Central District Heating & Power in a 32-building Community

SP
by Shahrzad Pedram0 views·Updated Oct 1, 2012
Powered by AI

Need to present on this topic?

Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.

Free to try, no credit card required

Transcript

Central Heating & Power (CHP)

in a 32-building Community

Intro to CHP

Modeling our Community

Results

Conclusion

Assumptions

  • Municipality vs. Building Owner point of view
  • Building information is available to the team.
  • Buildings modeled are built by good construction standards.
  • RETScreens and e-Quest will be sufficient tools for achieving the project objectives.

Limitations

CHP VS TRADITIONAL SYSTEM

  • no cooling equipment
  • space and domestic hot water heating: furnace with natural gas powered boiler
  • double glazed low-e coated vinyl frame windows
  • no overhangs
  • no skylights

typical working person occupancy schedule (5pm – 8am on weekdays)

The Buildings

Multi-unit Residential

City Hall

Single-family Residential

Elementary School

Simplified CHP Energy Model

x1

x1

x20

x10

Estimate loads & demands:

Heating & power

Calculate energy delivered and fuel consumption

Define equipment characteristics

Determine GHG emissions,

economic feasibility, etc.

Models

e-Quest

Loveleen Atwal &

Shahrzad Pedram

RETScreen

Base Case

Proposed Case

Electricity Consumption : 21 MWH

Heat Consumption : 48 MWH

Annual Utility Bills : $ 3,214

  • 2900 sqft of total floor space
  • standard 2x6 wood frame construction
  • insulation in the stud cavity (medium insulation)
  • two storeys above grade, one storey below grade

Primary Network Design

Apartments

Houses

25m

CHP Plant

52m

69m

15m

  • 159,000 sqft of total above-grade floor space
  • 144 residential units
  • 25 storeys above grade, 3-storey parking garage below grade
  • Perimeter/ core zoning pattern

Standard 2x6 steel frame construction with insulation in the stud cavity (poor insulation) with glass and spandrel enclosure, and concrete slab structure

42m

School

WHAT DO CHP PLANTS PROVIDE?

  • Double glazed low-e coated aluminum frame windows
  • Typical working person occupancy schedule (5pm – 7am on weekdays)

City Hall

  • No cooling equipment
  • Furnace with a natural gas powered boiler for space and domestic hot water heating

Electricity Consumption : 1000 MWH

Heat Consumption : 1729 MWH

Annual Utility Bills : $ 139,922

APPLICATIONS

Total Energy Demand of the Entire Network Community (Power and Heat)

Power Load (peak): 9,231 kW

Heat Load (peak): 11,063 kW

Single or Multiple Buildings

typical school occupancy schedule,

8am – 4pm Monday to Friday,

no occupancy June 1st – August 31st

  • doors and windows located and sized as per drawings
  • 3-foot south side overhangs, 5-foot north side overhangs
  • no skylights

packaged single-zone direct expansion (DX) coils cooling system and furnace heating system powered with a natural gas boiler, with ducted return air path

  • 4,000 sqft of total above grade floor space
  • 2x6 metal frame construction with exterior insulation and interior insulation in the stud cavity (good insulation)
  • one storey above grade

Electricity Consumption : 16 MWH

Heat Consumption : 33 MWH

Annual Utility Bills : $ 2,322

Operating Strategy : Heating Load Following

Commercial and industrial

ELECTRICITY

District energy systems

(e.g. communities)

COOLING

  • 42,000 sqft of total above grade floor space
  • 2x6 metal frame construction with insulation in the stud cavity (poor insulation) with brick clad enclosure
  • Four storeys above grade

Typically plant is sized for heating base load

(i.e. minimum heating load under normal operating conditions)

Heat output = 100-200% of electricity load

  • Packaged single-zone Direct Expansion (DX) Coils cooling system and furnace heating system powered with a natural gas boiler, with ducted return air path

HEATING

  • Doors and windows located and sized as per drawings
  • Double glazed clear tinted aluminum frame windows
  • No overhangs, no skylights

Typical work place occupancy schedule (8am – 5pm on weekdays)

Electricity Consumption : 403 MWH

Heat Consumption : 662 MWH

Annual Utility Bills : $ 55,554

Plant Heating Supply

Plant Power Supply

Peak Load Heating System

Multi-stage boiler system fueled by natural gas @ $7.00/GJ

Peak Load Power System

Capacity: 12,288

Grid electricity (BC Hydro)

Capacity: 9,231 kW

Base Load Power System

Base Load Heating System

Steam turbine fueled by

a) wood pellet @ $117/ton

b) natural gas @ $7.00/GJ

Heat recovered from steam turbine

Capacity: 44,527 kW

Capacity: 9,567 kW

Financial Summary

2% inflation

50 yr project life

70% debt ratio

6% interest rate

25 debt term

One-half to two-thirds of energy is wasted as heat

This heat, otherwise lost, can be used for industrial processes, space and water heating, cooling, etc.

Project Charter

Distribution System 9%

Primary & secondary piping network

Total Initial Cost of CHP System

  • $15,000,000

Technology and Fuels Used

Heating System 12%

Steam Turbine

Boilers, equipment, installation, etc.

Fuels

Natural Gas

Power System 70%

The CHP Concept

Wood Pellets

Steam turbine technology, plant, equipment, installation

Annual Savings and Income

  • $3,000,000

Tools:

100% from base case annual fuel savings

  • electrcity export income assumed $0
  • GHG reduction income assumed $0

Objective:

To prove that CHP is a better system in terms of reduced utility costs, maintenance, and GHG emissions.

Power equipment: Gas turbine, steam turbine, gas turbine-combined cycle, reciprocating engine, fuel cell

Heating equipment: Waste heat recovery, boiler / furnace / heater, heat pump, etc.

Is CHP Financially Viable

Wood pellet as fuel

Total Annual Costs

?

  • Pre-tax IRR 12.1%
  • Pre-tax IRR 5.4%
  • Simple payback 13.8 years
  • Equity payback 11.1 years

Wood Pellet

Assumptions

$2,700,000

Natural Gas

Wood Pellet

Only two types of fuel evaluated for energy production.

Natural gas as fuel

O & M 11%

$2,900,000

Debt Payments 30%

Natural Gas

  • Pre-tax IRR 9.2 %
  • Pre-tax IRR 4.2%
  • Simple payback 16.5 years
  • Equity payback 16.8 years

Fuel Cost 59%

O & M 10%

Debt Payments 29%

Fuel Cost 61%

Building materials limited to those in the database.

Emission Analysis

  • Base Case: 8,700 tons of CO2
  • Proposed Case:
  • Wood pellet - 2,900 tons of CO2
  • Natural gas - 11,000 tons of CO2

CHP generation system will not be covered in detail.

5,800 tons of CO2 reduced.

= 1000 cars and trucks not used

= 13,500 barrels of oil not consumed

= 1,300 arces of forest absorbing carbon

So why choose CHP?

2,300 tons of CO2 added!

Municipality

  • Lower utility rates
  • Lower carbon footprint
  • Reduction of GHG emissions
  • Savings in fuel costs
  • Increased heat and power supply efficiency
  • Income: e.g. export, carbon credit

Why CHP?

Consumer

  • In the Lower Mainland, central district heating and power as an alternative to other forms of building power supply and space heating can be an economically viable and energy efficient solution in medium to large sized new community developments.

Critique of CHP

Return on investment for medium to large communities

Developer

  • Depending on the system characteristics, CHP can be the best solution for all stakeholders involved.
  • The suitability of a CHP system largely depends on the system fuel type, the plant equipment and technology, and the municipality's objectives and requirements. These should be given careful consideration based on economic, technical, environmental, and social factors.
  • While Building retrofits or energy efficiency measures (EEMs) can reduce the energy demand of a building, CHP can have a greater overall impact due to superior system efficiencies.
  • MURB - 11%
  • City Hall - 17%

Thank you.

Questions?

Objective:

To prove that CHP is a better system in terms of reduced utility costs, maintenance, and GHG emissions.