Copy of Strategic Analysis Presentation

MT
by Meenal Tripathi0 views·Updated Jul 9, 2013
Powered by AI

Need to present on this topic?

Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.

Free to try, no credit card required

Transcript

iCoCo

A very brief introduction...

local tension, discrimination and social breakdown - a huge mountain to climb

Community cohesion as the policy answer for all of this...

What does the external environment look like?

PESTEL

Need for iCoCo services exists everywhere, but demand doesn't

The usual substitute is the 'bare minimum'

Proof - recently beaten to 2 'cohesion contracts' by other local universities

Internal Analysis

The significance of iCoCo's biggest costs does not align with the significance of its activities

What does iCoCo's portfolio look like now?

And how should it be developed in the future?

  • Competitive Scope : Narrow targets
  • Selection of new markets like education institutes, international networks etc.
  • Competitive Strategy : Differentiation
  • Generic Strategy : Focused differentiation
  • Exploiting these narrow target markets with tailor made services.

How does iCoCo achieve competitive advantage?

The future...some suggestions

Some suggestions for...

Sustaining differentiation based advantage

...Strategic Business Units (2012 – 13)

  • Base the services provided on academic research
  • Expand the learning curve
  • Learning by doing -“kaizen” (continuous improvement)
  • Consulting Corporate firms (private sector)
  • Post Graduate programs
  • Public Service Consultation (tension monitoring)
  • Academic research
  • International presence (technical assistance)

Harrison (2003) - a more relevant approach to generic strategy choice

Harrison (2003) - a more relevant approach to generic strategy choice

Three main decisions within a generic strategy:

  • Range of customers (broad or narrow market)
  • A narrow market for iCoCo
  • Level of quality (as perceived by consumers)
  • relatively high for iCoCo
  • Cost structure (patterns of resource use)

Three main value/price combinations:

  • Cost leadership: lower value, lower price
  • Differentiation: higher value, higher price
  • Best value: higher value at lower price

(Best value (hybrid) strategies challenge Porter’s insistence on commitment to a rigid strategy)

Three main decisions within a generic strategy:

  • Range of customers (broad or narrow market)
  • A narrow market for iCoCo
  • Level of quality (as perceived by consumers)
  • relatively high for iCoCo
  • Cost structure (patterns of resource use)

Three main value/price combinations:

  • Cost leadership: lower value, lower price
  • Differentiation: higher value, higher price
  • Best value: higher value at lower price

(Best value (hybrid) strategies challenge Porter’s insistence on commitment to a rigid strategy)

Current strategy

Current strategy

Future strategy

Using Porter’s Approach to Generic Strategies

Bowman’s Strategy Clock

iCoCo is here

  • Commitment to a distinctive or unique strategy that rules out other choices
  • The assumption that Differentiation is High quality service that is expensive to produce and Customers will be willing to pay more!

Criticism

Note: The strategy clock is adapted from the work of Cliff Bowman (see D. Faulkner and C. Bowman, The Essence of Competitive Strategy, Prentice Hall, 1995.) However, Bowman uses the dimenstion ‘Perceived Use Value’.

Source: Johnson, Scholes and Whittington (2005)

What generic strategy is iCoCo using?

SBUs 2011/12

Our key ideas

Macro-economic and political change in Europe and nothing for iCoCo in the UK

...but a growing international research market...

despite being costly an investment in research creates value for clients, greater impact and sustainability for iCoCo

An investment in research brings greater differentiation than external consultants and costs less

iCoCo needs dramatic change to survive in an extremely difficult environment

iCoCo must regain its power over its 5 forces through strategic choices and a new business model

iCoCo needs a new portfolio of services to complement its new markets...but this change must be managed through a careful process of diversification - changing too fast could be worse than staying still

Value should be created through internal resource not external reliance

iCoCo's current strategy doesn't offer enough value for its price, compared to its competitors - strategic choices must be made to lower the price and raise the value for iCoCo to have any competitive edge

  • Tension Monitoring
  • Community mapping
  • Post graduate program
  • Terrorism monitoring

Our recommendations

Diversify the portfolio - one market is too risky

International arena looks most promising - especially Africa

Investment in research creates sustainability and competitive edge

The University is full of academics, use them and recruit your own!!

Apply for funding through structured tendering processes - less power for the buyer

Re-brand and change name - don't align yourself wholly with political policy

Business Level Strategies

Thanks for listening...

Meenal, Leann, Praveen, Kamil, Bello and Tom

Analysis

Our key ideas

Macro-economic and political change in Europe and nothing for iCoCo in the UK

...but a growing international research market...

despite being costly an investment in research creates value for clients, greater impact and sustainability for iCoCo

An investment in research brings greater differentiation than external consultants and costs less

iCoCo needs dramatic change to survive in an extremely difficult environment

iCoCo must regain its power over its 5 forces through strategic choices and a new business model

future

Value should be created through internal resource not external reliance

iCoCo needs a new portfolio of services to complement its new markets...but this change must be managed through a careful process of diversification - changing too fast could be worse than staying still

after Ansoff's diversification

The Boston Consulting Group Matrix BCG (2012-13)

Star:

Tension Monitoring

Problem Child:

Academic Research

The Boston Consulting Group Matrix BCG (2011-12)

Cash Cow:

Postgraduate Programmes

Dog:

Community Mapping

Star:

Tension Monitoring

Problem Child:

Postgraduate Programmes

Relative market share

Cash Cow:

Community Mapping

Dog:

Preventing Terrorism

Relative market share

iCoCo's main services...

Tension Monitoring

Community Mapping

Postgraduate Courses

Terrorism Prevention

current

BCG

Ansoff

2

Phase 2...

...a diversified destination

crowded and declining market

We suggest...

Product/Market Diversification

Market Development

Developing new related services

...two phases of development

exploiting the last of a declining public sector market...

Phase 1...

...a transitional stage

a mixed market economy for success in today's research market

Developing new services for new markets

Product/Market Diversification

Developing new markets

iCoCo's current model...

...whilst testing new services with new potential markets before committing to them

Market Penetration

a remarkable story

a remarkable shift

a remarkable future

HR

HR

Procurement

Procurement

Support activities

Support activities

Infrastructure

Infrastructure

Administration and Procurement

Administration and Procurement

Sales

Sales

Client Relationship Management

Client Relationship Management

Service Delivery

Service Delivery

Project Management

Marketing and Campaigning

Project Management

Marketing and Campaigning

Primary Activities

Primary Activities

SWOT Analysis and Resource Audit

Where is value created at iCoCo?

Strengths

Weaknesses

Lots of project delivery experience

Strong national profile and connections

Full backing of the University resources, connections and brand

Located in city of peace and reconciliation

Administration functions well established

Culture of dedication and hard work for a cause

New director with strong international connections and experience

USP of national centre of cohesion work

Building and facilities extremely desirable

Excellent project managers

Foreign language speakers

Completely unique services

History of first-mover advantage

A comparative analysis

Proposition connected to Political ideology

Very small team reliant on expensive external consultants

Lack of research skills and experience

Reputation and reach fading fast

Revenue shrinking

Working in too many places with a very small core team

An exhausted idea connected to static and recycled offers

Through maturity, well into decline

Website out of date and under-utilised

Consultancy without research and innovation is not sustainable

Poor reputation for impact of work

Little academic talent

Huge financial deficit

=

New Director with international status and a University wanting international presence

Growing international research market

+

international development

Key Strengths

Key Weaknesses

SURGE vs iCoCo

University backing

Strong culture

New international Director

Funds for investment in R and D

Connected to party politics

Exhausted and static services

Consultancy model not sustainable

Reliant on expensive external consultants

Key Opportunities

Key Threats

Our key ideas

Community cohesion work on decline

Competitors have research background and greater competitive advantage

Government dislike cohesion ideas

Growing international social research market

Coventry University growing international presence

iCoCo needs dramatic change to survive in an extremely difficult environment

Macro-economic and political change in Europe and nothing for iCoCo in the UK

...but a growing international research market...

+

=

despite being costly an investment in research creates value for clients, greater impact and sustainability for iCoCo

iCoCo must regain its power over its 5 forces through strategic choices and a new business model

No academic research skills internally and reliance on expensive consultants

Competitors base services on research (SGA)

Comparative Cost

Domestic market saturated for many offers – high competition led to small businesses delivering essentials of our offer for

Recession has made community cohesion an expensive ideology – static offer seen as non-essential, iCoCo services have become highly elastic and demand reduced

Change in Government– community cohesion taken completely off the agenda in the UK

University resources not forever – time pressure

Partners shut down by government and contacts lost through redundancy

Duty to promote community cohesion in schools taken away

Competitors investing more in academic R and D – risk of being left behind

Key issue of our time – diversity and conflict

UN – intercultural dialogue as a new initiative

UK seen as a centre of authority in diversity matters

Coventry University growing international presence and overseas student market developments

Globalisation – cheaper and easier travel

Growing market for international research contracts and network building

International turmoil and conflict

International partners with similar interests

Some domestic work still available on small scale

Lots of economies of scale to be reaped from large research contracts

More than one way to be valuable to the University – research contribution over income. Opportunity to see the University as a customer.

recruit some academics and invest in research

An investment in research brings greater differentiation than external consultants and costs less

Value should be created through internal resource not external reliance

iCoCo

SURGE

Research and Development

Service Development and Delivery

Marketing, Sales and Political Campaigning

Project and Financial Management

Events and Client Relationship Management

HRM, Infrastructure and Procurement

Primary activities

Supporting activities

Opportunities

Threats

Comparative Differentiation

iCoCo

SURGE

Research and Development

Service Development and Delivery

Marketing, Sales and Political Campaigning

Project and Financial Management

Events and Client Relationship Management

HRM, Infrastructure and Procurement

Primary activities

Supporting activities

Rare and hard to imitate

What does it look like inside iCoCo?

A consultancy team's analysis of an institute in trouble

Tip

Exclusion

Far right

Violence

Recession

Migration

OUR jobs

Technology

Local communities

Segregation

Racism

Conflict and revolution

Globalisation

Dynamic and ever changing

Permanent diversity

Interconnected

To become a national centre of cohesion work, providing support and community solutions to local agencies, reducing the threat of extremism and creating cohesive communities

Mission statement...

To address global issues through local solutions and enhance the capacity of local and national agencies to understand their communities and increase cohesion at every level

Vision

Strategic Group Analysis

£2000/day

iCoCo

future

Nottingham University

CPRS

£1500/day

iCoCo

now

Sheffield Hallam

Price

(an example structure)

Our key ideas

iCoCo needs dramatic change to survive in an extremely difficult environment

Macro-economic and political change in Europe and nothing for iCoCo in the UK

...but a growing international research market...

despite being costly an investment in research creates value for clients, greater impact and sustainability for iCoCo

Local individual consultants

£100/day

Consultancy without research

Research with Consultancy

Scope of Work

Strategic Group Analysis

Our key ideas

Macro-economic and political change in Europe and nothing for iCoCo in the UK

...but a growing international research market...

Key Changes

UK emphasis on equality not cohesion

global events create international opportunities

market shrinks due to external changes

one main market

Offer

Offer

based on delivering community cohesion solutions

based on delivering community cohesion solutions

one main market

Community mapping

Community mapping

Tension monitoring

Tension monitoring

Cohesion reviews

Cohesion reviews

Preventing violent extremism

National and Local Government

Preventing violent extremism

National and Local Government

public spending cuts and economic crisis in Europe

national and local political shifts

2005 - 2009

2010 - 2012

LoNGPESTEL

External analysis

The Technological and Environmental are important to include in an external analysis but other factors seem more relevant in relation to iCoCo's current situation...

Life cycle

Where is iCoCo in its life cycle?

2010-2012

2007-8

2008-10

2005-6

iCoCo now

Five Forces

Our key ideas

Macro-economic and political change in Europe and nothing for iCoCo in the UK

...but a growing international research market...

iCoCo needs dramatic change to survive in an extremely difficult environment

Substitutes

Improve the following:

Schools

Social Care

Roads

Housing

Community Cohesion

The Clients 'to do' list

Non-competitive, informal and unstructured procurement

Buyers

Vulnerable to buyer demands both in setting pricing and in over-delivery

iCoCo's rivalry

little power and struggling to survive

Consultants often have other priorities, high prices and have the power to walk away whenever

Suppliers

very hard to make use of a learning curve if the learning is outside of iCoCo

External Consultants

a lot of the expertise and experience stayed outside of iCoCo

Our key ideas

Macro-economic and political change in Europe and nothing for iCoCo in the UK

...but a growing international research market...

iCoCo needs dramatic change to survive in an extremely difficult environment

despite being costly an investment in research creates value for clients, greater impact and sustainability for iCoCo

iCoCo must regain its power over its 5 forces through strategic choices and a new business model

New Entrants

Now lots of other research centres working towards similar aims

High threat

Previously iCoCo's first mover advantage built strong entry barriers

Competitors have now overcome those through investments in research and sustainability

iCoCo could now be seen as a new entrant in its own market!

Labour government invested heavily in social research

Industry Rivalry