How Have Recruitment Industry Changes Impacted Agency Valuations?

RH
by Rod Hore26 views·Updated Mar 22, 2016
Powered by AI

Need to present on this topic?

Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.

Free to try, no credit card required

Slide outline

  1. The future of the recruitment industry is exciting!
  2. TYPE OF COMPANY
  3. There is room for all types of business models within the industry.
  4. My accountant told me I’m worth 6 times
  5. But there are implications in the business model you choose.
  6. YEARS

Transcript

LIFESTYLE COMPANY

Owner has characteristics that show the business is not growing or not changing to market conditions.

These might be:

  • Small
  • Little growth for years
  • Withdraws significant profits (does not reinvest)
  • Works mostly the same clients year on year
  • Has another “job” eg property investment
  • Does not change or improve processes to meet circumstances.

OWNER DOMINANT

DESIRABLE FEATURES

Duration of business

Location

Brand, website & Social Media presence

Candidate database **

Technology adoption **

Owner has strategic intent, investment strategies, and a continuous improvement attitude.

These might be:

  • Sustainable size
  • Strategic planning
  • Investment in management level staff
  • Investment in marketing & sales
  • Investment in new business models
  • Strong analytical focus
  • Seeks external input

Leadership

Client mix and client relationships

Sector or sector mix

Sales focus

Office

03. DRIVERS OF VALUE

{ These are features that may attract more buyers but don’t add “VALUE” as business valuation is ultimately based on a profit multiple}

{A lack of these may make a buyer decline to offer}

FUTURE PERFORMANCE

services business value:

“The risk associated with earning future profits”

CORPORATE

  • Past performance is interesting but is not what is being sold
  • Risk analysis on future profit is critical
  • Sustainability, in all its forms, is the biggest part of risk assessment

{ Average of last three years profit is not a valuation method }

The business could, if it so desired, undertake an IPO – they are “pre-IPO” status.

Characteristics would then be:

  • size
  • predictable revenue and profits
  • less reliance on founders
  • multiple shareholders
  • external board
  • strong management team
  • auditable financials
  • strong corporate governance
  • a great understanding of risk

LONGEVITY

company age does not add value

but a young company has unanswered questions

  • Plenty of shooting stars in the industry
  • Need to consider the cycles of staff, clients, economic conditions, business models

SUSTAINABILITY

staff

VS

capital

clients

POINTS OF FAILURE

SIZE

TEMP/CONTRACT

VS

PERMANENT

  • Plenty of discussion on the need for sustainable revenue
  • Perm-dominant recruiters are usually valued lower (and may be unsaleable)
  • Temp/Contract needs to be a significant contributor in most sectors and most geographic locations

should be the aim for some sectors (eg IT)

70%

recommended contribution at the Gross Profit (NDR) level

50%

< some sectors have little Temp/Contract >

{ This is one of the major “DESIRABILITY” factors and one of the major determinants of value for smaller ANZ businesses }

THERE IS SO MUCH MORE!

Today’s recruitment industry is so much more than perm recruitment and temp/contract recruitment:

RPO

Online Staffing

SOW

Consulting

Provider to MSP/VMS

{ Smart buyers are seeking value-added capabilities }

{ The Recruitment Industry has skills and experience that Corporations need }

STRATEGY

VS

BUILD A FUTURE

stand for something in the market

NOT ALL ABOUT SIZE

"

Why would a client return your call when they have been approached by many of your peers?

"

{2009-}

CHANGING VALUATIONS

Current Business Values and Models

CONTENT

Some Considerations for Your Business

05

Profits

What to Do Now

06

Multiples

CHANGING VALUATIONS

04. HHMC OBSERVING

CHANGING VALUATIONS

01. A SHORT HISTORY

A Short History

07

Terminology and Definitions

POST FINANCIAL CRISIS

  • Growth uncertain
  • Aversion to risk (despite low interest rates)
  • HR & Procurement controlling purchasing processes
  • Increased regulation
  • Traditional recruitment processes under threat

Drivers of Value

02

$2.5M

Valuations are Changing

03

  • In demand

(can achieve higher valuations)

04

INDUSTRY IS MATURING

{Above 2M EBIT}

$2M

  • Better owner-dominant and corporate businesses are rare
  • Better understanding of risk

$1.5M

EARNINGS BEFORE INTEREST & TAX

CHANGING MARKET

$1M

  • Many, many smaller businesses
  • Not all agencies are thriving in the new environment
  • Large volume of baby boomer businesses

$.5M

{1981-2008}

{Below 500K EBIT}

  • Difficult to reduce risk for acquirer
  • Often receiving lower valuations (may not achieve sale)
  • Continuous growth – the industry “emerged”
  • Low barriers to entry
  • Unsophisticated buyers of service
  • Low assessment of risk

PRE FINANCIAL CRISIS

CANNOT DISCUSS VALUE WITHOUT

DISCUSSING STRUCTURE

1. Deal structure impacts price

OWNER DOMINANT BUSINESS

VALUE:

2.5-4.0

multiple

STRUCTURE:

50%

upfront and then

CANNOT DISCUSS VALUE WITHOUT

6-24

SOME DEALS

month earn-out

05. CURRENT BUSINESS

VALUES AND MODELS

DISCUSSING STRUCTURE

MOST DEALS

GOOD

1

2

3

LIFESTYLE BUSINESS

VALUE:

4

Purchase of BUSINESS ASSETS for CASH is still the most common mechanism

<3.0

2. Structure is the result of a risk & reward negotiation

{Multiples have barely changed for over a decade but profits have fluctuated wildly}

multiple

STRUCTURE:

more variation

50%

upfront and then

6-24

month earn-out

NON-FINANCIAL

Totally based on

Seller wants cash upfront

earn-out

FUTURE PERFORMANCE

3. There are many aspects that change the risk profile

{Without a contractor book, value is difficult to justify.}

eg perm pipeline or contractor book

Sustainability is a major issue

CORPORATE BUSINESS

WHAT AM I BUYING?

VALUE:

HIGHER

STRUCTURE:

multiples

Buyer wants to pay in the future, based on performance

usually an upfront purchase of shares

BUYER

The purchasers of these businesses may include larger overseas companies or Private Equity investors.

There are some examples in Australia and New Zealand; there are many examples in other countries.

BUYER

SELLER

06. STRATEGY CONSIDERATIONS FOR OWNERS

STRATEGY

%

HHMC has conversations with business owners about:

SELLER

Wealth creation

Partial sale

We want business owners to:

Educate themselves

Strategy

  • Don’t be insular
  • Read, attend conference

Seek external input and openly discuss the business

STRATEGY

Never stop

Shares in the transaction

We don’t like delivering bad news about business valuation

  • We want business owners to understand their business and get reward for their risk and effort

Make conscious decisions, don’t drift to an outcome

Major risks

  • Equity value
  • Risk

Know the implications of your decisions

There is no right decision or wrong decision

( like contract renewals)

  • Many inputs such as appetite for risk, access to capital, owner skills, and even geographic location

STRATEGY

Wealth Creation

A balance between

Reward for the owners

Investment in the business

Building the balance sheet by retaining cash in the business

The most successful people in the recruitment industry build a little wealth each year

WHAT IS YOUR BUSINESS MODEL?

02. TERMINOLOGY & DEFINITIONS

NET WORKING CAPITAL

Most easily described as cash plus debtors less creditors less staff entitlements

  • Takes into consideration shareholder loans and bank debt
  • Staff entitlements include annual leave and other obligations

BUSINESS VALUE

A multiple of normalised profit before interest and tax excluding working capital

Note:

EBIT, not EBITDA

NORMALISED PROFIT

Adjusting the revenue and expenses to reflect the business as if someone else was running it.  

07. QUESTIONS?

+61 2 9221 7596

+61 419 401 210

rod.hore@hhmc.com.au

HHMC AUSTRALIA PTY LTD

Level 3, 280 George Street, Sydney Australia

(corner George and Hunter Streets)

RCSA

INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE

2014

QUEENSTOWN,

NEW ZEALAND

1

The future of the recruitment industry is exciting!

2
  • Lifestyle Company
  • Owner-Dominant
  • Corporate
  • Global, Listed
3

TYPE OF COMPANY

4

There is room for all types of business models within the industry.

5

Candidate

6

My accountant told me I’m worth 6 times

I heard they

got $10M

My mate was

offered over

5 times

I’m going to sell at the top of the market

I’ll sell for $3M

7

Client

8

01

9

But there are implications in the business model you choose.

10

YEARS

5

10

15