Cultural Identity and School Success

KM
by Kristy Meyers0 views·Updated Aug 12, 2013
Powered by AI

Need to present on this topic?

Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.

Free to try, no credit card required

Transcript

So...

"given the ASCA National Model and its emphasis on recognizing and respecting students' ethnic cultural diversity, it seems fitting that school counselors make enhancing students' ethnic identity development a major component of comprehensive counseling programs" (Holcomb-McCoy, 2005 p.124)

Questions?

Directions for Future Research

Practical Implications

More representative participant samples

Divariablessaggregated data

Replicating with teachers/parents

Investigating other confounding

Cultural Identity

and Student Success

Method

Inclusive and equitable school environments that encourage identity and support all students (Holcomb-McCor, 2005; Sheets, 2006; Shin et al., 2007; Whiting, 2006)

  • instill self-esteem and cultural pride
  • create a valuable social context

Role of school counselors

  • curriculum and developmental guidance lessons
  • cultural sensitivity, barriers, and communication
  • Better training and more diverse staff
  • Community and resources
  • Education - Consultation - Collaboration - Referrals

Participants

  • 53 school counselors nation-wide
  • Demographics: age, gender, ethnicity, and work setting

Procedure

  • IRB approval and ASCA/MSCA distribution

Measures

  • 28 quantitative and qualitative questions in online survey
  • Demographic information
  • School curriculum, effectiveness, and cultural identity
  • Impact of cultural identity on 12 variables
  • Qualitative responses in regard to suggestions for educational professionals and importance of the topic
  • Collected via Google forms and available in table and graphical format online

Impacts of strong, positive cultural identity

  • Attendance: Over 50% rated at 8 or higher
  • School Engagement: over 50% at 8 or higher
  • Academic Goals: 55% at 8 or higher
  • Academic Self-confidence, School GPA, & Standardized test scores all with less significant relationships
  • Classroom Demeanor: 53% at 8 or higher
  • Motivation: 67% at 8 or higher
  • Relationships with peers and staff rated strongly
  • Self-esteem: 56% rated at 9 or 10 (most substantial)

Qualitative Findings

"How do you think your school climate could be more supportive of cultural identity development?"

  • Celebrate cultures/traditions
  • Better curriculum and interventions
  • Better cultural competency training and more diverse staff

"Why do you believe cultural identity is an important topic to education and the field of school counseling?"

The Research Question

Results

Kristina

Mandell

Curriculum for cultural identity development

  • 23% yes, 64% no, 13% unsure

Effectiveness of school

  • 26% rated school effectiveness at 6 of 10
  • 11% rated school effectiveness at 1 of 10

Scaled responses to cultural identity categories

  • In reality and in most settings: embrace host culture, accept host culture
  • Rated most beneficial: embrace and integrate both cultures

Cultural identity

  • from the dual perspective
  • in various settings

Impacts of cultural identity

  • Student success
  • Well-being
  • Mediating factors

Discussion

Ratings of cultural identity impacts and qualitative responses

  • Academic goals, school engagement, classroom demeanor, motivation, relationships with peer and staff
  • Most notable: self-esteem

Number of participants

Discrepancy between identities developed and most beneficial identity

Cultural Identity

The Benefits of Identity

Protective factor: contributing to sense of belonging, self-esteem, and resilience (Holcomb-Mccoy, 2005; Shin et al., 2007; Wakefield & Hudley, 2007)

Theories of cultural identity:

  • Historical deficit model
  • Oppositional identity (Ogbu, 2004)
  • Aronson's theory of stereotype threat (Altschul et al., 2008; Herman, 2009)
  • Segmented assimilation theory (Altschul et al. 2008)
  • Racial-Ethnic self-schema [RES] perspective

Twofold perspectives: acculturation to mainstream identity vs. identifying with culture of origin

Cultural identity and student Success

  • Academic motivation, adjustment, engagement, and achievement (Bhatti, 2006; Cohen & Garcia, 2008; Wakefield & Hudley, 2007; Worrell, 2007)
  • School performance and aspirations for the future (Schultz, 1999)

Cultural identity and well-being

  • Self-esteem, coping, and adaptive behaviors (Rayle & Myers, 2004)

Mediating effects of cultural identity

  • Fewer symptoms of depression and anxiety
  • Lower levels of delinquency, aggression, violence, and substance abuse (Holcomb-McCoy, 2005; Wakefield & Hudley, 2007)

The Context

The Literature

National achievement gap

  • Racial and socioeconomic academic disparities
  • Effects on well-being
  • Contributing factors: systemic inequities, drive, teacher training, cultural barriers

Culture and identity

Achievement gap focus

Current legislative efforts

Culture and identity

  • in-group vs. out-group, especially with cultures viewed as subordinate

Foundation