Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.
Free to try, no credit card requiredTo obtain feedback from our audience, we held a focus group consisting of range of 16 and 17 year old boys and girls. We first made them watch our music video and we then asked them a series of questions about their opinions with regard to the band's image along with the ancillary texts.
We received various kinds of readings in response to our video. In terms of the band music genre, most people said that they were 'indie pop' which was an oppostional reading for our product. We intended to encode the band image in a way that they come across as an altern-rock however, the audience did not seem to decode it in that way. Someone even thought that they were a heavy metal band. This was because of the poster - he thought that it was very dark and it did not look like it belonged to the same band. In fact, everyone in our focus group thought that. Again, this was an oppositional view because we intended the poster to match the video and come across as products of the same band. This ties in with theorist Stuart Hall's views that audiences are defined by lots of different elements and are not simply masses that consume these media products. This explains why our audience did not decode our video and ancillary texts in the way we meant to encoded it. This is especially the case with our tour poster. Our focus group thought it came across as dark, sinister and serious which is not what we had intended it to be. Also, only one girl correctly identfied the comic book font that we were going for in our digipak and posters. This was meant to be the main theme of our ancillary texts and it was a shame that only 10% of our focus group correctly identified this.
Having said that, we also had a lot of preferred readings. Most people got the idea of the video being fun, quirky and uplifting and our audience correctly identified our band as 'normal guys having fun'. Also, they believed that the band felt passionate about their music, which is another important message we meant to encode in our products.
When we asked our audience if they could relate to the band, some people thought that they were 'approachable and down to earth'. This can be linked to Lazerfeld, Blumler and Katz 's Users and Gratifications Model. They say that 'Personal Relationships' are formed via companionship, when media personalities, characters, etc. and socialability through discussion about the media artefact with other people. In terms of our products, the fact that people would like to know the band members better, fits this 'Personal Relationship' theory becuase it shows that they consume media proucts for social purposes. This also explains why a 100% of our focus group audience said that they would be fans of 'Suckers for Watchmen' and would watch them live.
We have also received some feedback from the video we uploaded on YouTube. These are what some of the people commented saying:
"The editing in this video is very good, it has obviously taken a very long time and it looks very professional!"
"I really liked this video, got a real feel of the band you created. The side shots of the instruments are very cool, nice work."
All of these comments are positive, and most of these seemed to love the editing style of our video.
5/10 people in our focus group said that they wouldn't want to watch the video again because they think they've seen enough. The remaining 5 think that they'd watch it again because they like the band and would like to better know/understand the characters and their personalities. This is the intended reason we had for people to watch the video again however we did expect more than 50% of our audience to want to watch it again.
Having said that, it is possible that our audience were biased because firstly, we had small sample size which may not have been representative of our target audience. Secondly, our products are targetted to 'geek chic' comic book readers and none of our focus group fit that category.
Overall, I think doing this focus group has really given us a lot of different kinds of feedback which helps us go deeper into th design of our products to understand why some of them have not been successfully decoded in the intended way. This will help us in the future because it allows us to pay more attention to not only how we encode our products, but also give a thought to how it may be decoded by our audiences.
Preferred/Oppositional Readings
We also filmed our focus group talk about our products.
Users and Gratifications Model
Audience Feedback - Baby Loves Me
"Clever editing!"
"Love the style and the editing"
"love the editing and the way that the shots are all cut into the one and edited at different times"
Evaluation
Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.
Free to try, no credit card required