The UN and the Environment

CH
by Corini Houser0 views·Updated Feb 11, 2016
Powered by AI

Need to present on this topic?

Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.

Free to try, no credit card required

Transcript

The UN and

the Environment

United Nations Conference on the Human Environment

  • 1. conference in Stockholm, 1972
  • 113 Nations were participating

UN

Environment Programme

  • Agreed on 26 principles and an action plan
  • Voice of environment within the UN
  • UNEP was founded
  • Headquartered in Nairobi, Kenya
  • Main tasks are:

Climate Change

Resource Efficiency

Kyoto Protocol

Disasters & Conflicts

Chemicals & Waste

Ecosystem Management

Kyoto, Japan1997

Environmental Governance

  • extension of the Framework Convention from Rio
  • binding obligations for developed countries to reduce their greenhouse gas emissions till 2012
  • heavier burden on developed countries due to more industrial activities since 150 years
  • Amendment were made in Doha 2012

Rio

Earth Summit

Brundtland

Commission

GO

GREEN

Gro Harlem Brundtland

  • UN Conference on Environment and Development

Report from 1987

  • Rio de Janeiro, Brazil in 1992

"Our Common Future"

  • Delegates from 172 nations
  • New concept of sustainability
  • Regional, national and international actions
  • 5 Resolutions adopted, 3 legally binding

"development which meets the needs of current generations without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs"

e.g.

- Agenda 21

- Statement of Forest Principles

  • 3 P's:

- UN Convention to Combat desertification

Planet, People, Profit

- UN Framework Convention on Climate Change

(UNFCCC)

Greenpeace Campaign

The Climate Conference

Environmental destruction:

through over exploiting common environmental resources

Efforts of the UN to protect our Environment

• Climate Change:

• Loss of species and biodiversity

  • Overfishing
  • Deforestation
  • Growing of monoculture plants
  • Rise of sea levels
  • Storm damage
  • Desertification

• Deforestation:

• Sea and water pollution:

  • The removal of a forest or stand of trees
  • About half of the Earth's mature tropical forests that until 1947 covered the planet have now been destroyed
  • Much of what remains of the world's rainforests is in the Amazon basin
  • 97% is ocean water
  • 1% use able as drinking water
  • 2% is frozen solid in the Arctic (for now)
  • Over 700 Million people without access to safe drinking water

Copenhagen conference

After the conference...

Effective Task Force or Big Paper Tiger?

The word of the day: FAIL

The Copenhagen Summit

the opening ceremony of the summit

<The city of Copenhagen is a climate crime scene tonight, with the guilty men and women fleeing to the airport in shame>

John Sauven comment

  • The 2009 United Nations Climate Change Conference, was held in Copenhagen between 7 and 8 December.
  • 192 countries took part in this assembly.

<The most important international gathering since World War II>

Lord Stern commented.

  • This conference raised climate change policy to the highest political level:

more than 40000 people including 115 world leaders attended the high-level segment

During the conference...

Before the conference...

2009, a year characterize by different meetings

Key players USA and China both responsable for 40% of CO2 global emission

Meeting in Davos

The Copenhagen most important goal was to find the agreement between states in order to reduce the emissions of CO2 from 15% to 30% by 2020 and from 50% to 80% by 2050 globally.

  • introduction speach was held by Connie Hedegaard
  • a lot of difference between developing and developed countries
  • general speaches about the different environmental problems
  • vague and not concrete speaches held by heads of states
  • protests out of the conference hall

How to success during and after Copenhagen?

  • engage heads of state governments
  • clear targets, ideas and commitments
  • agreement on funds and pricing of carbon

delegates during a plenary session

"Environment is defined as the conditions and circumstances that surround someone"

Reasons For Failure

The Agreement

Copenhagen Accord

Timing

1. Superficial, no concrete actions

Personal interests of the countries

2. Negotiations postponed the next year

Conference in context of Crisis

Short-term economic interests

After Copenhagen 2009....

- Keeping temperature rise below 2 °C

- Does not contain commitments to emission reductions

- No real target to achieve the goal

- No deadline of objectives

Presidental elections, e.g. Obama 2008

Any new developments to establish further agreements to protect the Environment?

The Problem of collective goods and climate change

Achievments:

  • Foundation of Green Climate Fund (2010, Cancún)
  • Frequent UN Summits on Climate Change
  • Political and Public Awareness

Conflict between Developed and Developing Countries

Lack of Power of UN

  • Rational individual actions produce collectively irrational outcomes
  • Free ride problem
  • Theory of games (excursion)

-Non-acceptance of a World Environmental Organization

Emerging countries : Not responsible of what happened before the last century. Demand the freedom of industrialization.

Developed countries : Don't want the emerging countries to catch up.

Financial help to developing countries.

BUT:

  • No new ideas how to cope with the ecological crisis
  • No follow-up agreements with specific targets
  • Until now "more questions than answers"

-The Copenhagen agreement : a draft between a few countries

Why did the 2009

Copenhagen Summit fail?

Questions & Discussion

?

If you don't have any further questions we have some for you!

Who of you thinks there should be done something against climate change and environmental destruction?

The System

Should there be more financial incentives for companies to further support green development?

Do you think that an environmental crisis,

not only Climate Change, can be challenged within the system of a neoliberal capitalist world?

Who would honestly be willing to (fundamentally) change his/her daily life to protect and save environment for the future generation?

Bibliography

Ingolfur Blühdorn, “The politics of unsustainability: COP15, post-ecologism, and the ecological paradox“, Organization and Environment, 24:1, March 2011, pp. 34-53.

Daniel Bodanski, “The Copenhagen climate change conference: a postmortem“, American Journal of International Law, 2:104, April 2010, pp.230-240.

Neil Carter, “Climate Change and the Politics of Global Environment“, in Mark Beeson and Nick Bisley (Eds), Issues in 21st Century World Politics, Palgrave MacMillan, Basingstoke, 2010, pp. 52-65.

Sven B. Gareis, The United Nations, Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, 2012, pp.234-274.

Gert Goeminne, “Climate policy is dead, long live climate politics!“, Ethics, Place & Environment: A Journal of Philosophy & Geography, 13:2, June 2010, pp.207-2014.

Margaret P. Karns and Karen A. Mingst, International Organizations, Lynne Rienner, Boulder, 2009, pp. 497-533.

Volker Rittenberger and Bernhard Zangl, International Organization, Palgrave, Basingstoke, 2006, chapter: The Environment.

http://www.yourdictionary.com/environment

http://water.org/water-crisis/water-facts/water/

http://www.drinking-water.org/html/en/Sources/Where-is-the-Earths-Water.html

http://www.nationalgeographic.com/eye/deforestation/effect.html

http://www.nature.org/ourinitiatives/urgentissues/rainforests/rainforests-facts.xml

National Geographic.; the Guardian; UN

Unequal distribution of the negative effects of Climate Change:

Theoretical explanations for the failure of the Copenhagen Summit

First general barriers and problems:

"Tragedy of the commons":

Individuals over-exploit common environmental ressources as the short-term interests of individual users overwhelm the longer-run collective interests in sustaining the resource

Lack of compliance:

There is no international authority with the power to force every country to conform

Theoretical explanations

for the failure of the

2009 Copenhagen Summmit:

Unequal distribution:

Some countries have contributed more than others to CC, others wil suffer more

No scientific consensus:

Dispute over the truth of scientific knowledge about CC, its validity and its importance

A social-theoretical approach: Post Ecologism

The Ecological Paradox

Pristine Nature

Human environment

  • Sociocultural norms & perceptions underpin all ecopolitics: Western techno-scientific culture

Environmental politics has turned into a

"politics of unsustainability" (Blühdorn, 2011)

Questioning the present socioeconomic order by formulating alternatives

Battle against CO2 within the existing neoliberal order

Which society do we want?

Which low carbon economy we want

  • Normalisation of the environmental crisis

How do advanced modern societies sustain the unsustainability:

  • The new paradigma of ecological modernisation: ways must be found to meet the expanding needs of late-modern societies

Any questions or comments ?

  • Carbon emission trading has grown and it is a new

commodity itself to meet emission reduction targets

  • frequent UN summits and working groups, paralysed and symbolic environmental politics, ....

5.2. The Ecological Paradox

Environmental politics has turned into a

"politics of unsustainability" (Blühdorn, 2011)

"The curious simultaneity of,

on the one hand,

an unprecedent recognition of the urgency of radical ecological policy change,

and on the other

an equally unprecedented unwillingness and inability to permform such change“

How may we explain this ecological paradox?

1. Environment

2. Efforts of the UN

3. The Climate Conference

4. Reasons for Failure

5. Theoretical Explanations

6. Questions & Discussion

08.01.15: Roxane Bouffard-Vercelli, Ernesto Buchholzer, Corinna Hausner, Julia Herrmann, Olexandra Melnyk