The Use Of Space In Dub, And How This Has Influenced Modern Electronic Music
An investigation into spatial effects used in dub and the creative possibilities this has opened up for modern producers
- What is Dub Reggae? – A Definition & History
- Spatial Effects and Their Uses in Dub
- The Creation of Impossible and Mystical Spaces or Audiotopias
- Dub Influences in Electronic Music
- New Genres Influenced by Dub
In 1976, Melody Maker published an article by music critic Richard Williams entitled “The Sound of Surprise.” Williams’ essay was a short but prescient description of the still-shockingly-new phenomenon of dub reggae. Williams prophetically noted that “there are possibilities inherent in this aberrant form which could perhaps resonate throughout other musics in the years to come.” (Williams 1976 quoted in Baker 2009 pg.5)
Definition and a Brief History of Dub
- Dub originated in Jamaica in The 1960’s and consisted initially of instrumental “versions” of reggae tracks containing what was described as the "riddim" or just bass and drums.
- "Dub is a kaleidoscopic montage which takes sounds originally intended as interlocking parts of another arrangement and using them as raw material, converts them into new and different sounds, then in its own rhythm and format, it continually reshuffles these new sounds into unusual juxtapositions." (Ehrlich 1982 p. 106)
- The development of the genre dub took place when the engineer would take an instrumental version of a track to the next level, using the effects such as echo, reverb and delay to change the whole sound and texture of the riddim. “This was the turning point in which dub emerged as a unique and characteristic branch of music itself, and can be credited almost entirely to the contributions of a mixing engineer known as King Tubby.” (Bush) King Tubby ran his own sound system in Kingston at the time called Tubby’s Hometown Hi Fi.
- Tubby who was experienced in electronics through his background in TV repairs customised his mixing desk at his studio in the ghetto district Waterhouse in Kingston, adding faders which allowed him to add or subtract the various elements of the tracks smoothly. He also created his own effects units by modifying tape machines to create delays and hitting spring reverb units which created the characteristic thunderclap sound used in dub.
- “Tubby’s innovations behind the mixing board introduced to Jamaica the idea of the mixing engineer playing a creative role in the music.” (Bush unknown)
- There were many traveling outdoor sound systems in Jamaica in the 1960's.
- One of the biggest sound systems of this time period was owned by Rudolph ‘Ruddy’ Redwood in Spanish Town. Known as Ruddy’s Supreme Ruler of Sound, he had one of the most impressive selections of music, as he had a long relationship with Duke Reid, one of Jamaica’s leading producers of the time. Ruddy had access to a number of exclusive recordings from Duke’s Treasure Isle Studio, giving him an edge over other sound system operators (Barrow and Dalton 1997, p. 200).
- The sound system engineers created what was known as "versions" which were instrumental mixes of a song without the vocals. "Ruddy played a key role in the initial development of dub, as he was the first to make a public performance of what would become known as version" (Bush unknown)
Spatial effects and their uses in dub
- In order to investigate how the spatial effects used in dub have influenced other genres, first we must define what effects are used to create the illusion of space and how they have been used in dub.
- Reverberation is the most commonly used effect used to create space. Izhaki (2012 pg.405) describes reverb in the following way,
- Lee ‘Scratch’ Perry and his band The Upsetters recorded Cloak and Dagger in 1972 which was “heavy on spacey sound effects and moody instrumentals...(and could be thought of as).. proto-dub... Perry and the Upsetters continued to experiment. Within a year, they would release their first all-dub LP, Blackboard Jungle Dub.” (Baker 2009)
- Perry later built his own studio, the legendary Black Ark, in 1974 in the Kingston suburb of Washington Gardens.
“In nature, reverb is observed mostly within enclosed spaces, such as rooms. Reverbs are easier to understand if we imagine an impulse sound, like a hand clap, emitted from a sound source in an empty room. Such a sound will propagate in a spherical fashion and for simplicity we should regard it as travelling in all directions. The emitted sound will travel in a direct path to a listener (or a microphone) followed by reflections that bounced from the walls, floor and ceiling. These will be gradually followed by denser reflections that have bounced many times from many surfaces. As sound both diminishes when travelling through air and being absorbed by surface materials, the reflections will slowly decay in amplitude. Reverb is the collective name given to the sound created by bounced reflections from room boundaries (which we consider to be the main reverb contributors, although in a room there might be many surfaces). In mixing, we use reverb emulators, either hardware units or software plugins, to simulate this natural phenomenon.”
- Black Ark became known for its signature sound which was heavy but uplifting at the same time
- Prince Jammy and Scientist who were trained by Tubby at his studio were the next generation of dub engineers. “Prince Jammy, otherwise named Lloyd James, would eventually go on to become one of the most successful producers during the dancehall era that Jamaica was soon to enter.... Using Tubby’s equipment, Jammy’s dubs would have the characteristic sound of Tubby’s studio, but in a style of his own. Jammy’s dubs were often more stripped down than Tubby’s, emphasizing the groove of the drum and bass, or the riddim.” (Bush)
- The amount of reverb in a space is dependent on the volume of the room but also the rate at which sound is absorbed by walls and other surfaces.
- Sabine's formula calculates the reverberation time which is defined by the time taken (in seconds) for a sound to drop by 60 decibels.
- V is the volume of the room in cubic meters. This is divided by the total absorption of the room expressed in Sabines which is calculated by the sum of all the surface areas in the room multiplied by the absorption coefficients for each material.
(magicmess.co.uk/electronics/spring.php)
- A characteristic dub reverb sound is the spring reverb. The spring reverb works by using the physical movement of a spring to generate the reflections.
(magicmess.co.uk/electronics/spring.php)
- The Roland RE 201 Space Echo uses a magnetic tape loop to create a tape delay effect.
- A common delay sound used in dub is the tape delay. Case (2007 pg.224) states that,
“Before the days of digital audio, a common approach to creating delays was to use a spare analogue tape machine as a generator...During mixdown the machine is constantly rolling in record mode. The signal is sent from the console to the input of the tape machine...That signal is recorded at the tape machine and milliseconds later is played back...(the tape machine) remains in repro mode so the output is what it sees at the playback head...The signal goes in gets printed onto tape the tape makes its way from the record head to the playback head (taking time to do so) and finally the signal is played back off tape and returned to the console. The result is tape delay.”
- Analogue tape delay also adds tape saturation and tape hiss, these sounds have become a highly sought after additional qualities of tape delay.
- Hodgson (2010 pg.124) states “the simple delay line is the building block of all delay processing techniques.”
- Audio signals are fed into a delay line where the signal is split and a copy is stored for a certain amount of time before being passed to the output after the direct signal.
- There are 3 common setting on most delay units
- Delay time or the amount of time between the input signal and the copy arriving at the output.
- The mix setting which adjusts the balance between the input signal and the delayed copy.
- And the feedback which controls the amount of the delayed signal which is routed back to the input.
- Another aspect of the use of space is creative sound staging. Moylan (2008) states,
"The sound stage is the singular area occupied by all of the sound sources of the music, as an aggregate or group. It has an apparent physical size of width and depth that are defined at the level of the individual sound source: (1) the dimension of width is defined by the furthest right and left sound (lateral localization) and (2) the dimension of depth is defined by the most distant sound source and the closest sound source."
Zagorski-Thomas (2010) takes this idea of the sound stage further to functional staging,
“Functional staging is a concept building on the idea of phonographic staging developed by William Moylan and Serge Lacasse and related to Allan Moore’s ‘sound-box’. The staging of sounds in the record production process is considered to be functional if the reason for their particular placement or treatment is related to the practicalities of audience reception rather than to aesthetics.” (Zagorski-Thomas 2010 pg.1)
“Functional staging relates to the size of the perceived space and the perception of distance rather than lateral placement.” (Zagorski-Thomas 2010 pg.6)
The Creation of Impossible and Mystical Spaces
- Dub artists with a strong connection to the Rastafarian religion were looking to create this connection with “the other” or to create something new and unheard before.
- With the help of the previously mentioned effects Dub artists were able to create impossible soundscapes or audiotopia’s which do not relate to any real world acoustic spaces.
- Doyle (2004 pg.43) states there is “an integral and enduring connection between what might be called “reverberancy” and the sacred.”
- Since ancient times reverberant spaces have been thought to have mystical, sacred or religious properties. Churches and cathedrals are designed to be reverberant and amplify the voice, while sacred caves served as some of the first natural religious spaces.
- Doyle (2004) talks about harnessing the echo, this allows the mystical properties of reverberant sound to be “harnessed” and used by producers through the development of technology.
- Baker (2009) uses “Josh Kun’s theories about “audiotopias” (temporary aural spaces created through music)” to describe dub’s sounscapes created with the use of echo and reverb effects.
“In order to study how sonic spaces create “new maps” that allow an individual to analyze their current social predicament. These “new maps,” therefore, engender a “remapping” of reality, a reconstitutive process that parallels dub’s emphasis on modification and alteration.” (Baker 2009 pg.ii)
Dub Influences in Electronic Music
New Genres Influenced By Dub
- Through the creative miss-use of studio equipment and effects dub producers cut themselves a niche as a new class of artist where the producer was the main focus rather than the band. This is where the lasting influence of dub can be seen over all electronic music.
- The characteristic of boosting the rhythm section of a track can be seen in most genres of modern electronic music such as hip-hop, house, techno, jungle/drum n bass, breaks, dub-step and electronica.
- New technology such as digital reverbs and delays enable today’s electronic artists to create impossible spaces through the use of algorithms such as convolution reverbs.
- The majority of modern electronic music employs the use of impossible acoustic spaces for the effect of trying to create something new and unheard before. This can be traced directly back to the original dub artists even if the modern artist would not cite dub as an influence on their music.
Augustus Pablo - King Tubby Meets The Rockers Uptown
Jacob Miller - Baby, I Love You So
Dub Techno
Basic Channel - e2e4 Basic Reshape
Dubstep
Bass Clef - Promises (Peverelist & Appleblim Remix)
Emika – Double Edge (Ninja Tune 2010)
Emika – Double Edge (Pinch mix)
- Pierce (2010) states “Dub also showed how tools traditionally associated with reproducing music could now be seen through the filter of creating music, which had an immeasurable impact on what would become hip-hop. By popularizing the notion of remixing existing hits to give them new contexts and new sounds, dub helped democratize pop music and spawned a generation of producers whose own take on the remix forever altered dance music.”
Further Development and Research in This Area
- Analysing specific tracks from each genre and examining the spatial qualities of each track so comparisons can be made.
- Looking at specific uses of spatial effects in dub so common settings such as delay times that create characteristic dub sounds can be identified in modern productions.
- Detailed investigation into dub production techniques and what new possibilities these techniques open up with the use of new technology.
- An investigation into how technology has changed and what impact this has had on spatial effects.
References and Bibliography
Baker. J. (2009) Natural audiotopias: The construction of sonic space in dub reggae. Scholar Commons, University of South Florida. (Accessed 21/09/12) http://scholarcommons.usf.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2841&context=etd
Barrow. S. and Dalton. P. (1997) Reggae: The Rough Guide. Rough Guides Ltd. London
Bates. M. (2007) The Representation of Space in Audio and Audiovisual Works. ARP Conference Paper (Accessed 12/10/2012) http://www.artofrecordproduction.com/content/view/104/95/
Bush. J. (unknown) Dub Revolution: The Story of Jamaican Dub Reggae and Its Legacy. (Accessed 27/10/12) http://debate.uvm.edu/dreadlibrary/bush.html
Camilleri. L. (2010) Shaping sounds, shaping spaces. Popular Music, 29, pp 199-211
Campbell. M. & Greated. C. (1987) The Musician’s Guide to Acoustics. Oxford University Press
Case. A. (2007) Sound FX: Unlocking The Creative Potential Of Recording Studio Effects
Doyle. P. (2004) From 'My Blue Heaven' to 'Race with the Devil': echo, reverb and (dis)ordered space in early popular music recording. Popular Music, Vol. 23, No. 1 (Jan., 2004), pp. 31-49. Cambridge University Press.
Doyle. P. (2005) Echo & Reverb: Fabricating Space in Popular Music Recording 1900-1960. Wesleyan University Press, Middletown.
Ehrlich. L. (1982) X-Ray Music and The Reggae Arrangement. Davis, Stephen and Simon, Peter. Reggae International. R and B. New York.
Hodgson. J. (2010) Understanding Records: A Field Guide to Recording Practice. Continuum International Publishing, New York.
Izhaki. R. (2012) Mixing Audio: Concepts Practices and Tools. 2nd Edition. Focal Press
www.magicmess.co.uk/electronics/spring.php (Accessed 27/10/12)
Moylan. W. (2007) Understanding and Crafting the Mix. Focal Press.
Moylan. W. (2008) Considering Space in Music. (Accessed 21/09/12) http://www.artofrecordproduction.com/content/view/180/109/
Pierce. L. (2010) Gateways to Geekery: Dub. (Accessed 10/12/12) http://www.avclub.com/articles/dub,37601/
Zagorski-Thomas. S. (2010). The stadium in your bedroom: functional staging, authenticity and the audience led aesthetic in record production. Popular Music, 29, pp 251-266.