How the smartphone technology has broken the boundaries between private and public life

MD
by Marta de la Torre2 views·Updated Dec 29, 2013
Powered by AI

Need to present on this topic?

Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.

Free to try, no credit card required

Slide outline

  1. Labour in iTime
  2. “[...]home has invaded work and work has invaded home and the boundary is likely never to be restored" — [Lee Rainie, director of the Pew Research Center’s Internet and American Life Project]

Transcript

Broken boundaries between private and public life

1. Set a Collective Goal of Personal Interest

- Valued by the team as a group

- Small but doable

- Concrete and measurable

In BCG: the collective goal was based on a way to give predictable time off without compromising the very demanding work they do for clients.

2. Structure and Create an Open Dialogue.

How do we achieve the collective goal?

“Have you achieved the goal and if not why not?”

“Looking ahead, how will we achieve the goal next week?”

How do we engage more generally in conversations about the work process itself?

“How are you feeling about this?"

" Are we delivering to our clients?"

" Are you learning and developing?"

" And, is this sustainable?”

3. Team Leaders' Involvement.

Legal terms of use of smartphones in Enterprises

29%

37%

could not live without their devices

PTO

Predictable Time Off

Smartphones Are Powerful, Real-Time Tools for Professionals

  • Ex1: Christopher Matthews, a paramedic. In the past : a bag of medical reference books with hi; now :constantly updated pharmaceutical database.

  • Multifunctionality

65%

26%

COMPANY

ISSUED

SMARTPHONE

be productive during "dead times" like traffic jams

easier to stay in touch with

people you care about

Technology is rewiring our brains.

  • ability to focus undermined by bursts of information. The stimulation provokes excitement -a dopamine squirt without which people feel bored =>cuts on creativity and deep thought, interrupting work and family life
  • myth of multitasking:
  • -20/40% efficiency;
  • real multitaskers=3% of the population;

but

  • improved neural circuity
  • improved ablity to catch details amid clutter

BYOD

All-in-One Handhelds Aren’t Perfect

  • Accidentally opened programs;
  • Multifunctionality can make them frustrating to use
  • "Always on" behavior = workaholism
  • Little to no expectation of privacy;
  • phone number belongs to the company;
  • tracking employees

9%

44%

  • Issues with enterprise information confidentiality:
  • issues retaining customers if employee leaves company

Attachment

Distraction

11%

7%

Waste of time

BCG started in the Boston office with one team of 6 consultants and 4 years later…

 

86% of the consulting staff in Boston was in teams engaged in PTO projects

Moreover, the PTO has become a global project

Changes in BCG were extremely positive

A genuine win-win:

 

* Happier employees --- better retention

* Dialogues --- improvements in the work process

Thank you for listening!

Any question?

Evolution of output at work

From the internet in the late 1980s

After World War II to the late 1980s

Smartphones at work: Engaged or just connected?

This is a global era of laptop (or fast [Agger, 1989]) capitalism.

Many people no longer need to dress for success in the white collars

"The Iron Rolling Mill" as painted by Adolph Menzel, 1872-1875.

How has the smartphone technology broken the boundaries between private and work life?

  • The early factory system sprung from the growth of European and American cities
  • Technology was rudimentary and output minimal
  • The struggle to survive was intense

They can wear t-shirts, as they ‘office’ from home, at Starbucks, even in their cars. This era involves ‘telecommuting,’ as workers are connected to the office via the internet (Leonhard, 1995).

iTime

This was the era of the ‘organization man’, as capitalism entered a bureaucratic stage and the labour process began to shift from factory to office (Mills, 2002; Whyte, 1956).

Structure

Mobile time:

time that is portable and elastic

  • The ‘‘anytime/anywhere’’ connectivity enabled by smart- phones means that employees can work longer hours (duration), access better quality data whenever they need it (intensity), and broaden the scope for work involvement (direction).
  • Duration: increases when connectivity becomes ubiquitous and continuous.
  • Intensity: increases when information flow increases
  • Direction: increases when users can carry their work with them and engage in work activities in locations and at times that were previously outside of work or off limits.
  • Evolution of output at work
  • Smartphones "at work"
  • Intrusion of work life in private life
  • Intrusion of private life in work life
  • Case study: BCG

Marx

foresaw solidity melting into air,

but perhaps

not in these

dramatic ways.

Entails

a lot of

literary activity

Is densely

compressed

1900

1700

1947

2013

1980s

[Marx and Engels, 1998]

Entails

maniac connectivity

Renders

history immobile

or even irrelevant

Frederick Taylor and Henry Ford’s effort to measure and manage industrial output

Chiara Occhipinti

Giammarco Rizzo

Marta de la Torre

Ofelia Botella

Silvia Diaz

A recent study (2012) investigated the use of BlackBerrys in two global investment banks.

  • Activity 24/7, with employees in constant communication with clients and colleagues world-wide.
  • High performance work ethic where employees are expected to work long hours and be responsive to the market and customer needs.
  • Early adopters of smartphone technology and therefore have relatively more evolved experience levels of use of the devices.

Ford initiated the era of mass production, using the assembly line to produce inexpensive goods in great volume, putting America on wheels and providing a model for other modes of production, eventually including agribusiness (Kay, 1997).

Type of users

3 categories of Smartphone users

Level of impact

Hypo connector

(Disengaged)

Hyper connector

(Disengagement)

Dynamic connector

(Functional Engagement)

Individual

  • Fear of loss of control/addiction
  • Boundary protection
  • Distracted
  • Low work focus
  • Avoidance
  • Autonomy
  • Control
  • Flexibility
  • Involvement
  • Boundary management
  • Self-efficacy
  • Ambidextrous
  • Burnout
  • Workaholic/addiction
  • No boundaries
  • Antisocial behaviors
  • Work-life conflict
  • Lack of recovery time

Dynamic Connectors

Hypo- Connectors

Hyper-Connectors

"[Even on holidays] I feel compelled to carry it all day long . . . there are no more complete breaks. It is a sort of permanent connection that did not exist before.’’

‘‘Previously, when I caught transport to and from work, I would’ve read the

paper, read a book . . .’’ ‘‘You just can’t get away from it.’’

‘‘My wife has made the comment that it’s the last thing I see at night and the first thing I see in the morning, which is somehow not good.’’ ‘‘It definitely detracts from your home life.’’

"I don’t want to be contactable 24/7.’’

‘‘I prefer to finish my work during the hours that I’m at work . . . there’s better things in life than being at work all the time.’’

Organization

"I can connect when and where I want . . . It means I am a lot less stressed because I can go home when I need to’’ . . . ‘‘I can stay on top of what needs to be done.’’

"I think I just have to be available during working hours and after working hours is up to me if I want to turn my phone off"

  • Out-of-connection, out-of-the loop
  • Misrepresentation
  • Unavailability
  • Disinterest
  • Pro activity
  • Coordination
  • Collaboration
  • Responsiveness
  • (internal and external customers)
  • Feedback
  • Flexible work design
  • Shallow, diffused, superficial communication
  • Job creep
  • Disruptive
  • Role modeling excess
  • Over-communication
  • Reactivity
  • Absent presence
  • Reduced delegation
1

Labour in iTime

  • Labour is largely writing of emails, texts, memos, blogs.
  • Professional work time is devoted to life on the screen, which bleeds into ‘private’ communication as interlocutors transact business and chat, sometimes indistinguishably.
  • Labour is not bound by either the business day or the office
  • Labour is self-reproducing, as messages trigger other messages, seemingly endlessly.
  • iTime oozes everywhere, driving out downtime.
  • Working everywhere
  • Working anytime
  • Freedom from the cubicle

No downtime

Trespassing of public/private border due to nearly limitless access and availability

2

“[...]home has invaded work and work has invaded home and the boundary is likely never to be restored"

[Lee Rainie, director of the Pew Research Center’s Internet and American Life Project]