Exploring cultural values (EPhMRA Asia 2013)

0 views·Updated Oct 13, 2014
Powered by AI

Need to present on this topic?

Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.

Free to try, no credit card required

Slide outline

  1. Reducing uncertainty in Japan
  2. Sources & references

Transcript

Exploring cultural values

For better results, tailor your marketing and research programs to local cultural values

What does it mean for research?

China

Philippines

Japan

Very high power distance

  • Strong sense of hierarchy may be observed
  • Build rapport by showing empathy to understand what drives behaviors

Masculine

  • Differences in genders’ role perceptions may lead to differing beliefs and/or behaviors towards conditions and their management
  • There may be greater differences between genders on the way patients cope with their condition

So what are the scores?

What do these scores mean in practice?

Cultural values in a specific therapy area

Perceptions of ADHD in the US and China

Through questionnaires sent to school teachers and psychology students, researchers have identified potential differences in attitudes towards ADHD

Short-term orientation in the Philippines

Perceptions of ADHD in China

Pharmacists as a first point of contact

Main criteria for diagnosis is hyperactivity

Respondents tend to agree with:

  • ADHD is biology based
  • Children with ADHD need to try harder
  • Parents of children with ADHD just don’t know how to control their children
  • It is schools’ job to instil discipline when parents have failed

Ping Fang, Jill M. Norvilitis Perceptions of ADHD in China and the United States: A Preliminary Study, Journal of Attention Disorders November 2005 9: 413-424,

Conclusion:

‘Restraint’ values lead to greater recognition of hyperactive behaviors

Collectivist values suggest it is everyone’s responsibility to deal with the condition

Recent research has highlighted that pharmacists are often used as first point of contact by patients

  • Pharmacists may be easier to reach than doctors
  • More available
  • Less expensive
  • Closer to patient’s home

Cultural values: A definition

The collective programming of the mind distinguishing the members of one group or category of people from another

6 key dimensions

Individualism

Power distance

Defines the degree of interdependence a society maintains among its members.

The extent to which the less powerful members of institutions and organizations within a country expect and accept that power is distributed unequally

Implications in healthcare

Implications in healthcare

In highly individualistic countries:

  • Higher share of both public and private income spent on healthcare
  • Individuals with disabilities are encouraged to live a ‘normal life’ as much as possible

In high PDI countries:

  • Doctors tend to lead the consultation
  • Consultations may be shorter
  • Use of antibiotics may be greater
  • Less blood transfusions

Indulgence vs. restraint

Uncertainty avoidance

The extent to which societies allow relatively free gratification of basic needs and human drives or regulates these gratifications by strict social norms

The extent to which a society is risk-averse or can tolerate environment ambiguity

Implications in healthcare

Implications in healthcare

High uncertainty avoidance has been linked to:

  • Less eye contact during medical consultations
  • Higher likelihood of getting a prescription
  • Lower nurse/doctor ratio

In high indulgence countries:

  • People tend to feel healthier
  • Higher level of self-reported happiness
  • Lower percentage of death from cardiovascular diseases

Long-term orientation

Masculinity

The extent to which a society shows a pragmatic future-oriented perspective rather than a conventional historical short-term point of view.

The extent to which competition and assertiveness are deemed masculine values and opposed to caring and quality of life, deemed feminine values

Considering cultural values

Cultural values: Definition & implications in healthcare

  • Power distance
  • Individualism
  • Masculinity
  • Uncertainty avoidance
  • Long-term orientation
  • Indulgence vs. restraint

Case study: Comparing scores across 3 countries

China, Japan, Philippines

What it means for researchers

Adapted from the presentation given in November 2013 at the EphMRA Asia conference in Singapore

1

Reducing uncertainty in Japan

Example of detailed & illustrated prescriptions

Detailed packaging

List of medications

2

Sources & references

Geert Hofstede, Gert Jan Hofstede, Michael Minkov, Cultures and Organizations: Software of the Mind. Revised and Expanded 3rd Edition. New York: McGraw-Hill USA, 2010

Ping Fang, Jill M. Norvilitis Perceptions of ADHD in China and the United States: A Preliminary Study, Journal of Attention Disorders November 2005 9: 413-424,

3

High uncertainty avoidance

  • Respondents may not feel comfortable in unstructured or novel situations
  • Researchers should be very clear about the research objectives and methodology to gain trust
4

Short term orientation

  • Respondents may focus on facts and have established beliefs
  • Emphasis on research objectives
5

Perceptions of ADHD in the US

  • Both hyperactivity and inattention are used for diagnosis
  • More than 80% think medication is overused
  • More than 60% think medication should be used only as a last resort

Respondents tend to

  • Disagree that ‘ADHD is biology based’
  • Disagree that children with ADHD need to do more/try harder
  • Disagree that parents of children with ADHD don’t know how to control their children

Conclusion:

Participants were generally skeptical about ADHD

No specific responsibility for dealing with the condition

6

Low uncertainty avoidance

& restraint orientation

  • Respondents may accept different viewpoint and thus not be used to express emotions
  • Research can use projective techniques to explore certain situations
7

Collectivist

  • Extended family and different circles of influence can play a great role
  • Research should create a sense of belonging