Copy of Indian Urban Slums

CB
by Carl Buchanon II3 views·Updated Jan 18, 2013
Powered by AI

Need to present on this topic?

Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.

Free to try, no credit card required

Transcript

Mahila Mandals:

Case Studies from the Field

Shivaji Nagar

Presentation Outline

I. Introduction

II. Background Information

III. Methods

IV. Results

V. Discussion

VI. Conclusion

Introduction

  • To study the organization and activities of women’s organizations in the Shivaji Nagar- Baigan Wadi communities.
  • To do case studies on two Mahila Mandals
  • To perform a SWOT analysis on these women’s organizations
  • To briefly discuss the public health significance of MM

A Brief History of the

Mahila Mandals

Registered vs. Non Registered

Mahila Mandals

  • Mahila Mandals need to be registered by the office of the Charity Commissioner, Maharashtra, under two acts:
  • An Act for the Registration of Literary, Scientific and Charitable Societies- Societies registration Act, 1860
  • The Bombay Public Trusts Act-1950

Assets

Methods

  • Qualitative design
  • Snowball sampling
  • SWOT analysis
  • Six interviews of Mahila Mandals
  • 2 in-depth interviews/case studies
  • 4 supplementary interviews
  • Apnalaya, CORO (Committee of Resource Organizations), & SNEHA (Society for Nutrition, Education & Health Action)

Nadira - Rafi Nagar

Plot 12 Mahila Mandal

Baigan Wadi

Discussion

  • One group had three members while another had 150.
  • Registration with government
  • Presence or lack of highly motivated leader
  • Ages of group members
  • Collaborations with other Mahila Mandals
  • *Key commonality: lack of outside funding

Based on our small sample of MMs, active organizations seem to:

  • Have a strong woman who has an additional community role (e.g. community health worker).
  • Have a supportive husband and family.
  • Have current NGO collaborations.
  • Have some educated women (at least 6th grade education).

Public Health Significance

  • Study participant complaints
  • Antiretroviral drug Tenofovir trials shut down in Cambodia and Ghana due to community opposition (see Page-Schafer et al., 2005; Singh and Mills, 2005; Tindana et al., 2007)
  • Will this opposition happen in Shivaji Nagar?
  • Problems with asking questions
  • May have inadequately exposed MMs weaknesses and threats.
  • Did not include observations of MM activities or interviews with unassociated community members.
  • Small sample of MMs.
  • Unknown impact of MMs (although impact is notoriously hard to measure)

Thank you for your attention!

References

Das, M. (2000, December 9-15). Mahila mandals in gender politics. Economic and Political Weekly, 35 (50), 4391-4395.

Devasia, L. (1998). Safe drinking water and its acquisition: rural women’s participation in water management in Maharastra, India. International Journal of Water Resources Development, 14 (4), 537-546.

Morgan, A. & Ziglio E. (2007). Revitalising the evidence base for public health: an assets model. Promotion and Education, 14, 17-22.

Page-Schafer, K., Saphonn, V., Sun, L.P., Vun, M.C., Cooper, D.A., Kaldor, J.M. (2005). HIV prevention research in a resource-limited setting: the experience of planning a trial in Cambodia. The Lancet, 366, 1499-1503.

Sharpe, P.A., Greany, M.L., Lee, P.R., Royce, S.W. (2000). Assets-oriented community assessment. Public Health Reports, 115, 205-211.

Singh, J.A. & Mills E.J. (2005). The abandoned trials of pre-exposure prophylaxis for HIV: What went wrong? PloS Medicine, 2(9), e234.

Tindana, P.O., Singh, J.A., Tracy, C.S., Upshur, R.E.G., Daar, A.S., Singer, P.A., Frohlich, J. Lavery, J.V. (2007). Grand challenges in global health: Community engagement in research in developing countries. PLoS Medicine, 4(9), e273.

Wilson, M.G., Lavis, J.N., Guta, A. (2012), Community-Based Organizations in the Health Sector: A Scoping Review. Health Research Policy and Systems, 10, 36-42

Common Threats

  • Local mafia
  • Corrupt politicians
  • Gender roles

RESULTS

Ethical Dilemmas

" I don't want other women to go through the same experiences as me "

History (Her-Story)

  • Arrived in 1995 from Calcutta
  • Mother of 4
  • 2005 - met with group in Lotus Colony
  • Received training from CORO
  • Founded Lokmanya Foundation (NGO)

Mahila Mandal

  • Registered
  • 150 women

Activities:

  • Train girls on how to deal with teasing and harassment
  • Help with family planning
  • Educate women on how to save money
  • Women's employment
  • Children's education

SWOT

STRENGTHS:

  • Educated up to 10th grade
  • Strong sense of organizational cohesiveness
  • Young women involved

WEAKNESSES:

  • none noted

OPPORTUNITIES:

  • Extremely supportive family
  • Empowered by CORO, NGO, and Lotus Colony

THREATS:

  • No outside funding
  • Fragmented network of MM in area - no collaboration
  • Religious beliefs
  • Men can be bullies, as can local mafia

Limitations

Shivaji Nagar Plot 18

  • Founded: 1988
  • Registered
  • 11 members
  • Clean up gutters and toilets by collecting money
  • Partner with NGOs, CORO, Apnalaya, pratham and other MMs
  • Established a temple in their plot
  • Motivate rag-pickers to create their own MM
  • Reduce tuition for kids and send them to schools

Mahila Mandals are an example of a grassroots initiative to improve the health of people in several areas:

Baigan Wadi Plot 24

  • Formed in 1985, 11 women
  • Registered
  • Collect money to celebrate 2-3 festivals
  • Very rarely clean the area
  • They accompany lonely people to the hospital
  • They started a new anganwadi (daycare)

Baigan Wadi Plot 22

  • Founded 12 years ago
  • Not registered
  • 3 women
  • They advocate for issues important to the community through authorities.
  • Encourage pregnant women to go to the hospital
  • Worked with NGOs like CORO, Apnalaya, and Pratham
  • Spread news about immunization camps
  • Inspire children to go to school

Deonar Dumping Ground

MM History

MM Activities

  • Founded 8yrs ago
  • Registered 5yrs ago
  • 20-25 women
  • Have chairman, secretary, & cashier
  • Receive no govt. funds
  • Clean bathrooms and gutters
  • Assist in Domestic Violence issues
  • ANC (Antenatal Care)
  • Encourage parents to get children immunized
  • Built temple for festivals and community events in plot

SWOT

STRENGTHS:

  • Educated women
  • Support from within group
  • Sense of community

THREATS:

  • No outside funding
  • Lack of communication with other MMs
  • No role of the government
  • Some families are not supportive

WEAKNESSES:

  • Few young women are involved in group
  • Lack of funds

OPPORTUNITIES:

  • Few partnerships with UHP and NGOs
  • Collaborations with other women’s organizations

Plot 30 - Adarsh Nagar Mahila Mandal

  • Registered in 2006
  • Consists of 12 women, the chair person is also a member of a political party
  • Promote children’s & women’s education
  • Employment for men and women
  • Provide financial support to children who are intelligent and cannot afford education
  • Have microloan schemes for emergency funds
  • Help people get their compensations from the government for occupational injuries
  • Maternal and child health
  • Sanitation
  • Water availability
  • Crime (e.g. domestic violence)

Group 1

The Asset Model

  • “Any factor (or resource), which enhances the abilities of individuals, groups, communities, populations, social systems, and/or institutions to maintain and sustain health and well being and to help to reduce health inequities,” (Morgan and Ziglio, 2007, 18).
  • Promotes the population as a producer rather than a consumer of health services.

Open gutter

MMs are community-based oragnizations that seek to improve health outcomes in the communities in which they live.

Megha Bhavsar

Carl Buchanon II

Nicole Cerra

Krithika Rupnarayan

Sarah Simpson

  • The Asset Model versus the Deficit Model
  • Both are important, but there is more research on the dominant Deficit Model
  • Asset mapping: build an inventory of the strengths and gifts of people, which reveals how to access community assets (Sharpe et al., 2000).
  • Research on assets is particularly important in poor communities.

Background Information

Conclusion

MMs are a valuable community asset that vary in size and scope.

It is imperative to utilize existing organizations such as MMs to further public health interventions in the slum and plot areas of Shivaji Nagar

  • A registered group has the advantage of being able to apply for government loans and financial schemes by the government.
  • Mahila Mandals, being community based organizations may or may not be registered to be able to function.
  • Traditional, local organizations of women who come together for celebrations or to address problems
  • Large number of women’s organizations since 19th century
  • Role in participatory development
  • Forum for dialogue and discussion

Special Thanks

  • Sachin Nikalaje
  • Shabnam Shiekh
  • Swati
  • Study Participants
  • Dr. Nilesh Gawade
  • Dr. Amit Bhondve
  • TISS

Registration

  • Capacity building of members to problem solve
  • Group confidence
  • Set agendas
  • Individual weaknesses collective action

Tasks of the Mahila Mandal

Welcome to Shivaji Nagar

  • Comprised of slums & plots: Shivaji Nagar, Baigan Wadi, Rafi Nagar, Adarsh Nagar and other communities
  • Population of about 600,000 people
  • Located near the Deonar dumping ground

Active organizations

Empower

Variations in size, scope, and activity level

V

i

c

e

Goals

Pow r

Themes &

Observations

  • To promote education- set up schools, anganwadis, balwadis, middle schools and high schools.
  • To promote women’s education
  • To help the intelligent children who cannot afford education
  • To help educated and uneducated men and women with employment
  • To help the orphaned, disabled, widowed – provide shelter for them
  • Keeping the community clean
  • To plant trees in the community, set up composting facilities
  • To help women with domestic violence issues

Goals

Why we chose this topic?

Sanitation Issues

Common activities include:

  • Collect money to clean community and celebrate festivals
  • Maternal education
  • Childhood education and vaccination
  • Advocacy
  • Creation of temple/public space

-From snowball sampling, we came to learn about Mahila Mandals.

-We were impressed by how Mahila Mandals came together to address some public health issues in their communities such as sanitation, immunization, education and domestic violence.

-We wanted to focus on public health solutions.

-Community-based organizations are important health system stakeholders (Wilson et al, 2012).

Public bathrooms

  • Are not cleaned daily which leads to dirty, smelly, & unusable stalls

Sewer system

  • Gutters, supposed to be cleaned
  • Most gutters are blocked with sewage and stagnant water

Can lead to diseases such as diarrhea, malaria, & gastroenteritis

Sanitation and Toilet Use

Community Organized Solutions

Plotted Areas:

  • Share one public toilet (14 stalls for men and 14 for women) among 100 households, about 1000 people
  • Supposed to be cleaned daily
  • Residents pool funds to hire bathroom and gutter cleaners
  • This was often organized by a group of women called Mahila Mandals (MMs)

Slums:

  • Have no toilet
  • Use Pay-to-use toilets or surrounding land