LIBR 271A Group Project

SB
by Sarah Butts0 views·Updated Jul 7, 2011
Powered by AI

Need to present on this topic?

Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.

Free to try, no credit card required

Transcript

Though there is a stigma about using comic books academically, there is a widening acceptance of it. Schwartz (2006) notes that people today get information not just from print, but from all types of media. Learners must be able to critically assess and analyze a variety of information sources. She says, “Both traditional alphabetic literacy and literacies such as information, visual, and media literacy can be well served by classroom engagement with

the graphic novel.” She discusses the

additional feature of exposing readers

to diversity and other cultures, a benefit

echoed by both McTaggart (2005) and

Downey (2009).

Romeo and Juliet

Moby Dick

The Odyssey

Jack London's Call of the Wild: The Graphic Novel

William Shakespeare - author. Adapted by Richard Appignanesi. Illustrated by Sonia Leong. 2007. New York: Harry N. Abrams. (978-0-8109-9325-9).

In Tokyo, Romeo and Juliet fall in love at first sight. The problem is their families are enemies, their love is forbidden. The star crossed lovers attempt to find happiness despite their rival Yakuza families but all ends in tragedy.

Herman Melville - author. Adapted by Lance Stahlberg. Illustrated by Lalit Kumar Singh. 2010. New Delhi, India: Campfire Graphic Novels. (9380028229).

Despite warnings, Ishmael boards a whaling vessel captained by Ahab who is out for revenge after being severely injured by an encounter with a whale.

Homer - author. Adapted by Tim Mucci. Illustrated by Ben Caldwell, Rick Lacy, Emanuel Tenderini. 2009. New York: Sterling. (978-1-4027-3155-6).

Homer’s mythic tale of heroism, vengeance, and homecoming is re-written in graphic novel format. All of the pivotal characters and plot points are portrayed.

Jack London - author. Adapted by Neil Kleid. Illustrated by Alex Nino. 2006. New York, NY: Puffin Books. (0-14-240571-X).

Follow Buck, in this graphic novel, as he is taken from his home and into the wild frozen Yukon. Taught the law of club and fang, Buck becomes a superior sled dog until abandoning civilization and joining a wolf pack.

Pride and Prejudice

The Picture of Dorian Gray

Jane Austen - author. Adapted by Nancy Butler. Illustrated by Hugo Petrus. 2009. New York: Marvel Enterprises.. (978-0-7851-3915-7).

The Bennet family has five daughters, all of which needs a husband. So the family works through British social circles, enduring triumph and turmoil. The addition Mister Darcy into Lizzy’s life just adds more drama for her and her family.

Oscar Wilde - author. Adapted by Roy Thomas. Illustrated by Sebastian Fiumara. 2008. New York: Marvel. ISBN: (978-0-7851-2654-60).

Dorian Gray, a handsome man in his prime, trades his soul to ensure that he will always have his youth. His portrait ages in his stead, a testament to the black marks he puts on his soul.

The Classics - Revisited

A graphic novel collection for high-school students.

Recommendations for Classroom Use

  • Romeo and Juliet: Grade 9 English- This manga format can help develop an understanding of the plot; providing an introduction to Shakespeare’s language and his works in general.
  • Jane Eyre: Grade 12 English- The fact that the text in the graphic novel is written in American English makes it easier for students to understand certain points where they may have had difficultly in the original text.
  • Pride and Prejudice: Grade 12 English- This adaptation allows an easier ability to read aloud in class; a selection of students taking on the role of a certain characters, while others follow along with the illustrations.
  • Around the World in 80 Days: Grade 9 English- Educators may wish to have students read the unabridged and graphic novel editions together so as to discuss the differences and weigh the pros and cons of each.
  • Moby Dick: Grade 12 English- To extend and supplement the story, educators may draw student attention to the last few pages of the book where information about whaling and the historical significance it had on society during that era is discussed.
  • Jack London’s The Call of the Wild: The Graphic Novel: Student demonstration of “Literary Craft and Structure,” as outlined by the California Reading Standards, when reading would include their ability to determine the meaning of the repetitive phrase “the law of club and fang” as it is used in the text.
  • Beowulf: A student’s ability to describe in detail the major events and scenes that occur in Beowulf would demonstrate their ability to conduct a successful “Narrative Analysis,” as outlined by the California Reading Standards.
  • Dante's Divine Comedy: Student proficiency at relating the literary works of authors to the major themes and issues of their time can be demonstrated by a student’s ability to identify how the different politics and scandals of Dante's time are also depicted in the Divine Comedy.
  • The Metamorphosis: This book would be good to use as a tool to analyze the central ideas and intent of the original. Students can critically evaluate this book as one interpretation of the text, discussing the ambiguities of Kafka's classic.
  • The Odyssey: This graphic adaptation might best be used by students struggling with literacy issues. If read concurrently with the original version, this book will provide plain-English context to the action in the book, bringing to life the mythic characters.
  • The Picture of Dorian Gray: This book could be read either in parallel with the original, along with one of Wilde's other pieces, or as part of a section on Victorian or gothic literature. Unlike some other adaptations, this novel contains enough if the spirit of the original that it can stand on its own, without a reader's prior knowledge of the canon.

Beowulf

The Metamorphosis

References

  • Downey, E. (2009). Graphic novels in curriculum and instruction collections. Reference & User Services Quarterly, 49(2), 181-188.
  • Henry, R., & Simpson, C. (2001). Picture books & older readers: A match made in heaven. Teacher Librarian, 28(3), 23-27.
  • Learning Point Associates. (2010). Access to print materials improves reading. Retrieved July 5, 2010, from www.rif.org/documents/us/RIFandLearningPointMeta-OnePager.pdf
  • McTaggart, J. (2005). Using comics and graphic novels to encourage reluctant readers. Reading Today, 23(2), 46.
  • Schwarz, G. (2006). Expanding literacies through graphic novels. English Journal, 95(6), 58-64.
  • Seyfried, Jonathan. (2008). Graphic novels as educational heavyweights. Knowledge Quest, 36 (3), 44-48.
  • Images of The Book of Kells and The Canterbury Tales throughout introduction courtesy of Creative Commons.
  • Baker & Taylor. (2011, July). Retrieved from http://publiclibrary.btol.com
  • BWI: Titletales. (2011, July). Retrieved from http://bwibooks.com

The Tools

We believe that inclusion of graphic novels in high

school literature curriculum is one answer to this

question. As Seyfried (2008) notes, “This revitalized

genre has not only saved the day for recreational

reading, it has also turned out to be a heavyweight in the teaching of

advanced themes in literature and visual literacy.” We hope that the collection presented here, all titles based on classic works, will serve as an inspiration to educators and librarians to use this medium as an educational tool. We believe graphic novels can improve literacy for both vociferous and reluctant readers, encourage critical thinking and analysis of information, and provide a sense of freedom and fun in the learning process. Our collection is not intended to replace the originals – it is offered as supplement and enrichment.

Henry and Simpson (2001) note “"The present

generation of students has come of age surrounded

by visual stimuli. They regularly watch television,

play video games, and use computers with

increasingly sophisticated graphics.” They continue,

“Picture books are a natural for them, combining

text and pictures in ways that make the story clearer and more fun to read." Graphic novels are being published that are adaptations of all types of books, movies, even video games. McTaggart (2005) supports the use of graphic novels in inspiring reluctant readers, stating: “Clearly, comics and graphic novels do not constitute what most of us consider to be good literature. However, before we can make kids read what we want them to, we must first make them want to read. If hooking kids on books requires us to do it their way, via comics and graphic novels, so be it.”

All too often we see high school students, when faced with traditional classic literature, check out mentally; either bored by the sometimes archaic language or threatened by the challenge of the curriculum. And yet, “children with greater access to books and other print materials—through either borrowing books or receiving books to own—express more

enjoyment of books, reading, and academics”

(Learning Point Associates, 2010). We

know these books are classics for a reason;

this literature has enriched our society and

even our entertainment for centuries, and the

stories are good too! So how do we lead our

children to these treasures and show them

the persevering relevance of these books?

The problem...

In an effort to provide a meaningful and quality bibliography to youth and educators, a variety of professional resources were cross referenced to substantiate the graphic novels that are included in the pathfinder. Specifically, the California Department of Education’s Language Arts Content Standards were referenced as a means to determine student appropriateness and educational tie-ins for each book. Local high school reading lists and professional collection development tools such as review journals, Baker and Taylor, and Book Wholesalers, Inc. were also utilized to evaluate the quality, age appropriateness and format of the graphic novels included in the list. The culmination resulted in a bibliography that not only supports California educational standards, but also provides broader access of quality graphic novels to recreational readers and to those seeking alternatives to classic literature in the traditional format.

Adapted and Illustrated by Gareth Hinds. 2007. Cambridge, MA: Candlewick Press. (978-0-7636-3022-5).

Follow the epic tale of Beowulf, in graphic novel format, as he battles barehanded against the evil monster called Grendel, vanquishes Grendel’s vengeful Mother, and fights his final battle against a rampaging dragon in order to protect his kingdom.

Franz Kafka - author. Adapted and illustrated by Peter Kuper. 2003. New York: Three River Press. (1-40000-5299-8).

Gregor Samsa awakes one morning to find that he has transformed, this time in graphic format. Gregor and his family must come to terms with his ghastly change, and learn how to move on.

LIBR 271A - Jennifer Medina, Devyn Reynolds, Sarah BUtts, and Jennifer Knell

Jane Eyre

Around the World in 80 Days

Dante's divine comedy

Jules Verne - author. Adapted and Illustrated by Rod Espinosa. 2008. Edina, Minnesota: Red Wagon. (1602700508).

Phileas Fogg wagers that he can travel the world in 80 days. The next day he sets off to tour the world traveling by boat, train and many other modes of transportation.

Charlotte Bronte - author. Adapted by Amy Corzine & Joe Sutliff Sanders. Illustrated by John M. Burns. 2008. Towcester, United Kingdom. (978-1-906332-48-8).

As an orphan Jane Eyre’s childhood was difficult. But as she grows Eyre perseveres and becomes a governess at Thornfield where she meets Mister Rochester and quickly falls in love for him. But Mister Rochester has many secrets.

Dante Alighieri - author. Adapted and Illustrated by Seymour Chwast. New York: Bloomsbury. (ISBN: 978-1-60819-084-3).

In this graphic novel adaptation of Dante's famous allegorical poem, take a tour Hell, Purgatory, and Paradise with Dante and his guide Virgil as they learn of the different pleasures and punishments that saints and sinners have been assigned.