Sino-Forest

JO
by Justin Ongaro11 views·Updated Mar 25, 2014
Powered by AI

Need to present on this topic?

Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.

Free to try, no credit card required

Slide outline

  1. The Fraud

Transcript

Motivation for Fraud

Opportunity

  • As senior management, actively engaged in daily operations
  • Direct connections with government bureau officials

Pressure

  • To continually exceed analyst and market expectations
  • Personal pressure to bolster self-interest (stock-based compensation)

Rationalization

  • Need funds to fuel "growth"
  • Eventually becoming a habit
  • Failure to perform adequate background checks of key personnel
  • Lack of industry experts
  • Failure to perform reasonableness checks and other analytical procedures
  • Did not obtain sufficient and appropriate evidence
  • Poyry Valuation Reports

Staff #1:

"How do we know that the trees that Poyry is inspecting (where we attend) are actually trees owned by the company? E.g. could they show us trees anywhere and we would not know the difference?"

Staff #2:

"I believe they could show us trees anywhere and we would not know the difference..."

EY Now

March 30, 2013

  • EY’s settlement of $117M is approved by the Ontario Superior Court of Justice
  • Largest 3rd party settlement by a Canadian audit firm in a class action
  • EY maintains confidence in the procedures they performed, making it clear that the settlement is NOT an admission of guilt

Auditor Involvement

Background

  • Sino-Forest operated in China, acquiring, holding and disposing of timber plantations
  • By 2010, valued at USD 6 Billion
  • Greater than the top two forestry companies in Canada combined

Pervasive Deficiencies

  • Lack of Professional Skepticism (CAS 200)
  • Audit Team Structure/Language Barrier
  • Board of Directors comprised of EY

Specific Deficiencies

  • Over-reliance on outsourced professionals (Pöyry)
  • Lack of understanding of related party transactions

Frequent auditor rotation

1996 to 1997 - EY

1998 to 1999 - Arthur Andersen

2000 to 2004 - EY

2005 to 2006 - BDO

2007 to 2010 - EY

Image: http://topics.cbc.ca/business/companies/sino-forest-corporation.htm

How was it Perpetrated?

  • Use of the “BVI Model”
  • Sales and purchases involving secret related parties (Off-book)
  • Use of bribery and forged documents

Image: http://www.hdwallpapersonly.com/hd-dark-wallpapers.html

Sino-Forest Now

  • Shares de-listed
  • “Emerald Plantations” formed and owned by the creditors to hold the assets of Sino-Forest
  • Sino-Forest along with its executives face a multitude of lawsuits that will continue for the foreseeable future

Image: http://www.flickr.com/photos/soilscience/

Questions?

How was it discovered?

  • June 2, 2011
  • Report released by Muddy Waters
  • "always being a fraud and overstating its assets.”

Image: http://www.scmp.com/business/commodities/article/1097678/olam-internationals-bond-sale-only-delays-collapse-says-carson

1

The Fraud

  • Utilized their complex business models to commit:
  • Financial Statement Fraud
  • Overstatement of Assets and Revenue
  • Misappropriation of Assets
  • Funneled money out of the corporation to the owners
  • Bribery was also needed to help execute parts of the fraud