ROYAL BANK OF CANADA - THE INDIAN CHAPTER
- Capital Markets had said that it would cover India from its office at London.
- Retail Banking stated that it did not have the resources for the Mumbai office.
- Wealth Management suggested that the Russian aristocracy had more potential than the Indian affluent.
- Business heads were not comfortable with the directives of EIC,as a rep office, by nature, was a cost center rather than a profit center.
What should RBC do to improve international orientation and collaboration among its businesses?
- RBC business researchers should explore into the various international markets prior to the watch tower proposal.
- Options and considerations for expansion have to be carefully dealt with coupled with a more hands-on approach.
- To improve the orientation, a careful insight has to be taken at the current economic situation where the bank proposes to invest.
- RBC needs to improve upon the decision making ability to expand in new markets, otherwise It will be left behind in the business with its competitors taking the lead.
- Ian Toone's dilemmas at two levels :
- The “Watch Tower” strategy for international expansion of RBC couldn't arouse the interest of big business groups.
- The business risk faced by GFI in terms of carrying the full financial load in the absence of other sponsors, placing its own finances at stake.
- Dual problem of focusing on the big picture while safeguarding the interests of GFI as a business unit, and his own as a career professional.
Internal processes at RBC leading towards a decision to expand globally
What are the drivers of globalization at RBC?
- A long hierarchical chain in RBC.
- The concept of “ one up and two up”.
- New Business Committee ( NBC).
- Enterprise International Committee ( EIC)
1. The creation and supply of money to national economies
2. International trade imbalances
3. Third World debt
4. The international flow of financial capital
5. Diversity
- Royal Bank of Canada entering into the Indian market on February 1st, 2008.
- The first representative office set up at Bandra Kurla, Mumbai.
- With people from India comprising the second highest Asian immigrant population in Canada after China, RBC is now well positioned to help them invest back into India's buoyant economy.
- Lengthy process of gaining approval and trust for a new financial venture.
- Lack of concensus amongst various departmental heads starting from risk management to legal and human resources departments.
- Members of the committee have their own apprehensions which leads to dissapprovals and inagreement.
- RBC previous failures due to presence of Silos playing a major role in hampering progress for this project.
- The Top management had a different approach towards expansion as compared to the middle management.
What should Ian Toone do?
- Arrange a meeting with Mr. Gordon Nixon for a fresh perspective towards the project.
- Meet Ms. Barbara Stymiest for financial support on the project.
- Convince and seek stronger commitment from the capital market by gaining the trust of the business heads.
- Provide insights about the potentials of growth and expansion in the Indian market.
- Provide a proper cost breakdown and indicate the benefits of having a physical office in comparison to foreign vigilance on the domestic market.
- What are the problems faced by global organisations while entering foreign markets?
- What are the ways in which they could overcome such barriers of entry?
- Suggest a few other efficient ways by which RBC and Ian Toone could have got the project approved?
- What measures would you have taken, had you been in Ian Toone’s shoes to successfully implement such a global project?