off by hand drawing a rough mock-up of various ideas in which we imaged our digipak. We chose our favourite aspects of each idea and combined them to produce our final version. We attempted three times to take the photos for the string line which the photographs hang on, each time it was near impossible to get the string in line for three different photographs. Eventually we decided to try a final time, we used a plain white background and two people held the string either ends of the white board and the other person took the photographs. We decided that if our third time failed we would have to think of a new idea quickly as we were pressured for time. We put the pictures on the Mac and to our delight they all fitted perfectly inline.

Finally, we presented our promotional advert and digipak to the other students, the response we received was very positive. This proved that we were successful in our initial target of producing two ancillary texts that were noticeably connected to our music video. The audience agreed that our products was much more affective connected to the video as it allowed them to understand the connection between the three.

IN WHAT WAYS DOES YOUR MUSIC VIDEO USE, DEVELOP OR CHALLENGE THE FORMS AND CONVENTIONS OF MUSIC VIDEO?

I started off by researching existing videos from the pop genre in which our song ‘Jar of Hearts’ by Christina Perri originated from. I then began to watch videos that had an element of stop motion to them, for example ‘End Love’ by ‘OK Go’. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V2fpgpanZAw I also watched other stop motion videos by people from all over the world and began to get fascinated with the unnaturalness of the movement. I found that creating life through an inanimate object seemed abnormal yet amazing so we decided as a group we were going to incorporate stop motion into our video, so we shot a single frame of the object and then moved it slightly.

We decided to use very stereotypical representations of mise-en-scene in our video to represent the significance and power of love amongst our characters. We had a flashback sequence at the beginning which showed very distinctive shots of a couple together, for example holding hands and walking in the snow. We did this to emphasise that there is no pragmatic meaning behind their love.

Similarly in our music video I think we went against typical conventions by not having a performing artist in the video and by not including any lip synching elements. We did this in order to make our video abstract and different from the typical, everyday ones we see on the TV. We did however still produce a narrative based video where we told a story through moving imagery, we decided to make it as synchronous as possible with the lyrics to create an easy flow for our audience. As our video is a concept video which portrays a story not performance I would say we have strayed away from everyday conventions.

We used a number of long, mid and close up shots in our video, to create emphasis on the letter, location or emotion. Similarly we used pans and tilts to follow the object. These are all typical conventions of music videos which we choose to include as they are important for getting the videos full potential across.

We think that our mise-en-scene was suitable for our genre choice, as a pop video we didn’t need to include mass amounts of instruments and stage equipment; the overcrowding didn’t fit with the narrative we desired which is why we only had two actors in the video. We had shots of our female actress walking down numerous isolated locations on her own, the mise-en-scene represents the isolation she is feeling from her lover and this brought a greater significance to the letter which was responsible for saving the connection between the two.

Our previous video for MGMT ‘Kids’ which we abandoned at the start of the editing process due to us being unhappy with the overall outcome and narrative represented, the lyrics did however set the undertone for the theme of the narrative as it created a tense atmosphere.

When we started the planning process of our video, we had previously done a lot of research into the conventions used in music videos, for example band footage. We referred to our theoretical research, for example Andrew Goodwin who has a theory on conventions.

1.There is a relationship between the visuals and the music.

2.There is a relationship between the lyrics and visuals.

3.There are often lots of close up shots of the artist. (who may have a visual style)

4.Music videos demonstrate characteristics (stage performance in a rock video.)

5.There is often a reference to voyeurism in the term of ‘looking’ this is particularly aimed at women.

6.There are sometimes intertextual references to films etc. (Decode – Paramore) links to the Twilight Saga.

We did this so that the audience could relate easily to the video if it consisted of common conventional features.

In our video we challenged a lot of the conventions, for example we didn’t have any voyeurism or any live band shots. We also chose not to have the girl miming in our video, we originally planned on doing so in order to create a synchronous link between the artist and the visuals on screen, we decided not to because we thought that the video was more effective without the miming element, again we challenged typical conventions. We wanted to create a video that linked to post modernity; our previous video for ‘MGMT’ portrayed this feature throughout by having a drug user and a business man, typical stereotypes. So in new video we showed the boy handwriting a love letter, an old traditional way of telling one you love them, he then screws it up and gets out his phone sending a basic text message, this is a signifier that technologies dominate the modern society. Post modernity is now simultaneous to the music industry.

Our music video corresponds with the representation theorist Saussure who states that meaning is constructed by the creation and interpretation of signs. This links to our video because the letter represents the love between the couple, throughout the video the letter gets worn, this represents the transition of the characters relationship. Similarly the locations are all isolated for the girl character this represents her lonely state of mind without her partner. However our music video challenged Todorov’s basic narrative theory with the equilibrium and disequilibrium stages, our product can be applied to the two stages but not the five, for instance our equilibrium would be the flashback sequence, our disequilibrium would be the couples break up, it’s not shown in our video but its implied through the characters distress.

One convention that we rejected from our product was having numerous actors; I think this was more effective as it put the sole focus on the protagonist and not a number of people. An example of a convention that we developed during the process of creating our media product was the use of a piece of notepaper and still photo images. We used the note paper as the love letter to travel to the girl and photo images to produce the stop motion aspect.

Finally our ancillary products followed the same path, we used the artist who is present in the music video on the digipak, we presented her in a distraught manner emphasizing to the audience that this album is about pain and destruction of not only the relationship but herself. We used the same images that are on our digipak on the advert too amongst others, this is effective as it links all three of them together, it also means the audience can recognise each product and see that they all clearly relate.

THE END!

Planning

WHAT HAVE YOU LEARNT FROM YOUR AUDIENCE FEEDBACK?

WHAT HAVE YOU LEARNT FROM YOUR AUDIENCE FEEDBACK?