Francesca Greco hydro hegemony 6th Virtual Rivers Interactions

FG
by Francesca Greco336 views·Updated Apr 19, 2013
Powered by AI

Need to present on this topic?

Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.

Free to try, no credit card required

Transcript

VIRTUAL WATER RIVERS , WATER ALLOCATION AND JUSTICE

IN VIRTUAL RIVERS INTERACTIONS ( VRI),

THE TRANSBOUNDARY NATURE OF VIRTUAL WATER

HEGEMONY IS CHARACTERIZED BY A DOUBLE SILENCE- MECHANISM

The only rule is apparently the “more dollars per drop” (Allan)

  • DO WE HAVE A JUSTICE PROBLEM HERE?
  • Which kind of justice is regulating the virtual water trade?
  • WHY DO WE EAT OTHER PEOPLE’S WATER?₁*
  • What are the power relations beyond virtual water rivers and virtual water hegemony?

AND WE COULD EVEN ADD MORE.......

IS HEGEMONY PRESENT IN VIRTUAL WATER ?

Yes

THERE IS THE SILENCE OF NON POLITICIZED ISSUES, BECAUSE ALL MECHANISM IS INTERNAL TO THE PRIVATE SECTOR

There is no state, no physical river basin, no diplomacy working on political issues.

SILENT BECAUSE THERE IS A DETACHMENT OF THE VALUE OF WATER FROM ITS LOCAL CONTEST.

Food consumers do not get any information on local provenance of the water they eat.

( this mechanism is also called embodied HANPP)

Comparison between

TRANSBOUNDARY WATER INTERACTIONS

and

VIRTUAL RIVERS INTERACTIONS ( VRI)

VIRTUAL WATER RIVERS TRANSBOUNDARY WATERS

Created by humans Created by the Nature

Non Physical contiguity Physical contiguity

Direction of flux can be inverted One way direction

Relatively shorter Historical path

historical path or

no historical path

₁ *Antonelli and Greco 2012 in Segre, A and Falasconi, L“Il libro blu dello spreco in Italia:l’acqua” , Edizioni Ambiente, 2012, Italy

This has been already extremely well presented by Sojamo et al.

in their paper on VIRTUAL WATER HEGEMONY where ABCD

agribusiness companies are in practice managing the majority

of agricultural products being traded in current times.

Therefore, they hold, in practice the power on how

the majority of human water consumption is

currently being managed used and sold under

the form of virtual water, through virtual rivers.

HISTORY OF A VIRTUAL RIVER

Data of stocks and flows provided by CUAHSI , MIT Boston 2008 Summer Institute . Reference:

Vorosmarty et al, Humans Transforming the Water Cycle: Implications for Society and Nature over a Multi-Century Timeframe through Synthesis Studies

Definition and example of one paradigmatic VIRTUAL RIVER:

The Charles River Basin loss in stocks and flows the US colonial time.

An entire ecosystem has been literally exported to the “motherland” Europe

VIRTUAL RIVERS, CALCULATED

TWO CASES OF VIRTUAL WATER RIVERS : WHICH JUSTICE FOR LOCAL POPULATION AND INDIGENOUS PEOPLE ?

SOUTH OF JORDAN – NON RENEWABLE GROUNDWATERS

-Disi is an emblematic case of both physical contiguity and virtual transboundarity .This Virtual Water River was created for securing a prior use right .Jordan in the future will have more bargaining power vs the Saudis(no treaty so far). Then they will"TURN THE VIRTUAL RIVER OFF"

The dispute with Saudi Arabia is also exacerbated by local Bedouin groups boycotting the project with violent actions (one killing last year)

The Italian virtual river : virtual water imports in 2010 in Italy, restricted to the MENA and European Regions, calculated by the “Water in Food” group, Turin University

American Geophysical Union, Fall Meeting 2010, abstract #H51I-01 – Picture: The Oxbow, Thomas Cole, 1836,

Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York.

DISI IS A MIX

OF TWINS

AND VRI

In this case a virtual water river was created and will be eventually stopped in order to build a prior use right in a transboundary water dispute

SOUTH OF ITALY- NON RENEWABLE/OVEREXPLOITED

GROUNDWATERS

Slavery

Contract farming causing food waste

Contract farming causing bankruptancy of hundreds of farmers

Famers enslaving migrant workers in order to obey the contract-farming imposed price

Allamano P., et al, in Antonelli M. and Greco, F “L’acqua che mangiamo”, Edizioni Ambiente, 2013 , Italy - forthcoming

According to the 2012 report from Flai Cgil, around 700 000 slaves are currently working in agricultural sector in Southern Italy

700 000 slaves

Can we ignore them? Or are they part of our

problem?

VIRTUAL RIVERS INTERACTION ( VRI)

COMING TO THE ISSUE OF JUSTICE….

The hydrological cycle “de facto’ in the virtual water rivers’ system

Do we have “equal access” to the water being used for virtual water trade?

Do local or indigenous people have the same right or do they get the same benefits of foreign consumers? Or less?

What about including labour and workers rights in virtual water trade?

What is the rule prevailing here?

How do we apply “water allocation doctrine”( riparian/no harm rights, prior use/historical rights, territorial sovereignty) in the case

of virtual water rivers?

Do I have the right to eat the water embedded into a tomato which has been irrigated

with non-renewable waters in a desert?

Or does the Bedouin gentlemen deserve a prior-use right on that water?

WHY LOCAL AND INDIGENOUS PEOPLE MOVEMENTS

ARE IMPORTANT IN VIRTUAL WATER JUSTICE

THE HYDROLOGICAL CYCLE ”DE FACTO”

Because movements are stretegic

in the politicisation and de-silencing

of issues in the agenda set by the

hegemons Movements are strategic

to impede the hegemons to set up

a “blocked” agenda

Because distributive justice

( participation, recognition and respect) is very difficult to achieve in virtual rivers interaction (VRI) due to the fact that we are dealing with PRIVATE entities and not state-actors the exact contrary of TWINS

( Transboundary Water Interaction nexuS)

WHY IS VIRTUAL WATER IMPORTANT

IN A TRANSBOUNDARY JUSTICE WORKSHOP?

BECAUSE THEY ARE NON-STATE ACTORS AND CAN PLAY “NEW ROLES” “extending of the realms of the possible” based on cosmopolitan citizenship ( Warner)

2) The water cycle in the anthropocene and

human interactions in the hydrologic system ( Vorosmarty)

COMPLEXITY ADDED TO COMPLEXITY

...we now also have to consider the international transboundarity of virtual water rivers and powers behind it

A river basin with a multinational company operating in crop production is NOT the same as a river basin without it.

"Water flows uphill to money and power "( Reisner)

In this case, water flows where “more dollars per drop” are being produced.

Virtual water rivers are adding complexity to the complexity of our “business as usual”. We always had to deal with competition among sectors ( domestic, industrial,agricultural and ecosystem maintainance) , and the upstream-downstream dynamics in case of physical contiguity of the transboundarity....

INCLUSION

PARTICIPATION

RECOGNITION are NOT AT ALL part of the

management of virtual water rivers.

Vorosmarty et al, Humans Transforming the Water Cycle: Implications for Society and Nature

over a Multi-Century Timeframe through Synthesis Studies, American Geophysical Union,

Fall Meeting 2010, abstract #H51I-01

ACTIONS FOR CHANGE

THE HYDROLOGICAL CYCLE ”DE FACTO”

1) The classical water cycle

Because virtual water IS transboundary

and it affects water allocation in local context of every

water basin , wether contiguously transboundary

( physically transboundary) or not .

Warner: A-HEGEMONY

"A change can be obtained through

an extension of the realms of the possible based on cosmopolitan citizenship

Through social movements transboundary water interactions will best be informed by “justice”

"Actions could be taken with a

reform of trade in the global political economy" (Tony Allan)

Implementation of water accountability in the private sector

Change in the global political economy of food-trade

yes but...how do we get there?

I WOULD SAY....

THANK YOU FOR

YOUR ATTENTION

francesca.greco@kcl.ac.uk

1)SUPPORT SOCIAL MOVEMENTS

Movements are able to get issues in the agenda from a non-hegemonic position

Movements are able to politicize and de-silence issues that had been silenced

 

2)USE CASE STUDIES AND ANALYSIS OF

ACTIVE SCIENTISTS COHERENTLY

Coherence of action is the most difficult

thing to achieve as cases of injustice

are fragmented and isolated at

local level, therefore a great

efforts is required to actually

spot and highlight every

single case

4) EDUCATION for

future generations

and AWARENESS RAISING for ADULTS

3) ENGAGE WITH THE PRIVATE

SECTOR FROM OUTSIDE (consumers'

demand for green and just products)

and from the INSIDE

(water accountability)

TO CREATE AN ALTERNATIVE

CULTURAL HEGEMONY

Hegemony and counter-hegemony in virtual

water trade: justice for indigenous people?

Francesca Greco, King’s College London

HH6: Transboundary Water Justice

Sixth International Workshop on Hydro-Hegemony

12-13 January 2013, UEA London