Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.
Free to try, no credit card required(Positivists)
They embraced two central tenets: reductionism and the synthetic–analytic distinction (e.g., Quine, 1970b).
Howe Disagrees with this completely.
As indicated earlier, the 2002 NRC report Scientific Research in
Education (SRE) is the exemplar of the new scientific orthodoxy
in education research.
In my view, the new orthodoxy, as codified in SRE and promoted in Advancing Scientific Research in Education, is pretty
much a positivist throwback.
SRE distinguishes scientific research from other kinds of scholarship in education in terms of the criterion of empirical testability, which is interpreted so as to exclude the humanities (philosophy and history are the explicit examples; NRC, 2002, p. 131, note), thus isolating the humanities from the intellectual activity identified as the key to improving education policy and practice.
The conception of education science exemplified by the new
orthodoxy does not significantly depart from a positivist conception.
It mirrors the epistemic difference between the context of
justification and the context of discovery, thereby diminishing
the true epistemic import of interpretive/qualitative methods
in intentionalist explanation.
Social Research and Political Values
The claim that social science is unavoidably infused with politics has been a recurrent and central theme in my analysis...This is definitely true
Conclusion
Under present conditions, “What constitutes education science?” is just not a good question to be asking. It is too liable to self-serving partisanship (witting or not), empowering the elevated ones to use their preferred definition of science to ummarily
exclude challenges and alternative views from the conversation about education policy and practice—as in, “What you say is 438 educational Researcher interesting perhaps, but it’s not science.” The exclusionary effect is likely to be less direct than this, but it is pervasive in areas such as funding and access to policy makers.
Nevertheless, it would be unwise to reject outright the general idea that education science would be a good thing. We simply have not come up with a satisfactory account of what it is. In the meantime, the idea of education science deserves to be rejected conditionally: If the new orthodoxy is what is meant by education science, then that conception is too technocratic, acritical, single-minded, exclusionary, and so forth, to be a good thing.
In a related vein, more could be done to emphasize important differences between social science and natural science as well as the blurred boundaries between the humanities and more empirically-oriented social science research. The contingent and contentious nature of the concept of education science could be more heavily emphasized as well, and so could the specific contributions that the humanities have to make to—or in—education science in determining “what works.” Again, “What works?” is elliptical for “What works to produce valued education outcomes?” Exploring what should be valued—is valuable—in human endeavors is at the heart of much scholarship in the humanities.
Epistemology Debate
Kenneth R. Howe
NLU
Monday, March 3, 2014
Educational Researcher
Epistemology, Methodology, and Education Sciences
The New Orthodoxy and the Rhetoric of Science
Three Positivist Dogmas and the New Scientific Orthodoxy: A Critique
Positivist Dogmas, Rhetoric, and the Education Science Question
The Quantitative-Qualitative Dilemma
The quantitative–qualitative dogma (or “incompatibility thesis”; Howe, 1988, 2003) holds that quantitative and qualitative research methods are incompatible with one another such that they may be combined “disjunctively” but not conjunctively” (Howe, 1985). That is, if combined, qualitative methods must be
assigned separate roles from quantitative methods, for example,
generating causal hypotheses that quantitative methods then test.
The Fact-Value Dogma
Micah's Prezi
http://prezi.com/9juov4rihyff/?utm_campaign=share&utm_medium=copy
Philip's Prezi
http://prezi.com/zccymso6v27b/?utm_campaign=share&utm_medium=copy&rc=ex0share
1. Pose significant questions that can be investigated empirically.
2. Link research to relevant theory.
3. Use methods that permit direct investigation of the question.
4. Provide a coherent and explicit chain of reasoning.
5. Replicate and generalize across studies.
6. Disclose research to encourage professional scrutiny and
critique.
The Empirical Science–Humanities Dogma
The third dogma of education research is the empirical science– humanities dichotomy
Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.
Free to try, no credit card required