Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.
Free to try, no credit card requiredStructuralism
Spectacular Culture
and
The Culture Industries
Desublimation
In psychoanalysis "desublimation" is a process through which hidden, trapped "libidinal energies" [= instinctive desires] are set free.
Desublimation can be liberating: an attack on stale social rules and formulas, a way of finding revolutionary perspectives [see: Surrealism]
But HF suggests that today's "culture industry" desublimates desires in a far from liberating way.
The culture industry channels subjects' desires so that they reinforce capitalist systems of production and consumption. [Pornography e.g.: a multi-billion-dollar international industry based on channelling the desublimation of sexual desire, in order to line pornographers' pockets with cash.]
YAB discusses structuralism. Structuralist criticism [e.g. by the young Roland Barthes] and anthropology [e.g. Claude Lévi-Strauss] offered antisubjectivist accounts of art and culture.
Structuralism identified patterns in art practices and compared them to wider social and cultural systems (as opposed to viewing works of art as unique, "inspired" creative outpourings that exceeded classification or rationalisation).
YAB connects various later C.20th artmaking tactics with structuralism— e.g. "the serial attitude" [ = working in series using set rules]; "indexical procedures" [e.g. dropping lumps of wet clay from a crane: the splattered lump is the index of the process]; "the monochrome, the grid, chance etc". These "anticompositional" tactics supported post-war artists' revolt against the cult of individual, essential expression.
BB views cultural developments since 1945 with deep gloom.
He asserts that cultural freedoms have steadily been dismantled and cultural practices gobbled up by the culture industries ["fashion, advertisement, entertainment" etc.], leaving a homogenised landscape that Guy Debord labelled "the integrated spectacle".
Debord argued that under advanced capitalism social life is taken over by commerce. Human subjects are "drugged by spectacular images"; superficial representations take over from real experience.
Following this argument, there are ample grounds for asserting that contemporary art museums and galleries deal in meaningless, showy commodities, not authentic art.
Is there still a place of escape from spectacular culture? Or have most artists and critics placidly accepted their roles within the spectacle?
So, it's another example of a cultural construct that can work both progressively and conservatively
"Indexical procedures":
Test Flights
[David Rickards, 2009]
O2: the Millennium Dome
Cinderela [joana Vasconcelos, 2007]
"Anti-Subjectivism"
"The serial attitude":
Spherical-Type Gas Holders
[Berndt and Hilla Becher, 2004]
Everything's going to hell in a handcart!
*The "de-psychologising of art"
*"Anti-subjectivism"
*"Bankrupt humanism"
This text contains many comments concerning the post-war critique of "free individual expression".
The authors assume that progressive art making, cultural production and cultural criticism involves rejecting or dismantling ideas of art focused on individual "pathos", "feeling", the individual psyche and the "free subject".
WHY? Discuss!
"The monochrome, the grid, chance etc."
Date Painting [On Kawara, Mar 5 2000]
Takashi Murakami exhibition
in Frankfurt, 2008
The "Magic Kingdom"
Maxxi, Rome [Zaha Hadid, arch. Completed 2008 ]
Art "now functions as commodity production, investment portfolio, and entertainment" says BB.
See here Matthew Barney, who's even worse than Jeff Koons: a "proto-totalitarian" who celebrates "the catastrophic conditions of existence under late capitalism".
Psychoanalysis
Bluewater,
Greenhithe,
Kent
Cremaster 5
[Matthew Barney,
1997]
Test Site
[Carsten Holler,
2007]
Jeff Koons
Exhibit at
Versailles
2008
HF: Since 1945 differing psychoanalytic approaches have supported artists and critics with differing agendas.
Some have used psychoanalysis to support the idea of the private "individual psyche" as the ultimate basis of art.
Others have used it to uncover the roots of artists' ideas and practices in collective social phenomena. These latter artists and critics wanted to "de-psychologise" art making — to move it away from "pathos" and ideas of individual expression and feeling, towards collective social and political issues and questions [using the word "political" very broadly].
Globalisation,
capitalism and the decentralisation of the art world
Documentation IV, Transitional Objects from the Post-Partum Document
[Mary Kelly, 1976]
Luncheon on the Grass
[Paul Cézanne, 1869-70]
THEN...
What do you think?
How does your practice relate to global issues, or local cultural practices?
Do you think "global" or "local" in the studio? Discuss!
HF: BB's linear narrative of avant-garde power travelling from pre-war Europe to the post-war US is overly simplistic. After 1945, the art world started to decentralise.Japan and Brazil, e.g., developed their own post-war avant-gardes. YAB says: Well, at first, those Japanese and Brazilian artists were indeed looking to the old power centres: Paris, New York. Then in 1968 things changed. There was protest and unrest internationally, and the Vietnam War united "progressive minds around the world… against American imperialism".
YAB thinks that the Bush administration and the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan have sparked a similar "negative internationalism" today. YAB wonders what impact this will have on the cultural sphere.
BRAZIL:
Dialogue Goggles
[Lygia Clark, 1968]
Methodology
JAPAN:
Saburo Murakami
performs
Tearing Paper
1955
Sharjah representatives at ZKM Karlsruhe [with El Anatsui work to LHS]
...and NOW
A methodology is like a tool kit. It's any intellectual system or philosophical method that provides a set of conceptual "tools".
The methodology or methodologies you select
will help shape your analysis of a given subject.
The opening sections of the discussion focus on five (psychoanalysis, structuralism, poststructuralism, phenomenology and a social-historical approach to art history) but many others appear in contemporary art criticism.
However, methodological "tools" tend to be soft and wobbly. They suggest ways of looking at things, rather than laying down rigid rules. And some methodologies can be "squidged together" very successfully (some types of feminism and some types of psychoanalysis, e.g.).
The
Predicament of Contemporary Art
HF compares the 1989 Paris blockbuster Magiciens de la Terre to current Biennials in places such as Gwangju, Johannesburg or Sharjah.
The 1989 show was very diverse with "a concerted attention to local traditions", but the works in today's shows seem very generic: installation art, video projection, photographic collections and "chat rooms" filled with archival-type clutter.
YAB suggests that the old "non-West" is no longer exotic, its centres are just points in a network of markets. Capitalist corporatism is the motor for globalisation in the current art world, says BB.
HF thinks that is simplistic. Models opposing American Empire exist [he cites Hardt and Negri, authors of the 2000 book Empire]. Contemporary art in China, India and the Islamic world may be following social projects other than global corporatism. The problem would then be to find ways to translate those alternatives to Western audiences without distorting them.
The Predicament of Contemporary Art
Roundtable discussion: Foster, Krauss, Bois & Buchloh
In: Art Since 1900, Thames & Hudson 2004, pp. 671-679
Post-structuralism:
Art media have no essential characteristics
RK says: In the post-war period various artists and writers attacked the Modernist idea that art mediums [painting, sculpture etc] form absolute, essential categories, and that an artist's job is to find and express those categorial essences.
For poststructuralists [eg Jacques Derrida] essences don’t exist.
Conceptualists pursued the idea of art, rather than issues of physical media.
Duchamp's campaign to downgrade the importance of traditional craft, media skills got rediscovered in the 60s.
And artists started exploring video, an apparatus that doesn't easily boil down to an "essence".
But what began as a radical challenge to dominant thinking (the essential character of media), has itself become the dominant view. Everyone accepts that art now exists beyond media. Installations are everywhere, goddamit!
For me, it's become a problem. Time to return to some version of Modernism, and an idea of medium specificity?
Barnett Newman
Marcel Duchamp
You are currently studying on a Fine Art BA with separate media pathways: painting, sculpture, print and time-based media.
Why?
Mandarins and
Grand Old Men
BB adds: Like RK he wishes aspects of the Modernist project might be continued; but the current cultural, historical and political situation makes the job very difficult.
Look at Richter and Marden (in painting), and Serra (in sculpture), for e.g. Each seems engaged in a deep exploration of his medium, but when that position gets fixed, their practices take on a conservative character
[Presumably, because they get boxed in: respectfully ignored as mandarin academics working in a bubble, or commodified as masterful "grand old men" at the pinnacle of the artworld].
HF thinks this historical tale: from Modernist medium-specific work, to a "post-medium condition", to the return of the medium — is far too neat. Loads of things have changed radically since 1945.
For most people the idea of a battle between a radical avant-garde vs. kitsch, mass-cultural rubbish, is over.
The dominance of spectacular culture is simply a fact
Some artists seek to "find productive cracks within this condition" and others — Barney, maybe — embrace it so fully that the gesture (for some) takes on a critical aspect.
Warhol was "an agent of spectacle" but his work also exposed a "dark side" of consumerism.
Cindy Sherman's photo-works reflected the repressive roles spectacular culture offered to women.
Thomas Hirschhorn's gigantic displays built from junk subversively parody mass culture and consumerism.
HF: "So we can't say that artists haven't diagnosed the problem and produced work that addresses it".
Linked Mannequins
[Thomas Hirschhorn, 2006]
Untitled (Woman in Sun Dress [Cindy Sherman, 2003]
Old new media
Self-Portrait
[Andy Warhol, 1986
HF comments that technologies have offered artists and critics new media and materials since the early 60s: see for e.g. the writer Marshall McLuhan. So "new media" already have a complex history: some technologies they used are already obsolete. Some artists generate an immersive "techno-sublime [art] that overwhelms body and space alike".
HF cites Bill Viola. Such artists repeat "the mind-blowing intensities produced by media culture at large" and enhance them with an arty, phony gloss of spiritual seriousness.
But others use "old-new media" to recover "suppressed aesthetic and social experiences" & "past subjectivities". E.g.s: Stan Douglas, Tacita Dean, Matthew Buckingham and William Kentridge.
BB responds: this talk of "exploring the social spaces of outmoded media" is all very well, but look at the Surrealists. They did that, and their experiments were "recuperated": they provided the advertising industry with the perfect visual language.
Morphy Richards 'Vorticity' ad, with ice skaters pretending to be carpet fibres and dirt! (How crap is that??!!)
Craneway Event [Tacita Dean, 2009]
The politics of "memory art"
Mnemonic art easily slides into fetishistic distortion and spectacle
The group suspect that artists such as Anselm Kiefer or Bill Viola cater for "the memory industry" within the art world— and it's a sure-fire route to success. They make synthetic, mythic "memory images" that feed the needs of the capitalist cultural system, a system that "entirely lacks the ability to remember and to reflect historically".
Emergence
[Bill Viola,
2002]
Innenraum
[Anselm Kiefer, 1981]
Memorial to the murdered Jews of Europe [Peter Eisenman and Buro Happold, 2005]
HF sums up: how to represent and understand the last two decades of art production? There does not seem to be a dominant narrative stitching the last two decades together, just a competition between "many local models".
And the methodologies listed in this text: psychoanalysis, Marxian social history, poststructuralism etc, seem to have lost their shine. "For many this... is a good thing: it permits artistic freedom and critical diversity."
But our lack of new methodologies has also spawned indifference, stagnation and "a consumerist-touristic culture of art sampling".
HF links this lack of narrative to the big art museums, eg the galleries at Tate Modern. They install works thematically, rather than trying to construct a sense of progressive history.
"We wander through museum spaces as if after the end of time".
...and in conclusion
YAB: But that's why we've written this book — to wake people up to "many aspects of the cultural production of these past hundred-plus years that has been ignored or deliberately repressed".
Maybe we won’t spark the revolution, but we shouldn’t whine either. And in the process we've put together a much more diverse art history than the one we were presented with. And who knows where that might lead?
BB thinks that the old functions of art museums as tools for educating the bourgeois middle classes, have been replaced by something that is vague and opaque to us.
For those investing and speculating in art, the museums serve as banks.
But they also seem to be surrogate "congregational spaces" for rites that stand in for, and also "obliterate", awareness of older revolutionary drives.
The Weather Project
[Olafur Eliasson, 2003-4]
Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.
Free to try, no credit card required